Macromodels of the Romanian transition Economy

Dobrescu, Emilian (1996): Macromodels of the Romanian transition Economy. Published in: Macromodels of the Romanian transition Economy, Expert Publishing House, Bucharest, 1996 (October 1996): pp. 2-159.

Abstract

The present book contains six chapters. In the first, the Romanian transition economy is characterized as a weakly structured economy (from the institutional point of view) with its main features: the poorly defined ownership rights, the limited effectiveness of new market mechanisms, the significant role of informal institutions, the behavioural instability of economic agents, the great influence of resources' allocation by the political factor. These features have many macroeconomic implications, of which three are especially analyzed: the waste of economic resources induced by the fuzzy ownership structure, by uncertainty and high transaction costs; the deep fracture between the real and nominal sectors; the presence of numerous economic activities not included in the official statistics (nonaccounted economy). The next chapter describes the main indicators used in the macromodel of the Romanian transition economy (definitions, symbols, specifications, relations among them, in accordance with the methodologies adopted by national statistics). The third chapter approaches the econometric problems. Unfortunately, the microeconomic foundations of the transition are not sufficiently studied and, in effect, in many cases we lack the necessary assumptions for building up econometric functions. On the other hand, the same statistical series are relatively short and are based on conventional simplifications imposed by the translation of the former methodologies (from material production system) to the language of the national accounts. Being weakly structured, the transition economy does not yet reveal consistent trends. Despite the unavoidable (under these conditions) instability of individual econometric functions, their integration into the macromodel, including the equilibrium constraints (accounting identities), can ensure acceptable results for short-run forecasts. Twenty econometric functions have been elaborated. They deal with: real output of the Romanian economy, domestic aggregate demand, investment,export, labour force, labour productivity, exchange rate, main deflators, labour incomes, households production for self-consumption, evolution of the nonaccounted economy, monetary processes. These functions reflect the peculiarities of the Romanian experience. It is possible that other transition economies may show similar tendencies, but eventual generalizations require supplementary researches. The fourth chapter is dedicated to the main version of the macromodel of the Romanian transition economy. Its tests for 1992 - 1995 (the 1994 - 1995 are presented herein), gave encouraging results. Consequently, it has been used for previsional estimations. Thus, in the fifth chapter, some possible scenarios of the evolution of the Romanian economy between 1996 - 2000 are examined. This analysis demonstrates that oniy a deep restructuring process is able to determine sound, long term sustainable, economic growth. Among the necessary policies I can mention: the realization of an ownership structure adequate to a modern market economy; the drastic limitation of inefficient economic activities subsidized by the state budget; the improvement of corporate governance; the progressive integration of Romania into the European and world economy; the effective functioning of different markets, including the capital one; maintenance of the inflation under control by a prudent monetary policy; lowering the share of the budget expenditures in GDP and the promotion, on this basis, of a rational fiscality. The last chapter examines an extended version of the macromodel, in which the general consolidated budget is explicitly presented. At the same time, other possible developments of the macromodel are outlined; its qualities and limits are mentioned. The most important problem remains the instability of the econometric functions. Consequently, it is necessary to reestimate them every year, taking into account new findings of the theory related to the transition and new statistical information. In other words, the macromodel must be permanently updated. In this way, a sort of sliding macroeconomic modelling is practiced. The appendices of the book contain a relevant set of macroeconomic indicators of Romania for the period 1980 -1995, the detailed presentation of the econometric functions and of the macroeconomic estimations, as well as a selective bibliography.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: model, econometric relationships, input-output analysis, simulations
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E0 - General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling

References

Abraham - Frois G.(1988): "Economie politique", Economica, traducere Humanitas, Bucureşti, 1994

Adair P.(1995): "Economie informelle et économie de marché industrialisées", Congrčs de l'AIELF, Bucarest

Albu L. L.(1995): "Underground economy and fiscal policies modelling", Research for the European Commission's Phare ACE Programme

Alessandrini S., Dallago: "The unofficial economy - Consequences and 8.(1989). perspectives in different economic systems", GOWER

Allen R.D.G. (1964): "Mathematical analysis for economists", Macmilan, London

Aoki M., Kim H. K. (edit.) "Corporate governance in transitional economies - (1995): Insider control and the role of banks", EDI Development Studies, The World Bank, Washington D. C.

Archambault E. (1985): "Comptabilité Nationale", Economica, Paris

Archambault E., Arkhipoff O. (edit.) (1986): "Etudes de comptabilité nationale", Economica, Paris

Archambault E., Arkhipoff O. (edit.) (1992): "La comptabilité nationale, porquoi faire?", Economica, Paris

Archambault E., ArkhipoffO. (edit.) (1990): "La comptabilité nationale face au défi international", Economica, Paris

Balcerowicz L., Gelb A. (1994): "Macropolicies in transition to market economy: a three-year perspective", The World Bank

Banciu D. (1993): "Corupţia în societatea românească postrevoluţionară în perspectivă normativă şi sociologică", Sociologie românească, Serie nouă, Anul IV, Nr. 4

Barry F. (1996): "The small open economy and the Romanian macromodel)", Working paper, Phare ACE programme of the European Union

Barro J. R. (1987): "Macroeconomics", John Wiley and sons, New York

Baumol W.J., Blinder A. S. (1991): "Economics - principles and policy", Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers

Begg D., Portes R. (1992): "Entreprise debt and economic transformation: financial restructuring of the state sector in Central and Eastern Europe", Center for Economic Policy Research, Discussion Paper No.695, June

Bernstam M.S. (1996): "The debt collusion and the mistery of Russian reform", Working paper, Hoover Institution

Bemstam M.S., MaCurdy T.E. (1996): "Why reform Russian banks, and how", Working paper, Hoover Institution

Blaga L (1935- 1937): "Orizont şi stil", "Spaţiul mioritic", "Geneza metaforei şi sensul culturii", Humanitas, Bucureşti, 1994

Blanchard O.J., Froot K.A., Sachs J.D. (1994): "The transition in Eastern Europe", National Bureau of Economic Research, The University of Chicago Press

Blommestein H., Marrese M. (edits) (1991): "Transformation of planned economies: property rights reform and macroeconomic stability", OECD, Paris

Bonke J. (1993): "Distribution of economic resources: implications of including houshold production", Review of Income and Wealth, Series 38, No. 3

Borges AM (1986): "Les modèles appliqués d'équilibre général: une évaluation de leur utilité pour l'analyse des politiques économiques", Revue Economique de l'OCDE, Nr.7

Brown W.S. (1988): "Macroeconomics", Prentince Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey

Capanu I., Wagner P., Mitruţ C. (1994): "Sistemul conturilor naţionale şi agregate macroeconomice", Editura AII, Bucureşti

Carlin W., Soskice D. (1990): "Macroeconomics and the Wage Bargain - A modern approach to employment, inflation and the exchange rate", Oxford University Press

Case K.E., Fair R. C. (1989): "Principles of economics", Prentince Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey

Chadeau A., Roy C. (1986): "Relating households' final consumption to household activities: substitutability or complementarity between market and non-market production", Review of Income and Wealth, Series 32, No. 4

Chadeau A. (1983): "Measuring household activities: some international comparisons", The 18th General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Luxemburg

Charemza W. W. and Deadman D. F. (1993): "New directions in econometric practice: general to specific modelling, cointegration and vector autoregression", Edward Elgar, England

Charmes J. (1982): "Comment mésurer la contribution du secteur non structuré a la production nationale dans les pays du tiers monde", Conférence Régionale Africaine de I'International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Donala, Novembre

Chiarella C. (1990): "The elements of a nonlinear theory of economic dynamics", Springer - Verlag Berlin Heidelberg New York "Macroeconomic models and controversies", St. Martin's Press, New York

Chirichiello G. (1994): "Macroeconomic models and controversies", St. Martin's Press, New York

Ciupagea C. (1994): "An elasticity approach to the analysis of Romanian foreign trade policy during the years of transition", Economics of Planning 27, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands

Clifton E. V., Khan S. M. (1993): "Interentreprise arrears in transforming economies: The case of Romania", IMF Staff Papers, vol.40, No.3

Coase R.H. (1937): "The nature of the firm", Economica, November

Coase R.H. (1960): "The problem of social cost", The journal of law and economics", October

Comisia Naţională pentru Statistică a României (1993): "Conturile Naţionale, anii 1989,1990,1991", Bucureşti

Croitoru L. (1995): "Funcţionarea economiei şi măsurarea economică", Teză de doctorat, ASE, Facultatea de Cibernetică, Statistică şi Informatică Economică

Daianu D. (1993): "Arieratele intra-întreprindere în economia de tranziţie", Oeconomica No.4

DallagoB. (1991): "Second and irregular economy in eastern Europe: its consequences for economic transition", Bureau of labour statistics, U.S. Department of Labour, Washington, February

Debare M.(1992): "Les milliards de l'ombre, l'économie souterraine", Hatier, Paris

Dernburg T.F.(1985): "Macroeconomics: concepts, theories and policies", McGraw-Hill, Inc.

Dicţionar de matematică şi cibernetică în economie (1979), Editura Ştiinţifică şi Enciclopedica, Bucureşti

Didier M. (1989): "Economie: les régies du jeu", Economica, Paris

Dobrescu E. (1989): "Măsurarea economică", Tratat de economie contemporană, voi. 2, cartea a ll-a, Editura Politică, Bucureşti

Dobrescu E„ Postolache T. "Consemnări economice", Ed. Academiei Române, (1990): Bucureşti

Dobrescu E, (1992): "The transition and economic behaviour", Romanian economic review, Tome 36, No. 1

Dobrescu E. (1993 a): "La transition et la modélisation macroéconomique", Romanian economic review, Tome 37, No. 2

Dobrescu E. (1993 b): "The L M function in a transition economy", SOREC - IRLI, Oeconomica, No. 5

Dobrescu E. (1994 a): "Econometric tests of some monetary hypotheses", SOREC seminar, Bucharest

Dobrescu E. (1994 b): "Money velocity in a transition economy: the case of Romania", Romanian economic review, Tome 38, No. 2

Dobrescu E. (1996 a): "The unstable processes and macroeconomic modelling", Romanian economic research, Observer, No. 3-4

Dobrescu E. (1996 b): "A possible short-run macromodel of the Romanian transition economy", Centre of economic information and documentation, Bucharest

Dogan M., PelassyD.(1992): "Economia mixtă", Editura Alternative, Bucureşti

Dornbush R., Fischer S., Sparks G. (1985): "Macroeconomics", McGraw-Hill Ryerson Limited

Drăghicescu D. (1907): "Din psihologia poporului român", Editura Albatros, Bucureşti, 1995

Drechsler L., Horvath P. (1985): "Some problems of the measurement of total consumption in Hungary", Review of Income and Wealth, Series 31, No. 2

Dunavôlgyi M., Sandor G. (1992): "Welfare measurement within non-market circumstances with special regard to Eastern Europe", The 22nd General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Flims, Switzerland, August-September

Eatwell J., Murray M., Newman P. (edits) (1991): "The world of economics - The new Palgrave", The Macmillan Press Limited

Eck R. van, Kazemier B. (1988): "Features of the hidden economy in the Netherlands", Review of income and wealth, Series 34, No. 3

Falconer, K. J. (1985): "The geometry of fractal sets", Cambridge, University

Feige E. L. (1989): "The underground economies - tax evasion and information distorsion", Cambridge University Press

Flood L, Klevmarken M.A. (1992): "Market work, household work and leisure: an analysis of time - use in Sweden", The 22nd General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Flims, Switzerland, August-September

Frydman R., Rapaczynski A., Earle J.S. (1993): "The privatization process in Central Europe", Central European University Press, London

Gaertner W., Wennig A. (1983): "The economics of the shadow economy", Proceedings of the International Conference on the economics of the shadow economy held at the University of Bielefeld, West Germany, Springer - Verlag, Berlin Heidelberg - New York -Tokyo 1985

Granger C. W. J. (edit.) (1990): "Modelling economic series: readings in econometric methodology", Oxford University Press, Oxford "Applied economic forecasting techniques", Harvester Wheatsheaf

Hall S.G. (edit.) (1994): "Macroeconomics", W. W. Norton and Company

Hall R.E, TaylorJ. B. (1991): "The econometric analysis of time series", Cambridge, Mass., MIT Press

Harvey A. C. (1990): "Introduction to the theory of neural computation", Addison - Wesley Publishing Company

Hertz J.,Krogh A., Palmer R. G. (1991): "Introduction to the theory of neural computation", Addison - Wesley Publishing Company

Houston J. F. (1990): "The policy implications of the underground economy", Journal of Economics and Business, No.42

lancu A. (1994): "Criza tranziţiei: criză predominant instituţională", Academia Română, Centrul de Informare şi Documentare Economică, Bucureşti

lonete C. (1993): "Criza de sistem a economiei de comandă şi etapa sa explozivă", Editura Expert, Bucureşti

KazemierB., ExelJ. (1992): "The allocation of time in the Netherlands in the context of the SNA", The 22nd General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Flims, Switzerland, August-September

Kenessey Z. (1987): "The primary, secondary, tertiary and quaternary Sectors of the Economy", The Review of Income and Wealth, December

Kuznets S.(1976): "Economic growth of nations. Total output production structure", Harward University Press

Kornai J. (1990): "The road to a free economy", W.W. Norton and Company, New York

Laski K. in cooperation with A. Bhaduri (1996): "Lessons to be drawn from main mistakes in the transition strategy", OECD /CCET Colloquim, Paris

Lazear E.P. (edit.) (1995): "Economic transition in Eastern Europe and Russia", Hoover Institution Press, Stanford University

Le systeme Elargi de Comptabilité Nationale (1976), Collections de l'INSEE, Série C Nr. 44-45, Mai

Le systeme Elargi de Comptabilité Nationale (1987), Collections de l'INSEE, Série C Nr.140-141

Leal A. M. (1994): "Economia ascunsă reflectată în conturile naţionale portugheze", Seminarul C.N.S., Bucureşti

Lord M. J. (1994): "Romanian macromodel for flexible exchange rate system", USAID, Development Alternatives

Malinvaud E. (1964): "Méthodes statistiques de l'économétrie", Dunod, Paris

Mandelbrot B. (1989): "Les objects fractals", NBS Flammarion, France

MankiwM. G. (1994): "Macroeconomics", Worth Publishers

Measurement of employment in the informal sector(1992), International Labour Organisation, Geneva, lanuary-February

Miltenburg H. (1995): "Development of productive capacity in Central Europe (1950 - 1992)", Annual Meeting of the Association for Evolutionary Economics (AFEE), Washington, January 8

Mihoc G., Urseanu V., Ursianu E. (1982): "Modele de analiză statistică", Editura Ştiinţifică şi Enciclopedică, Bucureşti

Mungiu A. (1995): "Românii după '89 - Istoria unei neînţelegeri", Humanitas, Bucureşti

Munteanu - Gurgu C. (1991): "Dimensiunea culturală a reformei economice", Oeconomica, Nr.1

Murphy M. (1981): "Comparative estimates of the value of household work in the United States for 1976", The 17th General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Gouvieux, France, August

North, D. C. (1992): "Institutions, institutional change and economic performance", Cambridge University Press

Paşti V. (1996): "România în tranziţie : Căderea în viitor", Editura Nemira, Bucureşti

Pesaran M.H. and Potter S.M. (edit.) (1993): "Nonlinear dynamics, chaos and econometrics", John Wiley and sons, England

Pestieau P.(1989): "L'économie souterraine", Hachette

Peters E.E. (1991): "Chaos and order in the capital markets: a new view of cycles, prices, and market volatility", John Wiley and Sons, New York

Petersen, H. G. (1987): "The Laffer curve and <illicit cash> in simple macroeconomic models", The 20th General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Rome, Italy, August

Phelps E. S„ in collaboration with Hoon H.T., Kanagis G., Zoega (1994): "Structural slumps - The modern theory of unemployment, interest, and assets", Harvard University Press

Pommerehne W.W., Prey B.S. (1988): "L'économie souterraine: Problemes de mésure et résultats quantitatifs", Revue d'économie politique, No. 3

Pichot A. (1989): "Elargissement des comptabilités nationales", Economica, Paris

Popovici P., Radu V., Popovici N. (1994): "Metodologie de reducere treptată a blocajului financiar", Tribuna Economică, No.47

Puwak H. (1993): "The shadow economy - theoretical, methodological and empirical approaches", Romanian National

Pyatt G. (1988): "A SAM Approach to Modelling", Journal of Policy Modelling, Vol.10, No.3

Pyatt G., Round J. (1985): "Social accounting matrices, A basis for planning", World Bank

Pyle D. J. (1989): "Tax evasion and the black economy", The Macmillan Press LTD

Ràdulescu S.M. (1993): "Fenomenul de corupţie ca tip de inovaţie socială în contextul stării anomice care caracterizează tranziţia în România", Sociologia românească, Serie nouă, Anul IV, No.4

Rădulescu - Motru C. (1907): "Puterea sufletească", Editura Moldova, laşi, 1995

Rădulescu - Motru C. (1910): "Sufletul neamului nostru - Calităţi bune şi defecte", Editura Anima, Bucureşti, 1990

Revised system of national accounts (1990), United Nations, New York

Roubaud F., SeruzierM. (1991): "Economie non-enregistrée par la statistique et secteur informal dans les pays en développement", STATECO, No.68, INSEE

Ruggles R., Ruggles N.D. (1985): "The integration of macro and micro data for the household sector", The 19th General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Noordwijkerhout, Netherlands, August

Sachs J.D., Larrain F.B. (1993): "Macroeconomics in the global economy", Printince Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey

Scarf H.E., Shoven J.B. (edit.) (1984): "Applied General Equilibrium Analysis", Cambridge University Press

Seel B., Hufnagel R. (1992): "Intra-household division of labour and the female labour supply", The 22nd General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Flims, Switzerland, August-September

ShleiferA. (1994): "Establishing property rights", The World Bank

Sims C.A. (1996): "Macroeconomics and methodology", Journal of economic perspective, Vol.10, No.1

Smith S.(1986): "Britain's shadow economy", Clarendon Press Oxford

Stern N. (1996): "The transition in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union: some strategic lessons from the experience of 25 countries over 6 years", OECDICCET Colloquim, Paris

Stiglitz J. E. (1994): "Whither Socialism?", The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts

Suwa A. (1991): "Les modeles d'équilibre général calculable", Economie et Prévision, Nr.97

Takayama, A. (1991): "Mathematical economics", Cambridge University Press

Tanzi V. (1983): "The underground economy in the United States: annual estimates, 1930-1980, IMF - Staff Papers, 30 (2)

Târhoacă C. (1995): "Perfecţionarea metodologiei de elaborare a balanţei legăturilor dintre ramuri şi de utilizare a ei în procesul conducerii economico-sociale", Teză de doctorat, ASE, Facultatea de Cibernetică, Statistică şi Informatică Economică

Theil H. (1971): "Principles of econometrics", New York, John Wiley

TraimondP. (1994): "La comptabilité nationale et l'économie non officielle russe", Université Paris 1 Pantheon Sorbone (Laboratoire d'économie sociale), INSEE, Paris

Transformation in Central and Eastern Europe (1993), British Review of Economic Issues, October

Valencia M., Klopf P., "Grey expectations", Business Central Europe, Volume 2, No.8

Vulcànescu M. (1940 - 1944): "Dimensiunea românească a existenţei", Editura Fundaţiei Culturale Române, 1991, Bucureşti

Willett T. D., Burdekin R. C. K., Sweeney R.J., Wihlborg C. (edit.) (1995): "Establishing monetary stability in emerging market economies", Westview Press

Willianson O.E. (1985): "The economic institutions of capitalism: firms, markets, relational contracting", The free press, a division of Macmillan, New York

Wolff E.M. (1981): "The size distribution of household disposable wealth in the United States", The 17th General conference of the International Association for Research in Income and Wealth, Gouvreieux, France, August

Zamfir C. (coordonator) (1995): "Dimensiuni ale sărăciei", Editura Expert, Bucureşti