Abatement costs of alternative tax systems to regulate agricultural nitrogen loss

Christensen, Jan and Hansen, Lars Gårn (2005): Abatement costs of alternative tax systems to regulate agricultural nitrogen loss. Published in: Environmental Economics and Policy Studies , Vol. 7, No. 2 (2005): pp. 53-74.

Abstract

Nitrogen emissions from agriculture are considered an important environmental problem in Denmark motivating consideration of different tax schemes as regulatory instruments. In this paper, input/output behaviour of Danish pig farmers is estimated with farm level panel data using the dual profit function approach, and emission functions for nitrogen loss are derived. With the estimated model we are able to compare cost-effectiveness of a comprehensive Pigouvian tax on nitrogen loss with simpler tax schemes that focus on nitrogen use. We find that both a fertilizer tax and a feed tax generate substantially higher abatement costs than Pigouvian incentives. A tax on nitrogen in all inputs will, on the other hand, only generate a marginal increase in abatement costs. These results are of interest because a tax on all nitrogen inputs is easier to implement than a comprehensive nitrogen loss tax. Our result implies that even a limited administrative cost advantage may make the input tax preferable to implementing Pigouvian incentives through an nitrogen loss tax.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: deposit-refund systems; non-point emissions; nitrogen emissions; agriculture
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies

References

Andersen, J.M., B. Münier, H.G. Bruun, W.A.H. Asman and A.B. Hald, (2000),'Miljø- og naturmæssige konsekvenser af en ændret svineproduction' DMU-rapport NR 311, Dan¬marks Miljøundersøgelser.

Baumol, W.J. and W.E.Oates, (1988), The Theory of Environmental Policy, second edition, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Brouwer, F.M., F.E.Godeschalk, P.J.G.J.Hellegers and H.J. Kelholt (1995), Mineral balances at farm level in the European Union', Report, The Hague, Agricultural Economics Research Institute.

Chambers, R.G. (1988), Applied Production Analysis - A dual approach. Cambridge Univer¬sity Press, Cambridge.

Danmarks Statistik (1999a), Statistiske Efterretninger - Landbrug 1999:1

Danmarks Statistik (1999b), Statistiske Efterretninger - Landbrug 1999:20

Fontein, P.F., G.J. Thijssen, J.R. Magnus, and J. Dijk (1994), 'On Levies to Reduce the Nitrogen Surplus: The Case of Dutch Pig Farms', Environmental and Resource Economics 4(5), 455-478.

Hallam, D. and R. Zanoli, (1993),'Error Correction Models and Agricultural Supply Re¬sponse', European Review of Agricultural Economics, vol. 20, 151-166.

Hansen L.G. (1999), 'A Deposit-Refund System Applied to Non-Point Nitrogen Emissions from Agriculture', Environmental Economics and Policy Studies (2).

Holt¬ermann, S. (1976), 'Alternative Tax Systems to Correct for Externalities, and the Ef¬¬¬¬ficiency of Paying Com¬pen¬¬¬¬sation',Eco¬no¬¬¬mica, vol. 43, 1-16.

Huang,W. and M. LeBlanc (1994),'Market-based Incentives for Addressing Non-Point Water Quality Problems: A Residual Nitrogen Tax Approach', Review of Agricultural Economics, vol. 16, no. 3, 427-440.

Kuiper, K.W. and M.T.G.Meulenberg, (1997), 'Co-integration and prediction analysis of market supply in the Dutch pig-farming industry' , European Review of Agricultural Eco¬nomics Vol. 24, no. 2, 285-312.

Skop, E. And J. Schou (1996) 'Distributing the agricultural farm structure spatially using farm statistics and GIS' in Integrated Environmental and Economic Analyses in Agriculture (A. Walter-Jørgensen and Steen Pilegaard, eds.), SJFI-report nr. 89.

Piot-Lepetit, I. and D. Vermersch (1998), 'Pricing Organic Nitrogen under the Weak Disposability Assumption: an Application to the French Pig Sector' , Journal of Agricultural Economics , vol 49, no. 1, 85-99.

Weaver, R.D., J.K. Harper and W.J. Gillmeister, (1996), ' Efficacy of Standards vs. Incentives for Managing the Environmental Impact of Agriculture', Journal of Environmental Manage¬ment vol. 46, 173-188.