Accounting Regulation and Management Discretion in a British Building Society, Circa 1960

Batiz-Lazo, Bernardo and Billings, Mark (2009): Accounting Regulation and Management Discretion in a British Building Society, Circa 1960.

Abstract

This article explores the manipulation of published financial reports in order to counter the potentially unfavourable impact of newly introduced regulation. In this case the reported capital ratio of a major building society was enhanced using a sale and leaseback transaction with a related party and a change in depreciation policy, methods which reflected limited alternatives. Analysis of the case is set in the context of the mid-term performance of the building society sector and addresses the questions of whether the manipulations involved were within then-prevailing generally accepted accounting principles and why, despite disclosure in the society’s financial statements, these failed to attract public comment or concern, regulatory action or an audit qualification. In examining a major British mutual financial organisation we depart from traditional analyses of managerial discretion in accounting choices in manufacturing, mining and transport companies prior to the watershed Companies Act 1948.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Accounting manipulation; Creative accounting; Sale and leaseback; Depreciation; Building societies; United Kingdom
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N24 - Europe: 1913-; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M4 - Accounting and Auditing > M42 - Auditing; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty > D82 - Asymmetric and Private Information ; Mechanism Design

References

Primary Sources

Building Societies Association (BSA) Archives, London: Report of the Council, 1959-60 and 1960-61.

BSA Circulars:-

664 (Evidence to the Radcliffe Committee, 3 July 1958).

671 (Memorandum on Annual Surpluses and Reserves, 8 August 1958).

Co-operative Permanent Building Society Archives (Nationwide Building Society), Wellingborough:

Board Minutes, 1943-65.

Confidential Minute Book, 1944-65.

National Archives, Kew, London (TNA): Building Society Annual Returns (forms A.R. 11) to the Chief Registrar of Friendly Societies, series FS14, 1951-60:

466: Abbey National.

472: Alliance.

559: Co-operative Permanent.

607: Exeter Benefit.

623: Halifax.

673: Leeds Permanent.

674: Leek and Moorlands.

900: Woolwich Equitable.

1961-70: FS14/ 976: Co-operative Permanent.

U.K. Statutes and Statutory Instruments, HMSO, London: House Purchase and Housing Act, 1959.

Building Societies (Designation for Trustee Investments) Regulations, 1959 (S. I. No. 1010).

Building Societies Act, 1960.

Building Societies (Accounts) Regulations, 1960 (S. I. No. 1826).

Building Societies (Annual Return and Auditor’s Report) Regulations, 1960 (S. I. No. 1827).

Woolwich Equitable Building Society Archive (Barclays Group plc), Manchester, England (referred to as WEBSA):

Development Committee papers, 1958 (1023/1249)

Board Minutes, 1958 (1023/49)

Private Communication: Richard Driver, Senior Partner, Myers Clark Chartered Accountants, Watford, on the history of Myers Clark, 2 February 2006.

Secondary Sources

Arnold, A. J., ‘Secret Reserves or Special Credits? A Reappraisal of the Reserve and Provision Accounting Policies of the Royal Mail Steam Packet Company, 1915-27’, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 21, No. 83, 1991.

Arnold, A.J., ‘Publishing your Private Affairs to the World’, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol. 7, No. 2, 1997.

Arnold, A. J. and P. Collier, The Evolution of Reserve and Provision Accounting in the UK, 1938-50, Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland, 2007.

Arnold, A. J. and D. R. Matthews, ‘Corporate Financial Disclosures in the UK, 1920-50: The Effects of Legislative Change and Managerial Discretion’, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 32, No. 1, 2002.

Ashworth, H., The Building Society Story, Franey & Co., 1980.

Ball, R., R. G. Walker and G. P. Whittred, ‘Audit Qualifications and Share Prices’, Abacus, Vol. 15, No. 1, 1979.

Barrow, R., Fifty More Years of the Halifax, 1953-2003, Richard Barrow, 2006.

Bátiz-Lazo, B., ‘Strategic Alliances and Competitive Edge: Insights from Spanish and U.K. Banking Histories’, Business History, Vol. 46, No. 1, 2004.

Bátiz-Lazo, B., ‘Changes in the depreciation of buildings in an English building society, circa 1959’, unpublished paper presented at 11th World Congress of Accounting Historians, Nantes, 2006.

Bátiz-Lazo, B. and M. Billings, ‘In Search of a Winning Strategy: A Case Study of Strategic Change at the Woolwich Equitable Building Society (1950-70)’, unpublished paper presented at Fifth Accounting History International Conference, Banff, 2007.

Bátiz-Lazo, B. and P. Wardley, ‘Banking on Change: Information Systems and Technologies in U.K. High Street Banking, 1919-1969’, Financial History Review, Vol. 14, No. 2, 2007.

Billings, M. and F. H. Capie, ‘Transparency and Financial Reporting in Mid-twentieth Century British Banking’, Accounting Forum, Vol. 33, No. 1, 2009.

Boddy, M., The Building Societies. Macmillan, 1980.

Boléat, M., Building Societies - A Descriptive Study, Building Societies Association, 1981.

Boléat, M., The Building Society Industry, Allen & Unwin, 1986.

BSA, Building Societies Yearbook: Official Handbook of the Building Societies Association. Franey & Co., 1950 to 1968. Building Societies Gazette.

Capie, F. and M. Billings, ‘Accounting Issues and the Measurement of Profits - English Banks 1920-68’, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol. 11, No. 2, 2001.

Cassell, M., Inside Nationwide: One Hundred Years of Co-operation, Nationwide Building Society, 1984.

Chandler, R. A., J. R. Edwards and M. Anderson, ‘Changing Perceptions of the Role of the Company Auditor, 1840-1940’, Accounting and Business Research, Vol. 23, No. 92, 1993.

Clarke, F. L., G. W. Dean and K. Oliver, Corporate Collapse: Accounting, Regulatory and Ethical Failure, second edition, Cambridge University Press, 2003.

Cleary, E. J., The Building Society Movement, Elek Books, 1965.

Clinch, G., ‘Alternative Hypotheses Concerning the Depreciation of Buildings’, Abacus, Vol. 19, No. 2, 1983.

Cortada, J. W., The Digital Hand (Vol. I), Oxford University Press, 2004.

Craswell, A. T., ‘An Examination of Alternative Hypotheses Concerning the Depreciation of Buildings’, Abacus, Vol. 22, No. 1, 1986.

Davies, G., Building Societies and their Branches: A Regional Economic Survey, Franey & Co., 1981.

de Paula, C., The Principles of Auditing, Sir Isaac Pitman & Sons, 1957 Economist.

Greer, R., Building Societies? Fabian Research Series No. 319, 1974.

Harvey, C. E., ‘Old Traditions, New Departures: The Later History of the Bristol & West Building Society’, in C. E. Harvey and J. Press, Studies in the Business History of Bristol, Bristol Academic Press, 1988.

Hobson, O.R., A Hundred Years of the Halifax: The History of the Halifax Building Society, 1853-1953, Batsford, 1953.

Humphries, J., ‘Inter-War House Building, Cheap Money and Building Societies: The Housing Boom Revisited’, Business History, Vol. 29, No. 3, 1987.

Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, Audits of Building Societies, ICAEW, 1960.

Jeremy, D. J., A Business History of Britain 1900-1990s, Oxford University Press, 1998.

Kettle, R., ‘The Auditor’s Report - I (Under the Companies Act, 1948, and Qualifications Thereof).’ The Accountant, Vol. 130, 6 March, 1954a.

Kettle, R., ‘The Auditor’s Report - II (Under the Companies Act, 1948, and Qualifications Thereof).’ The Accountant, Vol. 130, 13 March, 1954b.

Kitchen, J. and Parker, R. H., Accounting Thought and Education: Six English Pioneers, Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, 1980.

Maltby, J., ‘Was the 1947 Companies Act a Response to a National Crisis?’, Accounting History, Vol. 5, No. 2, 2000.

Matthews, D.R., A History of Auditing: The Changing Audit Process in Britain from the Nineteenth Century to the Present Day, Routledge, 2006.

McKillop, D. and C. Ferguson, Building Societies: Structure, Performance and Change, Graham and Trotman, 1993.

Napier, C. J., ‘Fixed Asset Accounting in the Shipping Industry: P&O 1840-1914’, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol. 1, No. 1, 1990.

Napier, C. J., ‘Secret Accounting: the P&O Group in the Inter-War Years’, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol. 1, No. 3, 1991.

Noguchi, M. and B. Bátiz-Lazo, ‘Reforming the Form of the Auditors’ Report: The Case of Building Societies, 1956-1960’, Accounting, Business and Financial History, forthcoming.

Pack, P. A., ‘Form A.R. 11 Again’, Building Societies Gazette, Vol. 80, No. 864, 1959.

Perks, R. W., Building Society Accounts and the Control of Operating Performance, Accounting and Finance. Glasgow, University of Strathclyde: 221, 1977.

Phillips, B. H., Building Society Finance, Chartered Building Societies Institute and Van Nostrand Reinhold (U.K.) Co. Ltd, 1983.

Price, S. J., Building Societies: The Origins and History, Franey & Co., 1959.

Registry of Friendly Societies, Report of the Chief Registrar of Friendly Societies for the Year 1959, Part 5: Building Societies, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1960.

Registry of Friendly Societies, Report of the Chief Registrar of Friendly Societies for the Year 1960 Part 5: Building Societies, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1961.

Registry of Friendly Societies, Report of the Chief Registrar of Friendly Societies for the Year 1961, Part 5: Building Societies, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, 1962.

Scott, P., The Property Masters: A History of the British Commercial Property Sector, E & F.N. Spon, 1996.

Stolowy, H. and G. Breton. ‘Accounts Manipulation: A Literature Review and Proposed Conceptual Framework’, Review of Accounting and Finance, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2004.

The Times. Various issues.