Financialization of the U.S. corporation: what has been lost, and how it can be regained

Lazonick, William (2012): Financialization of the U.S. corporation: what has been lost, and how it can be regained.

Abstract

The employment problems that the United States now faces are largely structural. The structural problem is not, however, as many economists have argued, a labor-market mismatch between the skills that prospective employers want and the skills that potential workers have. Rather the employment problem is rooted in changes in the ways that U.S. corporations employ workers as a result of "rationalization", "marketization", and "globalization". From the early 1980s rationalization, characterized by plant closings, eliminated the jobs of unionized blue-collar workers. From the early 1990s marketization, characterized by the end of a career with one company as an employment norm, placed the job security of middle-aged and older white-collar workers in jeopardy. From the early 2000s globalization, characterized by the movement of employment offshore, left all members of the U.S. labor force, even those with advanced educational credentials and substantial work experience, vulnerable to displacement. Nevertheless, the disappearance of these existing middle-class jobs does not explain why, in a world of technological change, U.S. business corporations have failed to use their substantial profits to invest in new rounds of innovation that can create enough new high value-added jobs to replace those that have been lost. I attribute that organizational failure to the financialization of the U.S. corporation. The most obvious manifestation of financialization is the phenomenon of the stock buyback, with which major U.S. corporations seek to manipulate the market prices of their own shares. For the decade 2001-2010 the companies in the S&P 500 Index expended about $3 trillion on stock repurchases. The prime motivation for stock buybacks is the stock-based pay of the corporate executives who make these allocation decisions. The justification for stock buybacks is the erroneous ideology, inherited from the conventional theory of the market economy, that, for superior economic performance, companies should be run to "maximize shareholder value". In this essay I summarize the damage that this ideology is doing to the U.S. economy, and I lay out a policy agenda for restoring equitable and stable economic growth.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: U.S. economy; employment; financialization; stock buybacks; executive pay; shareholder value; stock-market manipulation; income inequality; equitable and stable economic growth
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D21 - Firm Behavior: Theory; D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D31 - Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L21 - Business Objectives of the Firm; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G35 - Payout Policy; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G38 - Government Policy and Regulation; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J23 - Labor Demand

References

Abowd, John M., George T. Milkovich, and John M. Hannon, 1990, “The Effects of Human Resource Management Decisions on Shareholder Value,” Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 43, Special Issue: 203S-233S.

Abowd, John, John Haltiwanger, Julia Lane, Kevin L. McKinney, and Kristin Sandusky, 2007, “Technology and the Demand for Skill: An Analysis of Within and Between Firm Differences,” NBER Working Paper No. 13043, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Bass, Dina, 2006a, “Ballmer pressured to buy back shares of Microsoft stock,” Seattle Times, May 13.

Bass, Dina, 2006b, “Sagging stock sends Ballmer to Wall Street to quell critics,” Seattle Times, May 30.

Bednarzik, Robert W., 1983, “Layoffs and Permanent Job Losses: Workers’ Traits and Cyclical Patterns,” Monthly Labor Review, September: 3-12.

Bednarzik, Robert W., 2005, “Restructuring Information Technology: Is Offshoring a Concern?” Monthly Labor Review, August 2005, 11-20.

Bishop, Todd, 2004, “Microsoft wants to reduce its cash balance and improve its share price, analyst says; Stock buyback may be in the works,” Seattle Post-Intelligencer, June 16.

Blinder, Alan S., 2007, “How Many U.S. Jobs May be Offshorable?”, CEPS Working Paper No. 142, Princeton University, March.

Block, Fred, 2009, “Swimming Against the Current: The Rise of a Hidden Developmental State in the United States,” Politics & Society, 36, 2:169-206.

Block, Fred, and Matthew Keller, eds., 2011, State of Innovation: The U.S. Government’s Role in Technology Development, Paradigm Publishers.

Borrus, Michael, and John Zysman, 1997, “Wintelism and the Changing Terms of Global Competition: Prototype of the Future?” BRIE Working Paper No. 96B, University of California, Berkeley.

Breznitz, Dan, 2007, Innovation and the State: Political Choice and Strategies for Growth in Israel, Taiwan, and Ireland, Yale University Press.

Broder, John, 2010, “A call to triple U.S. spending on energy research,” New York Times, June 9.

Bronfenbrenner, Kate, and Stephanie Luce, “The Changing Nature of Global Corporate Restructuring: The Impact of Production Shifts on Jobs in the US, China, and Around the Globe,” submitted to the US-China Economic and Security Review Commission, October 14, at http://www.goiam.org/publications/pdfs/cornell_u_mass_report.pdf.

Burgelman, Robert A., 1994, “Fading Memories: A Process Theory of Strategic Exit in Dynamic Environments,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 39, 1: 24-56.

Chambers, John, and Safra Catz, 2010, “The overseas profits elephant in the room; There’s a trillion dollars waiting to be repatriated if tax policy is right,” Wall Street Journal, October 20.

Chandler, Jr., Alfred D., 2001, Inventing the Electronic Century: The Epic Story of the Consumer Electronic and Computer Industries, Free Press.

Chase, Marilyn, 2007, “Amgen cuts mark biotech squeeze,” Wall Street Journal, August 16.

Chesbrough, Henry, 2006, Open Innovation: The New Imperative for Creating and Profiting from Technology, Harvard Business School Press.

Christensen, Clayton M., Stephen P. Kaufman, and Willy C. Shih, 2008, “Innovation Killers: How Financial Tools Destroy Your Capacity to Do New Things,” Harvard Business Review, 86, 1: 98-105.

Congressional Budget Office, 2011, Trends in the Distribution of Household Income between 1979 and 2007, The Congress of the United States, October. Denning, Steve, 2011, “Clayton Christensen: How the pursuit of profits kills innovation,” Forbes, November 18, at http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/18/clayton-christensen-how-pursuit-of-profits-kills-innovation-and-the-us-economy/.

Dharmapala, Dhammika, C. Fritz Foley, and Kristin J. Forbes, 2011, “Watch What I Do, Not What I Say: The Unintended Consequences of the Homeland Investment Act,” Journal of Finance, 64, 3: 753-787.

Dittmar, Amy K., and Robert F. Dittmar, 2004, “Stock Repurchase Waves: An Explanation of the Trends in Aggregate Corporate Payout Policy,” Business School Working Paper, University of Michigan, at http://webuser.bus.umich.edu/adittmar/Stock_Repurchase_Waves.pdf.

Donmoyer, Ryan J., 2009, “Ballmer says tax would move Microsoft jobs offshore,” (update 3), Bloomberg, June 3, at http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aAKluP7yIwJY.

Drucker, Jesse, 2010, “Dodging repatriation tax lets US companies bring profits back home,” Bloomberg, December 29, at http://www.businessweek.com/news/2011-01-05/dodging-repatriation-tax-lets-u-s-companies-bring-home-cash.html

Eberts, Randall W., and Erica L Groshen, 1991, “Is This Really a ‘White-Collar Recession’?” Economic Commentary, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, March 15.

Ellig, Bruce R., 2006, “The Evolution of Executive Pay in the United States,” Compensation & Benefits Review, January/February: 55-61.

Engardio, Pete, Aaron Bernstein, and Manjeet Kripalani, 2003, “The great global job shift”, BusinessWeek, February 3.

Fairlie, Ronald, and Lori Kletzer, 1998, “Jobs Lost, Jobs Regained: An Analysis of Black/White Differences in Job Displacement in the 1980s,” Industrial Relations, 37, 4: 460–477,

Farber, Henry, 2010, “Job Loss and the Decline of Job Security in the United States,” in Katharine G. Abraham, James R. Spletzer, and Michael Harper, eds. Labor in the New Economy, University of Chicago Press: 223-262.

Fox, Justin, 2009, The Myth of the Rational Market: A History of Risk, Reward, and Delusion on Wall Street, Harper.

Fried, Jesse M., 2000, “Insider Signaling and Insider Trading with Repurchase Tender Offers.” University of Chicago Law Review, 67, 2: 421–477.

Fried, Jesse M., 2001, “Open Market Repurchases: Signaling or Market Opportunism?” Theoretical Inquiries in Law, 2, 2: 1–30.

Gardner, Jennifer M., 1994, “The 1990-91 Recession: How Bad Was the Labor Market?”, Monthly Labor Review, June: 3-11.

Garner, C. Alan, 2004, “Offshoring in the Service Sector: Economic Impact and Policy Issues,” Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Third Quarter: 5-37.

Giarratani, Frank, Gene Gruver, and Randall Jackson, 2007, “Clusters, Agglomeration, and Economic Development Potential: Empirical Evidence Based on the Advent of Slab Casting by U.S. Steel Minimills,” Economic Development Quarterly, 21, 2: 148-164.

Gimein, Mark, Eric Dash, Lisa Munoz, and Jessica Sung, 2002, “You bought. They sold. All over corporate America, top execs were cashing in stock even as their companies were tanking. Who was left holding the bag? You,” Fortune, September 2.

Gomory, Ralph, 2009, “Country and Company: Part I – Divergent Goals,” Huffington Post, March 16, at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ralph-gomory/country-and-company-part_b_174875.html.

Hamermesh, Daniel S., 1989, “What Do We Know About Worker Displacement in the U.S.?” Industrial Relations, 28, 1: 51-59.

Harris, Candee S., 1984, “The Magnitude of Job Loss from Plant Closings and the Generation of Replacement Jobs: Some Recent Evidence,” Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 475: 15-27.

Hayes, Robert H., and William J. Abernathy, 1980, “Managing Our Way to Economic Decline,” Harvard Business Review, 85, 7/8:138-149.

Hira, Ron, 2010, “Bridge to Immigration or Cheap Temporary Labor? The H-1B & L-1 Visa Programs Are a Source of Both” EPI Briefing Paper #257, February 17.

Hira, Ron and Anil Hira, 2008, Outsourcing America: The True Cost of Shipping Jobs Overseas and What Can Be Done About It, revised edition, AMACOM.

Hirsch, Michelle, 2011, “$1.4 trillion cash stash could stoke job market,” The Fiscal Times, October 14, 2011, at http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/Articles/2011/10/14/1-Point-4-Trillion-Cash-Stash-Could-Stoke-Job-Market.aspx#page1.

Hopkins, Matt, and William Lazonick, 2011, “There went the sun: Renewable energy needs patient capital,” Huffington Post, September 23, at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-lazonick/there-went-the-sun-renewa_b_978572.html

Houseman, Susan M., 2009, “Measuring Offshore Outsourcing and Offshoring: Problems for Economic Statistics,” Employment Research, 16, 1: 1-3, at http://www.upjohninstitute.org/publications/newsletter/snh_109.pdf.

Hudson, Richard L., 1982, “SEC eases way for repurchase of firms’ stock: Agency assures it won’t file charges of manipulation if certain rules are met,” Wall Street Journal, November 10.

Jensen, J. Bradford, and Lori B. Kletzer, 2005, “Tradable Services: Understanding the Scope and Impact of Services Outsourcing,” Institute for International Economics Working Paper 05-9, September.

Jensen, Michael C., 1986, “Agency Costs of Free Cash Flow, Corporate Finance, and Takeovers,” American Economic Review, 76, 2: 323-329.

Jensen, Michael C., and Kevin J. Murphy, 1990, “Performance Pay and Top Management Incentives,” Journal of Political Economy, 98, 2: 225-264.

Kalafsky, Ronald V., and Alan D. MacPherson, 2002, “The Competitive Characteristics of the U.S. Machine Tool Industry,” Small Business Economics, 19, 4: 355-369.

King, Neil, and Elizabeth Williamson, 2009, “Business fends off tax hit: Obama administration shelves plan to change how U.S. treats overseas profits,” Wall Street Journal, October 13.

Kletzer, Lori G., 1991, “Job Displacement, 1979–1986: How Blacks Fared Relative to Whites,” Monthly Labor Review, 114, 7: 17–25.

Kletzer, Lori, 1998, “Job Displacement,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 12, 1: 115-136.

Lazonick, William, 1988, “Financial Commitment and Economic Performance: Ownership and Control in the American Industrial Corporation,” Business and Economic History, second series, 17, 1988: 115-128.

Lazonick, William, 1990, Competitive Advantage on the Shop Floor, Harvard University Press.

Lazonick, William, 1991, Business Organization and the Myth of the Market Economy, Cambridge University Press.

Lazonick, William, 1992, “Controlling the Market for Corporate Control: The Historical Significance of Managerial Capitalism,” Industrial and Corporate Change, 1, 3: 445-488.

Lazonick, William, 1998, “Organizational Learning and International Competition,” in Jonathan Michie and John Grieve Smith, eds., Globalization, Growth, and Governance, Oxford University Press: 204-238.

Lazonick, William, 2002, “Innovative Enterprise and Historical Transformation,” Enterprise & Society, 3, 1: 35-54.

Lazonick, William, 2008, “Entrepreneurial Ventures and the Developmental State: Lessons from the Advanced Economies,” World Institute of Development Economics Research Discussion Paper dp2008-01, at http://www.wider.unu.edu/publications/working-papers/discussion-papers/2008/en_GB/dp2008-01/_files/78805634425684379/default/dp2008-01.pdf.

Lazonick, William, 2009a, Sustainable Prosperity in the New Economy? Business Organization and High-Tech Employment in the United States, Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Lazonick, William, 2009b, “The Explosion of Executive Pay and the Erosion of American Prosperity,” Entreprises et Histoire, 57, 141-164.

Lazonick, William, 2009c, “The New Economy Business Model and the Crisis of U.S. Capitalism,” Capitalism and Society, 4, 2, Article 4.

Lazonick, William, 2010a, “Innovative Business Models and Varieties of Capitalism,” Business History Review, 84, 4: 675-702.

Lazonick, William, 2010b, “The Chandlerian Corporation and the Theory of Innovative Enterprise,” Industrial and Corporate Change, 19, 2, 317-349.

Lazonick, William, 2011a, “Nine government investments that made us an industrial economic leader,” Huffington Post, September 8, at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-lazonick/nine-government-investmen_b_954185.html

Lazonick, William, 2011b, “The global tax dodgers: Why President Obama and Congress lack job creation plans,” Huffington Post, August 18, at http://www.huffingtonpost.com/william-lazonick/offshore-job-profits_b_930531.html

Lazonick, William, 2011c, “The Innovative Enterprise and the Developmental State: Toward an Economics of ‘Organizational Success’,” paper presented at the Institute for New Economic Thinking Annual Conference, Mount Washington Hotel, Bretton Woods, NH, April 8-11.

Lazonick, William, 2012a, “The Fragility of the U.S. Economy: The Financialized Corporation and the Disappearing Middle Class,” in Dan Breznitz, and John Zysman, eds., National Adjustments to a Changing Global Economy, Oxford University Press, forthcoming.

Lazonick, William, 2012b, “The Theory of Innovative Enterprise: Methodology, Ideology, Institutions,” in Jamee K. Moudud, Cyrus Bina and Patrick L. Mason, eds., Alternative Theories of Competition: Challenges to the Orthodoxy, Routledge: 127-159.

Lazonick, William, and Mariana Mazzucato, 2012, “The Risk-Reward Nexus in the Innovation-Inequality Relationship: Who Takes the Risks? Who Gets the Rewards?”, European Commission Finance, Innovation, and Growth (FINNOV) Project Working Paper Document #: FP7-SSH-2007-1.2.3-217466-FINNOV-D2.11, at http://www.finnov-fp7.eu/sites/default/files/FINNOV_DP2.11.pdf.

Lazonick, William, and Mary O’Sullivan, 2000, “Maximizing Shareholder Value: A New Ideology for Corporate Governance,” Economy and Society, 29, 1: 13-35.

Lazonick, William, and Öner Tulum, 2011, “U.S. Biopharmaceutical Finance and the Sustainability of the U.S. Biotech Business Model,” Research Policy, 40, 9, 2011: 1170-1187.

Louis, Henock, and Hal White, 2007, “Do Managers Intentionally Use Repurchase Tender Offers to Signal Private Information? Evidence from Firm Financial Reporting Behavior,” Journal of Financial Economics, 85, 1: 205-233.

Martin, Roger L., 2011, Fixing the Game: Bubbles, Crashes and What Capitalism Can Learn from the NFL, Harvard Business School Press.

McDougall, Paul, 2009, “IBM offers to move laid off workers to India: Big Blue wants to help redundant U.S. employees relocate to developing markets, according to an internal document,” InformationWeek, February 2.

Microsoft, 2004, “Microsoft outlines quarterly dividend, four-year stock buyback plan, and special dividend to shareholders,” Press release, July 4, at http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2004/jul04/07-20boardPR.mspx.

Microsoft, 2008, “Microsoft announces share repurchase program and increases quarterly dividend,” at http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/press/2008/sep08/09-22dividend.mspx.

National Research Council, 1999, Funding A Revolution: Government Support for Computing Research, National Academies Press.

OECD, 2011, “Growing Income Inequality in OECD Countries: What Drives It and How Can Policy Tackle It?’ OECD Forum on Tackling Income Inequality, Paris, May 2.

O’Sullivan, Mary, 2004, “What Drove the U.S. Stock Market in the Last Century?” INSEAD Working Paper, Fontainebleau, France.

Obama, Barack, 2009, “Remarks by the President on international tax policy reform,” May 4 , at http://www.whitehouse.gov/the_press_office/Remarks-By-The-President-On-International-Tax-Policy-Reform.

Obama, Barack, 2010, “Remarks by the President in State of the Union address,” January 27, at http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/remarks-president-state-union-address.

Okimoto, Daniel I., and Yoshio Nishi, 1994, “R&D Organization in Japanese and American Semiconductor Firms,” in Masahiko Aoki and Ronald Dore, eds., The Japanese Firm: The Sources of Competitive Strength, Oxford University Press: 178-208.

Palmon, Oded, Huey-Lian Sun, Alex P. Tang, 1997, “Layoff Announcements: Stock Market Impact and Financial Performance,” Financial Management, 26, 3: 54-68.

Piketty, Thomas, and Emmanuel Saez, 2012, “Table and Figures Updated to 2010 in Excel Format,” March, formerly available at http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~saez/.

Platzer, Michaela D., and Glennon J. Harrison, 2009, “The U.S. Auto Industry: National State Trends in Manufacturing Employment,” Congressional Record Service Report, 7-5700, August.

Romano, Benjamin J., 2006, “Ballmer defends Microsoft’s spending increase,” Seattle Times, May 1.

Rosen, Jan M., 1991, “New regulations on stock options,” New York Times, April 27.

Schultze, Charles L., 1999, “Downsized & Out: Job Security and American Workers,” Brookings Review, 17, 4: 9-17.

Sharpe, Rochelle, 1993, “Unequal opportunity; Losing ground on the employment front,” Wall Street Journal, September 14.

Stout, Lynn A., 2012, “New Thinking on ‘Shareholder Primacy’,” Accounting, Economics, and Law, 2, 2, Article 4.

Subcommittee on Annual Review, 1982-1983, “Annual Review of Federal Securities Regulation,” The Business Lawyer, 83, May: 1233-1265.

Trincal, Emma, 2008, “Lehman not an easy short story,” HedgeWorld News, June 5.

Uchitelle, Louis, 2007, The Disposable American: Layoffs and their Consequences, Vintage.

UK Department of Health, 2009, The Pharmaceutical Price Regulation Scheme, Tenth Report to Parliament, December.

U.S. Census Bureau, 2011, Current Population Survey, Annual Social and Economic Supplement, Income data, Historical tables, Income inequality at http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/income/data/historical/inequality/index.html

U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, 1983, Statistical Abstract of the United States 1984, 104th edition, U.S. Government Printing Office.

U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census, 1986, Statistical Abstract of the United States 1987, 107th edition, U.S. Government Printing Office.

U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2012, “Union Members – 2011,” News Release USDL-12-0094, January 27.

Vermaelen, Theo, 1981, “Stock Repurchases and Market Signaling,” Journal of Financial Economics, 9, 2: 139-183.

Vermaelen, Theo, 2005. Share Repurchases: Foundations and Trends in Finance, Now Publishers: Hanover, MA.

Wilson, William Julius, 1996-1997, “When Work Disappears,” Political Science Quarterly, 111, 4: 567-595.