A bridge too far; the strive to establish a financial service regulatory authority (OJK) in Indonesia

Pradiptyo, Rimawan and Rokhim, Rofikoh and Sahadewo, Gumilang Aryo and Ulpah, Maria and Sasmitasiwi, Banoon and Faradynawati, IAA (2011): A bridge too far; the strive to establish a financial service regulatory authority (OJK) in Indonesia.

Abstract

The Government of Indonesia (GOI) has been proposing a draft act on financial service regulatory authority, called Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK hereafter). In the aftermath of 1998 Asian crisis, the establishment of the institution was mandated through Bank Indonesia Act (Indonesia’s central bank bill) in 1999, which was later updated in 2004. According to the draft act, the OJK has been designed using an integrated approach, which is similar to the arrangement of FSA in the UK. This paper aims to examine the feasibility of establishing OJK. The existing financial supervision suffers from several problems: a) the quality of supervisions tend to be heterogeneous among the financial supervision bodies, b) there is a gap in supervision, whereby thousand of non-banking financial institutions have not been supervised properly, and c) financial offences have been flourishing in inter market transactions. We found that the establishment of OJK, however, would not minimize, let alone, resolve the problems above. The draft act has not proposed a mechanism on how to address these very issues. We estimated the minimum irreducible costs of establishing and operating OJK and found that the costs are paramount. According to the draft act, the costs would burden all financial institutions and obviously this creates complexity in financing OJK. Finally, two alternative approaches have been proposed in order to improve the feasibility and the effectiveness of the OJK by considering the structure of financial sector supervision in Indonesia.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Financial sector regulatory authority, supervision framework design, feasibility study
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L5 - Regulation and Industrial Policy > L51 - Economics of Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E61 - Policy Objectives ; Policy Designs and Consistency ; Policy Coordination

References

Abrams, R. dan Taylor, M.W., 2000, “Issues in the Unification of Financial Sector Supervision,” International Monetary Fund Working Paper, 213.

Ashari, 2006, “Potensi Lembaga Keuangan Mikro (LKM) dalam Pembangunan Ekonomi Pedesaan dan Kebijakan Pengembangannya,” Analisis Kebijakan Pertanian, 4:2, hal. 146-164, diakses Juni 2010 dari pse.litbang.deptan.go.id/ind/pdffiles/ART4-2c.pdf.

Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), 2009, “Annual Report 2009,” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://www.apra.gov.au/AboutAPRA/Annual-Report-2009.cfm

_____________, 2004a, “Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia Nomor 3 Tahun 2004 Tentang Perubahan Atas Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia Nomor 23 Tahun 1999 Tentang Bank Indonesia,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/NR/rdonlyres/C7402D01-A030-454A-BC75-9858774DF852/13447/uu_bi_no0304.pdf

____________, 2004b, Laporan Pengawasan Perbankan 2004, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Publikasi

_____________, 2005, Laporan Pengawasan Perbankan 2005, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Publikasi

_____________, 2007, Booklet Perbankan Indonesia 2007,Vol. 4.

_____________, 2009, Laporan Pengawasan Perbankan 2008, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Publikasi/Perbankan+dan+Stabilitas+Keuangan/Laporan+Pengawasan+Perbankan/LPP_2008_17042008.htm

_____________, 2010a, Laporan Keuangan Publikasi Bank, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Publikasi/Laporan+Keuangan+Publikasi+Bank/Bank/Bank+Umum+Konvensional/

_____________, 2010b, Laporan Pengawasan Perbankan 2009, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Publikasi/Perbankan+dan+Stabilitas+Keuangan/Laporan+Pengawasan+Perbankan/lpp_2009.htm

Bank Indonesia, 2010c, “Tujuan Pengaturan dan Pengawasan Bank,” diakses dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Perbankan/Ikhtisar+Perbankan/Pengaturan+dan+Pengawasan+Bank/Tujuan+dan+Kewenangan.

_____________, 2010d, “Tujuan dan Tugas Bank Indonesia,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Tentang+BI/Fungsi+Bank+Indonesia/Tujuan+dan+Tugas/

_____________, 2010e, “Statistika Perbankan Indonesia April 2010,” diakses Juni 2010 dari http://www.bi.go.id/web/id/Statistik/Statistik+Perbankan/Statistik+Perbankan+Indonesia/spi_0410.htm

_____________, 2010f, Dinamika Transformasi Pengawasan Bank di Indonesia, Humas Bank Indonesia: Jakarta.

Banque de France, 2010, “Presentation of the French Prudential Supervision Authority.”

Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan Republik Indonesia, 2007, “Agenda Strategik: Pusdiklat Pegawai Badan Pemeriksaa Keuangan.”

Badan Pemeriksa Keuangan Republik Indonesia, 2010, “Bidang Tugas Pimpinan BPK RI,” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://www.bpk.go.id/web/?page_id=41

Bank Mandiri, 2001, “Annual Report 2001,” diakses Juli 2010 dari www.bankmandiri.co.id/english/corporate01/pdf/202826836886.pdf.

Bapepam-LK, 2009, Laporan Tahunan 2008, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bapepam.go.id/bapepamlk/annual_report/AR-BAPEPAM-LK_2008.pdf

Bapepam-LK, 2010, “Pengawasan Lembaga Keuangan,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bapepam.go.id/p3/index.htm

Barth, J.R., D.E. Nolle, T. Phumiwasana, G. Yago, 2002, “A Cross-Country Analysis of the Bank Supervision Framework and Bank Performance,” Economic and Policy Analysis Working Paper, 2002.

Barth, J.R., G. Caprio Jr., R. Levine, 2004, “Bank Regulation and Supervision: What Work Best?” Journal of Financial Intermediation, 13, 2005-248.

Barth, R. James, D.E. Nolle, T. Phumiwasana, and G. Yago, 2002, “A Cross Country Analysis of the Bank Supervision Framework and Bank Performance”. Economic and Policy Analysis Working Paper,2002-2.

Bernanke, B., 2010, “The Federal Reserve’s Role in Bank Supervision,” diakses April 2010 dari http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/testimony/bernanke20100317a.htm

Biro Dana Pensiun, 2009, Laporan Tahunan Dana Pensiun 2008, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bapepam.go.id/dana_pensiun/publikasi_dp/annual_report_dp/Laptah2008/laptahdapen2008.pdf

Biro Perasuransian, 2008, Perasuransian Indonesia, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.bapepam.go.id/bapepamlk/others/Perasuransian_Indonesia_2008_part1.pdf

Blanchard, O., G. Dell’Ariccia, P. Mauro, 2009, “Rethinking Macroeconomic Policy,” International Monetary Fund Staff Position Note, 03.

Borio, C., 2009, Ímplementing the Macroprudential Approach to Financial Regulation and Supervision,” Banque de France: Financial Stability Review No. 13.

Briault, C., 1999, “The Rationale for a Single National Financial Services Regulator, FSA Occasional Paper, 2, diakses dari www.fsa.gov.uk/pubs/occpapers/OP02.pdf

Brunnermeier, M., A. Crockett, C. Goodhart, A. Persaud, and H.S. Shin, 2009, “The Fundamental Principles of Financial Regulation,” Geneva and London: International Center for Monetary and Banking Studies (ICMB), and Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR), London.

Carmichael, J., 2002, “APRA-The Way Forward,” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://www.apra.gov.au/speeches/02_12.cfm

Cervellati, E.M., dan E. Fioriti, 2007, “Financial Supervision in EU Countries,” working paper, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.efmaefm.org/0EFMAMEETINGS/EFMA%20ANNUAL%20MEETINGS/2007-Vienna/Papers/0522.pdf

Chowdhury, A., 2010, “Financial Sector Regulation in Developing Countries: Reckoning After the Crisis,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.ideaswebsite.org/featart/feb2010/Anis_Chowdhury.pdf

Coleman, W.D., 1996, “Financial Services, Globalization and Domestic Policy Change,” hal. 67, Macmillan Press Ltd, London dalam Lukman Hakim dkk, 2003, “Studi Dasar-Dasar Ekonomi Politik OJK,” Lembaga Studi Pengembangan Etika Usaha Indonesia (LSPEUI) Jakarta dan PPSK BI

Cole, D.C. dan B.S. Slade, 1996, “Building A Modern Financial System: The Indonesian Experience,” Cambridge University Press, New York dalam Lukman Hakim dkk, 2003, “Studi Dasar-Dasar Ekonomi Politik OJK,” Lembaga Studi Pengembangan Etika Usaha Indonesia (LSPEUI) Jakarta dan PPSK BI

Cooper et.al, 1991, “Selection Criteria in Coordination Games: Some Experimental Results,” Games Econ. Behav. 3, 25-59

Cooper et.al, 1996, “Cooperation Without Reputation: Experimental Evidence from Prisoner’s Dilemma Games,” Games Econ. Behav, 12, No. 0013, 187-218

Crockett, A., 2001, “Banking Supervision & Regulation: International Trends,” diakses April 2010 dari www.bis.org/speeches/sp010330.htm

Demaestri, E.dan F. Guerrero, 2002, “The Rationale for Integrating Financial Supervision in Latin America and the Carribean,” diakses Juni 2010 dari http://www.aaep.org.ar/espa/anales/PDF_03/Demaestri_Guerrero.pdf

Departemen Keuangan, 2010, “Data Pokok APBN 2005-2010,” diunduh Agustus 2010 dari www.fiskal.depkeu.go.id/webbkf/download/datapokok-ind2010.pdf.

Deposit Insurance Corporation Japan, 2010, “Scheme for Special Crisis Management,” diakses Juni 2010 dari http://www.dic.go.jp/ english/e_katsudou/e_katsudou2-4.html

Enrich, D. dan L. Norman (2010), “U.K. Shakes Up Its Bank Regulation: Once-Proud FSA Will Be No More, Folded Into Other Entities; More Power for Central Bank,” diakses Juni 2010 dari http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704198004575310451098811086.html

European Central Bank, 2001, “The Role of Central Banks in Prudential Supervision,” diakses Mei 2010 dari www.ecb.int/pub/pdf/other/prudentialsupcbrole_en.pdf

Financial Services Agency Japan, 2010, “The Organization of the FSA,” diakses Juni 2010 dari www.fsa.go.jp/en/index.html

Goodhart, C.A.E., 2000, “The Organisational Structure of Banking Supervision”. FSI Occasional Papers No. 1 – November 2000-10-25.

Goodhart, Charles dan Schoenmaker, Dirk, 1995, “Should the Functions of Monetary Policy and Banking Supervision Be Separated?,” Oxford Economic Papers, Oxford University Press, Vol. 47(4) pp. 539-60

Grenville, Stephen, 2005, “Financial Sector Supervision: What We Have Learned So Far,” diakses Agustus 2010 dari www.oecd.org/dataoecd/12/54/35497307.pdf

Group of Thirty, The Structure of Financial Supervision : Approaches and Challenges in Global Market Place, January 2009 G30 Financial Regulatory Systems Working Group, 2008, The Structure of Financial Supervision : Approaches and Challenges in Global Market Place

Grunbichler, A. dan P. Darlap, 2003, “Regulation and Supervision of Financial Markets and Institutions: A European Perspective,” diakses Juni 2010 dari www.fep.up.pt/disciplinas/pgaf924/.../Texto_7_Grunbichler_Darlap.pdf

Guardian, 2009, “David Cameron Unveils Plan to Scrap Financial Watchdog,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2009/jul/20/david-cameron-financial-regulation

Gugler, P., 2005, “The Integrated Supervision of Financial Markets: The Case of Switzerland,” The Geneva Papers, 30, (128-143)

Herring, R. J., dan J. Carmassi, 2008, “The Structure of Cross-Sector Financial Supervision,” Financial Markets, Institutions, and Instruments, 17, hal. 51-76.

Hoenig, T. M., 2004, “Exploring the Macro-Prudential Aspects of Financial Sector Supervision,”Meeting for Heads of Supervision Bank for International Settlements Basel.

Houben, A., J. Kakes, dan G. Schinasi, 2004, “Toward a Framework for Safeguarding Financial Stability,”IMF Working Paper, 04/101, diakses Juni 2010 dari www.ksri.org/bbs/files/research02/wp04101.pdf

House of Lords, 2009, “Banking Supervision and Regulation,” Select Committee on Economic Affairs: 2nd Report Session 2008-2009.

Ingves, S., 2007, “Housing and Monetary Policy: A View from an Inflation-Targeting Central Bank,” Paper dipresentasikan pada the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City Annual Conference on Housing, Housing Finance, and Monetary Policy, Jackson Hole, Wyoming diakses dari www.kansascityfed.org/publicat/sympos/2007/pdf/Ingves_0415.pdf International Organization of Securities Commissions, 2010, “Ordinary Members of IOSCO,” diakses 27 Juni 2010 http://www.iosco.org /lists/display_members. cfm?memID=1&orderBy=none

Ioannidou, V.P., 2003, “Does Monetary Policy Affect the Central Bank’s Role in Bank Supervision?”Journal of Financial Intermediation 14 (2005) 58-85.

Jackson, James K., 2009, “Canada’s Financial System: an Overview,” Congressional Research Service

Kashyap, Anil K, 2010, “ Testimony on “ Examining the Link between Fed Bank Supervision and Monetary Policy”, House Financial Services Committee, diakses Juli 2010 di http://www.house.gov/apps/list/hearing/financialsvcs_dem/kashyap.pdf Kawai,M. dan M. Pomerleano, 2010, “ Regulating Systemic Risk,” Asian Development Bank Institute, diakses Juni 2010 dari http ://ssrn.com/abstract=1581303

Kementrian Negara Koperasi dan UKM, 2009, “PP Simpan Pinjam Koperasi Segera Disempurnakan,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.depkop.go.id/Media%20Massa/659-pp-simpan-pinjam-koperasi-segera-disempurnakan.html

Kompas, 2010, “Pembentukan OJK Tidak Tepat,” Kompas cetak 14 Juni 2010, hal. 19.

Kreps, D., P. Milgrom, J. Roberts, and R. Wilson (1982), “Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoner’s Dilemma,” Journal of Economic Theory, 17: 245-252

Krivoy, R., 2000, “Reforming Bank Supervision in Developing Countries,” working paper, diakses Mei 2010 dari www.bos.frb.org/economic/conf/conf44/cf44_10.pdf

de Larosiere Group, 2009, Report on Financial Supervision: High-Level Group on Financial Supervision in the EU (February), diakses Juni 2010 dari http:// www.ec.europa.eu/internal_market/finances/docs/de_larosiere_report_en.pdf

Lacker, J.M, 2006, “Central Bank Credit in the Theory of Money and Payments,” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://www.richmondfed.org/press_room/speeches/president_jeff_lacker/ 2006/lacker_speech_20060329.cfm.

Levine, R., 1997, “Financial Development and Economic Growth: Views and Agenda,” Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 35, 688-726.

Llewellyn, D. T, 2006, “Institutional Structure of Financial Regulation and Supervision: The Basic Issues,” Paper dipresentasikan pada World Bank seminar “Aligning Supervision Structures with Country Needs” tanggal 6 dan 7 Juni 2006, Washington DC

Martinez, J.L. dan T.A. Rose, 2003, “International Survey of Integrated Financial Sector Supervision,” World Bank: Policy Sector Working Paper, 3096, diakses dari http://www.wds.worldbank.org/servlet/WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2003/08/23/000094946_03080904015686/Rendered/PDF/multi0page.pdf

Mas-Colell, A., M. D. Whinston, J. R. Green, 1995, Microeconomic Theory, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK

Mihalca, G., 2007, “The Relation between Financial Development and Economic Growth in Romania”. The 2nd Central European Conference in Regional Science, diakses Juni 2010 dari www.cers.tuke.sk/cers2007/PDF/Mihalca.pdf

Mueller, Dennis C.,1983, The Political Economy of Growth, Yale University Press: New Haven

Nasution, A., 2003, “Stabilitas Sistem Keuangan: Urgensi, Implikasi Hukum, dan Agenda kedepan”. Seminar Pembangunan Hukum Nasional VIIIoleh Badan Pembinaan Hukum Nasional - Departemen Kehakiman dan Hak Asasi Manusia Rl, Denpasar: 14-18 Juli 2003.

Nier, E.W., 2009, “Financial Stability Frameworks and The Role of Central Banks: Lessons From the Crisis,” International Monetary Fund Working Paper, 09/70, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/wp/2009/wp0970.pdf

PA Consulting Group, 2009, Financial Services Authority: Researching Regulatory Funding Models, diakses Juli 2010 dari www.fsa.gov.uk/pubs/other/reg_funding.pdf.

Peek, J., E.S. Rosengren, dan G.M.B. Tootell, 1999, “Is Bank Supervision Central to Central Banking?,” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, CXIV(2), pp. 629-653

Pawn office, 2010, Laporan Tahunan 2009, diakses Mei 2010 dari http://www.pawn office.co.id/k.annual.php?uid=

Pemerintah Republik Indonesia, 2010, Naskah Akademik Pembentukan Otoritas Jasa Keuangan (OJK), Tim Panitia Antar Departemen Rancangan Undang-undang tentang Otoritas Jasa Keuangan: Jakarta.

Pradiptyo, R., B Sasmitasiwi and G.A. Sahadewo, 2010, Evidence of Homo Economicus? Findings from Experiment on Evolutionary Prisoners’ Dilemma Game, Mimeo, Faculty of Economics and Business, Universitas Gadjah Mada, Indonesia

Samuelson, P.A., 1997, “Wherein Do the European and American Models Differ?,” Papers 320, Banca Italia-Servizio di Studi

Seelig, Steven A. dan Alicia Novoa, 2009, “Governance Practices at Financial Regulatory and Supervision Agencies,” IMF Working Paper No. 09/135

Segara, E., 2006, “Saatnya BMT Berbenah Diri,” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://edosegara.blogspot.com/2008/02/saatnya-bmt-berbenah-diri.html

Sinclair, P.J.N., 2000, “Central Banks and Financial Stability,” Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin, 2000, hal. 377-91.

SMECDA, 2006, “BMT Sebaiknya Tetap Berbadan Hukum Koperasi,” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://www.smecda.com/deputi7/BERITA%20KUKM%202006/REPUBLIKA_02082006.pdf

Squam Lake Working Group on Financial Regulation, 2009, “A Systemic Regulator for Financial Markets,” Working Paper, Council on Foreign Relations: Center for Geoeconomic Studies.

Stiglitz, J. (1994), “The Role of the State in Financial Markets”, Prosiding dalam World BankAnnual Conference on Development Economics Supplement, 1993, 19-61.

Suharto, S., 2008, “Peranan Permodalan BMT dalam Pemberdayaan Sektor UMK (3),” diakses Juli 2010 dari http://www.niriah.com/opini/detail.php?cid=2&id=816&pageNum=3 Taylor, Michael dan Alex Fleming, 1999, “Integrated Financial Supervision: Lessons of Northern European Experience,” Policy Research Working Paper, 2223, The World Bank Tsay, Chin-Tsair, “Overcoming Crisis and The Role of Deposit Insurance,” Central Deposit Corporation, diakses Juni 2010 dari www.cdic.gov.tw/public/Attachment/4111614353171.pdf

World Bank, 2009, “Agenda Perbaikan Sektor Keuangan Indonesia,” diakses Mei 2010 dari http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTINDONESIA/Resources/Publication/280016-1106130305439/617331-1110769011447/810296-1110769073153/financialsector.pdf