Preference for increasing wages: How do people value various streams of income?

Duffy, Sean and Smith, John (2010): Preference for increasing wages: How do people value various streams of income?

Abstract

Prior studies have found that subjects prefer an improving sequence of income over a constant sequence, even if the constant sequence offers a larger present discounted value. However, little is known about how these preferences vary with the size of the wage payments. In each of our three studies, we find a positive relationship between the preference for increasing payments and the size of the payments. Further, our measure of the decreasing marginal utility of money is only weakly associated with this relationship. Additionally, our results roughly confirm an earlier theoretical prediction that the preference for increasing wage payments will be largest for intermediate sized payments. Finally, consistent with the literature, we find mixed evidence regarding the relationship between the preference for increasing payments and such preferences in other domains.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: time preference; experimental economics; intertemporal choice
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice > D90 - General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C91 - Laboratory, Individual Behavior

References

Andersen, Steffen, Harrison, Glenn, Lau, Morten and Rutstrom, E. Elisabet (2008): "Eliciting Risk and Time Preferences," Econometrica, 76(3): 583--618.

Ariely, Dan and Carmon, Ziv (2000): "Gestalt characteristics of experiences: the defining features of summarized events," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 13: 191--201.

Attema, Arthur, Bleichrodt, Han, Rohde, Kirsten and Wakker, Peter (2010): "Time-Tradeoff Sequences for Analyzing Discounting and Time Inconsistency," Management Science, 56(11): 2015--2030.

Barsky, Robert, Juster, F. Thomas, Kimball, Miles and Shapiro, , Matthew (1997): "Preference Parameters and Behavioral Heterogeneity: An Experimental Approach in the Health and Retirement Study," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112 (2): 537--579.

Benzion, Uri, Rapoport, Amnon and Yagil, Joseph (1989): "Discount Rates Inferred from Decisions: An Experimental Study," Management Science, 35(3): 270--284.

Burchardt, Tania (2005): "Are One Man's Rags another Man's Riches? Identifying Adaptive Expectations Using Panel Data." Social Indicators Research, 74(1): 57--102.

Chapman, Gretchen (1996a): "Expectations and preferences for sequences of health and money," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 67: 59--75.

Chapman, Gretchen (1996b): "Temporal discounting and utility for health and money," Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 22: 771--791.

Chapman, Gretchen (2000): "Preferences for improving and declining sequences of health outcomes," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 13: 203--218.

Chapman, Gretchen (2002): "Your money or your health: Time preferences and trading money for health," Medical Decision Making, 22: 410--416.

Chapman, Gretchen and Elstein, Aurthur (1995): "Valuing the future: Temporal discounting of health and money," Medical Decision Making, 15: 373--386.

Chapman, Gretchen and Weber, Bethany (2006): "Decision biases in intertemporal choice and choice under uncertainty. Testing a common account," Memory & Cognition, 34(3): 589--602.

Clark, Andrew (1999): "Are Wages Habit-Forming? Evidence from Micro Data," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 39(2): 179--200.

Dave, Chetan, Eckel, Catherine, Johnson, Cathleen and Rojas, Christian (2010) "Eliciting Risk Preferences: When is Simple Better?" Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 41: 219--243.

Di Tella, Rafael , Haisken-De New, John and MacCulloch, Robert (2010): "Happiness Adaptation to Income and to Status in an Individual Panel," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 76(3): 834--852.

Eckel, Catherine and Grossman, Philip (2008): "Forecasting risk attitudes: An experimental study using actual and forecast gamble choices," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 68: 1--17.

Elster, Jonathan and Loewenstein, George (1992): "Utility from memory and anticipation." In G. F. Loewenstein, & J.Elster (Eds.), Choice over time (pp. 213--234). New York: Sage.

Flabbi, L., Ichino, A., (2001): "Productivity, seniority and wages: new evidence from personnel data," Labour Economics, 8: 359--387.

Frank, Robert and Hutchins, Robert (1993): "Wages, seniority and the demand for rising consumption profiles," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 21: 251--276.

Frederick, Shane and Loewenstein, George (2008): "Conflicting Motives in Evaluations of Sequences," Journal of Risk and Uncertainty, 37: 221--235.

Gigliotti, Gary and Sopher, Barry (2004): "Analysis of Intertemporal Choice: A New Framework and Experimental Results," Theory and Decision, 55: 209--233.

Gigliotti, Gary and Sopher, Barry (1997): "Violations of Present-Value Maximization in Income Choice," Theory and Decision, 43: 45--69.

Green, Leonard, Myerson, Joel and McFadden, Edward (1997): "Rate of Temporal Discounting Decreases with Amount of Reward," Memory & Cognition, 25(5): 715--723.

Green, Leonard, Myerson, Joel and Macaux, Eric (2005): "Temporal Discounting When the Choice Is Between Two Delayed Rewards," Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 31(5): 1121--1133.

Grund, Christian and Sliwka, Dirk (2007): "Reference-Dependent Preferences and the Impact of Wage Increases on Job Satisfaction: Theory and Evidence," Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 163(2): 313--335.

Guyse, Jeffery, Keller L. Robin and Eppel, Thomas (2002): "Valuing Environmental Outcomes: Preferences for Constant or Improving Sequences," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 87: 253--277.

Hardisty, David and Weber, Elke (2009): "Discounting Future Green: Money Versus the Environment," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 138(3): 329--340.

Holt, Charles and Laury, Susan (2002): "Risk aversion and incentive effects," American Economic Review, 92(5): 1644--1655.

Hsee, Christopher and Abelson, Robert (1991): "Velocity Relation: Satisfaction as a Function of the First Derivative of Outcome Over Time," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 60(3): 341--347.

Hsee, Christoper, Abelson, Robert and Salovey, Peter (1991): "The Relative Weighting of Position and Velocity in Satisfaction," Psychological Science, 2(4): 263--266.

Inglehart, Ronald and Rabier, Jacques-Rene (1986): "Aspirations Adapt to Situations: But Why Are the Belgians so Much Happier than the French? A Cross-Cultural Analysis of the Subjective Quality of Life," In Research on the Quality of Life, Frank Andrews (Ed.), Institute for Social Research, University of Michican, Ann Arbor.

Issler, Joao and Piqueira, Natalia (2000): "Estimating Relative Risk Aversion, the Discount Rate, and the Intertemporal Elasticity of Substitution in Consumption for Brazil Using Three Types of Utility Function," Brazilian Review of Econometrics, 20(2): 201--239.

Johnson, Matthew and Bickel, Warren (2002): "Within-Subject Comparison of Real and Hypothetical Money Rewards in Delay Discounting," Journal of the Analysis of Experimental Behavior, 77(2): 129--146.

Kapteyn, Arie and Teppa, Federica (2003): "Hypothetical Intertemporal Consumption Choices," Economic Journal, 113: C140--C152.

Lazear, Edward (1999): "Personnel Economics: Past Lessons and Future Directions," Journal of Labor Economics, 17(2): 198--236.

Loewenstein, George and Prelec, Drazen (1993): "Preferences for Sequences of Outcomes," Psychological Review, 100(1): 91--108.

Loewenstein, George and Sicherman, Nachum (1991): "Do Workers Prefer Increasing Wage Profiles?" Journal of Labor Economics, 9(1): 67--84.

Manzini, Paola, Mariotti, Marco and Mittone, Luigi (2010) "Choosing Monetary Sequences: Theory and Experimental Evidence," Theory and Decision, 69(3): 327--354.

Matsumoto, Dawn, Peecher, Mark and Rich, Jay (2000): "Evaluations of Outcome Sequences," Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 83(2): 331--352.

Medoff, James and Abraham, Katharine (1980): "Experience, Performance, and Earnings," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 95: 703--736.

National Association for Legal Career Professionals (2008): "Starting Salary Distribution for Class of 2008 More Dramatic than Previous Years," http://www.nalp.org/08saldistribution.

Raineri, Andres and Rachlin, Howard (1993): "The Effect of Temporal Constraints on the Value of Money and Other Commodities," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 6: 77--94.

Ross, W. T. Jr and Simonson, I. (1991): "Evaluating pairs of experiences: A preference for happy endings," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 4: 273--282.

Schoenfelder, Thomas and Hantula, Donald (2003): "A Job with a Future? Delay Discounting, Magnitude Effects, and Domain Independence of Utility for Career Decisions," Journal of Vocational Behavior, 62: 43--55.

Senik, Claudia (2008): "Is Man Doomed to Progress?" Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 68: 140--152.

Smith, Carter and Hantula, Donald (2008): "Methodological Considerations in the Study of Delay Discounting in Intertemporal Choice: A Comparison of Tasks and Modes," Behavior Research Methods, 40(4): 940--953.

Smith, John (2009a): "Imperfect Memory and the Preference for Increasing Payments" Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, 165(4): 684--700.

Smith, John (2009b): "Cognitive Dissonance and the Overtaking Anomaly: Psychology in the Principal-Agent Relationship," Journal of Socio-Economics, 38(4): 684--690.

Soman, Dilip (2003): "Prospective and Retrospective Evaluations of Experiences: How You Evaluate an Experience Depends on When You Evaluate It," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 16: 35--52.

Stevenson, Mary Kay (1993): "Decision making with long-term consequences: Temporal discounting for single and multiple outcomes in the future," Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 122: 3--22.

Thaler, Richard (1981): "Some Empirical Evidence of Dynamic Inconsistency," Economics Letters, 8: 201--207.

Varey, Carol and Kahneman, Daniel (1992): "Experiences extended across time: Evaluation of moments and episodes," Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 5, 169--185.

Warner, John and Pleeter, Saul (2001): "The Personal Discount Rate: Evidence from Military Downsizing Programs," American Economic Review, 91(1): 33--53.