Trade and agricultural policies in Malawi: Not all policy reform is equally good for the poor

Douillet, Mathilde (2012): Trade and agricultural policies in Malawi: Not all policy reform is equally good for the poor.

Abstract

The reduction of the existing global distortions to agricultural incentives is sometimes stated as a priority to fight poverty worldwide. But the impacts of global trade policy and domestic development policy reforms are rarely, if ever, compared. Despite technical limitations hindering rigorous comparison of the overall growth effects, also hampering cost-benefit analysis, this paper contributes at filling this gap by focusing on the comparison of the distributional poverty impacts of both types of policies. It uses the MIRAGE global computable general equilibrium –CGE- model feeding a national CGE model representing Malawi in 2007 linked to household survey to examine how different trade policy reforms by Malawi and the rest of the world would impact poverty in Malawi. The country’s recent agricultural growth history due to the Fertilizer Input Subsidy Program is replicated and compared with a more broad-based sectoral approach. The effects of accelerating growth in agriculture and downstream sectors are compared with those of integrating in the regional and multilateral markets. Non preferential trade policy reforms are found to be less favourable for poverty reduction of the poorest than regional integration or preferential integration. Faster intensification and diversification of agriculture is found to enable targeting the poorest that are less likely to be connected to international markets. Therefore, while policy reforms generating growth in general may be good for some poors, it is found that that not all policy reforms are equally good. Thus, despite the fact that trade policies could help fight poverty in Malawi, there are no substitute to development policies, and if undertaken simultaneously, their coherence should be checked thoroughly.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Malawi, Economic Growth, Trade policy, Agricultural Policy, Poverty, Computable General Equilibrium
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies > O55 - Africa; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q17 - Agriculture in International Trade; D - Microeconomics > D5 - General Equilibrium and Disequilibrium > D58 - Computable and Other Applied General Equilibrium Models; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy

References

ANDERSON K., COCKBURN J. and MARTIN W. (eds) 2010. Agricultural Distortions, Inequality and Poverty. Washington, DC, The World Bank

ANDERSON K., W. MARTIN, and D. VAN DER MENSBRUGGHE. 2006. “Would Multilateral Trade Reform Benefit Sub-Saharan Africans?”. Journal of African Economies 15(4): 626-670.

ANDERSON K., and E. VALENZUELA. 2008. “Estimates of Global Distortions to Agricultural Incentives, 1955–2007.” Data spreadsheet, October, World Bank, Washington, DC. http://go.worldbank.org/

ANDERSON K., MASTERS W., 2009. Distortions to Agricultural Incentives in Africa. Washington, DC: WORLD BANK.

BENIN S., THURLOW J., DIAO X., McCOOL C. and SIMTOWE F. 2008. Agricultural Growth and Investment Options for Poverty Reduction in Malawi. IFPRI Discussion Paper 794. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

BHORAT H., HANIVAL R., KANBUR R., 2006. “Poverty, Trade and Growth in Africa” Journal of African Economies, 15(4): 505-509

HARRISON A., J. MCLAREN, and M. S. MCMILLAN. 2010. Recent Findings on Trade and Inequality. NBER Working Paper no. 16425. Cambridge: National Bureau of Economic Research.

BOUET A., LABORDE D., DIENESCH E. and ELLIOTT K. 2010. The Costs and Benefits of Duty-Free, Quota-Free Market Access for Poor Countries: Who and What Matters? CATT WP No. 11. Pau : Centre d'analyse théorique et de traitement des données économiques de l’Université de Pays et des Pays de l’Adour.

BOUET A., and D. LABORDE. 2010. “Eight Years of Doha Trade Talks: Where Do We Stand?” Estey Centre Journal of International Law and Trade Policy 11 (2): 349–370.

BOUET A., C. ESTRADES and D. LABORDE. 2011. “Households heterogeneity in a global CGE Model: an illustration with the MIRAGE poverty module”, Paper presented at 14th Annual Conference on Global Economic Analysis, Venice, Italy. 2011.

BOURGUIGNON F., M. BUSSOLO, and J. COCKBURN. 2010. “Macro-Micro Analytics: Background, Motivation, Advantages and Remaining Challenges, Guest Editorial.” International Journal of Microsimulation 3 (1): 1–7.

BUFFIE, E.F. and M. ATOLIA. 2009. Agricultural Input Subsidies in Malawi. Good, Bad or Hard to Tell? FAO Commodity and Trade Policy Research Working Paper No. 28. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization.

CARRERE C., and de MELO J. 2010. “The Doha Round and Market Access for Least Developed Countries: Scenarios for the EU and US Markets.” Journal of World Trade 44 (1): 251–290.

CHIRWA, E. W., DORWARD A. and MATITA M. 2011. Conceptualizing Graduation from Agricultural Input Subsidies in Malawi. FAC SP Working Paper, Institute of Development Studies: Brighton, UK

CHISINGA B. 2012. The future of the Farm inp^çut Subsidy Programme (FISP): A political economy investigation. Lilongwe: Civil Society Network on Agriculture (CISANET)

CHALIRA B. 2007. Aid for Trade from Malawi’s perspective”. Policy Analysis Working Paper N°2. Lilongwe: Ministry of Indsutry, Trade and Private Sector Development.

CLING J.-P., MAROUANI M. A., RAZAFINDRAKOTO M., ROBILLIARD A.-S. and ROUBAUD F., 2009. "The Distributive Impact of Vietnam's Accession to the WTO," Economie Internationale, CEPII research center, 2Q: 43-71.

de JANVRY A., and SADOULET E. 2010. “Agriculture for Development in Africa: Business-as-Usual or New Departures?” Journal of African Economics 19 (S2): S7–S39.

DECREUX Y., and VALIN H. 2007. MIRAGE, Updated Version of the Model for Trade Policy Analysis: Focus on Agriculture and Dynamics. CEPII Working Paper, no. 2007-15. Paris : Centre d'Études Prospectives et d'Informations Internationales.

DEVEREUX S. 2007. The Impact of Droughts and Floods on Food Security and Policy Options to Alleviate Negative Effects. Agricultural Economics 37 (s1): 47-58.

DIAO X., and P. DOROSH 2007. “Demand Constraints on Agricultural Growth in East and Southern Africa: A General Equilibrium Analysis” Development Policy Review, 25 (3): 275-292

DIAO X., S. ROBINSON, M. THOMAS, and P. WOBST. 2002. Assessing the Impacts of Declines in the World Price of Tobacco on China, Malawi,Turkey and Zimbabwe. TMD Discussion Paper 91. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

DIMARANAN, B. V. 2006. Global trade, assistance and production: The GTAP 6 database: Center for global trade analysis, Purdue university.

DORWARD, A. POULTON, C., MORRISON, J. and H TCHALE. 2004. Disaggregated Impacts of Agricultural Policy Reform on Poor Rural Households: Linking Household, Rural Economy and Economy-wide Analysis. In: OECD Global Forum on Agriculture: Designing and Implementing Prop-Poor Agricultural Policies. (Unpublished)

DORWARD A. and E. CHIRWA. 2011. “The Malawi agricultural input subsidy programme: 2005/06 to 2008/09” International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability 9(1): 232-247

DOUILLET M. 2011. Which trade integration scheme can best help SSA develop and export more processed agricultural goods? IFPRI Discussion Paper 1119. Washington DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

DOUILLET M, PAUW K., 2012. Trade Integration in Sub-Saharan Africa: Lessons for Malawian Trade Policy. MaSSP n°10. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

DOUILLET M., PAUW K. and J. THURLOW. 2012. A Social Accounting Matrix for Malawi in 2007. Washington DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

DORWARD, A. POULTON, C., MORRISON, J. and H TCHALE. 2004. Disaggregated Impacts of Agricultural Policy Reform on Poor Rural Households: Linking Household, Rural Economy and Economy-wide Analysis. In: OECD Global Forum on Agriculture: Designing and Implementing Prop-Poor Agricultural Policies. (Unpublished)

DORWARD A. and E. CHIRWA. 2011. “The Malawi agricultural input subsidy programme: 2005/06 to 2008/09” International Journal of Agricultural Sustainability 9(1): 232-247

ECKER O., BREISINGER C. and PAUW K., 2011. Growth is good, but not enough to improve nutrition. IFPRI 2020 Conference Paper No. 7. Washington D.C.: International Food Policy Research Institute.

ECKER O., and M. QAIM. 2011. Analyzing Nutritional Impacts of. Policies: An Empirical Study for Malawi. World. Development, Vol. 39, No. 3, pp. 412-428. GERARD F., and PIKETTY M. G. 2008. Trade Liberalization on Poverty: Sensitivity of Results to Factors Mobility Among Sectors. Working Paper Moisa no. 5/2008. Montpellier : Centre de coopération internationale en recherche agronomique pour le développement.

HERTEL T. W., and WINTERS L. A. eds. 2006. Poverty and the WTO: Impacts of the Doha Development Agenda. London: Palgrave Macmillan; Washington, DC: WORLD BANK.

HORRIDGE M. and ZHAI F. 2006. “Shocking a Single-Country CGE Model with Export Prices and Quantities from a Global Model.” In Poverty and the WTO: Impacts of the Doha DevelopmentAgenda, ed. T. W. HERTEL and L. A. WINTERS, 94–104. London: Palgrave Macmillan; Washington, DC: WORLD BANK.

FRANCOIS, J. F., and W. MARTIN. 2007. “Great Expectations: Ex Ante Assessments of the Welfare Impacts of Trade Reforms.” Unpublished report, January, Erasmus University, Rotterdam.

JONES, C., O. MORRISSEY, and D. NELSON. 2011. "Did the World Bank Drive Tariff Reforms in Eastern Africa?" World Development, vol. 39(3): 324-335.

KING R. P. and BYERLEE D. (1978) “Factor intensity and locational impacts of rural consumption patterns in Sierra Leone”. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 60 (2), 197-206.

KRUEGER A. O., 1990, “Government Failures in Development” The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 4(3): 9-23

LOFGREN H. 2001. A CGE model for Malawi: Technical documentation. IFPRI Discussion Paper 70. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

LOW P., PIERMARTINI R. and RICHTERING J., 2005 Multilateral Solutions to the Erosion of Non-Reciprocal Preferences in NAMA. WTO Economic Research and Statistics Division Staff Working Paper. Geneva: World Trade Organization.

MINOT N. and BENSON T. 2009. Fertilizer subsidies in Africa, Are Vouchers the Answer?, IFPRI Issue Brief 60, July 2009. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

MEPD (Ministry of Economic Planning and Development), 2006. Malawi Growth and Development Strategy: from poverty to prosperity, 2006-2011. Lilongwe: Ministry of Economic Planning and Development, Government of Malawi.

MOAFS (Ministry of Agriculture & Food Security). 2010a. National Crop Estimates 2009/10. Ministry of Agriculture & Food Security, Governmentof Malawi.

MOAFS (Ministry of Agriculture & Food Security). 2010b. The Agriculture Sector Wide Approach (ASWAp) Malawi’s prioritised and harmonised Agricultural Development Agenda. Lilongwe: Ministry of Agriculture & Food Security, Governmentof Malawi.

MODPC (Ministry of Development Planning & Cooperation). 2009. The Malawi Growth and Development Strategy Annual Review 2009. Lilongwe: Ministry of Development Planning & Cooperation. Malawi: Government of Malawi.

MUSSA R. and K. PAUW. 2011. Poverty in Malawi: Current status and knowledge gaps. MaSSP n°9. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

MVAC (Malawi National Vulnerability Assessment Committee). 2005. Malawi Baseline Livelihood Profiles, Version 1. in collaboration with the SADC FANR Vulnerability Assessment Committee. Lilongwe: Ministry of Economic Planning and Development, Government of Malawi.

NKC. 2010. The Role of Burley Tobacco in Selected African Economies and the Expected Impact of a Decline in the Crop’s Production: Assessing Direct and Indirect Effects of Reducing Demand from Cigarette Manufacturers for Burley Produced in Five African Economies. Report prepared by NKC Independent Economists, Malawi.

NSO (National Statistical Office). 2005. Malawi 2004-05 Integrated Household Survey. Zomba: National Statistical Office, Government of Malawi.

NSO (National Statistical Office). 2010. National Accounts. Zomba: National Statistical Office, Government of Malawi.

NSO (National Statistical Office) and ICF Macro. 2011. Malawi Demographic and Health Survey 2010. Zomba Malawi, and Calverton, Maryland, USA: NSO and ICF Macro.

PAUW, K. J. THURLOW, and D. VAN SEVENTER. 2010. Droughts and Floods in Malawi. IFPRI Discussion Paper 946. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute.

POULTON, C., TYLER, G., HAZELL, P., DORWARD, A. KYDD, J., and STOCKBRIDGE, M. 2009. All-Africa Review of Experiences with Commercial Agriculture Lessons from Success and Failure. Background Paper for the Competitive Commercial Agriculture in Sub-Saharan Africa (CCAA) Study. Washington DC: WORLD BANK.

RESNICK D. 2012. Two steps forward, one step back: The limits of foreign aid on Malawi’s democratic consolidation. UNU-WIDER Working Paper 2012/28. Helsinki: United Nation University World Institute for Development Economics Research

ROBINSON S., CATTANEO, A. and M. EL-SAID. 2001. “Updating and estimating a social accounting matrix using cross entropy methods”, Economic Systems Research, 13(1), 47-64.

SADOULET E. and de JANVRY A. 1995. Quantitative Development Policy Analysis. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins Univeristy Press.

THURLOW J., DIAO X. and McCOLL C. 2008. A 2004 Social Accounting Matrix for Malawi. Washington D.C.: International Food Policy Research Institute.

THURLOW J. and WOBST P. 2006. "Not All Growth is Equally Good for the Poor: The Case of Zambia," Journal of African Economies, Oxford University Press: 15(4) 603-625

UNCTAD (United Nations Conference on Trade and Development),.2006. Malawi and the multilateral trading system: the impacts of WTO agreements, negotiations and implementations. Geneva: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development.

UNECA (United Nations Economic Commission for Africa). 2010. Assessing Regional Integration in Africa IV: Enhancing Intra-African Trade. Addis Ababa: United Nations Economic Commission for Africa.

VALENZUELA E., D. VAN DER MENSBRUGGHE, and K. ANDERSON. 2009. “General Equilibrium Effects of Price Distortions on Global Markets, Farm Incomes, and Welfare.” In Distortions to Agricultural Incentives: A Global Perspective, 1955–2007, ed. K. ANDERSON, chap. 13. London: Palgrave Macmillan; Washington, DC: WORLD BANK.

WINTERS L. A., McCULLOCH N., and McKAY A. 2004. “Trade Liberalization and Poverty: The Evidence so Far.” Journal of Economic Literature 42(1): 72-115.

WORLD BANK. 2009, Malawi: Country Economic Memorandum – Seizing Opportunities for Growth through Regional Integration and Trade, Vol. 1, Washington, D.C: The WORLD BANK.

WORLD BANK. 2010. World Development Indicators, The World Bank World Bank, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Agriculture and Food Security and Office of the Director of Public Procurement and Central Internal Audit. 2011. Malawi: Poverty Reduction Support Credit, Fertilizer Procurement Review of the 2010/11 Farm Input Subsidy Programme, December 2010-February 2011

WTO (World Trade Organization). 2011. Trade Policy review: Malawi. Geneva: World Trade Organization.