Firm heterogeneity in productivity across Europe. What explains what?

Aiello, Francesco and Ricotta, Fernanda (2014): Firm heterogeneity in productivity across Europe. What explains what?

Abstract

This paper analyses the TFP heterogeneity of a sample of manufacturing firms operating in seven EU countries (Austria, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Spain and UK). TFP data refer to 2008. The empirical setting is based on the multilevel modelling which provides two main results. Firstly, we show that TFP heterogeneity is largely due to firm-specific features (85% of TFP variability in the empty-model). Interestingly, we find that some key-drivers of TFP (size, family-management, group membership, innovations and human capital) influence heterogeneity in productivity with the expect sign, but do not, on the whole, absorb much of firm-TFP variance, implying that differences in productivity are due to sizable yet unobservable firm characteristics. Secondly, as far the role of localization is concerned, we demonstrate that country-effect is more influential than region-effect in explaining individual productivity. Net of the country-effect, the localisation in different European regions explains about 5% of TFP firm heterogeneity. When considering the case of three individual countries (France, Italy and Spain), location in different regions explains 5.3% of TFP heterogeneity in Italy, while this proportion is lower (3.6%) in France and higher (9.9%) in Spain.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: TFP heterogeneity, firm-behavior, localization, European countries, multilevel model
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C3 - Multiple or Simultaneous Equation Models ; Multiple Variables > C30 - General; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D22 - Firm Behavior: Empirical Analysis; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D24 - Production ; Cost ; Capital ; Capital, Total Factor, and Multifactor Productivity ; Capacity; L - Industrial Organization > L6 - Industry Studies: Manufacturing > L60 - General; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R11 - Regional Economic Activity: Growth, Development, Environmental Issues, and Changes; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R15 - Econometric and Input-Output Models ; Other Models

References

Aghion, P., and P. Howitt. 1992. “A Model of Growth through Creative Destruction:” Econometrica 60:323-351.

Aiello, F., C. Mastromarco and A. Zago. 2011, “Be productive or face decline. On the sources and determinants of output growth in Italian manufacturing firms” Empirical Economics 41 (3): 787-815.

Aiello, F. and V. Pupo. 2012. “Structural Funds and the Economic Divide in Italy2, Journal of Policy Modeling 34(3):403-418.

Aiello, F., V. Pupo and F. Ricotta. 2014. “Explaining Total Factor Productivity at Firm Level in Italy: Does Location Matter?” Spatial Economic Analysis, 9 (1):1–20.

Aiello, F., V. Pupo and F. Ricotta. 2015. “Firm Heterogeneity in TFP, sectoral innovation and location. Evidence from Italy”, International Review of Applied Economics 29(5):546-571

Altomonte, C. and T. Aquilante. 2012. “The EU-EFIGE/Bruegel-Unicredit dataset” Bruegel Working paper 13, Brussels.

Altomonte, C. and I. Colantone. 2008. “Firm heterogeneity and endogenous regional disparities” Journal of Economic Geography 8 (6): 779-810.

Altomonte, C., T. Aquilante and G. Ottaviano. 2012. “The triggers of competitiveness: The EFIGE cross-country report” Brugel Blueprint Series 17, Brussels.

Arosa, B., T. Iturralde and A. Maseda. 2010. “Ownership structure and firm performance in non-listed firms: evidence from Spain” Journal of Family Business Strategy 1(2):88–96.

Baldwin R.E., and T. Okubo. 2006. “Heterogeneous firms, agglomeration and economic geography: spatial selection and sorting.” Journal of Economic Geography 6:323-346.

Beugelsdijk, S. 2007. “The regional environment and a firm’s innovative performance: a plea for a multilevel interactionist approach.” Economic Geography 83:181-199

Barba Navaretti, G., M. Bugamelli, F. Schivardi F., C. Altomonte, D. Horgos and D. Maggioni D. 2011. “The Global Operations of European Firms” Bruegel Blueprint 12, Brussels.

Barontino, R., and I. Caprio. 2006. “The effect of family control on firm value and performance: Evidence from continental Europe” European Financial Management 12:689-723.

Barth, E., T. Gulbrandsen and P. Schøne P. 2005. “Family Ownership and Productivity: The Role of Owner-Management” Journal of Corporate Finance 11:107–127.

Bartkowskaa, M. and A. Riedla. 2012. “Regional convergence clubs in Europe: Identification and conditioning factors” Economic Modelling 29 (1):22–31.

Bhattacharjee, A., de Castro, E., Jensen-Butler, E. C..2009. “Regional variation in productivity: a study of the Danish economy”, Journal of Productivity Analysis 31:195-212.

Bellmann, L., Crimmann, A., Evers, K., Hujer, R. 2013. “Regional Determinants of Establishments' Innovation Activities: A Multi-Level Approach”, IZA Discussion Paper Series No. 7572.

Bellone, F, Guillou, S., Nesta L. 2009. “Are export premia robust to innovation statistics? » Document de travail, 15. Observatoir Français des Conjuctures Economiques, Paris

Benfratello, L. and A. Sembenelli. 2006. “Foreign Ownership and Productivity. Is the direction of causality so obvious?” International Journal of Industrial Organization 24 (4):733–751.

Bickel, R. 2007. Multilevel Analysis for Applied Research, It’s Just Regression!, The Guilford Press, New York.

Bloom, N. and J. Van Reenen. 2010. “Why Do Management Practices Differ across Firms and Countries?”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 24(1):203–224.

Boldrin, M., Canova, F. 2001. “Inequality and convergence: Reconsidering European regional policies” Economic Policy, 32:207–253.

Caselli, F. 2005. Accounting for cross-country income differences, in The Handbook of Economic Growth, edited by Aghion P. and S. Durlauf North Holland, Amsterdam

Caggiano, G. and L. Leonida,. 2013. “Multimodality in the distribution of GDP and the absolute convergence hypothesis, Empirical Economics, 44(3):1203-1215.

Cassiman, B, E. Goloso, and E. Martinez-Ros. 2010. “Innovation, export and productivity” International Journal of Industrial Organization 28:372-376.

Castellacci, F. 2007. “Evolutionary and new growth theories. Are they converging?” Journal of Economic Surveys 21:585-627.

Cohen, W.M. and D.A. Levinthal. 1990. “Absorptive capacity: a new perspective of learning and innovation” Administrative Science Quarterly 35: 128-152.

Corrado, L. and B. Fingleton. 2012 “Where is the economics in spatial econometrics” Journal of Regional Science 52(2):210-239

Crozet M, I. Méjan and S. Zignago. 2011. “Plus grandes, plus fortes plus loin…Les performances des firmes exportatrices françaises” Revue économique 62(4):717-736.

Cucculelli, M., L. Mannarino, V. Pupo, and F. Ricotta. 2014. “Owner-management, firm age and productivity in Italian family firms” Journal of Small Business Management 52(2):325-343.

De la Fuente, A. 2002a. “The effect of structural on the Spanish Regions: an Assessment of the 1994-1999 Objective 1 CSF” CERP Discussion Paper, n. 3673.

De la Fuente, A. 2002b. “On the Sources of Convergence: A Close Look at the Spanish Regions” European Economic Review 46:569-599.

Di Liberto, A. and S. Usai. 2013. “TFP Convergence Across European Regions: A Comparative Spatial Dynamics Analysis”, in Geography Institutions and Regional Economic Performance Advances in Spatial Science, edited by R. Crescenzi and M. Percoco, Springer Berlin Heidelberg

Dosi, G. and R. Nelson. 2010. “Technical Change and Industrial Dynamics as Evolutionary Processes.” In Handbook of the Economics of Innovation, edited by B. Hall, and N. Rosenberg. London: North Holland.

European Commission. 2007. Growing regions, growing Europe. Fourth report on economic and social cohesion, May, ISDN 92-79-05710-6, Brussels.

Fazio G. and D. Piacentino. 2010. “A Spatial Multilevel Analysis of Italian SMEs' Productivity” Spatial Economic Analysis, 5(3):299-316.

Foster, L., J.C. Haltiwanger, and C. Krizan. 2001. “Aggregate Productivity Growth. Lessons from Microeconomic Evidence”, in New Developments in Productivity Analysis , edited by Hulten C.R., E.R. Dean and M.J. Harper, University Chicago Press, Chicago.

Goldstein, H. 2003. Multilevel Statistical Models, London, Arnold.

Griffith, R. 1999. “Using the ARD establishment data to looking at foreign ownership and productivity in the United Kingdom” Economic Journal 109:416– 442.

Griffith, R., E. Huergo, J. Mairesse and B. Peters. 2006. “Innovation and productivity across four European countries” Oxford Review of Economic Policy 22(4):483-498.

Griliches, Z. 2000. “R&D, Education and Productivity A Retrospective” Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Hall, B. H. 2011. “Innovation and productivity” Nordic Economic Policy Review 2:167-195.

Hall, R. and C. Jones. 1999. “Why do some countries produce so much more output per worker than others?” Quarterly Journal of Economics 114:83-116.

Heck, R.H. and S.L. Thomas. 2000. An introduction to multilevel modelling techniques. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey.

Hox, J.J. 2002. Multilevel analysis: techniques and applications. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey.

ISGEP, International Study Group on Exports and Productivity (2008), Understanding Cross-Country Differences in Exporter Premia: Comparable Evidence for 14 Countries, Review of World Economics, 144 (4), 596 – 635.

Klenow, P. and A. Rodriguez-Clare. 1997. The neoclassical revival in growth economics: has it gone too far?, NBER Macroeconomics Annual, 12, 73-103.

Krueger, A.B. and M. Lindahl. 2001, Education for Growth; Why and for Whom? Journal of Economic Literature, 39, 4, 1101-1136.

Krugman, P. 1991. Geography and Trade, Cambridge University Press.

Leckie, G. 2013. Cross-Classified Multilevel Models - Concepts. LEMMA VLE Module 12, 1-60. http://www.bristol.ac.uk/cmm/learning/course.html.

Levinsohn, J., and A. Petrin. 2003. “Estimating production functions using inputs to control for unobservables” Review of Economic Studies, 7:317–341

Luke, A. 2014. Multilevel Modelling. London: Sage.

Malerba, F. 2005. “Sectoral systems of innovation: a framework for linking innovation to the knowledge base, structure and dynamics of sectors.” Economics of Innovation and New Technology 14, 1-2: 63-82.

Mass, J.M, and J.J. Hox. 2004 ”Robustness issues in multilevel regression analysis. Statistica Neederlandica 58:127-137.

Mahlberg B., I. Freund, J. Crespo Cuaresma and A. Prskawetz. 2013. “The age-productivity pattern: Do location and sector affiliation matter?”, Journal of the Economics of Ageing, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jeoa.2013.08.002.

Maury, B. 2006. “Family ownership and firm performance: empirical evidence from Western European corporations” Journal of Corporate Finance 12:321–41.

Melitz, M. J. 2003. “The Impact of Trade on Intra-Industry Reallocations and Aggregate Industry Productivity” Econometrica 71(6):1695–1725.

Miller, D., Breton-Miller, I. L., Lester, R., and A.Cannella. 2007. “Are Family Firms Really Superior Performers?, The Journal of Corporate Finance 13:82-97.

Mundlack, Y. 1978. “On the pooling of time series and cross-sectional data” Econometrica 46:69-86.

Ortega-Argilés R., L. Potters, and M. Vivarelli. 2011. “R&D and Productivity: Testing Sectoral Peculiarities Using Micro Data” Empirical Economics 41, 817-839.

Ottaviano, G. 2008. Infrastructure and economic geography: an overview of theory and evidence, EIB Papers, 13, 9-35.

Parisi M. L., F. Schiantarelli and A. Sembenelli. 2006. “Productivity, Innovation and R&D: Micro Evidence for Italy” European Economic Review 50(8):2037-2061.

Pindado, J., I. Requejo and C. Torre. 2008. Does family ownership impact positively on firm value? Empirical evidence from Western Europe, Working Papers "New Trends on Business Administration", Universities of Valladolid, Burgos, Salamanca and León (Spain).

Rabe-Hesketh S., Skrondal A. 2008. Multilevel and Longitudinal Modeling Using Stata. Stata Press, 2nd edition.

Raspe, O. 2009. The Regional Knowledge Economy; a Multilevel Perspective on Firm Performance and Localized Knowledge Externalities, Netherlands by AD Druk b.v. – Zeist.

Raspe, O., and F. van Oort. 2011. “Firm Heterogeneity, Productivity, and Spatially Bounded Knowledge Externalities”, Socio-Economic Planning Sciences 45:38-47

Richter, T. 2006. “What is wrong with ANOVA and multiple regression? Analyzing sentence reading times with hierarchical linear models”, Discourse Processes, 41(3):221-250.

Rodriguez-Pose A. 2009. Do institutions matter for regional development?, Paper presented at the RSA Annual Conference: Understanding and Shaping Regions: Spatial, Social and Economic Futures, Leuven, Belgium, 6 8 April.

Romer, P. 1986. “Increasing returns and long-run growth.” Journal of Political Economy 94:1002-1037.

Rutherford, M., D. Kuratko, and D. Holt. 2008. “Examining the link between “familiness“ and performance: can the F-PEC untangle the family business theory jungle?” Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice 32(6):1089–1109.

Schulze, W. S., and E.R. Gedajlovic. 2010. “Guest editors’ introduction. Whither family business?, Journal of Management Studies 47:191-204.

Schumpeter, J. 1934. “The Theory of Economic Development.” Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press.

Snijders, T.A.B. and R.J. Bosker. 2008. “Diagnostic checks for multilevel models” in Handbook of multilevel Analysis, edited by Jan de Leeuw, New York: Springer.

Sraer, D., and D. Thesmar. 2007. “Performance and behavior of family firms: Evidence from the French Stock Market” Journal of the European Economic Association 5:709-751.

Srholec, M. 2010. “Multilevel Approach to Geography of Innovation.” Regional Studies 44:1207-1220.

Srholec, M. 2015. “Understanding the Diversity of Cooperation on Innovation across Countries.” Economics of Innovation and New Technology 24(1-2):159-182.

Sveikauskas, L. 2007. “R&D and Productivity Growth: A Review of the Literature” Working Paper 408 U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Washington

Tamàs-Borsi, M. and N. Metiu. 2015. “The evolution of economic convergence in the European Union.” Empirical Economics 48, 2: 657-681.

Teece, D. J., G. Pisan and A. Shuen, A. 1997. “Dynamic Capabilities and Strategic Management” Strategic Management Journal 18(7):509-533.

Van Biesebroeck, J. 2003. “Revisiting some productivity debates” NBER10065, Washington DC.

Vernon Henderson, J., S. Zmarak and A.J. Venables. 2001. “Geography and development” Journal of Economic Geography 1(1):81-105.

Wagner, J. 2007. “Exports and productivity: a survey of the evidence from firm-level data” The World Economy 30(1):60-82.

Weche Gelübcke, J.P. 2013. “The performance of foreign affiliates in German manufacturing: Evidence from a new database”, Review of World Economics 149(1):151-182.