MNOHALETÁ MEZINÁRODNÍ DISKUSE O SOCIALISMU A TRHU

Fišer, Drago and Kyn, Oldrich (1967): MNOHALETÁ MEZINÁRODNÍ DISKUSE O SOCIALISMU A TRHU. Published in: Politická ekonomie No. No. 7-8 (1967)

Abstract

This article was published in the leading Czech journal of economics named “Politicka Ekonomie” in 1967 that is during the process of Economic Reform intended to change the Soviet-type Command Economy in a sort of Market Socialism. It was curious that while the need to revive the market mechanism was accepted by the majority of economists and politicians, the famous “Socialist Controversy” that was just about this crucial problem was still virtually unknown in Czechoslovakia at that time. Our purpose was not only to provide the basic information about that controversy, but also to put it in the broader context of the evolution of the economic theory in the 19 th and 20 th century. Because of the previous domination of the orthodox Marxist economics, any developments of the non-Marxist economics after the classical contributions of Smith and Ricardo were regarded as the attempts of the “bourgeoisie” to falsify the “true” economics for the purpose of preserving Capitalism. We found it therefore necessary to start with the explanation of neoclassical concepts of marginal utility, imputation of value from final products to intermediate products and primary resources, as well as concepts of general equilibrium. After explaining these “roots” of the controversy the critical points of von Mises and Hayek are presented and the socialist responses of Maurice Dobb, Oskar Lange, Abba Lerner and others are discussed with a clear aim to show that without the market the socialist economy cannot be efficient.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: Czech
• Keywords: Socialist Controversy; Market Socialism; von Mises; Hayek; Oskar Lange; A. P. Lerner; M. Dobb
• Subjects: P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P39 - Other; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P29 - Other

References

BARONE ENRICO: The Ministry ot Production in the Collectivist State, ve sborniku Collectivist Economic Planning, Routiedge, London 1935, str. 124—290; p ů vodn ě Il ministero della produzione nello stato collectivista, Giornale degli economisti, 1908. BAUER OTTO: Der Weg zum Sozialiamus, Wien 1919, podle Hayek , str. 31. BORNSTEIN MORRIS, po ř adatel sborníku Comparative Economic Systems: Models and Cases, Richard D. Irwin, Homewood, Illinois 1965. BÖHM- BAWERK: Macht und ökonomisches Gesitz, Zeitschrift für Volkswirtschaft, Sozialpolitik und Verwaltung, 1914; podle Hayek , str. 28. BRUTZKUS BORIS: Problems of Social Economy under Socialism, rusky v ruském č asopise Ekonomist v zim ě 1921—1922, pak rusky v Berlín ě 1923, n ě mecky pod titulem Die Lehren des Marxismus im Lichte der russischen Revolution, Berlin 1928 a anglicky v prvé č ásti Economic Planning in Soviet Russia, Routledge, London 1935; podle Hayek , str. 35 a , str. 292, 203. CANNAN E.: A History of the Theories of Production and Distribution, 1893, t ř etí vydání 1917; podle Hayek [1], str. 26. CASSEL GUSTAV: The Theory of Social Economy, London 1932.

[1] DICKINSON H. D.: Price Formation in a Socialist Community, Economic Journal, June 1933; podle Hayek [2], str. 207, 292; Lange [1] str. 54 [2] DICKINSON H. D.: economics ot Socialism, Oxford 1933, podle Hayek , str. 98. [1] DOBB MAURICE Economic Theory and the Problems of a Socialist Economy, Economic Journal, December 1933; podle Hayek [2] , str. 215, 293. [2] DOBB MAURICE: Political Economy and Capitalism, kap. VIII., 1937; podle Hayek [3], str. 97. [3] DOBB MAURICE Economic Theory ans Socialist economy, A Reply, Review of Economic Studies, 1934—1935. DREWNOWSKI JAN: The Economic Theory of Socialism: A Suggestion for Reconsideration, ve sborníku Bornstein, str. 117—134; p ů vodn ě Journal of Political Economy, Vol. LXIX, No. 4, August 1961. ENGELS BED Ř ICH: Anti-Dühning, Svoboda, Praha 1952. GOSSEN H. H.: Entwicklung der Gesetze der menschlichen Verkehrs und der daraus fliessenden Regeln für menschliches Handeln, Braunschweig 1854; podle Hayek [1], str. 26. GRAY JOHN: viz D ž on Grey: So č in ě nija, Moskva 1955. HALM GEORG.: Further Considerations on the Possibility ot Adequate Calculation in a Socialist Country, ve sborniku Collectivist Economic Planning, str. 131 —200, p ů vodn ě n ě mecky, pramen neudán. [1] HAYEK F. A.: The Nature and History of the Problem, ve sborníku Collectevist Economic Planning, Routledge, London 1935, str. 1—40. Sborník uapo ř ádal F. A. Hayek. [2] HAYEK F. A.: The Present State ot the Debate, ve sborniku Collectivist Economic Planning, Routledge, London 1935, str. 201 an. [3] HAYEK F. A.: Socialist Calculation: the Competitive Solution, ve sborniku Bornstein, str. 95—116; p ů vodn ě Economica New Series, Vol. VII, No. 26, May 1940. [4] HAYEK F. A.: The Price System as a Mechaniam for Using Knowledge, ve sborníku Bornstein, str. 39—50; American Economic Review, Vol. XXXV, No. 4, September 1945; p ů vodn ě publikováno pod titulem The Use ot Knowledge in Society, bli ž š í neudáno. [1] HEIMAN E.: Kapitalismus und Sozialismua, Potsdam 1931; podle Halm, str. 190. [2] HEIMAN E.: Sozialistische Wirtachatts und Arbeitsordnung, Potsdam 1932; podle Lange [1] , str. 54. KAUTSKY KARL: The Social Revolution, Londýn 1907; Kerr, Chicago 1910; obsahuje p ř edná š ku The Day after the Revolution, p ř ednesenou v r. 1902; podle Lange [1], str. 138. KAUTSKY KARL: Die proletarische Revolution und ihr Programm, Berlin 1922; podle Lange [1], str. 139. KNIGHT L.: The Place of Marginal economics in a Collectivist System, American Economic Review Supplement, March 1936; podle Lange [1] , str. 54. [1] LANGE OSKAR: On the Economic Theory of Socialism, The Review of Economic Studies 1936—37, str. 53—71, 123— 142. [2] LANGE OSKAR: Mr. Lerner's Note on Socialist economics, Review of Economic. Studies, 1936—37, str. 143 a ž 144. [3] LANGE OSKAR: On the Economic Theory of Socialism, ve sborníku Bornstein, str. 86—94: výtah z Lange [1]. [4] LANGE OSKAR: Trial and Error in Socialist Economy, ve sborníku Leeman, str. 21— 27; výtah z Lange [1] zprost ř edkovaný vydáním E. E. Lippincotta tj. On the Eto-nomic Theory of Socialism by O. Lange and Fred M. Taylor, Minneapolis, University of Minnesota Press, 1938. LEEMAN WAYNE A.: po ř adatel sborníku Capitalism, Market Socialism and Central Planning, Readings in Comparative Economic Systems, Houghton Mifflin, Boston 1963. [1] LERNER A. P. Economic Theory and Socialist Economy, Review of Economic Studies, 1934—1935. [2] LERNER A. P.: Economic Theory and Socialist Economy, A Rejoinder, Review of Economic Studies, 1934— 1935. [3] LERNER A. P.: A Note on Socialist Economy, Review of Economic Studies, 1935— 1936. [4] LERNER A. P.: Statics and Dynamics in the Socialist economics, Economic Journal, September 1937, str. 253 a ž 270. LERNER A. P.: Theory and Practice in Socialist Economics, Review of Economic Studies, 1938—1939, str. 71—75. MARX KAREL: Kapitál, díl I., SNPL, Praha 1953. [1] MISES L.: Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth, ve sborníku Collectivist Economic Planning, Routiedge, London 1935; p ů vodn ě Die Wirtschaftsrechnung un sozialistischen Gemeinwesen, Archiv für Sozialwissenschaften und Sozialpolitik, Vol. 47/1, April 1920. [2] MISES L.: Economic Calculation in Socialism, ve sborníku Bornstein, str. 79—85; výtah z Die Gemeinwirtschaft, Jena 1922, zprost ř edkovaný knihou Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis, New Haven, Yale University Press, 1951. [3] MISES L.: Neue Beitrage zum Problem der sozialistischen Wirtschaftsrechnung, Archiv für Sozialwisseaschaft, Vol. 51, 1924. [4] MISES L.: Neue Schriften zur Problem der sozialistischen Wirtschaftsrechnung, Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft, Vol. 60, 1928. NEURATH O.: Durch die Kriegswirtschaft zur Naturalwirtschaft, München 1919; podle Hayek [1], str. 31 a , str. 96. PARETO VILFREDO: Cours d‘économie politique, Vol. II., F. Rouge, Lausanne; Pichon, Paris 1897; podle Hayek [1], str. 29 ,[3] str. 97, 119; Lange [1], str. 54. [2] PARETO VILFREDO: Manuel d‘economie politique, V. Girard et Brieve, Paris 1909; citováno druhe vydáni 1927; podle Hayek [3], str. 96, 119, Lange [1], str. 54. PIERSON N. G.: The Problem of Value in the Socialist Community, ve sborníku Collectivist Economic Planning, Routledge, London 1935; p ů vodn ě Het waardeproblem in den socialistische Maatschappij, De Economist, Vol. 41, s‘Gravenhage 1902, str. 423— 56. RICCI UMBERTO: Pareto and Pure economics, The Review of Economic Studies, 1933, No. 1, p ř eklad z č asopisu Giornale degli Economisti, 1924. [1] ROBBINS LIONEL: The Great Depresion, London 1934. [2] ROBBINS LIONEL: Economic Planning and International Order, MacMillan, London 1938 (první vydáni 1937). ROBINSONOVÁ JOAN: The economics Of Imperfect Competition, Mac Millan, London 1954 (první vydání 1933). ROPER W. GROSBY: The Problem of Pricing in a Socialiat State, Cambridge (Mass.) 1929; podle Hayek [2], str. 207, 292. SCHILLER KARL: Sozialismus und Wettbewerb, ve sborníku Grundfragen moderner Wirtschaftspolitik Europaeische Verlagsanstallt, Frankfurt ain Main, bez data; základem je autorova p ř ednáska z roku 1954. SULZER G.: Die Zukunft des Sozialismus, Dresden 1899; podle Hayek [1], str. 27. TAYLOR F. M.: The Guidance of Production in a Socialist State, American Economic Review, Vol. XIX, 1929; podle Hayek [2], str. 207, 292 s Lange [1], str. 56. TISCH KLÁRE: Wirtschaftsrechnung und Verteilung im zentralisch organisierten sozialistischen Gemeinwesen, doktorská dizertace na universit ě v Bonnu, Wuppertal-Elberfeld 1932; podle Hayek [2], str. 184, 292. TROCKY L.: Soviet Economy in Danger, Pioneer Publishers, New York 1932; podle Lange [1], str. 140—141. UNGERN-STERNBERG RODERIC: Die Planung als Ordnungsprinzip der deutschen Industriewirtschaft, Stuttgart 1932; podle Halm, str. 186. WALRAS LÉON: Eléments d‘Economie politique pure, 1874. WEBER MAX: Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft (Grundrisse der Sozialökonomik, Vol. III), Tübingen 1921; podle Hayek [1], str. 34. WIESER F.: The Natural Value, London 1893, podle Hayek [1], str. 25, [3], str. 97. ZASSENHAUS H.: Uber die ökonomische Theorie der Planwirtschaft, Zeitschrift für Nationalökonomie, Bd. V; podle Lange [1], str. 54.