On the informative value of the EU-wide stress tests and the determinants of banks’ stock return reactions

Georgoutsos, Dimitris and Moratis, George (2020): On the informative value of the EU-wide stress tests and the determinants of banks’ stock return reactions.

Abstract

We examine the informative value of the 2016 and 2018 supervisory EU stress tests on the basis of the bank stock and CDS abnormal returns they have caused. Our conclusions are based on results from event study analysis and from regressions on the determinants of bank stocks’ abnormal returns. We conclude that the 2018 stress test has been comparatively more informative for investors but only for a sub-group of banks based on sovereign debt-ridden and non-Eurozone countries. The robustness of our results is tested by applying an exhaustive set of event study test statistics on abnormal returns generated from both single and Fama-French factor models. The equity Tier I, leverage and profitability ratios are important determinants of abnormal bank stock returns for the same group of countries as in the event study analysis. Non-linear reactions highlight the fact that investors assign varying degrees of importance on the information they get from the stress tested financial ratios. Overall, our results substantiate the claim that the recent EU stress tests have been calibrated towards revealing the weaknesses of the banking sectors of peripheral Eurozone and non-Eurozone countries.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: EBA stress tests, event study analysis, factor models, quantile regression analysis
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

Acharya, V. V., Berger, A. N., Roman, R. A., 2018. Lending implications of U.S. bank stress tests: Costs or benefits?. Journal of Financial Intermediation, Elsevier, 34(C), 58-90.

Acharya, V. V., Pierret, D., Steffen, S., 2016. Capital Shortfalls of European Banks since the Start of the Banking Union. http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~sternfin/vacharya/public_html/pdfs/shortfalls_v27July2016%20(1).pdf

Acharya, V. V., Steffen, S., 2014. Falling short of expectations? stress-testing the European banking system (CEPS papers). Center for European Policy Studies. http://EconPapers.repec.org/RePEc:eps:cepswp:8803.

Acharya V.V., Drechsler, I., Schnabl, P., 2014. A Pyrrhic Victory? Bank Bailouts and Sovereign Credit Risk. The Journal of Finance, 69 (6), 2689-2739.

Acharya V.V., Engle, R., Richardson, M., 2012. Capital shortfall: A New Approach to Ranking and Regulating Systemic Risks. American Economic Review: Paper and Proceedings, 102(3) , 59-64.

Blundell-Wignall, A., Slovik, P., 2010. The EU stress test and sovereign debt exposures. Paris: OECD.

Boehmer, E., Masumeci, J., Poulsen, A., 1991. Event-study methodology under conditions of event-induced variance, Journal of Financial Economics, Vol. 30, Issue 2, pp. 253-272.

Bookstaber, R., Cetina, J., Feldberg, G., Flood, M., Glasserman, P., 2014. Stress tests to promote financial stability: Assesing progress and looking to the future. Journal of Risk Management in Financial Institutions, Vol. 7(1), pp. 16-25.

Calem, P., Correa, R., and S.J. Lee, 2016. “Prudential policies and their impact on credit in the U.S.,” International Finance Discussion Papers 1186. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.

Candelon, Β., Amadou N. R. Sy., 2015. How do markets react to stress tests? (IMF working papers 15/75). International Monetary Fund. https://ideas.repec.org/p/imf/imfwpa/15-75.html.

Cardinali, A., Nordmark, J. 2011. How informative are bank stress tests? Bank opacity in the European Union . Lund: Lund University.

Chiaramonte, L. , Casu, B., 2012. The determinants of bank CDS spreads: Evidence from the financial crisis. The European Journal of Finance, 19(9), 861-887.

Demirguc-Kunt, A., Detragiache, E, Merrouche, Q., 2013. Bank Capital: Lessons from the Financial Crisis. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 45 (6), 1147-1164.

Drago, D., Di Tommaso, C., Thornton, J., 2017. What determines bank CDS spreads? Evidence from the European and US banks. Finance Research Letters, 22, 140-145.

Ellahie, Atif. 2013. “Capital Market Consequences of EU Bank Stress Tests.” Available at http://ssrn.com.abstract=2157715.

European Banking Association, 2016. “2016 EU‐Wide Stress Test- results”, https://eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/1532819/2016-EU-wide-stress-test-Results.pdf

European Banking Association, 2018. “2018 EU‐Wide Stress Test- results”, https://eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/2419200/2018-EU-wide-stress-test-Results.pdf

Fama, E.F., French, K.R., 2015. A five-factor asset pricing model, Journal of Financial Economics, Volume 116, Issue 1, Pages 1-22.

Faria-e-Castro, M., Martinez, J., Philippon, T., 2016. Runs versus Lemons: Information Disclosure and Fiscal Capacity. Review of Economic Studies, 01, 1-27.

Flannery, M. J., Hirtle, B., Kovner, A., 2016. Evaluating the information in the Federal Reserve stress tests. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff Reports, no. 744.

Glasserman, P., Gowtham, T ., 2015. “Are the Federal Reserve’s Stress Test Results Predictable?” Office of Financial Research Working Paper 15‐02.

Goldstein, I., and Sapra, H., 2014. Should Banks’ Stress Test Results be Disclosed? An Analysis of the Costs and Benefits. Foundations and Trends in Finance, 8(1), 1-54.

Gross, M. and Población, J., 2019. Implications of Model Uncertainty for Bank Stress testing. Journal of Financial Services Research, 55, pp. 31-58.

Hanson, S., Kashyap, A., Sten, J., 2011. A Macroprudential Approach to Financial Regulation. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 25, 3-28.

Hirtle, B., Flannery, M., Kovner, A., 2017. Evaluating the Information in the Federal Reserve Stress Tests. Journal of Financial Intermediation, vol. 29, 1-18

Hirtle, ,B., Til , S., Kevin J. S., 2009. Macroprudential supervision of financial institutions: Lessons from the SCAP. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1515800

Kapinos, P., Martin, C., Mitnik, O., 2018. Stress Testing Banks: Whence and Whither? Journal of Financial Perspectives, vol. 5, No. 1.

Kolari, J.W., Pynnönen, S., 2011. Nonparametric rank tests for event studies. Journal of Empirical Finance, 18 (5), 953-971.

Kolari, J.W., Pynnönen, S., 2010. Event Study Testing with Cross-sectional Correlation of Abnormal Returns. The Review of Financial Studies,23 (11), 3996–4025.

Morrison, A., White, L., 2013. Reputational Contagion and Optimal Regulatory Forbearance. Journal of Financial Economics, 110, 642-658.

Neretina, E., Sahin, C., de Haan, J., 2014. Banking stress test effects on returns and risks , DNB working papers 419. Amsterdam: The Netherlands Central Bank, Research Department.

Patell, J.A., 1976. Corporate Forecasts of Earnings per Share and Stock Price Behavior Empirical Test. Journal of Accounting Research, 14, 246-276.

Peristiani, S., Morgan, D., Savino, V., 2014. The Information Value of the Stress Test and Bank Opacity. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 46, no. 7, 1479-1500.

Petrella, G., Resti, A., 2013. Supervisors as information producers: Do stress tests reduce bank opaqueness? Journal of Banking and Finance 37 (12), 5406–5420.

Pierret, D., Steffen, S., 2018. Capital Shortfalls of European Banks following the 2018 Stress Test. https://www.allnews.ch/sites/default/files/files/shortfalls_v6November2018.pdf

Sahin, C., de Haan, J., 2015. Market reactions to the ECB’s Comprehensive Assessment, Working Paper No. 463, De Nederlandsche Bank NV.

Shapiro, J. Skeie, D., 2015. Information management in banking crises. The Review of Financial Studies, 28(8), 2322–2363.

Shapiro, J., Zeng, J., 2019. Stress Testing and Bank Lending. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3432291 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3432291.

Morrison. A., White, L., 2013. Reputational contagion and optimal regulatory forbearance. Journal of Financial Economics, 110, 642–658.