Information Transmission and Vehicle Recalls: The Role and Regulation of Recall Notification Letters

Bae, Yong-Kyun and Benitez-Silva, Hugo (2013): Information Transmission and Vehicle Recalls: The Role and Regulation of Recall Notification Letters.

Abstract

Using data on correction rates for vehicle recalls in the United States from 2007 to 2010, we investigate information transmission from manufacturers to owners regarding the defects of recalled vehicles. We pay special attention to the role of the language manufacturers use to convey each recall's seriousness in the letters they send to owners to explain the nature of the defects in their vehicles, and the possible consequences if the defects are not fixed. We find that recalls linked to riskier defects, defined by the type of equipment affected in the vehicles, are associated with higher correction rates. Interestingly, the content of recall notification letters plays an important role in increasing correction rates because the letters convey information to owners above and beyond baseline information about which part of their vehicles can present problems. We also find that, in a number of cases, the language that manufacturers use to explain the risks to owners are worryingly milder than the descriptions the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) use, resulting in significantly lower correction rates. We conclude that information transmission to owners regarding recalls should be more clearly regulated since the language affects drivers' likelihood of taking their cars to be fixed. We advocate that the NHTSA return to the pre-2001 practice of assigning hazard levels to all recalls, and that the agency consider making sure manufacturers clearly communicate recall rating information to vehicle owners. Our results indicate that these practices would result in higher correction rates, remove faulty cars from the roads, and, consequently, save lives.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Safety Regulation, Vehicle Defects, Automobile Recalls, Transmission of Information, Consumer Behavior
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D01 - Microeconomic Behavior: Underlying Principles; L - Industrial Organization > L5 - Regulation and Industrial Policy > L51 - Economics of Regulation; L - Industrial Organization > L6 - Industry Studies: Manufacturing > L62 - Automobiles ; Other Transportation Equipment ; Related Parts and Equipment

References

[1] Bae, Yong-Kyun and Benitez-Silva, Hugo:“Do Vehicle Recalls Reduce the Number of Accidents? The Case of the U.S. Car Market”, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, Vol 30, No. 4. (2011): 821-862.

[2] Bae, Yong-Kyun and Beniıtez-Silva, Hugo: “The Effects of Automobile Recalls on the Severity of Accidents”, Economic Inquiry, Vol 51:2. (2013): 1232-1250.

[3] Bates, Hillary., Holweb, Matthias, Michael Lewis, Michael, and Oliver, Nick: “Motor vehicle recalls: Trends, patterns and emerging issues.” Omega: International Journal of Management Science, 35(2), (2007): 202-210.

[4] Crafton, Steven M., Hoffer, George E., and Reilly, Robert J.: “Testing the Impact of Recalls on the Demand for Automobiles”, Economic Inquiry. Vol 19:4. (1981): 694-703.

[5] GAO, NHTSA Has Options to Improve the Safety Defect Recall Process, Report to Congressional Requesters, 2011.

[6] Hartman, Raymond S.: “Product Quality and Market Efficiency: The Effect of Product Recalls on Resale Prices and Firm Valuation”, The Review of Economics and Statistics, vol. 69, No. 2. (1987), 367-372.

[7] Hoffer, George E., Pruitt, Stephen W., and Reilly, Robert J: “When Recalls Matter: Factors Affecting Owner Response to Automotive Recalls”, Journal of Consumer Affairs, vol 28:1.(1994): 96-106.

[8] Hoffman, R.: “Effective Recall Notification and Public Awareness,” (2013), Qmed, Qualified Suppliers to the Medical Device Industry.

[9] Huble, Norma F., Arndt, Mark W.: “A Review of Crash Data Analysis in a Defect and Recall Investigation of the General Motors C/K Pickup Trucks.” Accident Analysis and Prevention, 28(1), (1996): 33-42.

[10] Jarrel, Gregg., and Peltzman, Sam: “The Impact of Product Recalls on the Wealth of Sellers.” Journal of Political Economy, vol 93:3. (1985): 512-536.

[11] Keeler, Theodore E.: “Highway Safety, Economic Behavior, and Driving Environment”, American Economic Review, vol. 84, (1994): 684-693.

[12] Kolstad, Charles D., Ulen, Thomas S., and Johnson, Gary V.:“Ex Post Liability for Harm vs. Ex Ante Safety Regulation: Substitutes or Complements?” The American Economic Review, vol. 80, No. 4, (1990): 888-901

[13] Marino, Anthony M.: (1997): “A Model of Product Recalls with Asymmetric Information. Journal of Regulatory Economics,” 12(3), (1997): 245-265.

[14] NHTSA: The Impact of Motor Vehicle Crashes 2000, U.S. Department of Transportation, DOT HS 809 446, 2002.

[15] NHTSA: Traffic Safety Facts, U.S. Department of Transportation, DOT HS 810 818, 2006.

[16] NHTSA: National Automotive Sampling System(NASS), General Estimates System(GES), U.S. Department of Transportation, 1988-2007.

[17] NHTSA: Safety Recall Compendium, Defects and Recall Information Analysis Division, U.S. Department of Transportation, 2001.

[18] Rhee, Mooweon., and Pamela, H.: “The Liability of Good Reputation: A Study of Product Recalls in the U.S. Automobile Industry.” Organization Science, 17(1), (2006): 101-117.

[19] Ross, M., and Wenzel, T.: An Analysis of Traffic Deaths by Vehicle Type and Model. American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (2002).

[20] Rupp, Nicholas G., and Taylor, Curtis R.: “Who Initiates Recalls and Who Cares?: Evidence from the Automobile Industry.” Journal of Industrial Economics, vol. L, No. 2, (2002): 123-149.

[21] U.S. Government Printing Office, “http://edocket.access.gpo.gov/cfr 2009/octqtr/pdf/49cfr573.7.pdf”.

[22] Vellequette, Larry P.: “Why recall letters could be a real boon for Jeep dealers,” (2013), Automotive News, autonews.com.

[23] Ward's Automotive Yearbook, Annual, Detroit, MI.

[24] Wooldridge, Jeffrey M.: Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, The MIT Press, 2002

[25] Recall Effectiveness Research: A Review and Summary of the Literature on Consumer Motivation and Behavior, Heiden Associates, 2003