The puzzle of job search and housing tenure. A reconciliation of theory and empirical evidence

Morescalchi, Andrea (2014): The puzzle of job search and housing tenure. A reconciliation of theory and empirical evidence.

Abstract

Oswald's thesis posits that workers who own their own home should have longer unemployment spells due to restricted mobility, but repeatedly the reverse is found. We contribute to shed light on this puzzle in two key ways. First, we show that the thesis holds when stated in terms of search intensity instead of unemployment. In a job search model with moving costs we show that unemployed homeowners search less than renters. We confirm this result empirically using UK LFS data. Second, we provide evidence that homeowners select search methods associated with shorter unemployment spells, suggesting that they search more effciently.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: job search, search methods, housing tenure, homeownership, Oswald effect.
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J64 - Unemployment: Models, Duration, Incidence, and Job Search; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R21 - Housing Demand; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R23 - Regional Migration ; Regional Labor Markets ; Population ; Neighborhood Characteristics; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R2 - Household Analysis > R29 - Other

References

J. Addison & P. Portugal (2002). “Job search methods and outcomes”. Oxford Economic Papers 54:505-533.

P. Allison (1982). Discrete time methods for the analysis of event histories. Jossey-Bass, in Sociological Methodology, S. Leinhardt edn.

J. Angrist & W. Evans (1998). “Children and their parents’ labor supply: Evidence from exogenous variation in family size”. American Economic Review 88:450-477.

W. Arulampalam, et al. (2000). “Unemployment Persistence”. Oxford Economic Papers 52(1):24-50.

R. Bachmann & D. Baumgarten (2012). “How Do the Unemployed Search for a Job? Evidence from the EU Labour Force Survey”. Iza working paper series, IZA.

J. A. Barrios García & J. Rodríguez Hernández (2004). “User cost changes, unemployment and home-ownership: Evidence from Spain”. Urban Studies 41:563-578.

H. Battu, et al. (2008). “Housing Tenure, Job Mobility and Unemployment in the UK”. The Economic Journal 118:311-328.

C. R. Bhat (2001). “Quasi-Random Maximum Simulated Likelihood Estimation of the Mixed Multinomial Logit Model”. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological 35:677-693.

J. Bishop & K. Abraham (1993). “Improving Job Matches in the U.S. Labor Market”. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. Microeconomics 1:335-400.

D. G. Blanchflower & A. J. Oswald (2013). “Does High Home-Ownership Impair the Labor Market?”. NBER working paper no. 19079.

D. Blau & F. Robins (1990). “Job search outcomes for the employed and unemployed”. Journal of Political Economy 98:637-655.

R. Boeheim & M. Taylor (2001). “Job search methods, intensity and success in Britain in the 1990s”. ISER Working Paper Series 7, University of Essex.

C. Brunet, et al. (2007). “Statut Résidentiel et Durée de Chômage en France et au Royaume-Uni.” Revue française d”Economie 22(2):165-190.

C. Brunet & J.-Y. Lesueur (2004). “Le statut résidentiel affecte-t-il la durée de chômage?”. Revue économique 55(3):569-578.

C. Brunet & J.-Y. Lesueur (2009). “Do homeowners stay unemployed longer? A French microeconometric study”. In C. van Ewijk & M. van Leuvensteijn (eds.), Homeownership and the Labour Market in Europe, chap. 6. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

A. C. Cameron & P. K. Trivedi (1998). Regression Analysis of Count Data. Econometric Society Monograph No. 30. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

N. Coulson & L. Fisher (2009). “Housing Tenure and Labor Market Impacts: The Search Goes On”. Journal of Urban Economics 65(3):252-264.

N. E. Coulson & L. M. Fisher (2002). “Tenure Choice and Labour Market Outcomes”. Housing Studies 17(1):35-49.

T. De Graaf & M. Van Leuvensteijn (2007). “The impact of housing market institutions on labour mobility: A European cross country comparison”. Tech. Rep. 82, CPB Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis.

T. De Graaf, et al. (2009). Homeownership, social renting and labor mobility across Europe, chap. 3, pp. 53-70. Oxford University Press, in homeownership & the labour market in europe, C. Van Ewijk and M. Van Leuvensteijn edn.

P. Deb & P. Trivedi (2006a). “Maximum Simulated Likelihood Estimation of a Negative Binomial Regression Model with Multinomial Endogenous Treatment”. The Stata Journal 6(2):246-255.

P. Deb & P. Trivedi (2006b). “Specification and Simulated Likelihood Estimation of a Non-Normal Treatment-Outcome with Selection: Application to Health Care Utilization”. Econometrics Journal 9:307-331.

D. Di Pasquale & E. Glaeser (1999). “Incentives and Social Capital: Are Homeowners Better Citizens?”. Journal of Urban Economics 45:354-384.

R. Di Tella & R. MacCulloch (2005). “The Consequences of Labor Market Flexibility: Panel Evidence Based on Survey Data”. European Economic Review 49:1225-1259.

R. Dietz & D. Haurin (2003). “The social and private micro-level consequences of homeownership”. Journal of Urban Economics 54:401-450.

G. Engelhardt, et al. (2010). “What are the social benefits of homeownership? Experimental evidence for low-income households”. Journal of Urban Economics 67:249-258.

P. Flatau, et al. (2003). “Homeownership and Unemployment: The Roles of Leverage and Public Housing”. NBER Working Papers 10021, National Bureau of Economic Research.

P. Flatau, et al. (2002). “Home ownership and unemployment in Australia”. Working Paper 190, Murdoch University.

E. P. Goss & J. M. Phillips (1997). “The Impact of Home Ownership on the Duration of Unemployment”. Review of Regional Studies 27(1):9-27.

C. Gourieroux, et al. (1984). “Pseudo Maximum Likelihood Methods: Theory”. Econometrica 52(3):681-700.

A. Green, et al. (2011). “Job Search Study: Literature review and analysis of the Labour Force Survey”. Research Report 726, Department for Work and Pensions.

C. Green (2011). “Employed and Unemployed Job Search Methods: Australian Evidence on Search Duration, Wages and Job Stability”.

R. Green & P. Hendershott (2001a). “Home-ownership and Unemployment in the US”. Urban Studies 38:1501-1520.

R. Green & P. Hendershott (2001b). “Homeownership and the Duration of Unemployment: A Test of the Oswald Hypothesis”. NBER working paper, National Bureau of Economic Research.

P. Gregg & J. Wadsworth (1996). “How Effective Are State Employment Agencies? Jobcentre Use and Job Matching in Britain”. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics 58:443-467.

N. Havet & A. Penot (2010). “Does Homeownership Harm Labour Market Peformance?”. Working Paper 1012, GATE Lyon-St Etienne.

A. Henley (1998). “Residential Mobility, Housing Equity and the Labour Market”. The Economic Journal 108:414-427.

H. Holzer (1988). “Search Method Use by Unemployed Youth”. Journal of Labor Economics 6(1):1-20.

G. Hughes & B. McCormick (1981). “Do Council Housing Policies Reduce Migration Between Regions?”. Economic Journal 91:919-937.

G. Hughes & B. McCormick (1987). “Housing Markets, Unemployment and Labour Market Flexibility in the UK”. European Economic Review 31:615-645.

G. Hughes & B. McCormick (2000). “Housing Policy and Labour Market Performance”. Tech. rep., Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions, London.

J. Kantor, et al. (2013). “Homeownership, unemployment and commuting distances”. Discussion Paper 144, Tinbergen Institute.

J. P. Laamanen (2013). “Home-Ownership and the labour market: evidence from rental housing market deregulation”. Tampere Working Papers Net Series 89, University of Tampere.

S. Longhi & M. Taylor (2011). “Explaining differences in job search outcomes between employed and unemployed job seekers”. Working paper, ISER.

A. Manning (2009). “You Can”t Always Get What You Want: The Impact of the Jobseeker’s Allowance”. Labour Economics 16:239-250.

B. McCormick (1983). “Housing and Unemployment in Great Britain”. Oxford Economic Papers 35:283-305.

D. Mortensen (1986). “Job Search and Labor Market Analysis”. In O. Ashenfelter & D. Card (eds.), Handbook of Labor Economics, vol. 2, chap. 15, pp. 849-919. Elsevier, Amsterdam.

J. Munch, et al. (2006). “Are Home Owners Really More Unemployed?” The Economic Journal 116:991-1013.

S. Nickell (1998). “Unemployment: Questions and Some Answers”. Economic Journal 108:802-816.

S. Nickell & R. Layard (1999). “Labor Market Institutions and Economic Performance”, vol. 3, chap. 46, pp. 3029-3084. Elsevier, in Handbook of Labor Economics, O. Ashenfelter and D. Card edn.

L. Osberg (1993). “Fishing in Different Pools: Job-Search Strategies and Job-Finding Success in Canada in the Early 1980s”. Journal of Labor Economics 11:348-386.

A. J. Oswald (1996). “A Conjecture on the Explanation for High Unemployment in the Industrialized Nations: Part 1”. Working paper, University of Warwick.

A. J. Oswald (1997). “Thoughts on NAIRU”. Journal of Economic Perspectives 11(1):227-228.

A. J. Oswald (1999). “The Housing Market and Europe’s Unemployment: A Non-Technical Paper”. Working paper, University of Warwick.

B. Petrongolo (2009). “The Long-Term Effects of Job Search Requirements: Evidence from the UK JSA Reform”. Journal of Public Economics vol. 93:1234-1253.

M. Ports (1993). “Trends in Job Search Methods”. Monthly Labor Review 116:63-67.

D. Rivers & Q. H. Vuong (1988). “Limited Information Estimators and Exogeneity Tests for Simultaneous Probit Models”. Journal of Econometrics 39:347-366.

W. Rohe, et al. (2002). The social benefits and costs of homeownership: a critical assessment of the research, pp. 57-86. Brookings Institution Press, Washington DC, in Low-Income Homeownership: Examining the Unexamined Goal, N. Retsinas and E. Belsky edn.

J. Rouwendal & P. Nijkamp (2010). “Homeownership and Labour Market Behaviour: Interpreting the Evidence”. Environment and Planning A 42:419-433.

J. Schmitt & J. Wadsworth (1993). “Unemployment Benefit Levels and Search Activity”. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistic 55:1-24.

K. Train (2003). Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

P. K. Trivedi & M. K. Munkin (2010). “Recent Developments in Cross Section and Panel Count Models”. In A. Ullah & D. Giles (eds.), Handbook of Empirical Economics and Finance, chap. 4, pp. 87-131. Francis and Taylor.

G. J. Van den Berg & A. Van Vuuren (1998). “Job Search and the Non-Monetary Cost of Moving to a New Residence”. Working paper, Free University.

M. Van Leuvensteijn & P. Koning (2004). “The Effect of Homeownesrship on Labor Mobility in The Netherlands”. Journal of Urban Economics 55(3):580-596.

A. Van Vuuren (2009). “The Impact of Homeownership on Unemployment in the Netherlands”. In C. Van Ewijk & M. Van Leuvensteijn (eds.), Homeownership and the Labour Market in Europe, chap. 5. Oxford University Press, Oxford.

J. Wadsworth (1991). “Unemployment Benefits and Search Effort in the UK Labour Market”. Economica 58:117-34.

A. Weber & H. Mahringer (2008). “Choice and Success of Job Search Methods”. Empirical Economics 35(1):153-178.