The Inheritance of Gregory Clark

McCloskey, Deirdre Nansen (2009): The Inheritance of Gregory Clark.

Abstract

An extreme materialist hypothesis explaining the Industrial Revolution would be simply genetic. Gregory Clark asserts such a theory of sociobiological inheritance in his Farewell to Alms (2007). Rich people proliferated in England, Clark argues, and by a social Darwinian struggle the poor and incompetent died out, leaving a master race of Englishmen with the bourgeois values to conquer the world. Clark will have no truck with ideas as causes, adopting a materialist (and as he believes is implied by materialism a quantitative) theory of truth. His method, that is, follows Marx in historical materialism, as many scholars did 1890 to 1980. But he does not follow through on his promise to show his argument quantitatively. The argument fails, on many grounds. For one thing, non-English people succeeded, as for instance the Chinese now are succeeding. And such people have always done fine in a bourgeois country. For another, Clark does not show that his inheritance mechanism has the quantitative oomph to change people generally into bourgeois, nor does he show that bourgeois habits of working hard mattered, or that bourgeois values caused innovation. What made for success in 1500 is not obviously the same as what made for innovation in 1800. And in the modern world of literacy such values are not transmitted down families, but across families. Literal inheritance anyway dissipates in reversion to the mean. What mattered in modern economic growth was not a doubtfully measured change in the inherited abilities of English people. What mattered was a radical change 1600-1776, “measurable” in every play and pamphlet, in what English people wanted, paid for, revalued.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: gregory clark, economic history, industrial revolution, sociobiological inheritance
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N0 - General > N01 - Development of the Discipline: Historiographical; Sources and Methods; N - Economic History > N0 - General; N - Economic History > N3 - Labor and Consumers, Demography, Education, Health, Welfare, Income, Wealth, Religion, and Philanthropy > N34 - Europe: 1913-

References

Adhia, Nimish. 2009. “Bourgeois Virtues in India: How Bollywood Heralded India’s Economic Liberalization.” Unpublished paper, Department of Economics, University of Illinois at Chicago. At http://www.allacademic.com/ meta/p_mla_apa_ research_citation /3/6/3/7/6/p363765 _index.html

Allen, Robert C. 1983. “Collective Invention.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 4 (1, Jan.): 605-633.

Allen, Robert C. 2006. “The British Industrial Revolution in Global Perspective: How Commerce Created the Industrial Revolution and Modern Economic Growth.” Unpublished paper Nuffield College, Oxford University. At http://www.nuffield.ox.ac.uk/users/allen/ unpublished/econinvent-3.pdf

Ashton, Thomas S. 1948. The Industrial Revolution, 1760-1830. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Barbalet, Jack. 2008. Weber, Passion and Profits: ‘The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism’ in Context. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Bowles, Samuel. 2007. “Genetically Capitalist? Review of Farewell to Alms.” Science 318, no. 5849 (19 Oct): 394-396.

Clark, Gregory, and Gillian Hamilton. 2006. “Survival of the Richest: The Malthusian Mechanism in Pre-Industrial England.” Journal of Economic History 66 (Sept): 707-736.

Clark, Gregory. 1987. “Why Isn’t the Whole World Developed? Lessons from the Cotton Mills.” Journal of Economic History 47 (March): 141-173.

Clark, Gregory. 2007a. A Farewell to Alms: A Brief Economic History of the World. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Clark, Gregory. 2007b. “Some Limited Responses to My Critics.” Power point presentation to the Social Science History Association, Chicago Meeting, November 17.

Clark, Gregory. 2007c. “A Review of Avner Greif’s Institutions and the Path to the Modern Economy: Lessons from Medieval Trade. Journal of Economic Literature 45 (Sept): 727-743.

Collins, Francis. 2007. The Language of God: A Scientist Presents Evidence for Belief. New York: Simon and Schuster.

David, Paul A. 2008. “The Historical Origins of ‘Open Science’: An Essay on Patronage, Reputation and Common Agency Contracting in the Scientific Revolution.” Capitalism and Society 3: 1-103. (Berkeley Electronic Press)

de Vries, Jan. 2008. “Review of Clark, A Farewell to Alms.” Journal of Economic History 68: 1180-1181.

de Vries, Jan. 2008a. “Did People in the Eighteenth Century Really Work Harder, and, If So, Why?” Paper presented to the Midwest Economics Association, Chicago, March.

de Vries, Jan. 2008b. The Industrious Revolution: Consumer Behavior and the Household Economy, 1650 to the Present. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Earle, Peter. 1989. The Making of the English Middle Class: Business, Society and Family Life in London, 1660-1730. London: Methuen.

Easterlin, Richard A. 2004. The Reluctant Economist: Perspectives on Economics, Economic History, and Demography. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Engels, Friedrich. 1877-1878. Anti-Dühring. At http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1877/anti-duhring/index.htm

Forgacs, David, ed. 2000. The Antonio Gramsci Reader: Selected Writings 1916-1935. New York: New York University Press.

Friedman, Benjamin M. 2007. “Industrial Evolution [A Review of Farewell to Alms].” New York Times Sunday Review of Books. Dec. 9.

Galor, Oded, and Omer Moav. 2002. “Natural Selection and the Origins of Economic Growth.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 117 (Nov.): 1133-1191.

Galton, Francis. 1901. “The Possible Improvement of the Human Breed Under Existing Conditions of Law and Sentiment.” Huxley Lecture to the Anthropological Institute, printed as pp. 1-34 in Essays in Eugenics. London: Eugenics Education Society.

Gintis, Herbert. 2008. “Five Principles for the Unification of the Behavioral Sciences.” Unpublished paper, Sante Fe Institute and Central European University. May 13, 2008. At http://www.umass.edu/preferen/ gintis/NewUnity.pdf

Goldgar, Anne. 2007. Tulipmania: Money, Honor, and Knowledge in the Dutch Golden Age. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Goldstone, Jack A. 2007b. “Review of Clark’s Farewell to Alms.” World Economics 8 (3): 207-225.

Grantham. George. 2007. “Discussion of Clark’s Farewell to Alms.” Meet-the-Author Session at the Social Science History Convention, Chicago, November. http://eh.net/bookreviews /ssha_farewell_to_alms.pdf

Guinnane, Timothy. 2009. Speech to the Chicago Friends of Economic History, May 8. Department of Economics, Yale University.

Harley, C. K. 1980. “Transportation, the World Wheat Trade and Kuznets Cycle.” Explorations in Economic History 17: 218-250.

Harley, C. K. 1993. “Reassessing the Industrial Revolution: A Macro View.” Pp. 171-226 in J. Mokyr, ed., The British Industrial Revolution: An Economic Perspective. Boulder: Westview.

Hill, Kim R., and A. Magdalena Hurtado. 2003. “Hunting.” In Mokyr, ed., Oxford Encyclopedia of Economic History.

Johnson, William A. 2000. “Towards a Sociology of Reading in Classical Antiquity.” American Journal of Philology 121: 593-627.

Lenin, V. I. 1902. What is to Be Done? J. Fineberg, G. Hanna, R. Service, trans. London: Penguin, 1988. Lyovin, Anatole V. 1997. An Introduction to the Languages of the World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Manski, Charles F. 2008. Identification for Prediction and Decision. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Manuelli, Rodolfo, and Ananth Seshardi. 2005. “Human Capital and the Wealth of Nations.” Unpublished paper, Department of Economics, University of Wisconsin-Madison. At http://www.ssc.wisc.edu/ ~manuelli/research/ humcapwealthnation5_05.pdf

Margo, Robert. 2008. “Review of Clark’s Farewell to Alms.” EH-Net. March. http://eh.net/mailman/ listinfo/eh.net-review.

Marx, Karl, and Friedrich Engels. 1848. The Communist Manifesto. 1888 English translation, with additional notes and introduction by F. L. Bender. Norton Critical Edition. New York: W. W. Norton, 1988.

Marx, Karl. 1846. “Letter [on Proudhon, in French] to Pavel Yasilyevich Annenkov.” December 28, trans. Peter and Betty Ross, Marx Engels Collected Works Vol 38, p. 95, reproduced at http://www.marxists.org/archive/ marx/works/1846/letters/46_12_28.htm

Marx, Karl. 1859. “Selections from the Preface to A Contribution to the Criticism of Political Economy.” N. I. Stone, tr. 1904. Pp. 42-46 in Lewis S. Feuer, ed. ,Basic Writings on Politics and Philosophy, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. New York: Anchor Books ,1959.

McCloskey, Deirdre N. 1981. “The Industrial Revolution, 1780-1860: A Survey.” Chapter 6 in Floud and McCloskey eds., The Economic History of Britain, 1700-Present (1981), Vol. 1, pp. 103-127, reprinted in J. Mokyr, ed. Economic History and the Industrial Revolution (Rowman and Littlefield, 1985).

McGrath, Alistair. 2007. Dawkins’ God: Genes, Memes, and the Meaning of Life. London: Blackwell.

McInerney, James O., and Davide Pisani. 2007. “Paradigm for Life.” Science 318 (20 Nov): 1390-1391.

Milton, John. 1644. “Areopagitica: A Speech for the Liberty of Unlicensed Printing to the Parliament of England.” Renascence [sic] Editions. At http://www.uoregon.edu/~rbear/areopagitica.html

Mokyr, Joel. 2007b. “Discussion of Clark’s Farewell to Alms.” Meet-the-Author Session at the Social Science History Convention, Chicago, November. http://eh.net/bookreviews /ssha_farewell_to_alms.pdf

Novak, Michael. 2007. “Beyond Weber.” Pp. 220-238 in Nee and Swedberg, eds. On Capitalism. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Ó Gráda, Cormac. 2009. Famine: A Short History. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Sampson, Geoffrey. 2005. The “Language Instinct” Debate. Revised edition. London and New York: Continuum.

Solow, Robert. 2007. “Survival of the Richest? (Review of Clark’s Farewell to Alms).” New York Review of Books 54 (18, Nov 22).

Sorek, Rotem, et al. 2006. “Genome-Wide Experimental Determination of Barriers to Horizontal Gene Transfer.” Science. 318 (30 Nov.): 1449-1452.

Stark, Rodney. 2003. For The Glory of God: How Monotheism Led to Reformations, Science, Witch-Hunts, and the End of Slavery. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Stone, Lawrence. 1964. “The Educational Revolution in England, 1560-1640.” Past and Present 28: 41-80

Vickery, Amanda. 1998. The Gentleman’s Daughter: Women’s Lives in Georgian England. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Vlastos, Stephen. 1986. Peasant Protests and Uprisings in Tokugawa Japan. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press.

Voth, Hans-Joachim. 1998. “Time and Work in Eighteenth-Century London.” Journal of Economic History 58 (1): 29-58.

Voth, Hans-Joachim. 2001. Time and Work in England, 1760-1839. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Voth, Hans-Joachim. 2003. “Labor Time.” In Mokyr, ed., Oxford Encyclopedia of Economic History.

Wade, Nicholas. 2006. Before the Dawn: Recovering the Lost History of Our Ancestors. New York: Penguin.

Walzer, Michael. 1988. The Company of Critics. New York: Basic Books.

Winchester, Simon. 2008. The Man Who Loved China. New York: HarperCollins.

Witkowski, Jan A., and John R. Inglis, eds. 2008. Davenport’s Dream: 21st Century Reflections on Heredity and Eugenics. Cold Spring Harbor, NY: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press.

Wootton, David. 1992. “The Levellers.” Pp. 71-89 in John Dunn, ed. Democracy: The Unfinished Journey, 508 BC to AD 1993. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Ziliak, Stephen, and Deirdre McCloskey. 2008. The Cult of Statistical Significance: How the Standard Error Costs Us Jobs, Justice, and Lives. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.