David and Goliath: small banks in an era of consolidation. Evidence from Italy

Bongini, Paola and Di Battista, Maria Luisa and Zavarrone, Emma (2006): David and Goliath: small banks in an era of consolidation. Evidence from Italy.

Abstract

Consolidation in the banking industry has caused concern about the survival of small banks. However, empirical evidence shows that often small banks are performing better than larger banks in terms of loan growth and profitability. This paper addresses the main question of “how David can be successful in a Goliath’s world” analysing two broad sets of issues, tested on a sample of Italian small banks. We first address the question of whether peculiarities of small banks, e.g their ability to lever on relationship lending, are good explanatory variables of their loan growth. Second, we investigate the relationship between loan growth and profitability and credit risk to point out which small banks can continue to be a viable competitor of larger bank.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: University of Milan-Bicocca; Catholic University of Piacenza
• Language: English
• Keywords: Small banks; relationship lending; consolidation
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G34 - Mergers ; Acquisitions ; Restructuring ; Corporate Governance; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets

References

Alessandrini, P., Croci, M., Zazzaro, A., (2005), “The geography of banking power: the role of functional distance”, paper presented at AAG 2005 Conference, Denver, Colorado. Angelini, P., Di Salvo, R., Ferri, G., (1998), “Availability and cost of credit for small businesses: customer relationships and credit cooperatives”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 22: 925-54. Avery R. B., Samolyk K.A., (2004), “Bank consolidation and small business lending: the role of community banks”, Journal of financial services research 25, 291-325 Banca d’Italia, (2004; 2005), Annual Reports, Rome. Banerje A.V., Besley T., Guinnane T.W, (1994), “Thy neighbor’s keeper: the design of a credit cooperative with theory and a test”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 109, 491-515. Basset B., Brady, T., (2002), “What drives the persistent competitiveness of small banks?”, The Federal Reserve Board, Finance and Economics Discussion Series n.28 Berger, A. N., Humphrey D.B., (1997), “Efficiency of Financial institutions: international survey and directions for future research”, European Journal of Operational Research, 98: 175-213. Berger, A. N., Demsetz R.S., Strahan, P.E., (1999), “The consolidation of the financial services industry: causes, consequences and implications for the future”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 23:135-194. Berger, A.N., Miller, N.H Petersen, M.A. Rajan, R.G., J.C. Stein, (2002), “Does Function Follow Organizational Form? Evidence from the Lending Practices of Large and Small Banks”, NBER Working Paper No. W8752. Berger, A.N., Udell G.F., (2002), “Small Business Credit Availability and Relationship Lending: The Importance of Bank Organizational Structure”, The Economic Journal, 112: F32-F53. Berger, A.N., Saunders A. Scalise J.M., Udell, G.F, (1998), “The effects of bank mergers and acquisitions on small business lending”, Journal of financial economics 50,187-229. Besley T., Coate S., (1995), “Group lending, repayment incentives and social collateral”, Journal of development economics 46, 1-18. Bonaccorsi di Patti E., Eramo, G., Gobbi, G., (2005) “Piccole e grandi banche nel mercato del credito in Italia dal 1996 al 2003”, Banca Impresa Società n 1 2005. Bonaccorsi di Patti, E., Gobbi, G., (2001), “The Changing Structure of Local Credit Markets: Are Small Business Special?”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 25: 2209-2237. Boot A. W.A., (2000), “Relationship banking: what do we know?”, Journal of financial intermediation 9, 7-25. Breiman L. F., Olshen, Stone, (1984), Classification and Regression trees, Belmont (CA-USA), Wadsworth International Group, Statistics/probability Series DeYoung, R., Hunter, W.C., (2002), “Deregulation the internet and the competitive viability of large banks and community banks.”, in The future of banking, ed. Benton Gup, Greenwood Press Quorum Books. DeYoung R., Hunter, W.C., Udell, G.F., (2003), “The Past, Present and Probable Future for Community Banks”, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago WP 2003-14. DeYoung, R, Goldberg L G., White, L. J., (1999) “Youth adolescence and maturity at banks: credit availability to small business in an era of bank consolidation”, Journal of banking and finance 23, 463-492. Diamond D. W., (1984), “Financial intermediation and delegated monitoring”, Review of Economic Studies 51, 393-414. Ferri, G., (1997), “Branch manager turnover and lending efficiency: local vs. national banks”, BNL Quarterly Review, Special Issue, March: 229-47. Focarelli D., Panetta F., Salleo C., (2002), “Why do banks merge: some empirical evidence from Italy”, Journal of Money credit and Banking 34, n.4, 1047-1066. Fox, J. (1997), Applied Regression Analysis, Linear Models, and Related Methods, Thousand Oaks: Sage. Gobbi G., Lotti F., (2004), “ L’ingresso nei mercati locali: le strategie delle banche”, Cooperazione di credito 183, 115-135. Goldberg L G.,White L. J., (1998), “The novo banks and lending to small businesses”, Journal of banking and finance 22, 851-867. Hesse, H., Čihák, M. (2007), “Cooperative banks and financial stability”, IMF working paper WP/07/2 Hoff K., Stiglitz J.E., (1990), “Introduction: imperfect information and rural credit markets. Puzzles and policy perspectives”, World bank economic Review 4, 235-250. Keeton W.R., (1995), “Multi-office bank lending to small businesses: some new evidence”, Federal reserve bank of Kansas City Economic Review 80 (“), 45-57. Ongena, S., Smith, D.C., (2000), “Bank relationships: a review”, in T.H. Patrick and S. A. Zenios (eds.), Performance of financial institutions: efficiency, innovation, regulation, 221-258. Panetta F., 2005 (ed), Il sistema bancario italiano negli anni novanta, Bologna il Mulino. Pastré O. , (2001), “Industrie bancaire: les espoirs des Davids face aux Goliaths? », Revue d’Economie financière , 1-10. Petersen, M.A., Rajan R.G., (1995) “The effect of credit market competition on lending relationships”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 110, 407-443. Peek, J. , Rosengren, E.S., (1998), “ Bank consolidation and small business lending: it’s not just bank size that matters”, Journal of Banking and Finance, 22, 799-819. Sapienza P., (2002) “The effects of banking mergers on loan contracts”, The Journal of Finance, 57, n.1, 329-367. Scott, J.A., (2004), “Small business and the value of community financial institutions”, Journal of Financial Services Research 25: 207-30. Stein, J.C., (2002), “Information Production and Capital Allocation: Decentralized versus Hierarchical Firms”, Journal of Finance, 57: 1891-1922. Stiglitz J.E., (1990), “Peer monitoring in credit markets”, World Bank Economic Review 4, 351-366. Sheskin, D.J., (2000), Handbook of Parametric and Nonparametric Statistical Procedures., Boca Raton et. al. : Chapman & Hall