Neuroeconomics: A Critique of ‘Neuroeconomics: A Critical Reconsideration’

Stanton, Angela A. (2008): Neuroeconomics: A Critique of ‘Neuroeconomics: A Critical Reconsideration’.

Abstract

Some economists believe that neuroeconomists threatens the theory of economics. Glenn Harrison’s paper “Neuroeconomics: A Critical Reconsideration” (2008) provides some support for this view, though some of the points he makes are somewhat disguised. The field of neuroeconomics is barely into its teenage years; and it is trying to do what? Criticize and redesign the field of economics developed over hundreds of years? But that is not what neuroeconomics is trying to do, in spite of all the efforts of some economists trying to place it into that shoebox (see the argument in great detail in Andrew Caplin, Andrew Schotter 2008). Neuroeconomics is a Mendelian-Economics of sort; it is a science that is able to generate data by fixing the environment to some degree, varying a single independent variable for its affects, and is able to see each individual’s choices from initiation of the decision-making process to its outcome. Mainstream (standard) economics, on the other hand, looks at the average of the outcomes of many individuals and proposes how people chose those outcomes, retroactively. The two fields, neuroeconomics and standard economics, are evaluating two sides of the same coin: one with and the other without ceteris paribus; they are not in conflict with one another.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Neuroeconomics, Standard Economics, Ceteris Paribus, Hormones
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D01 - Microeconomic Behavior: Underlying Principles; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C91 - Laboratory, Individual Behavior; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D87 - Neuroeconomics

References

Apicella, Coren L.; Dreber, Anna; Campbell, Benjamin; Gray, Peter B.; Hoffman, Moshe and Little, Anthony C.

"Testosterone and Financial Risk Preferences." Evolution and Human Behavior, 2008, 29, pp. 384-90.

Bernhardt, P. C.; Dabbs, J. M., Jr.; Fielden, J. A. and Lutter, C. D. "Testosterone Changes During Vicarious Experiences of Winning and Losing among Fans at Sporting Events." Physiol Behav, 1998, 65(1), pp. 59-62.

Camerer, Colin, George Loewenstein, and Drazen Prelec.2004. "Neuroeconomics: Why Economics Needs Brains"." Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 106(3): 555-579.

Camerer, Colin, George Loewenstein, and Drazen Prelec.2005. "Neuroeconomics: How Neuroscience Can Inform Economics." Journal of Economic Literature, 43(March): 9-64.

Caplin, Andrew and Andrew Schotter. 2008. The Foundations of Positive and Normative Economics. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Coates, J. M. and Herbert, J. "Endogenous Steroids and Financial Risk Taking on a London Trading Floor." Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 2008, 105(16), pp. 6167-72.

Deaner, Robert O., Amit V. Khera, and Michael L. Platt.2005. "Monkeys Pay Per View: Adaptive Valuation of Social Images by Rhesus Macaques." Current Biology, 15(March 29): 543-548.

DeQuervain, D. J-F., U. Fischbacher, V. Treyer, M. Schellhammer, U. Schnyder, A. Buck, and E. Fehr.2004. "The Neural Basis of Altruistic Punishment." Science, 305(1254): 1258.

Dreher, Jean-Claude; Schmidt, Peter J.; Kohn, Philip; Furman, Daniella; Rubinow, David and Berman, Karen Faith. "Menstrual Cycle Phase Modulates Reward-Related Neural Function in Women." Proc Natl Acad Sci, 2007, 104(7), pp. 2465-70.

Durante, K. M.; Li, N.P. and Haselton, M.G. "Changes in Women's Choice of Dress across the Ovulatory Cycle: Naturalistic and Laboratory Task-Based Evidence." Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 2008, 34, pp. 1451-60.

Ehrsson, H. Henrik, Katja Wiech, Nikolaus Weiskopf, Raymond J. Dolan, and Richard E. Passingham.2007. "Threatening a Rubber Hand that You Feel is Yours Elicits a Cortical Anxiety Response." Proc Natl Acad Sci, 104(23): 9828-9833.

Farage, M.A. and Osborn, T.W. "Cognitive, Sensory, and Emotional Changes Associated with the Menstrual Cycle: A Review." Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics, 2008, 278, pp. 299-307.

Fowler, James H.2005. "Altruistic Punishment and the Origin of Cooperation." Proc Natl Acad Sci, 102(19): 7047-7049.

Gazzola, Valeria, Lisa Aziz-Zadeh, and Christian Keysers.2006. "Empathy and the Somatotopic Auditory Mirror System in Humans." Current Biology, 16(September 19): 1824-1829.

Gul, Faruk and Wolfgang Pesendorfer. 2008. "The Case of Mindless Economics." In The Foundations of Positive and Normative Economics. ed. Andrew Caplin and Andrew SchotterOxford: University Press.

Harrison, Glenn W.2008. "Neuroeconomics: A Critical Reconsideration." Economics and Philosophy, 24 (forthcoming).

Henrich, Joseph Patrick. 2004. Foundations of human sociality economic experiments and ethnographic evidence from fifteen small-scale societies. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Henrich, Joseph Patrick, Robert. Boyd, Samuel Bowles, Colin Camerer, Ernst Fehr, Herbert Gintis, and Richard McElreath.2001. "In Search of Homo Economicus: Behavioral Experiments in 15 Small-Scale Societies." The American Economic Review, 91(73): 78.

Henrich, Joseph Patrick, Robert. Boyd, Samuel Bowles, Colin Camerer, Ernst Fehr, Herbert Gintis, Richard McElreath, Michael Alvard, Abigail Barr, Jean Ensminger et al.2005. ""Economic Man" in Cross-Cultural Perspective: Behavioral Experiments in 15 Small-Scale Societies." Behav.Brain Sci., 28: 795-855.

Jackson, Philip L., Eric Brunet, Andrew N. Meltzoff, and Jean Decety.2006. "Empathy Examined Through the neural Mechanisms Involved in Imagining How I Feel versus How You Feel Pain." Neuropsychologia, 44: 752-761.

Jackson, Philip L., Andrew N. Meltzoff, and Jean Decety.2005. "How Do We Perceive the Pain of Others? A Window into the Neural Processes Involved in Empathy." NeuroImage, 24: 771-779.

Klinesmith, J.; Kasser, T. and McAndrew, F. T. "Guns, Testosterone, and Aggression: An Experimental Test of a Mediational Hypothesis." Psychol Sci, 2006, 17(7), pp. 568-71.

Kosfeld, Michael, Markus Heinrichs, Paul J. Zak, Urs Fischbacher, and Ernst Fehr.2005. "Oxytocin Increases Trust in Humans." Nature, 435: 673-676.

Mas-Colell, Andrew, Michael D. Whinston, and Jerry R. Green. 1995. Microeconomic Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press

Mehta, P. H.; Jones, A. C. and Josephs, R. A. "The Social Endocrinology of Dominance: Basal Testosterone Predicts Cortisol Changes and Behavior Following Victory and Defeat." J Pers Soc Psychol, 2008, 94(6), pp. 1078-93.

Mehta, P. H. and Josephs, R. A. "Testosterone Change after Losing Predicts the Decision to Compete Again." Horm Behav, 2006, 50(5), pp. 684-92.

Miller, G.F.; Tybur, J. and Jordan, B. . "Ovulatory Cycle Effects on Tip Earnings by Lap-Dancers: Economic Evidence for Human Estrus?" Evolution and Human Behavior, 2007, 28, pp. 375-81.

Morrison, India, Donna Lloyd, Giuseppe di Pellegrino, and Neil Roberts.2004. "Vicarious Responses to Pain in Anterior Cingulate Cortex: Is Empathy a Multisensory Issue?" Cognitive, Affective, & Behavioral Neuroscience, 4(2): 270-278.

Padoa-Schioppa, Camillo.2007. "Orbitofrontal Cortex and the Computation of Economic Value." Ann.N.Y.Acad.Sci., 1121: 232-253.

Pearson, M. and Schipper, B.C. "Menstrual Cycle and Competitive Bidding," unpublished manuscript. UC Davis, 2008.

Penton-Voak, I. S.; Perrett, D. I.; Castles, D. L.; Kobayashi, T.; Burt, D. M.; Murray, L. K. and Minamisawa, R. "Menstrual Cycle Alters Face Preference." Nature, 1999, 399(6738), pp. 741-2.

Penton-Voak, I.S.; and Perrett, D.I.;. "Female Preference for Male Faces Changes Cyclically: Further Evidence." Evolution and Human Behavior, 2000, 21, pp. 39-48.

Platt, M. L. and P. W. Glimcher.1999. "Neural Correlates of Decision Variables in Parietal Cortex." Nature, 400: 233-238.

Quiggin, John. 1993. Generalized expected utility theory the rank-dependent model. Boston: Kluwer Roney, J. R.; Lukaszewski, A. W. and Simmons, Z. L. "Rapid Endocrine Responses of Young Men to Social Interactions with Young Women." Horm Behav, 2007, 52(3), pp. 326-33.

Roney, J. R. and Simmons, Z. L. "Women's Estradiol Predicts Preference for Facial Cues of Men's Testosterone." Horm Behav, 2008, 53(1), pp. 14-9.

Saad, G. and Vongas, J. "The Effect of Conspicuous Consumption on Men's Testosterone Levels." Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, under review.

Singer, Tania, Ben Seymour, John P. O'Doherty, Klaas E. Stephan, Raymond J. Dolan, and Chris D. Frith.2006. "Empathic Neural Responses are Modulated by the Perceived Fairness of Others." Nature, 439: 466-469.

Stanton, Angela A.2007. "Neural Substrates of Decision-Making in Economic Games." Journal of Dissertation, 1(1).

Williamson, Oliver E.1993. "Calculativeness, Trust, and Economic Organization." Journal of Law and Economics, XXXVI: 453-486.

Zak, Paul J., Karla Borja, William T. Matzner, and Robert Kurzban.2005. "The Neuroeconomics of Distrust: Sex Differences in Behavior and Physiology." The American Economic Review, 95(2): 360-363.

Zak, Paul J., Robert Kurzban, and William T. Matzner.2004. "The Neurolobiology of Trust." Ann.N.Y.Acad.Sci., 1032: 224-227.

Zak, Paul J., Robert Kurzban, and William T. Matzner.2005. "Oxytocin is Associated with Human Trustworthiness." Hormones and Behavior, 48: 522-527.

Zak, Paul J., Angela A Stanton, and Sheila Ahmadi.2007. "Oxytocin Increases Generosity in Humans." PLoS ONE, 2(11): e1128.