Do Parking Requirements Significantly Increase The Area Dedicated To Parking? A Test Of The Effect Of Parking Requirements Values In Los Angeles County

Franco, Sofia and Cutter, Bowman and DeWoody, Autumn (2010): Do Parking Requirements Significantly Increase The Area Dedicated To Parking? A Test Of The Effect Of Parking Requirements Values In Los Angeles County.

Abstract

Minimum parking requirements are the norm for urban and suburban development in the United States (Davidson and Dolnick (2002)). The justification for parking space requirements is that overflow parking will occupy nearby street or off-street parking. Shoup (1999) and Willson (1995) provides cases where there is reason to believe that parking space requirements have forced parcel developers to place more parking than they would in the absence of parking requirements. If the effect of parking minimums is to significantly increase the land area devoted to parking, then the increase in impervious surfaces would likely cause water quality degradation, increased flooding, and decreased groundwater recharge. However, to our knowledge the existing literature does not test the effect of parking minimums on the amount of lot space devoted to parking beyond a few case studies. This paper tests the hypothesis that parking space requirements cause an oversupply of parking by examining the implicit marginal value of land allocated to parking spaces. This is an indirect test of the effects of parking requirements that is similar to Glaeser and Gyourko (2003). A simple theoretical model shows that the marginal value of additional parking to the sale price should be equal to the cost of land plus the cost of parking construction. We estimate the marginal values of parking and lot area with spatial methods using a large data set from the Los Angeles area non-residential property sales and find that for most of the property types the marginal value of parking is significantly below that of the parcel area. This evidence supports the contention that minimum parking requirements significantly increase the amount of parcel area devoted to parking.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Minimum Parking Requirements; Land Use; Externalities
• Subjects: R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R5 - Regional Government Analysis > R52 - Land Use and Other Regulations; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies

References

Anderson, S. P. and A. de Palma (2004). "The economics of pricing parking." Journal of Urban Economics 55(1): 1-20.

Arnold, C. L. and C. J. Gibbons (1996). "Impervious surface coverage - The emergence of a key environmental indicator." Journal of the American Planning Association 62(2): 243-258.

Arnott, R., Tilmann Rave, and Ronnie Schob (2005). Alleviating Urban traffic Congestion. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

Bento, A. M., S. F. Franco, et al. (2006). "The efficiency and distributional impacts of alternative anti-sprawl policies." Journal of Urban Economics 59 (1): 121-141.

Bell, K. P. and N. E. Bockstael (2000). "Applying the generalized-moments estimation approach to spatial problems involving micro level data." Review of Economics and Statistics 82(1): 72-82.

Bollinger, C. R., K. R. Ihlanfeldt, et al. (1998). "Spatial variation in office rents within the Atlanta region." Urban Studies 35(7): 1097-1118.

Brueckner, J. K. (2000). "Urban sprawl: Diagnosis and remedies." International Regional Science Review 23(2): 160-171.

Chattopadhyay, S., J. B. Braden, et al. (2005). "Benefits of hazardous waste cleanup: New evidence from survey- and market-based property value approaches." Contemporary Economic Policy 23(3): 357-375.

Colwell, P. F. (1993). "Semiparametric Estimates Of The Marginal Price Of Floorspace - Comment." Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 7(1): 73-75.

Colwell, P. F. and H. J. Munneke (2006). "Bargaining strength and property class in office markets." Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 33(3): 197-213.

Colwell, P. F., H. J. Munneke, et al. (1998). "Chicago's office market: Price indices, location and time." Real Estate Economics 26(1): 83-106.

Colwell, P. F. and C. F. Sirmans (1978). "Area, Time, Centrality And Value Of Urban Land." Land Economics 54(4): 514-519.

Cutter, W. B., K. A. Baerenklau, et al. (2008). "Costs and benefits of capturing urban runoff with competitive bidding for decentralized best management practices." Water Resources Research 44(9).

Cutter, W. B., Dewoody, et al. (forthcoming). "Parking Externalities in Commercial Real Estate."

Davidson, M., F. Dolnick, et al. (2002). Parking standards. Chicago, IL, American Planning Association, Planning Advisory Service.

Deaton, B. J. and J. P. Hoehn (2004). "Hedonic analysis of hazardous waste sites in the presence of other urban disamenities." Environmental Science & Policy 7(6): 499-508.

Ecker, M. D. and H. R. Isakson (2005). "A unified convex-concave model of urban land values." Regional Science and Urban Economics 35(3): 265-277.

Feitelson, E. and O. Rotem (2004). "The case for taxing surface parking." Transportation Research Part D-Transport and Environment 9(4): 319-333.

Ferguson, B. K. (2005). Porous pavements. Boca Raton, Fla., Taylor & Francis.

Ferguson, E. (2003). "Zoning for parking as policy innovation." Transportation Quarterly 57(2): 47-55.

Fisher, J., D. Gatzlaff, et al. (2003). "Controlling for the impact of variable liquidity in commercial real estate price indices." Real Estate Economics 31(2): 269-303.

Glaeser, E. L. and J. Gyourko (2003). "The Impact of Building Restrictions on Housing Affordability." Federal Reserve Bank of New York Economic Policy Review 9(2): 21-39.

Hodgson, D. J., B. A. Slade, et al. (2006). "Constructing commercial indices: A semiparametric adaptive estimator approach." Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 32(2): 151-168.

Hunnicutt, J. (1982). Parking, Loading, and Terminal Facilities. Transportation and Traffic Engineering Handbook. I. o. T. Engineering, Prentice Hall.

Ihlanfeldt, K. R. and L. O. Taylor (2004). "Externality effects of small-scale hazardous waste sites: evidence from urban commercial property markets." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 47(1): 117-139.

Institute of Transportation Engineers. (1985). Parking generation. Washington, D.C., USA, Institute of Transportation Engineers.

Kennedy, P. and NetLibrary Inc. (1998). A Guide To Econometrics. Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press,.

Kiel, K. A. and M. Williams (2007). "The impact of Superfund sites on local property values: Are all sites the same?" Journal of Urban Economics 61(1): 170-192.

Krinsky, I. and A. L. Robb (1986). "On Approximating The Statistical Properties Of Elasticities." Review of Economics and Statistics 68(4): 715-719.

Levine, J. and A. Inam (2004). "The market for transportation-land use integration: Do developers want smarter growth than regulations allow?" Transportation 31(4): 409-427.

Maddison, D. (2006). "Environmental Kuznets curves: A spatial econometric approach." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 51(2): 218-230.

Manville, M. and D. Shoup (2005). "Parking, people, and cities." Journal of Urban Planning and Development-Asce 131(4): 233-245.

McCluskey, J. J. and G. C. Rausser (2003). "Hazardous waste sites and housing appreciation rates." Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 45(2): 166-176.

Munneke, H. J. (1996). "Redevelopment decisions for commercial and industrial properties." Journal of Urban Economics 39(2): 229-253.

Munneke, H. J. (2005). "Dynamics of the urban zoning structure: An empirical investigation of zoning change." Journal of Urban Economics 58(3): 455-473.

Munneke, H. J. and B. A. Slade (2001). "A metropolitan transaction-based commercial price index: A time-varying parameter approach." Real Estate Economics 29(1): 55-84.

Ryan, S. (2005). "The value of access to highways and light rail transit: Evidence for industrial and office firms." Urban Studies 42(4): 751-764.

Shoup, D. C. (1999). "In lieu of required parking." Journal of Planning Education and Research 18(4): 307-320.

Shoup, D. C. (1999). "The trouble with minimum parking requirements." Transportation Research Part a-Policy and Practice 33(7-8): 549-574.

Shoup, D. C. (2004). "The ideal source of local public revenue." Regional Science and Urban Economics 34(6): 753-784.

Shoup, D. C. and American Planning Association. (2005). The high cost of free parking. Chicago, Planners Press, American Planning Association.

Shoup, D. C. and D. H. Pickrell (1978). "Problems With Parking Requirements In Zoning Ordinances." Traffic Quarterly 32(4): 545-561.

Simons, R. A. and J. D. Saginor (2006). "A meta-analysis of the effect of environmental contamination and positive amenities on residential real estate values." Journal of Real Estate Research 28(1): 71-104.

Sivitanidou, R. (1995). "Urban Spatial Variations In Office-Commercial Rents - The Role Of Spatial Amenities And Commercial Zoning." Journal of Urban Economics 38(1): 23-49.

Small, K.A. (1992). “using the revenues from congestion pricing.” Transportation 19: 359-381.

Willson, R. W. (1995). "Suburban Parking Requirements - A Tacit Policy For Automobile Use And Sprawl." Journal of the American Planning Association 61(1): 29-42.