Economic Instruments For Improved Water Resources Management In Egypt

McCauley, David and Anderson, Robert and Bowen, Richard and Elassiouty, Ibrahim and Mahdy, Elsayed and Soliman, Ibrahim (2002): Economic Instruments For Improved Water Resources Management In Egypt. Published in: Final Report of the Research Project (UNDER Water Policy Program, USAID, Cairo , Vol. 1, No. USAID-Cairo, Research Report No. PCE-I-00-96-00002-00 (30 April 2002): pp. 1-173.

Abstract

Egypt seems to be on the brink of a new era in water management. The country suppose to follow a different operational mode that is “water conservation oriented, decentralized, environmentally sensitive, private sector oriented, equitable and operationally efficient” The focus of this study was on market-based instruments (MBI’s) as complements to traditional command and control measures for managing water quantity and quality. Prior to evaluating potential water MBIs, it was necessary to identify the water management problems and challenges that need to be addressed through policy adjustments. These challenges were threat of water shortages, service delivery in municipal water supply, lake Nasser pollution, Irrigation service delivery challenges, Nile River pollution above Cairo, Insufficient irrigation system upkeep, water pollution in the Nile Delta, Pollution of lakes , low user contribution to irrigation system upkeep, groundwater contamination, and Weak attention to in-stream flows. Such challenges have impacts on: (1) Nonrenewable groundwater management, (2) Adverse effects on human health, (3) Subsidies affecting water use efficiency, (4) Reduced agricultural productivity, (5) Rainfall capture and flash flood protection. The impacts generated some Threats to aquatic ecosystems, particularly, Negative consequences of rising water tables and Negative impacts on aesthetics (incl. tourism) A two-step screening process was developed and utilized to evaluate the likely success of alternative market-based policy instruments in response to one or more of water management challenges. The instruments were screened based on economic efficiency and equity and other economic factors relating to the nature of the instrument itself. They also were evaluated based on criteria that considered the specific social, cultural, political, and institutional context in which the instrument will be applied. Thereon, the study explored the applicability of economic instruments to help address Egypt’s current water management challenges. It resulted in an initial evaluation of twenty instruments that seemed most promising. Screening criteria were developed and applied to assess the merits of each, and direction also was received from nearly 60 participants who attended the study’s concluding Workshop on Economic Incentives for Water. The most promising policy instruments that concluded from the study were: Woith respect to the water quantity management deemed of highest priority for follow-up analysis and possible policy action were: Groundwater Extraction Charges, Tariff Reductions for Imported Water Meters and Water Conserving Equipment, Several other measures were identified as warranting careful further analysis. These include area-based irrigation service charges; volumetric water delivery charges for large agricultural enterprises; and increased user fees for the supply of urban and industrial water services. Likewise, the most promising policy measures identified to address water quality problems were: Increased User Fees for Wastewater Treatment, Increased Subsidies to Finance Wastewater Treatment Facilities, Subsidized Rural Sanitation, and Subsidized Pollution Control Equipment To achieve such model four approaches to positive change have been identified. These include Creating incentives and disincentives for water management to protect its quality. In addition to Institutionalizing the role private participation; environmental protection and identifying mechanisms to ensure appropriate benefits for participating private sector partners, decentralizing decision making, institutionalizing environmental protection, changing the role of government and improving personnel policies at macro-level decision making regarding uses of the Nile River, and improving awareness of water resources and associated environmental issues.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Water management institutions and policies, Principal water management challenges , Evaluating alternative policy instruments
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q3 - Nonrenewable Resources and Conservation > Q32 - Exhaustible Resources and Economic Development; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q3 - Nonrenewable Resources and Conservation > Q34 - Natural Resources and Domestic and International Conflicts; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q3 - Nonrenewable Resources and Conservation > Q38 - Government Policy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q53 - Air Pollution ; Water Pollution ; Noise ; Hazardous Waste ; Solid Waste ; Recycling

References

Abu-Zeid, Mahmoud, 2001 “Water Pricing in Irrigated Agriculture”, Water Resources Development, Vol. 17, No. 4, pp. 527-538

APRP Water Policy Program, 1998 “Egypt’s Irrigation Improvement Program”, Report No. 7, Cairo, Egypt

APRP Water Policy Program, 1999a “Free-Flowing Groundwater Management in the Western Desert” Report No. 16 Main Document, Cairo, Egypt

APRP Water Policy Program, 1999b “Establishment of Branch Canal Water User Associations in the Egyptian Irrigation System”, Report No. 17, Main Document, Cairo, Egypt

APRP Water Policy Program, 2001 “MWRI Policy on Irrigation Management Transfer| Report No. 47 Main Document.

ARD Raise, 2000 “An Assessment of the Agricultural Policy Reform Project in Egypt” ARD Raise Report to USAID/Egypt.

Boland, John, and Dale Whittington, 2000 “The Political Economy of Water Tariff Design in Developing Countries: Increasing Block Tariffs versus Uniform Price with Rebate” Chapter 10 in the Political Economic of Water Pricing Reforms, World Bank, 2000. Edited by Ariel Dinar, Oxford University Press

Bowen, Richard L. 1982. “Allocation Efficiency and Equity in Charging for Irrigation Water: A Case Study in Egypt” PhD Dissertation, Department of Economics, Colorado State University

Cestti, Rita E, 1995 “Strengthening Irrigation Management in Egypt: A Program for the Future”, International Irrigation Management Institute in cooperation with APRP Water Policy Program 68 on Economic Incentives for Water Management, Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources and the US Agency for International Development, Cairo

Chemonics International, 1999 “Proposed Framework for Water/Wastewater Sector Reform in Egypt” under the Legal, Institutional and Regulatory Reform of the Egyptian Water and Wastewater Sector Project, Cairo

COWI Consult, 1995 “Inception Report: Economic Instruments Study in Egypt”, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and DANIDA, Cairo.

EEAA, 2001 “The National Environmental Action Plan of Egypt 2002/17 (draft version dated October 22, 2001)”, Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency, Cairo, Egypt

Elassiouty, Ibrahim M. 1984 “Pricing of Irrigation Water in Egypt” Final Report. Supreme Council of Universities

El-Zanaty and Associates, 1998 “Knowledge, Attitudes and Practices of Egyptian Farmers toward Water Resources: A National Survey”, Green Com Egypt III of the Water Policy Reform Program in Collaboration with the Water Communication Unit, Agricultural Policy Reform Project, USAID/MWRI Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources: Cairo.

Emam, E. and Ibrahim, K., 1996 “Minimum Nile Drainage Needs for Sustainable Estuarine Ecosystem,” National Water Research Center, Cairo EPIQ/PSU, 2001 “Environmental Economic Instruments Strategy Report: The Nature and Role of Economic Instruments”, (Chapter 2–Draft), EPIQ/PSU/USAID: Cairo. Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency and World Bank ERM Economics, 1997 “Economic Instruments to Improve the Environmental Performance of Key Polluting Industries in Egypt”, 6th October City”, Scoping Report, Cairo

Government of India, 1992 “Report of the Committee on Pricing of Irrigation Water, Planning Commission, New Delhi, India

Hazzell, Peter, N. Perez, G. Siam and Ibrahim Soliman, 1995 “Impact of the Structural Adjustment Program on Agricultural Production and Resource Use in Egypt”, EPTD Paper No. 10, Environment and Production Division, International Food Policy Research Institute Wash. D.C. USA

Hoehn, John P. and Douglas J. Krieger, 1996 “Economic Benefit Assessment, APRP Water Policy Program 69, Economic Incentives for Water Management I: Main Report”, Environmental Policy and Training Project (EPAT). Midwest Universities Consortium for International Activities (MUCIA), Michigan State University

Hussein Elwan, 1998 “Environmental Resources and ERM, Economic Instruments for Industrial Pollution Control in Egypt: Policy Findings and Recommendations”, (Final Report), Irrigation Sector MWRI, Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency and World Bank.

International Irrigation Management Institute 2001 Egyptian Environmental Policy Program (EEPP), Policy Support Unit “The Nature and Role of Economic Instruments in Environmental Economic Instruments for Egypt”, Egyptian Environmental Policy Program (EEPP), Policy Support Unit , Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency and World Bank, Cairo

International Irrigation Management Institute, 1995. Irrigation Service Cost Recovery in Egypt”, Proceeding of a Workshop Held at the International Irrigation Management Institute in cooperation with Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources and the US Agency for International Development, Cairo

Egyptian Environmental Policy Program (EEPP), Policy Support Unit, 1995 “A National Water Services Cost Sharing Program: Proposed Mechanisms and Phasing for Implementation”, in cooperation with Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources and the US Agency for International Development, Cairo.

USDA, US Agency for International Development in Cairo, ISPAN, 1993 “Irrigation Support Project for Asia and the Near East Irrigation Water Cost Recovery in Egypt: Determination of Water Costs, “, Cairo, Egypt

USDA, US Agency for International Development, 1994, “Irrigation Water Cost Recovery in Egypt: Determination of Water Costs: Tradable Water Rights: Experiences in Reforming Water Allocation Policy”, Washington, USA

Kelly, R. A and James Welsh, 1992 “Egypt Water Quality Management Action Plan– Phase II, Project in Development and the Environment, US Agency for International Development, Near East Bureau, Cairo, Egypt

Khouzam, Raouf, 1995 “Future Municipal and Industrial Water Use Projection for 2025, National Water Resources Plan for Egypt: Water Quality and Pollution Control” , National Water Research Center, EPAT/Winrock International Water Resources Strategic Research Publication Series No. 17-4.

Mahdy, El-Sayed,.1998 "Pattern Changes in the Economic Value of Irrigation Water During the Era of Agricultural Policies Reform 1986-1996" Egyptian Journal of Agricultural Economics, Egyptian Association of Agricultural Economics, Vol., 8, No. 2

Mahmoud, Abdou Mabrouk, Hossam El Refaay and Mohammed, Hindawy, 1994 "Nile Water Quality Management in Egypt” Environmental Management Course, American University in Cairo, APRP Water Policy Program 70 Economic Incentives for Water Management McCauley, David, 2000 “Exploring the Potential for Application of Economic Instruments to Improved Water Management in Egypt”, EPIQ/WPRP

Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1995a “An Action Plan for Strengthening Water Resource Management in Egypt”, International Irrigation Management Institute, International Irrigation Management Institute, Strengthening Irrigation Management in Egypt, Report No. 3.

Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1995b “Water Resources, Irrigation Operations and Institutional Issues” Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, Government of Egypt, International Irrigation Management Institute, Strengthening Irrigation Management in Egypt Report No. 2.

Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1996a, ”National Level Strategies and Policies for Utilizing Egypt’s Water Resources”, Water Resources Strategic Research Activity Publication Series No. 1. Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1996b “Agricultural use and Management of Low Quality Water: Sewage Effluents” (Part I), National Water Resources Plan for Egypt: Water Quality and Pollution Control, National Water Research Center, Winrock International, Water Resources Strategic Research Publication Series No. 17

Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1996c “Municipal and Industrial Wastewater: Reuse Potentiality” National Water Resources Plan for Egypt: Water Quality and Pollution Control, National Water Research Center, Winrock International Water Resources Strategic Research Publication Series No. 15

Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1997 “Review of Egypt’s Water Policies, Water Resources Planning” Working Paper INS02: Cairo

Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources, 1998 “Southern Egypt Development Project of Water Resources”, National Water Research Center: Cairo

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 1998 “National Policy for Drainage Water Reuse”, EPIQ Water Policy Program Report No. 8

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 1999a, “Revision of Law 48 of 1982 for the Protection of the Nile River and its Waterways from Pollution”, Tranche III Water Benchmark C8 Report, EPIQ Water Policy Program Report No. 21

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 1999b “Revision of Law 48 of 1982 for the Protection of the Nile River and its Waterways from Pollution: Appendices” Tranche III Water Benchmark C8 Report, EPIQ Water Policy Program Report No. 21, APRP Water Policy, Program 71 Economic Incentives for Water Management

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 2000a “North Sinai Development Project” North Sinai Development Organization, Cairo, Egypt

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 2000b “National Water Resources Plan for Egypt: Water Quality and Pollution Control”, Delft Hydraulics NWRP Technical Report No. 5

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 2000c “Policies and Procedures for Improved Urban Wastewater Discharge and Reuse”, PIQ Water Policy Program Report No. 34

Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, 2001 “Strengthening of the Water Quality Unit within the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation”, Advisory Panel Project on Water Management and Drainage Project Document, Cairo, Egypt

Mohi-Al din, Mohamed, M., 1995 “The Land Tax System in Egypt: A Descriptive Report of Its Historical, Legal and Organizational Aspects” International Irrigation Management Institute in cooperation with Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources and US Agency for International Development, Cairo, Egypt

Mollinga, Peter (ed.), 1998 “Water Control in Egypt’s Canal Irrigation: A Discussion of Institutional Issues at Different Levels”, Wageningen Agricultural University, Liquid Gold Paper No. 3

O’mera, Gerald, Ibrahim Soliman, Emad El Hawary and Samir Mostafa, 1994 “The Cotton Supply Response: Agronomic and Economic Factors Affecting Cotton Production in Egypt”, APCP/USAID PROJECT NO. 263-0202, PBDAC and Chemonics International

Perry, C.J., 1995 “Egypt: Water Services Charges to Agriculture”, International Irrigation Management Institute in cooperation with Ministry of Public Works and Water Resources and US Agency for International Development, Cairo

Perry, C.J., Michael Rock, and D. Seckler, 1997 “Water as an Economic Good: A Solution, or a Problem?” Research Report 14, International Irrigation Management Institute

Perry, C.J. 2001, “Charging for Irrigation Water: The Issues and Options with a Case Study from Iran” Research Report 52, International Water Management Institute. APRP Water Policy Program 72 Economic Incentives for Water Management

Seckler, David, UpaliAmarasinghe, David, Molden, Radhika de Silva and Randolph Barker, 1998 “World Water Demand and Supply, 2000-2025”, International Water Management Institute (IWMI), Research Report 19

Soliman, Ibrahim, Mahdy, El Sayed and Gaber, M., 1992 “Major Constraints of Water Management in El Fayoum Governorate” Egyptian Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 2, No.2, Agricultural Club Dokki, Cairo

Soliman, Ibrahim, Megahed, M., 1998 “Factors Affecting Fuel Consumption Efficiency of Agricultural Tractor in Egypt” the Egyptian Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 8, No. 1, Page: 73-82

Soliman, Ibrahim, Gaber, M., and Ibrahim, A., 1994 “Socio-Economic Impacts of Application of Non-Conventional Mechanization for Wheat Crop: A case Study in Kafr Al Sheikh providence” Minia J. Agric. Res. & Vol. 16, No. 3, P: 958-980

Soliman, Ibrahim, Gaber, M. and Ibrahim, A., 1994 “Socio-Economic Impacts of the Bio-mechanical Technological Package Applied for Sugar Cane Development: A case Study in Minia Governorate” 5th Conf. Agric. Dev. Res., Fac. Agric., Ain Shams Univ., Cairo, Egypt. Page: 1-22

Soliman, Ibrahim Gad, O., and Gaber, M., 1997 “Wheat Marketing Performance under Free Market System” Egyptian Journal of Agricultural economics, Vol.7, No.2 Stavins, R.N. 2000 “Experience With Market-Based Environmental Policy Instruments” Paper No. 00-09, Resources for the Future, Wash. D.C

US Agency for International Development/Egypt, 2000, “USAID/Egypt Strategic Plan FY 2000–2009: Advancing the Partnership”, USAID: Cairo

Water Research Center and Winrock International (WRC/WI) 1992 "Roundtable on Egyptian Water Policy", Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation, Cairo, Egypt

World Bank, 2000 “Water Pricing Experiences: An International Perspective” Edited by Ariel Dinar and Ashok Subramanian, Technical Report No. 386

World Bank, 2000 “The Political Economy of Water Pricing Reforms” Edited by Ariel Dinar. Oxford University Press

WPWWR, 1995 “Irrigation Service Cost Recovery in Egypt” Report on a Workshop. 24-27 May, 1995 Alexandria, Egypt

WPWWR/USAID, 1995 “National Water Services Cost Sharing Program: Proposed Mechanisms and Phasing for Implementation” Report Number APRP Water Policy Program 73 Economic Incentives for Water Management