"A 'Trojan Horse' in Daoguang China?: Explaining the flows of silver (and opium) in and out of China"

Irigoin, Alejandra (2013): "A 'Trojan Horse' in Daoguang China?: Explaining the flows of silver (and opium) in and out of China". Published in: LSE Economic History Department Working Papers , Vol. 2013, No. 173 (25 January 2013): pp. 1-34.

Abstract

Economic historians have offered several explanations for China’s cycles of silverisation and de-silverisation in the 18th and 19th centuries focusing either on exogenous supply shortages in world silver markets or an outflow of silver as a consequence of opium imports. This paper challenges both existing “supply-side” and “demand-side” explanations. Section two shows that the supply side change was not a decline in the quantity of silver but in the quality of imported silver coins after the 1820s. Section three shows that this led to a decline in demand because China did not perform as a classic bi-metallic system as usually assumed. Because China lacked monetary sovereignty, the Chinese adopted a foreign coin, the Spanish American peso as the preferred means of payment in some areas of southern China, and increasingly further into the interior. Section four presents evidence for the exchange rate premium of the Spanish American silver coin over other coins and, more importantly, over silver sycee in China after the 1790s. This allowed for large-scale arbitrage by means of acquiring silver sycee in China for export, while bringing coined silver to China. Underlying this sort of 'dollarization' in China was opium. Hence section five shows that opium imports did not trigger the outflow of silver. Instead the flight of silver in fact seems to be the cause for large opium imports.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Monetary history of China; bimetallic system; 'dollarization'; silver trade; Opium imports; Daoguang depression
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E42 - Monetary Systems ; Standards ; Regimes ; Government and the Monetary System ; Payment Systems; N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N25 - Asia including Middle East; N - Economic History > N0 - General > N00 - General; N - Economic History > N1 - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics ; Industrial Structure ; Growth ; Fluctuations > N15 - Asia including Middle East

References

Bailey, W & Zhao, B (2009) “Familiarity, Convenience, and Commodity Money: Spanish and Mexican Silver Dollars in Qing and Republican China” http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1424070

Blusse, L. (2011) ’Junks to Java’ E Tragliacozo & Wen Chin-Chang (eds) Chinese Circulations, Capital, Commodities and Networks in Southeast Asia (Durham)

British Parliamentary Papers, (1847) “The Select Committee on Commercial relation with China” (654)

British Parliamentary Papers, (1857-58) “Silver, & c. (China) Copies of correspondence received at the Colonial Office and the Foreign Office upon the subject of the supply of silver in the markets of China”, (287)

Chen, CN (1975), ‘Flexible Bimetallic Exchange rates in China 1650-1850: a historical example of optimal currency areas’ Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 7 (1975)

Chen, CN, Chou, CF and Tsaur, TW (1979), ‘The Flexible Bimetallic Exchange Rate System Revisited’, in C. M. Hou and T. S. Yu (eds.), Modern Chinese Economic History, (Taipei)

Crouzet, F. (1972) ‘Capital Formation in Great Britain during the Industrial Revolution’ ch in Capital formation in the industrial revolution (London)

Feige, C. & Miron, J. (2008). "The opium wars, opium legalization and opium consumption in China," Applied Economics Letters, 15:12, pp 911-913

Finegan, M. (1978), ‘Merchant Activities and Business Practices as revealed by several manuscripts from Fukien’ C’hing shh wen-ti, 3: 9

Flynn, D.O. (1990). "[Review of] Spenders and Hoarders: The World Distribution of Spanish American Silver, 1550-1750". The Journal of Economic History. 50 (3): 721-724.

Gayer, A., Rostow W. & Schwartz, A. (1975) The Growth and fluctuations of the British Economy, (New York)

Grafe, R & Irigoin, A (2006) “The Spanish empire and its legacy. Fiscal redistribution and political conflict in colonial and postcolonial Spanish America”, Journal of Global History, 1 pp 241-267

Hamashita, T. (1984) “Foreign trade finance in China 1810”in L Grove & C Daniels State and Society in China, Japanese perspectives on Ming-Qing Social and Economic History, (Tokyo) pp387-481

Hao, Yen-pʻing. (1986). The commercial revolution in nineteenth-century China: the rise of Sino-Western mercantile capitalism. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Irigoin, A. (2009) “The End of a Silver Standard, the consequence of the breakdown of the Spanish Peso Standard in China and the US, 1780s-1850s” Journal of World History, 20, 2 pp 207-244

Ibid, (2009) “Gresham, on Horseback: The Monetary roots of Spanish American Political Fragmentation in the Nineteenth Century” Economic History Review, 62, 3 pp 551-575

Kann, E. (1927), The Currencies of China. An investigation of silver and gold transactions affecting China. (Shanghai)

Kindleberger, C.P. (1989), Spenders and Hoarders: The World Distribution of Spanish American Silver 1550-1750 (Singapore)

King, F.H. H. (1965). Money and monetary policy in China, 1845-1895.

Kishimoto, M. (1991) “’The Seventy-Percent Cash (Ch’i-che Ch’ien)’ Custom of the Mid-ching Period” The Memories of the Toyo Bunko 49, pp 1-25,

Kuroda, A. (2005) “The Collapse of the Chinese Imperial Monetary System” in K. Sugihara (ed) Japan, China and the Growth of the International Economy, 1850-1914. (Oxford)

Lin, Man-houng (2004) “The Shift from East Asia to the World: The role of Maritime Silver in China’s Economy in the Seventeenth to Late Eighteenth Century” in W. Gungwu & N. Chin-keong,, (2004) Maritime China in Transition 1750-1850, (Wiesbaden) pp 80-81.

Ibid, (2005) “China’s “Dual Economy” in International Trade Relations. 1842-1949” in K. Sugihara (ed) Japan, China and the Growth of the International Economy, 1850-1914. (Oxford)

Ibid. (2006). China upside down: currency, society, and ideologies, 1808-1856. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Asia Center.

Ma, D. (2012) “Money and Monetary System in China in the 19th and 20th Century: An Overview”, LSE Economic History Department Working Paper, #159.

Morse, HB (1908) Trade and Administration of China, (London)

Ibid (1926) Chronicles of the East India Company Trading to China, 1635-1834 (Oxford)

Naquin. S. & Rawski, E.S. (1987), Chinese Society in the Eighteenth Century. (New Haven)

Ohashi, A. (2011). "World Silver flows and the formation of the forced cultivation system in Java: 1800-1840." Nagoya University GSID Discussion Papers #183.

Pomeranz, K. (2000). The great divergence: China, Europe, and the making of the modern world economy. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.

Rowe, WT (2011) “Money, Economy and Polity in the Daoguang era Paper Currency Debates’ Late Imperial China, 31,2 pp 69-96.

Shiromaya, T. (2008) China during the Great Depression. Market, State and the World Economy, 1929-1937, (Cambridge)

Tan Chung, (1974). “The Britain, India Trade Triangle (1771-1840)” Indian Economic Social History Review, 11:1

Trocki, C.A. (1999) Opium, Empire and the Global Political economy: a study of Asian Opium trade 1750-1950 (London)

Vogel, H (1987) ‘Chinese Central Monetary Policy, 1644-1800’ Late Imperial China

Von Glahn, R. (1996). Fountain of fortune money and monetary policy in China, 1000-1700. Berkeley, Calif: University of California Press

Ibid, (1996) ‘Comments on “Arbitrage, China and World trade in the Early Modern Period’ Journal of Economic and Social History of the Orient, 39:3 pp 365-67

Ibid, (2003) ‘ Money Use in China and Changing Patters of Global trade in Monetary Metals, 1500-1800’, in D Flynn, A Giraldez & R Von Glahn, Global Connections and Monetary History, 1470-1800, (Burlington)

Ibid (2007) “Foreign Silver Coins and Markets Culture in Nineteenth Century China” International Journal of Asian Studies, 4 ,1.

Vries, P. (2012), “Public Finance in China and Britain in the Long Eighteenth Century” LSE Economic History Working Paper series # 167

Wells Williams, S. (1863/1966), The Chinese Commercial Guide, (Taipei)

Wolters, WG. (2009) “The use of monies of account in exchange banks: The Amsterdam Exchange Bank, the Hamburg Bank and the Hong Kong and Shanghai Bank, 17th 19th centuries” Presented to the Panel “Revisiting Money As A Unified Unit of Account from a Complementary Viewpoint” WEHC, Utrecht