Regulating private pension funds’ structure, performance and investments: cross-country evidence

Srinivas, P.S. and Whitehouse, Edward and Yermo, Juan (2000): Regulating private pension funds’ structure, performance and investments: cross-country evidence. Published in: Social Protection Discussion Paper

Abstract

A number of countries have introduced individual, privately managed defined-contribution accounts, where the value of the pension benefit will depend on accumulated contributions and investment returns. These schemes expose workers’ future pension benefits to a number of different risks. To try to mitigate these risks, reforming governments have often strictly regulated the pension fund management industry’s structure, performance, and asset allocation. Structural regulations often force workers to choose only one manager and one fund. So, workers are unable to diversify investments across funds, exposing them to aberrant behaviour by fund managers, and preventing portfolio adjustments according to the individual’s age, household characteristics, career profile and attitude to risk. Strict asset-allocation rules and relative performance criteria mean that pension funds often invest and perform almost identically, removing any substantive choice for workers over the allocation of their pension fund’s assets and the portfolio’s risk and returns. Concentration in the pension fund management industry is found to be higher in the new pension systems of Latin America and Eastern Europe than in most OECD countries. Concentration might be because the new pension markets are smaller than in countries with more established funded pension systems, but it could also be because of restrictions on industry structure. In Latin America, asset allocation and performance is nearly identical across pension funds. So-called ‘herding’ behaviour is almost a defining characteristics of these pension regimes. Again, this reflects, at least in part, asset allocation restrictions and strict performance regulation. There is also evidence that pension funds have often under-performed simple portfolios composed of market indices of stocks and bonds. All the rules imposed in the new systems of Latin American and Eastern Europe seem to be more stringent than in the OECD, with one exception: portfolio limits. Some OECD countries have a tighter investment regime than countries such as Argentina, Chile, Colombia, Peru and Poland. But OECD countries tend to have fewer barriers to entry and impose fewer constraints on performance than Latin American and Eastern European countries.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: pensions; portfolios; investments
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G23 - Non-bank Financial Institutions ; Financial Instruments ; Institutional Investors; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

Adler, M. and Jorion, P. (1992), ‘Foreign portfolio investment’, in New Palgrave Dictionary of Money and Finance, Macmillan, London.

Altman, N. (1992), ‘Government regulation: enhancing the equity, adequacy and security of pension benefits’, in OECD, Private Pensions and Public Policy, Paris.

Ameriks, J, King, F.P. and Warshawsky, M. (1997), ‘Premium allocations and accumulations in TIAA-CREF — trends in participant choices among asset classes and investment accounts’, TIAA-CREF Research Dialogues no. 51.

Asher, M.G. (1998), ‘The financial crisis and its implications for pension funds in South-East Asia’, presentation’, presented at EDI/World Bank conference, Hangzhou, China, April 1998.

Bajtelsmit, V.L. and VanDerhei, J.L. (1997), ‘Risk aversion and pension investment choices’ in Gordon, M., Mitchell, O.S. and Twinney, M. (eds), Positioning Pensions for the Twenty-First Century, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, Penn.

Ball, R. Kothari, S.P. Shanken, J. (1995), ‘Problems in measuring portfolio performance: an application to contrarian investment strategies’, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 38, pp. 79-107.

Bassett, W.F., Fleming, M.J. and Rodrigues, A.P. (1998), ‘How workers use 401(k) plans: the participation, contribution and withdrawal decisions’, National Tax Journal, vol. 51, no. 2, pp. 263-289.

Baxter, M. and Jermann, U.J. (1997), ‘The international diversification puzzle is worse than you think’, American Economic Review, vol. 87, no. 1.

Beltratti, A. (1998), Asset allocation of pension funds: identification of benchmarks’, in Blommenstein, H.J. and Funke, N. (eds), Institutional Investors in the New Financial Landscape, OECD, Paris.

Benston, G.J. (1988), Regulating Financial Markets: A Critique and Some Proposals, Hobart Paper no. 135, Institute of Economic Affairs, London.

Blake, D., Lehmann, B.N. and Timmerman, A. (1997), ‘Performance measurement using multiple asset class portfolio data: a study of UK pension funds’, Discussion Paper no. 1618, Centre for Economic Policy Research, London.

Blanchard, O.J. (1993), ‘The vanishing equity premium’, in O’Brien, R. (ed.), Finance and the International Economy 7, Oxford University Press.

Blommenstein, H.J. (1997), ‘Institutional investors, pension reform and emerging securities markets’, Working Paper no. 359, Office of the Chief Economist, Inter-American Development Bank, Washington, DC.

Blommenstein, H.J. (1998), ‘Impact of institutional investors on financial markets’, in Blommenstein, H.J. and Funke, N. (eds), Institutional Investors in the New Financial Landscape, OECD, Paris.

Bodie, Z. (1990), ‘Pensions as retirement income insurance’, Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 28, pp. 28-49.

Bodie, Z. (1996), ‘What the pension benefit guarantee corporation can learn from the federal savings and loans insurance’, Journal of Financial Services Research, no. 10, pp. 83-100.

Bodie, Z., Marcus, A.J. and Merton, R.C. (1988), ‘Defined-benefit versus defined-contribution pension plans: what are the real trade-offs?’, in Z. Bodie, J.B. Shoven and D.A. Wise (eds), Pensions in the US Economy, University of Chicago Press for National Bureau of Economic Research.

Bodie, Z. and Merton, R.C. (1994), ‘Pension benefit guarantees in the United States: a functional analysis’, in Schmitt, R. (ed.), The Future of Pensions in the United States, University of Pennsylvania Press.

Bodie Z., Merton, R.C. and Samuelson, W.F. (1992), ‘Labour-supply flexibility and portfolio choice in a life-cycle model’, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, vol. 16, no. 3, pp. 427-449.

Brancato, C.K. (1994), The Brancato Report on Institutional Investment, the Conference Board, Seminar on Trends in U.S. Institutional Investment and Implications for Corporate Governance, New York.

Brown, S.J. and Goetzmann, W.N. (1995), Performance persistence, Journal of Finance, vol. 50, pp. 679-698.

Brown, S.J., Goetzmann, W.N. Ibbotson, R.G. and Ross, S.A. (1992), ‘Survivorship bias in performance studies’, Review of Financial Studies, vol. 5, pp. 553-580.

Brown, S.J., Goetzmann, W.N. and Ross, S.A. (1995), Survival, Journal of Finance, vol. 50, pp. 853-873.

Bunt, K., Winterbotham, N. and Williams, R. (1998), The Role of Pension Scheme Trustees, Research Report no. 81, Department of Social Security, London.

Campbell, J.Y., Cocco, J.F., Gomes, F.J. and Maenhout, P.J. (1999), ‘Investing retirement wealth: a life-cycle model’, Working Paper no. 7029, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Mass.

Candia, F. (1998), ‘International diversification for LAC funds: why or why not?’, presented at IMD/EDI World Bank conference, LAC Pension Systems: Investing for the 21st Century, Washington, D.C., July 1998.

Carhart, M.M. (1997), ‘On persistence in mutual fund performance’, Journal of Finance, vol. 52, pp. 57-82.

Chen, Z., and Knez, P.J. (1995), ‘Portfolio performance measurement: theory and applications’, Review of Financial Studies, vol. 9, pp. 511-555.

Chisari, O. and Dal Bó, P. (1996), ‘Las regulaciones a la composición de cartera y las inversiones de los fondos de jubilaciones y pensiones: un ejercicio de simulación para el caso Argentino’, Revista de Análisis Económico, vol 11, no 1.

Clark, R. Goodfellow, G.P., Schieber, S.J. and Warwick, D. (1998), ‘Making the most of 401(k) plans: who’s choosing what and why?’ Working Paper no. 98-12, Pensions Research Council, Philadelphia, Penn.

Combined Actuarial Performance Services (1993), Pension Fund Investment Performance: General Report, CAPS, Leeds.

Constantinides, G., Donaldson, J. and Mehra, R. (1998), “‘Junior can’t borrow.” A new perspective on the equity premium puzzle’, Working Paper no. 6617, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge.

Corsetti, G. and Schmidt Hebbel, K. (1997), ‘Pension reform and growth’, in Valdés-Prieto, S. (ed.); The Economics of Pensions: Principles, Policies, and International Experience, Cambridge University Press.

Davis, E.P. (1998), ‘Regulation of pension fund assets’, in Blommenstein, H. J. and Funke, N. (eds), Institutional Investors in the New Financial Landscape, OECD, Paris.

Demarco, G., Rofman, R., with Whitehouse, E.R. (1998), ‘Supervising mandatory funded pension systems: issue and challenges’, Pension Reform Primer Series, Social Protection Discussion Paper no. 9817, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Demirguç-Kunt, A. and Levine, R. (1996), ‘Stock-market development and financial intermediaries: stylised facts’, World Bank Economic Review, vol. 10, no. 2.

De Ryck, K. (1998), ‘Asset allocation, financial market behaviour and impact of EU pension funds on European capital markets’, in Blommenstein, H.J and Funke, N. (eds), Institutiional Investors in the New Financial Landscape, OECD, Paris.

Dilnot, A.W., Disney R.F., Johnson, P.G. and Whitehouse, E.R. (1994), Pensions Policy in the UK: An Economic Analysis, Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.

Disney, R.F. and Whitehouse, E.R. (1994), ‘Choice of private pension and pension benefits in Britain’, Institute for Fiscal Studies, Working Paper no. 94/2.

Disney, R.F. and Whitehouse, E.R. (1996), ‘What are pension plan entitlements worth in Britain?’, Economica, vol. 63, pp. 213-238.

Dooley, M.P. (1995), ‘A survey of academic literature on controls over international capital transactions’, Working Paper no. 5352, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge.

Duval, D. (1999), ‘Institutional Arrangements for mandatory funded pensions’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper, World Bank, Washington, D.C., forthcoming.

Edey, M and Simon, J. (1996), ‘Australia’s retirement income system: implications for saving and capital markets’, Working Paper no. 5799, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Mass.

Edwards, S. (1996), ‘Chile: los fondos mutuos’, Regional Studies Report no. 39e, Latin America and Caribbean Technical Department.

Elton, E.J., Gruber, M.J. and Blake, C.R. (1996a), Survivorship bias and mutual fund performance’, Review of Financial Studies, vol. 10, pp. 1097-1120.

Elton, E.J., Gruber, M.J. and Blake, C.R. (1996b), ‘The persistence of risk-adjusted mutual fund performance’, Journal of Business, vol. 69, pp. 133 157.

Elton, E.J., Gruber, M.J., Das, S. and Hlavka, M. (1993), ‘Efficiency with costly information: a reinterpretation of evidence for managed portfolios’, Review of Financial Studies, vol. 6, pp. 1-22.

European Federation for Retirement Provision (1996), European Pension Funds: Their Impact on European Capital Markets and Competitiveness, EFRP, London.

Fama, E.F., and French K.R., (1993), ‘Common risk factors in the return on bonds and stocks’, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 33, pp 3-53.

Ferson, W. and Schadt, R. (1996), ‘Measuring fund strategy and performance in changing economic conditions’, Journal of Finance, vol. 51, pp. 425-462.

Ferson, W. and Warther, V.A. (1996), ‘Evaluating fund performance in a dynamic market’, Financial Analysts Journal, pp. 20-28.

Flanagan, K. (1999), ‘Pension reform in Australia’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper, World Bank, Washington, D.C., forthcoming.

French, K.R. and Poterba, J.M (1991), ‘Investor diversification and international equity markets’, American Economic Review, vol. 81, pp. 222-226.

Fontaine, J. A. (1997), ‘Are there good macroeconomic reasons for limiting external investments by pension funds? The Chilean experience’, in Valdés-Prieto, S. (ed.), The Economics of Pensions: Principles, Policies and International Experience, Cambridge University Press.

Frijns, J. and Petersen, C. (1992), ‘Financing, administration and portfolio management: how secure is the pension promise?’ in OECD, Private Pensions and Public Policy, Paris.

Goodfellow, G.P. and Schieber, S.J. (1997), ‘Investment of assets in self-directed retirement plans’, in Gordon, M.,

Mitchell, O.S. and Twinney, M. (eds), Positioning Pensions for the Twenty-First Century, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, Penn.

Chlon, A., Góra, M. and Rutkowski, M. (1999), ‘Shaping pension reform in Poland: Security through Diversity’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper no. 9923, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Heller, P.S. (1998), ‘Rethinking public pension reform initiatives’, Working Paper no. 98/61, Fiscal Affairs department, International Monetary Fund, Washington, D.C.

Hinz, R., McCarthy, D. and Turner, J. (1997), ‘Are women conservative investors? Gender differences in participant-directed pension investments’, in Gordon, M., Mitchell, O.S. and Twinney, M. (eds), Positioning Pensions for the Twenty-First Century, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia, Penn.

Holzmann, R. (1998a), ‘A World Bank perspective on pension reform’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper no. 9807, World Bank, Washington, D.C..

Hozmann, R. (1998b) ‘Financing the transition to multipillar’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper no. 9809, World Bank, Washington, D.C..

Howell, M. and Cozzini, A. (1990), International Equity Flows, Salomon Brothers.

Iglesias, A. (1990), ‘Estrategias de Inversión de los Fondos de Pensiones’, presented at Third Congress of Finance, Escuela de Administración, Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, August 1990.

Jagannathan, R. and Kocherlakota, N. (1996), ‘Why should older people invest less in stocks than younger people?’, Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review, vol. 20, no. 3, Summer.

Kessler, C. (1996), 'Diversification — Is it still alive?' Economic and Financial Prospects, no. 6, Swiss Bank Corporation.

Kotlikoff, L.J. (1994), ‘A critical review of the World Bank’s social security analysis’, Education and Social Policy department, World Bank.

KPMG Peat Marwick (1998), Retirement Benefits in the 1990s: 1998 Survey Data, Washington, D.C.

Laboul, A. (1998), ‘Private pension systems: regulatory policies’, Ageing Working Paper no. 2.2, OECD, Paris.

Lakonishok, J. Shleifer, A. and Vishny, R.W. (1992), ‘The structure and performance of the money management industry’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity: Microeconomics, pp. 339-93.

Lakonishok, J. Shleifer, A., Thaler, R and Vishny, R.W. (1991), ‘Window-dressing by pension fund managers’, American Economic Review.

Leibowitz, M. L., Bader, L. and Kogelman, S. (1998), Return Targets and Shortfall Risks: Studies in Strategic Asset Management, Irwin.

Llewellyn, D. (1999), ‘The economic rationale for financial regulation’, Occasional Paper no. 1, Financial Services Authority, London.

Mariscal, O.J. (1998a), ‘Argentine Pension and mutual funds and their impact on stocks’, Goldman Sachs Investment Research, New York.

Mariscal, O.J. (1998b), ‘Brazilian Pension and mutual funds and their impact on stocks’, Goldman Sachs Investment Research, New York.

Mariscal, O.J. (1998c), ‘Chilean Pension and mutual funds and their impact on stocks’, Goldman Sachs Investment Research, New York.

Mariscal, O.J. (1998d), ‘Mexican Pension and mutual funds and their impact on stocks’, Goldman Sachs Investment Research, New York.

Mehra, R. and Prescott, E.C. (1985), ‘The equity premium: a puzzle’, Journal of Monetary Economics, vol. 15, pp. 145-161.

Merton, R.C. and Bodie, Z. (1992), ‘On the management of financial guarantees’, Financial Management, Winter, pp. 87-109.

Monks, R.A.G. (1992), ‘Reckless “prudence”: investment of pension fund assets in the United States of America’, Lens.

Musumeci, J., ‘Investing for a distant goal: optimal asset allocation and attitudes toward risk’, TIAA-CREF Research Dialogues, no. 56.

Nowakowski, C. and Ralli, P. (1987), ‘International investment, diversification and global markets’, in Altman, E.I. (ed.), Handbook of Financial Markets and Institutions, John Wiley, New York.

OECD (1998), Maintaing Prosperity in an Ageing Society, Paris.

Otermin, M. and Zablotzky, E. (1996), Análisis de la Performance de los Fondos de Jubilaciones y Pensiones en Argentina, Centro de Estudios Macroeconómicos de Argentina.

Palacios, R. and Rocha, R. (1998), ‘The Hungarian pension system in transition’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion paper no. 9805, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Palacios, R. and Whitehouse, E.R. (1998), ‘Individual choice and the transition to a funded pension system’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper no. 9812, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Papke, L.E. (1998), ‘How are participants invesdting their accounts in participant-directed individual account pension plans?’ American Economic Review, vol. 88, no. 2, pp. 212-216.

Parisi, F. and Parisi, A. (1997), ‘Desempeño y ranking de los fondos mutuos de renta variable en Chile desde 1992 a 1995’, Revista de Análisis Económico, vol. 12, no. 2, pp. 101-123.

Poterba, J.M and Wise, D.A. (1998), ‘Individual financial decisions in retirement savings plans’, in Feldstein, M. (ed.), Privatising Social Security, University of Chicago Press for National Bureau of Economic Research.

Pratten, C. and Stachell, S. (1998), Pension Scheme Investment Policies, Research Report no. 82, Department of Social Security, London.

Queisser, M. (1998a), ‘Regulation and supervision of pension funds: principles and practices’, International Social Security Review, vol. 51, no. 2.

Queisser, M. (1998b), ‘The second-generation pension reforms in Latin America’, Ageing Working Paper no. 5.4, OECD, Paris.

Ramirez Tomic, M. (1997), ‘Efecto manada en la administración de los fondos de pensiones Chilenos: relevancia de la regulación vigente’, mimeo., Seminario de Título Microeconomía, Santiago.

Reisen, H. (1997), ‘Liberalising foreign investment by pension funds: positive and normative aspects’, World Development, July.

Reisen, H. (1998a), ‘Liberalising foreign investment by pension funds: positive and normative aspects’, Ageing Working Paper no. 5.3, OECD, Paris.

Reisen, H. (1998b), ‘Warning: past pension fund performance is no guarantee for future performance’, in Blommenstein, H.J. and Funke, N. (eds), Institutional Investors in the New Financial Landscape, OECD, Paris.

Reisen, H. and Williamson, J. (1997), ‘Pension Funds, capital controls, and macroeconomic stability’, in Valdés-Prieto, S. (ed.), The Economics of Pensions: Principles, Policies and International Experience, Cambridge University Press.

Rojas-Suarez and Weisbrod, S. (1996), ‘Building stability in Latin American financial markets’, pp. 139-166 in

Hausmann, R. and Reisen, H. (eds), Securing Stability and Growth in Latin America: Policy Issues and Prospects for Shock-Prone Economies, OECD, Paris.

Samuelson, P.A. (1989a), ‘The judgement of economic science on rational portfolio management: indexing, timing and long-horizon effects’, Journal of Portfolio Management, pp. 4-12, Fall.

Samuelson, P.A. (1989b), ‘A case at last for age-phased reduction in equity’, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 86, pp. 9048-9051.

Schwarz, A.M. and Demirguç-Kunt, A. (1999), ‘Taking stock of pension reforms around the world’, Pension Reform Primer series, Social Protection Discussion Paper no. 9917, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Shah, H. (1997), ‘Toward better regulation of private pension funds’, Policy Research Working Paper no. 1791, World Bank.

Shoven, J.B. (1999), ‘The location and allocation of assets in pension and conventional savings accounts’, Working Paper no. 7007, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, Mass.

Singh, A. (1993), ‘The stock-market and economic development: should developing countries encourage stock markets?’, UNCTAD Review, no. 4, United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, Geneva.

Singh, A. (1996), ‘Pension reform, the stock market, capital formation and economic growth: a critical commentary on the World Bank’s proposals’, International Social Security Review, vol. 49, no. 3.

Solnik, B.H. (1991), International Investments, Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass.

Solnik, B.H., Boucle, C and Le Fur, Y., ‘International market correlation and volatility’, Financial Analysts Journal, 9/10.

Sunden, A.E. and Surette, B.J. (1998), ‘Gender differences in the allocation of assets in retirement savings plans’, American Economic Review, vol. 88, no. 2, pp. 207-211.

Srinivas, P.S. and Yermo. J. (1998), ‘Do Investment Regulations Compromise Pension Fund Performance – Evidence from Latin America’, forthcoming in The Viewpoints Series of the Latin American and Caribbean Region, The World Bank.

Tirole, J. (1988) The Theory of Industrial Organisation, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

United Kingdom, Department of Social Security (1998), A New Contract for Welfare: Partnership in Pensions, London. United Kingdom, Her Majesty’s Treasury (1999), ‘Helping to deliver stakeholder pensions: flexibility in pension investment’, London.

Uthoff, A. W. (1997), ‘Reformas a los sistemas de pensiones, mercado de capitales y ahorro’, Revista de la CEPAL, no 63, December.

Valdés-Prieto, S. (1997), ‘Libertad de precios para las AFPs: aún insuficiente’, Estudios Públicos, no. 68, Primavera, Santiago.

Valdés-Prieto, S. and Ramírez, M. (1999), ‘Herding in DC pension funds: regulation or market forces?’, mimeo.

VanDerhei, J.L., Galer, R., Quick, C. and Rea, J. (1999), 401(k) Plan Asset Allocation, Account Balances, and Loan Activity, Employee Benefit Research Institute, Washington, D.C.

Vittas, D. (1996), ‘Pension funds and capital markets’, Financial Sector Development Note no. 71, World Bank.

Vittas, D. (1998a), ‘The role of non-bank financial intermediaries’, Policy Research Working Paper no. 1892, World Bank.

Vittas, D. (1998b), ‘Regulatory controversies of private pension funds’, Policy Research Working Paper no. 1893, World Bank.

Vittas, D. (1998c), ‘Investment rules and state guarantees for mandatory private pension funds’, in Blommenstein, H. J. and Funke, N. (eds), Institutional Investors in the New Financial Landscape, OECD, Paris.

Walker, E. (1991), ‘Reflexiones en torno a políticas de inversión adecuadas para las AFP’, Cuadernos de Economía, no. 85, December.

Walker, E. (1993a), ‘Desempeño financiero de las carteras de renta fija de los fondos de pensiones en Chile. ha tenido desventajas ser grandes?’, Cuadernos de Economía, no. 89, April.

Walker, E. (1993b), ‘Desempeño financiero de las carteras accionarias de los fondos de pensiones en Chile. ha tenido desventajas ser grandes?’, Cuadernos de Economía, no. 89, April.

World Bank (1994), Averting the Old Age Crisis: Policies to Protect the Old and Promote Growth, Oxford University Press.

Yaboboski, P.J. and VanDerhei, J.L. (1996), ‘Worker investment decisions: an analysis of large 401(k) plan data’, Issue Brief no. 176, Employee Benefit Research Institute, Washington, D.C.

Zheng, L. (1998), ‘Is money smart? A survey of mutual fund investors’ fund selection ability’, Journal of Finance.