Internal Migration, Selection Bias and Human Development: Evidence from Indonesia and Mexico

Deb, Partha and Seck, Papa (2009): Internal Migration, Selection Bias and Human Development: Evidence from Indonesia and Mexico. Published in: Human Development Research Paper (HDRP) Series , Vol. 31, No. 2009

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to measure the returns to migration using non-experimental data taking both observed and unobserved characteristics into account. A significant challenge related to migration research and the issues of unobserved heterogeneity is that the standard 2stage least squares estimator (2SLS) is strictly only applicable to situations with linear and continuous treatment and outcomes, both of which are not appropriate for models of migration and many outcomes of interest. Furthermore, migration is not always a binary process given that people migrate to city or non-city locations and some migrants do return. Introducing these multinomial treatment effects means that one cannot rely on standard 2SLS methods. Using panel data from Indonesia (Indonesia Family Life Survey—IFLS) and Mexico (Mexican Family Life Survey— MxFLS) and applying non-linear instrumental variable (Heckman’s treatment effects model) and maximum simulated likelihood models, we measure the impacts of migration on a broad range of variables that include socio economic outcomes such as consumption, nutrition, health status and emotional well-being for adult household members and health and schooling outcomes for children. We find consistent results for both countries that point to significant trade-offs related to migration. We found that migration can greatly improve socio-economic status through increases in income or consumption but can also be detrimental to the health status and emotional well-being of migrants and/or their extended families.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: The aim of this paper is to measure the returns to migration using non-experimental data taking both observed and unobserved characteristics into account. A significant challenge related to migration research and the issues of unobserved heterogeneity is that the standard 2stage least squares estimator (2SLS) is strictly only applicable to situations with linear and continuous treatment and outcomes, both of which are not appropriate for models of migration and many outcomes of interest. Furthermore, migration is not always a binary process given that people migrate to city or non-city locations and some migrants do return. Introducing these multinomial treatment effects means that one cannot rely on standard 2SLS methods. Using panel data from Indonesia (Indonesia Family Life Survey—IFLS) and Mexico (Mexican Family Life Survey— MxFLS) and applying non-linear instrumental variable (Heckman’s treatment effects model) and maximum simulated likelihood models, we measure the impacts of migration on a broad range of variables that include socio economic outcomes such as consumption, nutrition, health status and emotional well-being for adult household members and health and schooling outcomes for children. We find consistent results for both countries that point to significant trade-offs related to migration. We found that migration can greatly improve socio-economic status through increases in income or consumption but can also be detrimental to the health status and emotional well-being of migrants and/or their extended families.
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C3 - Multiple or Simultaneous Equation Models ; Multiple Variables; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C8 - Data Collection and Data Estimation Methodology ; Computer Programs

References

Adams, J. (2004). Remittances and Poverty in Guatemala. SSRN eLibrary.

Adams, R. J., Cuecuecha, A., & Page, J. (2008). Remittances, Consumption and Investment in Ghana. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper, 4515.

Alderman, H., Behrman, J., Kohler, H. P., Maluccio, J., & Watkins, S. (2001). Attrition in Longitudinal Household Survey Data. Demographic Research, 5, 79-124.

Amuedo-Dorantes, C., Sainz, T., and Pozo, S. (2007). Remittances and Healthcare Expenditure Patterns of Populations in Origin Communities: Evidence from Mexico.

Antecol, Heather and Bedard, Kelly. Unhealthy assimilation: Why do immigrants converge to American health status levels. IZA Discussion Paper Series [1654]. 2005. Bonn.

Beegle, K., De Weerdt, J., & Dercon, S. (2008). Migration and Economic Mobility in Tanzania: Evidence from a Tracking Survey. SSRN eLibrary.

Borjas, G. J. (1988). Self-Selection and the Earnings of Immigrants. The American Economic Review, 77, 531-553.

Bowles, S. (1970). Migration as Investment: Empirical Tests of the Human Investment Approach to Geographical Mobility. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 52, 356-362.

Bracking, S. (2003). Sending money home: are remittances always beneficial to those who stay behind? Journal of International Development, 15, 633-644.

Carballo, M. (2007). The challenge of migration and health. ICMH Feature Article.

Deb, P. & Trivedi, P. (2006a). Maximum simulated likelihood estimation of a negative binomial regression model with multinomial endogenous treatment. Stata Journal, 6, 246- 255.

Deb, P. & Trivedi, P. K. (2006b). Specification and Simulated Likelihood Estimation of a Non-Normal Treatment-Outcome Model With Selection: Application to Health Care Utilization. Econometrics Journal, Vol.9, No.2, pp.307-331, July 2006.

Fennelly, Katherine. "The Healthy Migrant Effect." Healthy Generations 5.3 (2005). Frankenberg, E and Karoly, L. The 1993 Indonesian Family Life Survey: Overview and Field Report. 1995. November, 1995. RAND. DRU-1195/1-NICHD/AID.

Greenwood, M. (1975). Research on Internal Migration in the United States, a Survey. Journal of Economic Literature, 13, 379-433.

Gourieroux, C., A. Monfort, and A. Trognon. "Pseudo Maximum Likelihood Methods: Theory." Econometrica 52.3 (1984): 681-700. Greenwood, M. (2004). Internal Migration (Further Types): Industrialized Countries. International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioral Sciences, 7737-7741.

Greenwood, M. J. (1997a). Chapter 12 Internal migration in developed countries. In Handbook of Population and Family Economics (pp. 647-720). Elsevier.

Greenwood, M. J. (1997b). Chapter 12 Internal migration in developed countries. In Handbook of Population and Family Economics (pp. 647-720). Elsevier.

Gustafsson, B. & Makonnen, N. (1993). Poverty and Remittances in Lesotho. Journal of African Economies, 2, 49-73.

Halliday, T. (2006). Migration, Risk, and Liquidity Constraints in El Salvador. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 54, 893-925.

Harris, J. R. & Todaro, M. P. (1970). Migration, Unemployment and Development: A Two- Sector Analysis. The American Economic Review, 60, 126-142.

Hoddinott, J. (2000). A Model of Migration and Remittances Applied to Western Kenya. Oxford Economic Papers, 46, 459-476.

Kanaiaupuni, S. M. & Donato, K. M. (1999). Migradollars and Mortality: The Efffects of Migration on Infant Survival in Mexico. Demography, 36, 339-353.

Lauby, J. & Stark, O. (2000). Individual Migration as a Family Strategy: Young Women in the Philippines. Population Studies, 42, 473-486.

Lucas, R. & Stark, O. (1985). Motivations to remit: evidence from Botswana. The Journal of Political Economy, 93, 901-918.

Lucas, R. E. B. (1997). Internal Migration in Developing Countries. In Handbook of Population and Family Economics ( Elsevier Science.

Massey, D. S. (1990). Social Structure, Household Strategies, and the Cumulative Causation of Migration. Population Index, 56, 3-26.

McKay, L., Macintyre, S., and Ellaway, A. (2003). Migration and health: a review of the international literature.

McKenzie, D. & Sasin, M. (2007). Migration, Remittances, Poverty, and Human Capital. World Bank, WPS4274.

McKenzie, D. J., Gibson, J., & Stillman, S. (2006). How Important is Selection? Experimental Versus Non-experimental Measures of the Income Gains from Migration. SSRN eLibrary.

Miguel, E. & Kremer, M. (2004). Worms: Identifying Impacts on Education and Health in the Presence of Treatment Externalities. Econometrica, 72, 159-217. Muedo-Dorantes, C., Georges, A., & Pozo, S. Migration, Remittances and Children's Schooling in Haiti. SSRN eLibrary.

Mueller, V. & Sharif, A. (2009). Preliminary Evidence on Internal Migration, Remittances, and Teen Schooling in India. International Food Policy Research Institute.

Munshi, K. (2003). Networks in the Modern Economy: Mexican Migrants in the U.S. Labor Market*. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118, 549-599. O'Donnell, Owen et al. "Health Outcome #3: Adult Health." Analyzing Health Equity Using Household Survey Data. The World Bank, 2007. 57-66.

Ravallion, M. (2005). Evaluating Anti-Poverty Programs. SSRN eLibrary.

Roberts, K. D. & Morris, M. D. S. (2003). Fortune, Risk, and Remittances: An Application of Option Theory to Participation in Village-Based Migration Networks. International Migration Review, 37, 1252-1281.

Rosenbaum, P. R. & Rubin, D. B. (1984). Reducing Bias in Observational Studies Using Subclassification on the Propensity Score. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 79, 516-524.

Rosenzweig, M. & Stark, O. (1989). Consumption Smoothing, Migration, and Marriage: Evidence from Rural India. Journal of Political Economy, 97, 905-926.

Rubalcava, Luis and Teruel, Graciela. User's Guide for the Mexican Family Life Survey First Wave. 2006. www.mxfls.uia.mx.

Sjaastad, L. A. (1962). The Costs and Returns of Human Migration. The Journal of Political Economy, 70, 80-93.

Stark, O. (1991). The Migration of Labor. Basil Blackwell.

Stark, O. & Bloom, D. (1985). The new economics of Labour Migration. American Economic Review, 75, 173-178.

Stark, O., Taylor, J. E., & Yitzhaki, S. (1986). Remittances and Inequality. The Economic Journal, 96, 722-740.

Strauss, John; Beegle, Kathleen; Sikoki, Bondan; Dwiyanto Agus; Herawati, Yulia; Witoelar, Firman. The Third Wave of the Indonesia Family Life Survey: Overview and Field Report

(IFLS3). 2004. March 2004. WR-144/1-NIA/NICHD. Thomas, D., Frankenberg, E., & Smith, J. P. (2001). Lost but Not Forgotten: Attrition and Follow-up in the Indonesia Family Life Survey. Journal of Human Resources, 556-592.

Tirtosudarmo, R. (2009). Indonesia: Human Development on the Move.

Todaro, M. P. (1969). A Model of Labor Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less Developed Countries. The American Economic Review, 59, 138-148.

Wodon, Q., Diego, A., Gabriel, G., Diana, O. R., and Corinne, S. (2003). Migration and Poverty in Mexico's Southern States. http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/10574/.

Yang, D. (2005). International Migration, Human Capital, and Entrepreneurship: evidence from Philippine migrants? exchange rate shocks. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series.