Recent developments in empirical IO: dynamic demand and dynamic games

Aguirregabiria, Victor and Nevo, Aviv (2010): Recent developments in empirical IO: dynamic demand and dynamic games.

Abstract

Empirically studying dynamic competition in oligopoly markets requires dealing with large states spaces and tackling difficult computational problems, while handling heterogeneity and multiple equilibria. In this paper, we discuss some of the ways recent work in Industrial Organization has dealt with these challenges. We illustrate problems and proposed solutions using as examples recent work on dynamic demand for differentiated products and on dynamic games of oligopoly competition. Our discussion of dynamic demand focuses on models for storable and durable goods and surveys how researchers have used the "inclusive value" to deal with dimensionality problems and reduce the computational burden. We clarify the assumptions needed for this approach to work, the implications for the treatment of heterogeneity and the different ways it has been used. In our discussion of the econometrics of dynamics games of oligopoly competition, we deal with challenges related to estimation and counterfactual experiments in models with multiple equilibria. We also examine methods for the estimation of models with persistent unobserved heterogeneity in product characteristics, firms’ costs, or local market profitability. Finally, we discuss different approaches to deal with large state spaces in dynamic games.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Industrial Organization; Oligopoly competition; Dynamic demand; Dynamic games; Estimation; Counterfactual experiments; Multiple equilibria; Inclusive values; Unobserved heterogeneity.
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L13 - Oligopoly and Other Imperfect Markets; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; L - Industrial Organization > L0 - General > L00 - General

References

[1] Aguirregabiria, V. (2009): "A Method for Implementing Counterfactual Experiments in Models with Multiple Equilibria," Working Papers tecipa-381, University of Toronto.

[2] Aguirregabiria, V. (2010): "Another Look at the Identification of Dynamic Discrete Decision Processes: An Application to Retirement Behavior,” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 28(2), 201-218.

[3] Aguirregabiria, V. and C-Y. Ho (2009): "A dynamic oligopoly game of the US airline industry: Estimation and policy experiments," Manuscript. University of Toronto.

[4] Aguirregabiria, V., and P. Mira (2002): “Swapping the nested fixed point algorithm: A class of estimators for Markov decision models,” Econometrica, 70(4), 1519-43.

[5] Aguirregabiria, V. and P. Mira (2007): "Sequential estimation of dynamic discrete games," Econometrica 75, 1—53.

[6] Aguirregabiria, V. and P. Mira (2010): "Stability of Equilibria and Properties of Sequential Estimators: Problems and Solutions," Manuscript. University of Toronto.

[7] Aguirregabiria, V., P. Mira, and H. Roman (2007): "An estimable dynamic model of entry, exit and growth in oligopoly retail markets," American Economic Review 97, 449-454.

[8] Akerlof, G. (1970): "The Market for ’Lemons’: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 84(3), 488-500.

[9] Altonji, J. and L. Segal (1996): "Small-Sample Bias in GMM Estimation of Covariance Structures," Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 14(3), 353-366.

[10] Arcidiacono, P. and R. Miller (2009): "CCP Estimation of Dynamic Discrete Choice Models with Unobserved Heterogeneity," manuscript. Tepper School of Business. Carnegie Mellon University.

[11] Bajari, P. & Benkard, C. L. (2005): "Demand estimation with heterogeneous consumers and unobserved product characteristics: A hedonic approach," Journal of Political Economy, 113, 1239—1276.

[12] Bajari, P., L. Benkard and J. Levin (2007): "Estimating dynamic models of imperfect competition," Econometrica 75, 1331-1370.

[13] Beresteanu, A. and P. Ellickson (2005): "The Dynamics of Retail Oligopoly," Manuscript. Department of Economics. Duke University.

[14] Berry, S. (1992): “Estimation of a model of entry in the airline industry”, Econometrica, 60(4), 889-917.

[15] Berry, S. and P. Haile (2009): "Identification in Differentiated Products Markets Using Market Level Data," manuscript. Department of Economics. Yale University.

[16] Berry, S., Levinsohn, J., & Pakes, A. (1995): "Automobile prices in market equilibrium," Econometrica, 63, 841—890.

[17] Boizot, C., J-M Robin, and M. Visser (2001): "The Demand for Food Products: An Analysis of Interpurchase Times and Purchased Quantities," Economic Journal, 111, 391-419.

[18] Bonnet, C. and P. Dubois (2010): "Inference on vertical contracts between manufacturers and retailers allowing for nonlinear pricing and resale price maintenance," RAND Journal of Economics, 41(1), 139-164. 54

[19] Bresnahan, T. (1981): "Departures from marginal-cost pricing in the American automobile industry: Estimates for 1977—1978," Journal of Econometrics, 17(2), 201-227.

[20] Bresnahan, T. (1987): "Competition and Collusion in the American Automobile Industry: The 1955 Price War," Journal of Industrial Economics, 35(4), 457-482.

[21] Bresnahan, T., and P. Reiss (1990): “Entry in monopoly markets”, Review of Economic Studies, 57, 531-553.

[22] Bresnahan, T., and P. Reiss (1991a): “Empirical models of discrete games”, Journal of Econometrics 48, 57-81.

[23] Bresnahan, T., and P. Reiss (1991b): “Entry and competition in concentrated markets”, Journal of Political Economy, 99, 977-1009.

[24] Bresnahan, T., and P. Reiss (1993): “Measuring the Importance of Sunk Costs," Annales d’Economie et de Statistique, 34.

[25] Carranza, J. (2006): "Demand for durable goods and the dynamics of quality," Unpublished manuscript, University of Wisconsin.

[26] Collard-Wexler, A. (2006): "Demand Fluctuations in the Ready-Mix Concrete Industry," Manuscript. New York University.

[27] De Paula, A. and X. Tang (2010): "Inference of Signs of Interaction Effects in Simultaneous Games with Incomplete Information," PIER Working Paper 10-021. UPenn.

[28] Doraszelski, U., and Satterthwaite, M. (2010): "Computable Markov-Perfect Industry Dynamics," RAND Journal of Economics, 41(2), 215—243.

[29] Dunne, T., S. Klimek, M. Roberts, and Y. Xu (2009): "Entry, Exit and the Determinants of Market Structure," manuscript. Department of Economics. Pennsylvania State University.

[30] Eichenbaum, M., N. Jaimovich, and S. Rebelo (2008): "Reference Prices and Nominal Rigidities," NBER Working Paper 13829.

[31] Einav, L. (2009): “Not All Rivals Look Alike: An Empirical Model for Discrete Games with Asymmetric Rivals,” Economic Inquiry, 48(2), 369-390.

[32] Einav, L., E. Leibtag, and A. Nevo (2009): “Recording Discrepancies in Nielsen Homescan Data: Are they Present and Do they Matter?," Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 8(2).

[33] Erdem, T., S. Imai and M. P. Keane (2003): "Brand and Quantity Choice Dynamics under Price Uncertainty," Quantitative Marketing and Economics 1, 5-64.

[34] Ericson, R., and A. Pakes (1995): “Markov-Perfect industry dynamics: A framework for empirical work”, Review of Economic Studies, 62, 53-82.

[35] Esteban, S. & Shum, M. (2007). "Durable goods oligopoly with secondary markets: The case of automobiles," RAND Journal of Economics, 38, 332-354.

[36] Finger, S. (2008): "An Empirical Analysis of R&D Competition in the Chemicals Industry," manuscript. University of South Carolina.

[37] General Motors Corproration (1939): "The dynamics of automobile demand," based upon papers presented at a joint meeting of the American Statistical Association and the Econometric Society in Detroit, Michigan on December 27, 1938.

[38] Goettler, R. and B. Gordon (2009): "Does AMD spur Intel to innovate more?" manuscript. University of Chicago Booth School of Business.

[39] Goldberg, P. (1995): "Product Differentiation and Oligopoly in International Markets: The Case of the U.S. Automobile Industry," Econometrica, 63, 891-951.

[40] Gowrisankaran,G. and M. Rysman (2009): "Dynamics of Consumer Demand for New Durable Goods," manuscript. University of Arizona.

[41] Gowrisankaran, G., C. Lucarelli, P. Schmidt-Dengler, and R. Town (2010): "Government policy and the dynamics of market structure: Evidence from Critical Access Hospitals," manuscript. University of Arizona.

[42] Griffith, R., A. Leicester, E. Leibtag, and A. Nevo (2009) “Consumer Shopping Behavior: How Much Do Consumers Save?,” Journal of Economics Perspectives, 23(2), 99-120.

[43] Hall, P. and X-H Zhou (2003): "Nonparametric Estimation of Component Distributions in a Multivariate Mixture," Annals of Statistics, 31(1), 201-224.

[44] Hartmann, W. (2006): "Intertemporal effects of consumption and their implications for demand elasticity estimates," Quantitative Marketing and Economics, 4(4), 325-349.

[45] Hashmi, A. and J. Van Biesebroeck (2010): "Market Structure and Innovation: A Dynamic Analysis of the Global Automobile Industry," NBER Working Paper 15959.

[46] Hausman, J., G. Leonard, and J. Zona(1994): "Competitive Analysis with Differentiated Products," Annales D’Economie et de Statistique, 34.

[47] Heckman, J. (1981): “ The incidental parameters problem and the problem of initial conditions in estimating a discrete time - discrete data stochastic process,” in C. Manski and D. McFadden (eds.), Structural Analysis of Discrete Data with Econometric Applications. MIT Press.

[48] Hendel, I. and A. Nevo (2004): "Intertemporal Substitution and Storable Products," Journal of the European Economic Association, 2(2-3), pages 536-547.

[49] Hendel, I., and A. Nevo (2006a): "Measuring the Implications of Sales and Consumer Inventory Behavior. Econometrica 74, 1637-1674.

[50] Hendel, I. and A. Nevo (2006b): "Sales and Consumer Inventory," RAND Journal of Economics, 37(3), 543-561.

[51] Hendel, I. and A. Nevo (2010): "A Simple Model of Demand Anticipation," manuscript. Department of Economics. Northwestern University.

[52] Horowitz, J. (1998): “Bootstrap Methods for Covariance Structures,” Journal of Human Resources, 33, 39-61.

[53] Hotz, J., and R.A. Miller (1993): “Conditional choice probabilities and the estimation of dynamic models,” Review of Economic Studies, 60, 497-529.

[54] Hotz, J., R.A. Miller, S. Sanders, and J. Smith (1994): ”A simulation estimator for dynamic models of discrete choice,” Review of Economic Studies, 61, 265-89.

[55] Imai, S., N. Jain, and A. Ching (2009): "Bayesian Estimation of Dynamic Discrete Choice Models," Econometrica, 77(6), 1865-1899.

[56] Jovanovic, B. (1989): “Observable implications of models with multiple equilibria”, Econometrica, 57, 1431-1437.

[57] Kasahara, H. and K. Shumitsu (2008a): "Pseudo-likelihood Estimation and Bootstrap Inference for Structural Discrete Markov Decision Models," Journal of Econometrics, 146(1), 2008, 92-106.

[58] Kasahara, H. and K. Shumitsu (2008b): "Nonparametric Identification of Finite Mixture Models of Dynamic Discrete Choices," Econometrica, 77(1), 2009, 135-175.

[59] Kasahara, H. and K. Shumitsu (2009): "Sequential Estimation of Structural Models with a Fixed Point Constraint," manuscript. University of Western Ontario.

[60] Kehoe, P. and V. Midrigan (2008): "Temporary Price Changes and the Real Effects of Monetary Policy," NBER Working Papers 14392.

[61] Kryukov, Y. (2010): “Dynamic R&D and the Effectiveness of Policy Intervention in the Pharmaceutical Industry,” manuscript. Tepper School of Business. Carnegie Mellon University.

[62] Lee, R. (2009): "Dynamic Demand Estimation in Platform and Two-Sided Markets," manuscript. Stern School of Business. New York University.

[63] Lou, W., D. Prentice, and X. Yin (2008): "The Effects of Product Ageing on Demand: The Case of Digital Cameras," MPRA Paper 13407.

[64] Macieira, J. (2007): "Extending the frontier: A structural model of investment and technological competition in the supercomputer industry," manuscript. Virginia Tech.

[65] Magnac, T. and D. Thesmar (2002): "Identifying Dynamic Discrete Decision Processes," Econometrica, 70(2), 801-816.

[66] Maskin, E. and Tirole, J. (1987): “A Theory of Dynamic Oligopoly, III: Cournot Competition,” European Economic Review, 31, 947—968.

[67] Maskin, E. and Tirole, J. (1988a): “A Theory of Dynamic Oligopoly, I: Overview and Quantity Competition with Large Fixed Costs,” Econometrica, 56, 549—569.

[68] Maskin, E. and Tirole, J. (1988b): “A Theory of Dynamic Oligopoly, II: Price Competition, Kinked Demand Curves, and Edgeworth Cycles,” Econometrica, 56, 571—599.

[69] McFadden, D. (1974): "Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice Behavior," in P. Zarembka (ed.), Frontiers in Econometrics, 105-142, Academic Press. New York.

[70] Melnikov, O., 2000, Demand for Differentiated Durable Products: The Case of the U.S. Computer Printer Market. Manuscript. Department of Economics, Yale University.

[71] Nakamura, E. and J. Steinsson (2008): "Five Facts about Prices: A Reevaluation of Menu Cost Models," The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123(4), 1415-1464.

[72] Nevo, A. (2001): "Measuring Market Power in the Ready-to-Eat Cereal Industry," Econometrica, 69(2), 307-342.

[73] Nevo, A. and Rossi, F. (2008): "An approach for extending dynamic models to settings with multi-product firms," Economics Letters, 100(1), 49-52.

[74] Norets, A. (2009): “Inference in Dynamic Discrete Choice Models with Serially Correlated Unobserved State Variables,” Econometrica, 77, 1665—1682.

[75] Pakes, A. (1994): "Dynamic structural models, problems and prospects," in C. Sims (ed.) Advances in Econometrics. Sixth World Congress, Cambridge University Press.

[76] Pakes, A. and P. McGuire (1994): “Computing Markov-Perfect Nash Equilibria: Numerical Implications of a Dynamic Differentiated Product Model," RAND Journal of Economics, 25(4), 555-589.

[77] Pakes, A. and P. McGuire (2001) “Stochastic Algorithms, Symmetric Markov Perfect Equilibrium, and the ’Curse of Dimensionality’,”Econometrica, 69, 1261-1281.

[78] Pakes, A., M. Ostrovsky, and S. Berry (2007): "Simple estimators for the parameters of discrete dynamic games (with entry/exit examples)," Rand Journal of Economics 38, 373-399.

[79] Perrone, H. (2009): "Inventories, Unobservable Heterogeneity and Long Run Price Elasticities," manuscript. Departement of Economics and Business at Universitat Pompeu Fabra

[80] Pesendorfer, M. (2002): "Retail Sales: A Study of Pricing Behavior in Supermarkets," Journal of Business, 75(1), pages 33-66.

[81] Pesendorfer, M. and P. Schmidt-Dengler (2003): "Identification and Estimation of Dynamic Games," NBER Working Papers 9726, National Bureau of Economic Research.

[82] Pesendorfer, M. and P. Schmidt-Dengler (2008): "Asymptotic Least Squares Estimators for Dynamic Games," Review of Economic Studies, 75(3), pages 901-928.

[83] Pesendorfer, M. and P. Schmidt-Dengler (2010): "Sequential Estimation of Dynamic Discrete Games: A Comment," Econometrica, 78(2), pages 833-842.

[84] Porter, R. (1983): "A Study of Cartel Stability: The Joint Executive Committee, 1880-1886," Bell Journal of Economics, 14(2), 301-314.

[85] Rust, J. (1987): "Optimal Replacement of GMC Bus Engines: An Empirical Model of Harold Zurcher," Econometrica, 55(5), 999-1033.

[86] Rust, J. (1994): “Estimation of dynamic structural models, problems and prospects: discrete decision processes”, in C. Sims (ed.) Advances in Econometrics. Sixth World Congress, Cambridge University Press.

[87] Ryan, S. (2006): "The Costs of Environmental Regulation in a Concentrated Industry," manuscript. Department of Economics. MIT.

[88] Samuelson, P. (1947): "Foundations of Economic Analysis,"

[89] Schiraldi, P. (2010): "Automobile Replacement: a Dynamic Structural Approach," manuscript. London School of Economics.

[90] Shcherbakov, O. (2008): "Measuring switching costs in the television industry," manuscript. University of Arizona.

[91] Smith, J. M. (1982), ”Evolution and the Theory of Games,” Cambridge University Press.

[92] Snider, C. (2009): "Predatory incentives and predation policy: the American Airlines case," manuscript. Department of Economics. UCLA.

[93] Su C., and K. Judd (2008): "Constrainted Optimization Approaches to Estimation of Structural Models," Discussion Papers 1460, Northwestern University, Center for Mathematical Studies in Economics and Management Science.

[94] Suzuki, J. (2010): "Land Use Regulation as a Barrier to Entry: Evidence from the Texas Lodging Industry," manuscript. Department of Economics. University of Toronto.

[95] Sweeting, A. (2007): "Dynamic Product Repositioning in Differentiated Product Markets: The Case of Format Switching in the Commercial Radio Industry," NBER Working Paper #13522.

[96] Sweeting, A. (2009): "The Strategic Timing of Radio Commercials: An Empirical Analysis Using Multiple Equilibria," RAND Journal of Economics, 40(4), 710-742.

[97] Walrath, M. (2010): "Religion as an Industry: Estimating a Strategic Entry Model for Churches," manuscript. University of St. Thomas.