Distributional effects of a flat tax: An empirical analysis for the Netherlands

Caminada, Koen and Goudswaard, Kees (1997): Distributional effects of a flat tax: An empirical analysis for the Netherlands. Published in: Department of Economics Research Memorandum No. 97.04 (1997): pp. 1-34.

Abstract

In this paper, we construct a flat rate/broad base personal income tax system and we compare the distribution of the current personal income tax (including social contributions) in the Netherlands to the distribution of the simulated flat rate tax. Using extended data (personal income panel survey), the effects are simulated of eliminating deductions in exchange for a reduction in tax rates, sufficient to keep personal income tax revenue constant at the initial level and distribution of pre-tax incomes. Our simulations indicate that: - The redistributive effect of the current rate structure of the Dutch tax system - with marginal rates of 37.5%, 50% and 60% - is substantially diminished by tax deductions. Deductions appear to be very income-elastic. - After the simulated base broadening, a proportional rate of 33.2% balances the budget (ex ante). Such a flat rate causes only relatively small changes in average tax ratios. For a clear majority of the taxpayers, effects on after-tax income lie within a range of minus/plus 5%. - Tax progressivity is mainly caused by the fixed personal exemption, which was maintained in the simulated flat rate tax. We calculated only a 7 percent lower income elasticity in a flat rate system. We conclude that the income effects of the introduction of a broad base/flat personal income tax would be relatively small and cannot be considered as prohibitive.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: flat tax, deductions, progressivity, distribution of the tax burden
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H22 - Incidence; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies

References

Allers, M.A. (1994) Administrative and Compliance Costs of Taxation and Public Transfers in the Netherlands, Wolters-Noordhoff, Groningen.

Atkinson, A.B. (1995) Public Economics in Action: The Basic Income/Flat Tax Proposal, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Caminada, K. and K.P. Goudswaard (1996) 'Progression and Revenue Effects of Income Tax Reform' International Tax and Public Finance 3 (1), pp.57-66.

Caminada, K. (1996) De progressie van het belastingstelsel (Phd in Dutch about Liability Progression and Tax Revenue Elasticity), Thesis Publishers, Amsterdam.

Central Bureau of Statistics (1993) Statistical Yearbook (in Dutch), Heerlen/Voorburg.

Central Bureau of Statistics (1993) Personal Income Distribution 1990 (in Dutch), SDU-uitgeverij, The Hague.

Cnossen, S., and K. Messere (1990) 'Income Tax Reforms in OECD Member Countries' Bulletin International Bureau of Fiscal Documentation, October, pp.463-483.

Cnossen, S. (1995) 'Towards a New Tax Covenant' De Economist 143 (3), pp.285-315.

Economist, The (1996) America's Tax Reform, January 13th, pp.52-54.

Feld, A.L. (1995) 'Living with the Flat Tax' National Tax Journal 48 (4), pp.603-618.

Formby, J.P., W.J. Smith and P.D. Thistle (1990) 'The Average Tax Burden and the Welfare Implications of Global Tax Progressivity' Public Finance Quarterly 18 (1), pp.3-24.

Frederiksen, N.K. (1994) A Dynamic General Equilibrium Simulation Model for Fiscal Policy Analysis, EPRU Economic Studies 1/1994, Copenhagen Business School.

Frederiksen, N.K. (1996) Flat Rate Income Taxation: Macroeconomic and Efficiency Effects, paper presented at the 52nd IIPF Congress, August 26-29, Tel Aviv, Israel.

Hall, R.E., and A. Rabushka (1985) The Flat Tax, Hoover Institution Press, Stanford.

Herwaarden, F.G. Van, and C.A. De Kam (1983) 'An Operational Concept of the Ability to Pay Principle (with an Application for the Netherlands, 1973)' De Economist 131 (1), pp.55-64.

Kakwani, N.C. (1977) 'Applications of Lorenz Curves in Economic Analysis' Econometrica 45 (3), pp.719-727.

Kiefer, D.W. (1984) 'Distributional Tax Progressivity Indexes' National Tax Journal 37, pp.497-513.

Lambert, P.J., and W. Pfähler (1992) 'Income Tax Pro¬gression and Redistributive Effect: The Influence of Changes in the Pre-Tax Income Distribution' Public Finance 47 (1), pp.1-16.

Lambert, P.J. (1993) The Distribution and Redistribution of Income: a Mathematical Analysis, second edition, Manchester University Press, Manchester.

McLure, C.E. Jr. (1996) 'International Implications of the Flat Tax' Bulletin for International Fiscal Documentation, November/December, pp.511-515.

Ministerie van Financiën (1994) Bouwstenennotitie; Materiaal voor onderhoud en aanpassing van de loon en inkomstenbelasting op weg naar 2000 (report by the Dutch Ministry of Finance about adjusting the income tax system around the year 2000), The Hague.

OECD (1994) The OECD Jobs Study: Evidence and Explanations, part 1 and 2, Paris.

Owens, J. (1997) Emerging Issues in Tax Reform: the Perspective of an International Administrator, paper presented at the 53rd IIPF Congress, August 25th, Kyoto, Japan.

Pechman, J.A. (1990) 'The Future of the Income Tax' American Economic Review 80 (1), pp.1 20.

Ruiz-Huerta, J., J. Lopez-Laborda, J. Onrubia and N. Badenes (1996) Income Tax Reform, Fiscal Decentralization and Income Redistribution: Some Empirical Evidence for the Spanish Case Derived from a Panel Data Base Analysis, paper presented at the 52nd IIPF Congress, August 26-29, Tel Aviv, Israel.

Simons, H.C. (1938) Personal Income Taxation, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Sørensen, P.B. (1994) 'From the Global Income Tax to the Dual Income Tax: Recent Tax Reforms in the Nordic Countries' International Tax and Public Finance 1 (1), pp.57-79.

Stevens, L.G.M. (1996) 'Dual Income Tax Systems: A European Challenge?' EC Tax Review 5 (1), pp. 6-12.