Influence of wind power on hourly electricity prices and GHG emissions: Evidence that congestion matters from Ontario zonal data

Amor, Mourad Ben and Billette de Villemeur, Etienne and Pellat, Marie and Pineau, Pierre-Olivier (2014): Influence of wind power on hourly electricity prices and GHG emissions: Evidence that congestion matters from Ontario zonal data.

Abstract

With the growing share of wind production, understanding its impacts on electricity price and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions becomes increasingly relevant, especially to design better wind-supporting policies. Internal grid congestion is usually not taken into account when assessing the price impact of fluctuating wind output. Using 2006-2011 hourly data from Ontario (Canada) , we establish that the impact of wind output, both on price level and marginal GHG emissions, greatly differs depending on the congestion level. Indeed, from a 3.3% price reduction when wind production doubles, the reduction jumps to 5.5% during uncongested hours, but is only 0.8% when congestion prevails. Similarly, avoided GHG emissions due to wind are estimated to 331.93 kilograms per megawatt-hour (kg/MWh) using all data, while for uncongested and congested hours, estimates are respectively 283.49 and 393.68 kg/MWh. These empirical estimates, being based on 2006-2011 Ontario data, cannot be generalized to other contexts. The main contribution of this paper is to underscore the importance of congestion in assessing the price and GHG impacts of wind. We also contribute by developing an approach to create clusters of data according to the congestion status and location. Finally, we compare different approaches to estimate avoided GHG emissions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Wind energy; Electricity prices; Congestion; marginal GHG emissions.
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L94 - Electric Utilities; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q42 - Alternative Energy Sources

References

Rosen J, Tietze-Stöckinger I, Rentz O. Model-based analysis of effects from large-scale wind power production. Energy. 2007;32(4):575-83.

Lund H. Large-scale integration of wind power into different energy systems. Energy. 2005;30(13):2402-12.

Lund H. Renewable Energy Systems - The Choice and Modeling of 100% Renewable Solutions 2010.

Sensfuß F, Ragwitz M, Genoese M. The merit-order effect: A detailed analysis of the price effect of renewable electricity generation on spot market prices in Germany. Energy Policy. 2008;36(8):3086-94.

Jónsson T, Pinson P, Madsen H. On the market impact of wind energy forecasts. Energy Economics. 2010;32(2):313-20.

Munksgaard J, Morthorst PE. Wind power in the Danish liberalised power market—Policy measures, price impact and investor incentives. Energy Policy. 2008;36(10):3940-7.

Weigt H. Germany’s wind energy: The potential for fossil capacity replacement and cost saving. Applied Energy. 2009;86(10):1857-63.

Woo CK, Horowitz I, Moore J, Pacheco A. The impact of wind generation on the electricity spot-market price level and variance: The Texas experience. Energy Policy. 2011;39(7):3939-44.

Woo CK, Zarnikau J, Moore J, Horowitz I. Wind generation and zonal-market price divergence: Evidence from Texas. Energy Policy. 2011;39(7):3928-38.

Cutler NJ, Boerema ND, MacGill IF, Outhred HR. High penetration wind generation impacts on spot prices in the Australian national electricity market. Energy Policy. 2011;39(10):5939-49.

Bach P-F. The Effects of Wind Power on Spot Prices. Danemark: Renewable Energy Foundation; 2009. p. 17.

Li G, Shi J. Agent-based modeling for trading wind power with uncertainty in the day-ahead wholesale electricity markets of single-sided auctions. Applied Energy. 2012;99(0):13-22.

Daniel T. Kaffine, Brannin J. McBee, Lieskovsky J. Emissions Savings from Wind Power Generation in Texas. The Energy Journal. 2013;34(1):155-75.

Canadian Wind Energy Association. Powering Canada's future CANWEA; 2012. p. 1.

Ontario. Ontario’s Long-Term Energy Plan. Toronto: Ontario; 2010. p. 37.

Ontario. Ontario’s Feed-in Tariff Program - Two-Year Review Report. Toronto: Ontario; 2012. p. 32.

Canadian Wind Energy Association. Canadian wind energy market. CANWEA; 2012. p. 4.

Ontario Society of Professional Engineers. Wind and the Electrical Grid-Mitigating the Rise in Electricity Rates and Greenhouse Gas Emissions. OSPE2012. p. 43.

IESO. Renewable Integration (SE-91), Toronto: Independent Electricity System Operator. 2013.

Timmins TJ, Mondrow IA. Assessing Curtailment Risk In Ontario. 2013.

IESO. Hourly Generator Output & Capability. 2012.

IESO. Market Data-IESO Public Reports. 2012.

IESO. Monthly Generator Disclosure Report. 2012.

IESO. Monthly Generator Disclosure Report. IESO; 2011. p. 28.

Moreno B, López AJ, García-Álvarez MT. The electricity prices in the European Union. The role of renewable energies and regulatory electric market reforms. Energy.

Gil H, Deslauriers JC, Dignard-Bailey L, Joos G. Integration of Wind Generation with Power Systems in Canada – Overview of Technical and Economic Impacts. Varennes: CANMET Energy Technology Centre –Natural Resources Canada; 2006. p. 44.

Soimakallio S, Kiviluoma J, Saikku L. The complexity and challenges of determining GHG (greenhouse gas) emissions from grid electricity consumption and conservation in LCA (life cycle assessment) – A methodological review. Energy. 2011;36(12):6705-13.

Weber CL, Jaramillo P, Marriott J, Samaras C. Life Cycle Assessment and Grid Electricity: What Do We Know and What Can We Know? Environmental Science & Technology. 2010;44(6):1895-901.

Environment Canada. National Inventory Report 1990-2008: Greenhouse Gas Sources and Sinks in Canada. In: Government of Canada, editor.2010.

Mallia E, Lewis G. Life cycle greenhouse gas emissions of electricity generation in the province of Ontario, Canada. Int J Life Cycle Assess. 2012:1-15.

Hirst E. Integrating wind output with bulk power operations and wholesale electricity markets. Wind Energy. 2002;5(1):19-36.

Nicholson E, Rogers J, Porter K. The Relationship between Wind Generation and Balancing-Energy Market Prices in ERCOT: 2007–2009. Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory; 2010. p. 34.

Alberta Environment. Offset Protocol Development Guidance. Edmonton: Alberta Environment; 2011. p. 92.

Amor MB, Pineau P-O, Gaudreault C, Samson R. Electricity trade and GHG emissions: Assessment of Quebec's hydropower in the Northeastern American market (2006–2008). Energy Policy. 2011;39(3):1711-21.

Milligan M, Porter K, DeMeo E, Denholm P, Holttinen H, Kirby B, et al. Preface: Wind Power Myths Debunked. Wind Power in Power Systems: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd; 2012. p. 7-20.