Relational contract theory and management contracts: A paradigm for the application of the Theory of the Norms

Diathesopoulos, Michael (2010): Relational contract theory and management contracts: A paradigm for the application of the Theory of the Norms.

Abstract

This paper examines management contracts as a paradigm for the application of relational contracts theory and especially of the theory of contractual and relational norms. This theory, deriving from Macauley's implications, but structured and analysed by I.R. MacNeil gives us a framework for the explanation and understanding of contractual obligations and business relations' rules and practice. After presenting the key literature about the norms theory and especially defining the content of MacNeil's norms, we define management contracts as relations, characterised by a high relational element and we explain why, investigating all their features, which make them a suitable object for an application of norms theory. Then, we select a list of the core obligations for the recipient, provider and both parties in such a relation and we analyse each obligation according to MacNeil's model of norms. Specifically, we test the application of specific relative norms to each obligation and we examine which norms appear in which obligation. Finally, we concentrate our results and we result to our conclusions, based on a matrix showing the strength, breadth and depth of the application of each norm, while we also compare our results to those coming up from the application of a shorter comprehensive model of norms (Austen-Baker's model). The above analysis and tests provide us valuable results about the application, significance and practical value of the theory of the norms, about the significance of each norm for business relations and finally about the potential to present a more useful and comprehensive model of norms.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Relational Contracts; Macneil; Management Contracts; Norms; Contracts Law; Fiduciary Duties; Directors Duties; Law and Economics; Umbrella Contracts; Interorganisational Trust; Business Cooperation; Reciprocity; Contractual Solidarity; Comprehensive Norms; Contractual Norms; Outsourcing Contracts; relational contracts theory; hotel management agreement
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L14 - Transactional Relationships ; Contracts and Reputation ; Networks; K - Law and Economics > K0 - General > K00 - General; K - Law and Economics > K1 - Basic Areas of Law > K12 - Contract Law; K - Law and Economics > K2 - Regulation and Business Law > K22 - Business and Securities Law; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L20 - General; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L24 - Contracting Out ; Joint Ventures ; Technology Licensing; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M1 - Business Administration > M13 - New Firms ; Startups

References

- P. S. Atiyah, Essays on Contract, (New York USA:OUP, 1986)

- R. Austen-Baker, “A Relational Law of Contract?”, (2004) 20 Journal of Contract Law, 125

- R. Austen-Baker, “Consumer Supplier Relations, Regulation and Essential Contract Theory”, (2008) 24 Journal of Contract Law, 60

- R. Austen-Baker, "Comprehensive Contract Theory: A Four Norm Model of Contract Relations", (2009) 25 Journal of Contract Law, 216

- D. Baird, “Self-Interest and Cooperation in Long-Term Contracts”, (1990) 19 Journal of Legal Studies, 583

- D. Baird, R. Gertner, R. Picker, “Game Theory and the Law”, (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1998)

- H. Beale and T. Dugdale, “Contracts between Businessmen: Planning and the Use of Contractual Remedies”, (1975) 2 British Journal of Law and Society, 45

- L. Bernstein, "Opting Out of the Legal System: Extralegal Contractual Relations in the Diamond Industry," (1992) 21 Journal of Legal Studies 115

- L. Bernstein, "Social Norms and Default Rules Analysis", (1993) 3 Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal, 59

- L. Bernstein, “Private Commercial Law in the Cotton Industry: Creating Cooperation through Rules, Norms, and Institutions”, (2001) U Chicago Law & Economics, Olin Working Paper No. 133

- R. Bird, “Employment as a Relational Contract”, (2005) 8 University of Pennsylvania Journal of Labour and Employment Law, 149

- P. Blau, Exchange and Power in Social Life,( London: John Wiley, 1967)

- K. Blois and B. Ivens, “Measuring Relational Norms: Some Methodological Issues”, (2006) 40 European Journal of Marketing, 352 (also at http://www.impgroup.org/uploads/papers/4668.pdf)

- K. Blois, B. Ivens, “Relational Exchange Norms in Marketing: A Critical Review of Macneil’s Contribution”, (2004) 4 Marketing Theory, 239

- O. Bouin, A. Michalet, Rebalancing the public and private sectors: Developing Country Experiences, (Paris: OCDE, 1991)

- M. Brooke, International management: a review of strategies and operations, (Cheltenham UK: Hutchinson, 3rd ed., 1996)

- D. Campbell, D. Harris, ‘Flexibility in Long-term Contractual Relationships: The Role of Co-operation’, (1993) 20 Journal of Law and Society, 166

- D. Campbell (eds.), The Relational Theory of Contract: Selected Works of Ian Macneil (London: Sweet & Maxwell, 2001)

- D. Campbell, “Ian Macneil and the Relational Theory of Contract”, (2004) CDAMS Discussion Paper 04/1E

- D. Campbell, “The Relational Constitution of Remedy: Co-operation as the Implicit Second Principle of Remedies for Breach of Contract”, (2005) 11 Texas Wesleyan Law Review, 455

- T. Caplow, Sociology, (Englewood Cliffs NJ: Prentice Hall, 2nd ed., 1975)

- D. Carmichael, Contracts & International Project Management, (Rotterdam: Balkema Publ., 2000)

- S. Carson, A. Madhok, T. Wu, Uncertainty, Opportunism and Governance: The Effects of Volatility and Ambiguity on Formal and Relational Contracting, (2006) 49 Academy of Management Journal, 1058.

- T. Cavusgil, P. Ghauri, M. Agarwal, Doing business in developing countries: Entry and Negotiation Strategies, (London: Sage, 2002)

- R. Cotterrell, Emile Durkheim: Law in a Moral Domain, (Edinburgh: EUP, 1999

- O. M. Cunill, The growth strategies of hotel chains: best business practices by leading companies, (New York: Haworth Hospitality Press, 2006)

- V. De Stefano, ‘Smuggling Flexibility: Temporary Working Contracts and the “Implicit Threat” Mechanism,’ (2009) ILO Working Document No 4

- T. Donaldson, L. Preston, "The Stakeholder Theory of the Corporation: Concepts, Evidence, and Implications", (1995) 20 Academy of Management Review, 71

- I. Doole, R. Lowe, International marketing strategy: analysis, development and implementation, (London: Cengage, 5th ed., 2008)

- P. Drucker, Managing for Results, (London: Heinemann,1964)

- J. Dunning, S. Lundan, Multinational enterprises and the global economy, (Cheltenham UK: Edward Elgar Publ., 2nd ed., 2008)

- W. Dymsza, “Successes and Failures of Joint Ventures in Developing Countries: Lessons from Experience” in F. Contractor, P. Lorange (eds.), Cooperative Strategies in International Business, (Oxford UK: Elsevier, 2002)

- F. H. Easterbrook and D. R. Fischel, The Economic Structure Of Corporate Law, (Cambridge MA: Harvard University Press,1991)

- F. H. Easterbrook and D. R. Fischel, “Contract and Fiduciary Duty”, (1993) 36 Journal of Law and Economics, 425

- M. A. Eisenberg, ‘Relational Contracts’, in J. Beatson and D. Friedmann (eds.), Good Faith and Fault in Contract Law, (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995)

- C. Fill, E. Visser., “The outsourcing dilemma: a composite approach to the make or buy decision”, (2000) 38 Management Decision, 43

- M. Gelbard, Y. Adar, “The Role of Remedies in the Relational Theory of Contract - A Preliminary Inquiry”, (2010) 6 European Review of Contract Law (forthcoming) available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=1416750.

- G. Gilmore, The Death of Contracts (Columbus, Ohio: Ohio State UP, 1974)

- C. Goetz, R. Scott, “Principles of Relational Contracts”, (1981) 67 Virginia Law Review, 1089

- R. Graf, J. Perrien, “The Role of Trust and Satisfaction in a Relationship: The Case of High Tech Firms and Banks”, Presentation at Munich 2005 Conference of the European Marketing Academy (EMAC)

- H. Gunter, O. Nass, Management Know-How Transfer by multinational Corporations in South-East Asia, (Braunshweig: Technischen Universitat, Inst. fur Wirtschaftswiss, 1996)

- S. Hackett, ‘Is Relational Exchange Possible in the Absence of Reputations and Repeated Contract?’, (1994) 10 Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization, 360

- H. Hakansson, I. Snehota, (1995). “The Burden of Relationships or Whose Next?” (1995) Proceedings of 11th. IMP Conference, Manchester, 522.

- M. Hviid, ‘Relational Contracts and Repeated Games’ in D. Campbell, P. Vincent-Jones (eds.), Contract and Economic Organisation: Socio-legal Initiatives, (Aldershot UK: Dartmouth, 1996)

- M. Hviid, ‘Relational Contracts, Repeated Interactions and Contract Modification’, (1998) 5 European Journal of Law and Economics, 179

- M. Hviid, “Long Term Contracts and Relational Contracts”, in B. Bouckaert. and G. De Geest (eds), The Encyclopaedia of Law and Economics vol. III: The Regulation of Contracts, (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2000), also at (http://www.scribd.com/doc/239254/LongTerm-Contracts-and-Relational-Contracts)

- J. D. Hynes, Freedom of Contract, Fiduciary Duties, and Partnerships: The Bargain Principle and the Law of Agency, (1997) 54 Washington and Lee Law Review, 439

- M. Jennejohn, Governing Innovative Collaboration: A new Theory of Contract, (2006) Columbia Law and Economics Working Paper 319 (available at http://ssrn.com/ abstract=1014420)

- B. Klein, “Why Hold Ups Occur: The Self Enforcing Range of Contractual Relationships”, (1996) 34 Economic Inquiry, 444

- Laby, “The Fiduciary Obligation as the Adoption of Ends”, (2008) 56 Buffalo Law Review, 99 (also at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1124722)

- T. Laaksonen, K. Pajunen, H. Kulmala., “Co-evolution of trust and dependence in customer–supplier relationships”, (2008) 37 Industrial Marketing Management, 910

- P. Lenney, G. Easton, S. Mouzas, 'Umbrella agreements as commitment framing devices', (2008) 24th IMP Conference (Uppsala University, Sweden)

- S. Macaulay, “Non-Contractual Relations in Business: A Preliminary Study”, (1963) 28 American Sociological Review, 55

- S. Macaulay, “An Empirical View of Contract”, (1985) Wisconsin Law Review, 465

- S. Macauley, “The Real and the Paper Deal: Empirical Pictures of Relationships, Complexity and the Urge for Transparent Simple Rules” in D. Campbell, H. Collins, J. Whiteman (eds.), Implicit Dimensions of Contract: Discrete, Relational and Network Contracts (Oxford UK and Portland Oregon USA: Hart, 2003)

- J. R. Macey, “Fiduciary Duties as Residual Claims: Obligations to Nonshareholder Constituencies from a Theory of the Firm Perspective”, (1999) 84 Cornell Law Review, 1266

- R. Macneil, Contracts, instruments for social cooperation, East Africa: text, cases, materials, (South Hackensack, N.J.: F. B. Rothman, 1968)

- R. Macneil, “Whither Contracts?” (1969) 21 Journal of Legal Education, 403

- R. Macneil, “Restatement (Second) of Contracts and Presentiation”, (1974) 60 Virginia Law Review, 589

- R. Macneil, “The Many Futures of Contracts”, (1974) 47 Southern California Law Review, 691

- R. Macneil, “Contracts: Adjustment of Long-Term Economic Relations under Classical, Neoclassical and Relational Contract Law”, (1978) 72 Northwestern University Law Review, 854

- R. Macneil, The New Social Contract, (New Haven, Conn. USA: Yale UP, 1980)

- R. Macneil, “Economic Analysis of Contractual Relations: Its Shortfalls and the Need for a "Rich Classificatory Apparatus””, (1981) 75 Northwestern University Law Review, 1018

- R. Macneil, “Values in Contract: internal and external”, (1983) 78 Northwestern University Law Review, 340

- R. Macneil, 'Exchange Revisited: Individual Utility and Social Solidarity' (1986) 96 Ethics, 567.

- R. Macneil, “Relational Contract Theory as Sociology: A Reply to Professors Limberg & de Vos.”, (1987) 143 Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 272

- R. Macneil, “Political Exchange as Relational Contract” in B. Marin (eds.), Generalized Political Exchange (Colorado USA: Frederick Praeger, 1990)

- R. Macneil, “Contracting Worlds and Essential Contract Theory”, (2000) 9 Social & Legal Studies, 431

- R. Macneil, “Relational Contract Theory: Challenges and Queries”, (2000) 94 Northwestern University Law Review, 877

- M. Martinek, Moderne Vertragstypen II: Franchising, Know-how-Verträge, Management- und Consultingverträge, (München: C. H. Beck, 1992)

- W. Megginson, Financial Economics of Privatization, (New York: Oxford University Press, 2005)

- Misztal, Trust in Modern Societies, (Cambridge: Polity Press, 1996)

- Mitchell, “Contracts and Contract Law: Challenging the Distinction between the ‘Real’ and ‘Paper’ Deal”, (2009) 29 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, 675

- S. Mouzas, M. Furmston, 'From contract to umbrella agreement', (2008) 67 Cambridge Law Journal, 37

- S. Mouzas, D. Ford, 'Contracts in asymmetric relationships', (2007) Proceedings of the 22nd IMP Conference (University of Bocconi: Milan)

- S. Mouzas, S. Henneberg, P. Naudé, 2007, 'Trust and reliance in business relationships', (2007) 41 European Journal of Marketing, 1016

- S. Mouzas, “Negotiating Umbrella Agreements”, (2007) 22 Negotiation Journal, 279

- S. Mouzas, D. Ford, ‘Managing Relations in Showery Weather: The role of Umbrella Agreements’, (2006) 59 Journal of Business Research, 1248

- Moyer, J. McGuigan, W. Kretlow, Contemporary Financial Management, (Mason, OH USA: Cengage 11th ed., 2009)

- T. Nenova, C. Hickey, “Self-Dealing: Sneaking Corporate Value through the Back Door”, (2006) 312 Public Policy Journal.

- Nevin, Relationship marketing and distribution channels: Exploring fundamental issues, (1995) 23 Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 327

- R. Palmiter, Corporations: Examples and Explanations, (New York: Aspen, 6th ed, 2009)

- D. Pannier, S. Schiavo-Campo, “Corporate Governance of Public Enterprises: The Comparative Experience” in D. Pannier (eds.), Corporate Governance of Public Enterprises in Transitional Economies, World Bank Technical paper No 323, (Washington DC: The World Bank, 1996)

- Prim-Allaz I., J. Perrien (2000), « Présentation d'un document de travail: The Relevance of Macneil's Relational Norms to Understand the Exit of an Interorganizational Relationship”, (2000) First Nordic Workshop on Relationship Dissolution (Kuusamo, Finlande)

- E. Ribstein, “Are Partners Fiduciaries?”, (2005) University of Illinois Law Review, 209

- Schluter, Management - und Consulting –Vertrage, (Berlin: Walter de Gruyter,1987)

- R. Scott, ‘Conflict and Cooperation in Long-Term Contracts’, (1987) 75 California Law Review, 2005

- R. Scott, “The Case for Formalism in Relational Contract”, (2000) 94 Northwestern University Law Review, 847, (also at http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=215129)

- R. Sloof, J. Sonnemans, “The interaction between Explicit and Relational Incentives: An experiment”, (2009) University of Amsterdam, Tinbergen Institute, Discussion Paper 09-030/1, available at http://www1.fee.uva.nl/pp/bin/951fulltext.pdf

- R. Stone, The Modern Law of Contracts, (London: Cavendish, 6th ed., 2005)

- Stinchcombe, Information and Organizations, (Berkeley, Cal. USA: University of California Press Ltd., 1990)

- R. Thompson, “The Story of Meinhard v. Salmon and Fiduciary Duty's Punctilio”, (2008), No. 08-44 Vanderbilt Public Law Research Paper, available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1285705

- United Nations Centre on Transnational Corporations, Management Contracts in Developing Countries: An Analysis of Their Substantive Provisions: A Technical Paper, (New York : United Nations, 1983)

- P. Vincent-Jones, The New Public Contracting: Regulation. Responsiveness, Relationality, (Oxford, OUP, 2006)

- G. Westring, “Construction and Management Contracts” in N. Horn and C. Schmitthoff (eds.), The Transnational Law of Commercial Transactions (London: Kluwer, 1982)

- T. Wheelen and D. Hunger, Concepts in Strategic Management and Business Policy, (Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall, 10th ed., 2006)

- A. Wint, Corporate management in developing countries: the challenge of international competitiveness: The Challenge of International Competitiveness, (Westport CT USA: Quorum Books, 1995)

- D. Yavuz, “Reputation, Network Effects and the Theory of the Firm: A Renegotiation-Proof Approach” (2007), available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=994662