The effects of public supports on business R&D: firm-level evidence across EU countries

Aristei, David and Sterlacchini, Alessandro and Venturini, Francesco (2015): The effects of public supports on business R&D: firm-level evidence across EU countries.

Abstract

Using homogenous firm-level data for the largest Member States of the EU over the period 2007-2009, we test whether manufacturing firms receiving R&D public supports (subsidies and/or tax incentives) spent more on R&D. The analysis is performed by means of both non-parametric (Propensity Score Matching) and parametric estimations (OLS and mixed-model system, with the latter accounting for the possible endogeneity of public supports). The hypothesis of full crowding-out of private with public funds (i.e. public support reduced privately-funded R&D expenses) is rejected for all countries, with the partial exception of Spain. However, we do not find evidence for the hypothesis of additionality of R&D subsidies (i.e. direct funding did not raise private R&D). These findings contrast with earlier works and might be due to the period under assessment, which covers the financial turmoil and the subsequent economic downturn. A focused analysis on France suggests that R&D tax credits exerted a positive impact on R&D. Overall, our findings indicate that, albeit they were not expansive, public supports avoided the reduction of firm R&D at the outset of financial crisis.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: R&D; subsidies; tax incentives; policy evaluation; EU manufacturing firms
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C21 - Cross-Sectional Models ; Spatial Models ; Treatment Effect Models ; Quantile Regressions; D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D04 - Microeconomic Policy: Formulation, Implementation, and Evaluation; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O32 - Management of Technological Innovation and R&D; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O38 - Government Policy

References

Almus, M., and Czarnitzki, D. (2003) The effects of public R&D subsidies on firms’ innovation activities: the case of Eastern Germany, Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 21, 226-236.

Altomonte, C., and Aquilante, T. (2012) The EU-EFIGE/Bruegel-Unicredit dataset, Bruegel Working Paper 2012/13.

Barbieri E., Iorio R., and Lubrano Lavadera G. (2012) R&D policy evaluation: The effects of R&D subsidies in Italy, World Review of Science, Technology and Sustainable Development, 9(2/3/4), 283-313.

Becker, B. (2014) Public R&D policies and private R&D investment: A survey of the empirical evidence, Journal of Economic Surveys, DOI: 10.1111/joes.12074.

Bloom N., Griffith, R., and Van Reenen J. (2002) Do R&D tax credits work? Evidence from a panel of countries 1979-1997, Journal of Public Economics, 85 (1), 1-31.

Busom, I. (2000) An Empirical Evaluation of the Effects of R&D Subsides, Economics of Innovation and New Technology, 9(1), 111-148.

Busom, I., and Fernández-Ribas, A. (2008) The impact of firm participation in R&D programmes on R&D partnerships, Research Policy, 37, 240-257.

Busom, I., Corchuelo B., and Martinez Ros, E. (2012) Tax incentives or subsidies for R&D?, UNU-Merit working paper, #2012-056.

Cantabene C., and Nascia, L. (2014) The race for R&D subsidies: Evaluating the effectiveness of tax credits in Italy, Economia e Politica Industriale, 3, 133-158.

Carboni, O.A. (2011) R&D subsidies and private R&D expenditures: Evidence from Italian manufacturing data, International Review of Applied Economics, 25 (4), 419-439.

Castellacci, F., and Mee Lie, C. (2015) Do the effects of R&D tax credits vary across industries? A meta-regression analysis, Research Policy, 44(4), 819-832.

Cerulli, G. (2010) Modelling and measuring the effect of public subsidies on business R&D: A critical review of the econometric literature, Economic Record, 86, 421-449.

Cerulli G., and Potì B. (2012a) The differential impact of privately and publicly funded R&D on R&D investment and innovation: the Italian case, Prometheus, 30(1), 113-149.

Cerulli, G., and Potì, B. (2012b) Evaluating the robustness of the effect of public subsidies on firms' R&D: An application to Italy, Journal of Applied Economics, 15(2), 287-320.

Charron, N., Lapuente, V.V., and Rothstein, B. (2011) Measuring quality of government and sub-national variation. Report for the EU Commission of Regional Development, European Commission. Directorate-General Regional Policy.

CPB, CASE, ETLA and IHS (2014) A study on R&D tax incentives: Final report. European Commission, DG TAXUD, Taxation Papers n. 52.

Czarnitzki, D., and Licht, G. (2006) Additionality of public R&D grants in a transition economy The case of Eastern Germany, Economics of Transition, 14(1), 101-131.

Czarnitzki, D., Ebersberger, B., and Fier, A., (2007) The relationship between R&D collaboration, subsidies and R&D performance: Empirical evidence from Finland and Germany, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 22(7), 1347-1366.

Czarnitzki, D., and Lopes Bento, C. (2012) Evaluation of public R&D policies: A cross-country comparison, World Review of Science, Technology and Sustainable development, 9(2), 254-282.

Czarnitzki, D., and Lopes Bento, C. (2013) Value for money? New microeconometric evidence on public R&D grants in Flanders, Research Policy, 42, 76-89.

David, P.A. Hall, B.H., and Toole, A.A. (2000) Is public R&D a complement or substitute for private R&D? A review of the econometric evidence, Research Policy, 29(4-5), 497-529.

Driver, C., and Guedes, M.J.C. (2012) Research and development, cash flow, agency and governance: UK large companies, Research Policy, 41(9), 1565-1577.

Duguet, E. (2004) Are R&D subsidies a substitute or a complement to privately funded R&D? Evidence from France using propensity score methods for non experimental data, Revue d' Économie Politique, 114(2), 263-392.

Duguet, E. (2012) The effect of the incremental R&D tax credit on the private funding of R&D: An econometric evaluation on French firm level data, Revue d' Économie Politique, 122(3), 405-435.

Einiö, E. (2014) R&D Subsidies and company performance: Evidence from geographic variation in government funding based on the ERDF population-density rule, Review of Economics and Statistics, 96(3), 710-728.

Eisner, R., Albert, S.H., and Sullivan, M.A. (1986) The new incremental tax credit for R&D: Incentive or disincentive, National Tax Journal, XXXVII, 171-183.

García-Quevedo, J. (2004) Do public subsidies complement business R&D? A meta-analysis of the econometric evidence, KYKLOS, 57(1), 87-102.

González, X., Jaumandreu, J., and Pazo, C. (2005) Barriers to innovation and subsidy effectiveness, RAND Journal of Economics, 36(4), 930-950.

González, X., and Pazó, C. (2008) Do public subsidies stimulate private R&D spending?, Research Policy 37(3), 371-389.

Hall, B., and Van Reenen, J. (2000) How effective are fiscal incentives for R&D? A review of the evidence, Research Policy, 29(4-5), 449-469.

Heckman, J.J. (1978) Dummy endogenous variables in a simultaneous equation system, Econometrica, 46, 931-959.

HM Revenue & Customs (2014) Research and Development Tax Credits Statistics, Report released on August, 15 2014, downloadable at www.gov.uk.

Honorè F., Munari, F., and Van Pottelsberghe De La Potterie, B. (2015) Corporate governance practices and companies’ R&D intensity: Evidence from European countries. Research Policy, 44(2), 533-543.

Hud, M., and Hussinger, K. (2014) The impact of R&D subsidies during the crisis, ZEW Discussion Paper No. 14-024.

Hussinger, K. (2008) R&D and subsidies at the firm level: An application of parametric and semiparametric two-step selection model, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 23, 729-747.

Levinsohn, J., and Petrin, A. (2003) Estimating production functions using inputs to control for unobservables, Review of Economic Studies, 70, 317-341.

Mancusi, M.L., and Vezzulli, A. (2014) R&D and credit rationing in SMEs, Economic Inquiry, 52(3), 1153-1172.

Ministère de l'Éducation nationale, de l'Enseignement supérieur et de la Recherche (2011) L’état de l’Enseignement supérieur et de la Recherche en France. Annual reports downloadable at www.enseignementsup-recherche.gouv.fr.

Mulkay, B., and Mairesse, J. (2013) The R&D tax credit in France: Assessment and ex-ante evaluation of the 2008 Reform, Oxford Economic Papers, 65(3), 746-766.

OECD (2011a) Government funding of R&D, OECD Science, Technology and Industry Scoreboard 2011, OECD Publishing; doi 10.1787/20725345.

OECD (2011b) Tax incentives for business R&D, OECD Science, Technology and Industry Scoreboard 2011, OECD Publishing; doi 10.1787/20725345.

Parisi, M.L. Schiantarelli, F., and Sembenelli, A. (2006) Productivity, innovation and R&D: Micro evidence for Italy, European Economic Review, 50(8), 2037-2061.

Roodman. D. (2011), Fitting fully observed recursive mixed-process models with cmp, Stata Journal, 11(2), 159-206.

Thomson, R. (2013) Measures of R&D tax incentives for OECD countries, Review of Economics and Institutions, 4(3), article 4.

Zùniga-Vicente, J.A., C. Alonso-Borrego, F. J. Forcadell and Galàn, J. I. (2014) Assessing the effect of public subsidies on firm R&D investment: A survey, Journal of Economic Surveys, 28(1), 36-67.