Deconstructing Supermarket Interventions as a Mechanism for Improving Diet: Lessons from the Seacroft Intervention Study

Rudkin, Simon (2015): Deconstructing Supermarket Interventions as a Mechanism for Improving Diet: Lessons from the Seacroft Intervention Study.

Abstract

Supermarkets, with vast product ranges and relatively low prices, are an established solution to problems of availability of healthy foodstuffs in areas of limited retail access. However, where they may indeed raise consumption of desirable goods they also open up new opportunities to buy less healthful items for less, a situation which potentially undermines their ability to improve diet. Using under-reported diary data from the Seacroft Intervention Study in the United Kingdom takes this paper beyond the extant fruit and vegetable focus, giving it scope to explore the full effect of supermarkets. Quantile regressions show existing behaviours are reinforced, and intervention stores may do little to improve diet. Switching to Tesco Seacroft is shown to increase the portions of unhealthy food consumed by almost 1 portion per day for the least healthy. Managing demand through promoting balanced diets and restricting offers on unhealthy items will be more effective than intervention, and is an essential accompaniment to new large format retailers if they are not to entrench dietary inequality further. Policymakers and practitioners alike should avoided being distracted by aggregate conclusions if food deserts are to be truly tackled.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: retail intervention, food deserts, diet, healthy eating
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I14 - Health and Inequality; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I18 - Government Policy ; Regulation ; Public Health

References

Adams J, Halligan J, Burgess Watson D, Ryan V, Penn L, Adamson A J, White M, 2012, “The Change4Life convenience store programme to increase retail access to fruit and vegetables: a mixed methods process evaluation” PLoS One 7(6) Aggrawal A, Cook A J, Jiao J, Seguin R A, Moudon A V, Hurvitz P M, Drewnowski A, 2014, “Access to supermarkets and fruit and vegetable consumption” American Journal of Public Health 104(5) 917-923 Caspi C E, Sorensen G, Subramanian S V, Kwachi I, 2012a, “The local food environment and diet: a systematic review” Health and Place 18 1172-1187 Caspi C E, Kawachi I, Subramanian S V, Adamkiewicz G, Sorensen G, 2012b, “The relationship between diet and perceived and objective access to supermarkets among low-income housing residents” Social Science and Medicine 75 1254-1262 Cummins S, Petticrew M, Sparks L, Findlay A, 2005, “Large scale food retail interventions and diet” Das, 2014, “Measures, spatial profile and determinants of dietary diversity: evidence from India” available at SSRN http://ssrn.com/abstract=2511823 accessed 05/02/2015 Dimitri C, Oberholtzer L, Zive M, Sandolo C, 2014, “Enhancing food security of low-income consumers: an investigation of financial incentives for use at farmers markets” Food Policy in press Dobson, P.W. and Waterson, M. (2008), "Chain-Store Competition: Customized vs. Uniform Pricing", The Warwick Economics Research Paper Series (TWERPS) 840, University of Warwick, Department of Economics. Donald B, 2013, “Food retail and access after the crash: rethinking the food desert problem” Journal of Economic Geography 13 231-237 Drescher L S, Thiele S, Mensink G B M, 2007, “A new index to measure healthy food diversity better reflects a healthy diet than traditional measures” The Journal of Nutrition 137 647-651 Evans A E, Jennings R, Smiley A W, Medina J L, Sharma S V, Rutledge R, Stigler M H, Hoelscher D M, 2012, “Introduction of farm stands in low-income communities increases fruit and vegetables among community residents” Health and Place 18 1137-1143 Findlay A, Sparks L, 2008, “Weaving new retail and consumer landscapes in the Scottish Borders” Journal of Rural Studies 24 86-97 Fitch D, 2004, “Measuring convenience: Scots’ perceptions of local food and retail provision” International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management 32 100-108 Ford P B, Dzewaltovski D A, 2011, “Neighbourhood deprivation, supermarket availability and BMI in low-income women: a multilevel analysis” Journal of Community Health 36 785-796 Gohsh-Dastidar B, Cohen D, Hunter G, Zenk S N, Huang C, Beckman R, Dubowitz R, 2014, “Distance to store, food prices and obesity in urban food deserts” American Journal of Preventative Medicine 47(5) 587-595 Gill L, Rudkin S, 2014, “Deconstructing supermarket intervention effects on fruit and vegetable consumption in areas of limited retail access: evidence from the Seacroft study” Environment and Planning A 46 649-665 Gittelsohn J, Song H-J, Suratkar S, Kumar M B, Henry E G, 2009, “An urban food store intervention positively affects food-related psychosocial variables and food behaviours” Health Education and Behavior 37(3) 390-402 Gustat J, O’Maley K, Luckett B G, Johnson CC, 2015, “fresh produce consumption and the assosciation between frequency of food shopping, car access, and distance to supermarkets” Preventative Medicine Reports 2 47-52 Hosler A S, Kammer J R, 2014, “Trends of fruit and vegetable availability in neighborhoods in Albany, NY, USA, 2003-2012” Public Health Nutrition 18(3) 562-568 Jilcott Pitts S B, Gustafson A, Wu Q, Mayo M L, Ward R K, McGuirt J T, Rafferty A P, Lancaster M F, Evenson K R, Keyserling T C, Ammerman A S, 2014, “Farmers market use is associated with fruit and vegetable consumption in diverse southern rural communities” Nutrition Journal 13(1) 1-11 Kelly M, Seubsman S, Banwell C, Dixon J, Sleigh A, 2014, “Thailand’s food retail transition: supermarket and fresh market effects on diet quality” British Food Journal 116(7) 1180-1193 Kim T H, Lee E-K, Han E, 2014, “Food away from home and body mass outcomes: taking heterogeneity into account enhances quality of results” Nutrition 30(9) 1015-1021 Koenker R, Bassett G, 1978, “Regression Quantiles” Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society 46 (1) 33-50. Lear S A, Gasevic D, Schuurman N, 2013, “Association of supermarket characteristics with the body mass index of their shoppers” Nutrition Journal 12 (1/17) 1-8 Lenardson J D, Hanson A Y, Hartley D, 2015, “Rural and remote food environments and obesity” Current Obesity Reports (in press) Liu K E, Chang H, Chern W S, 2011, “Examining changes in fresh fruit and vegetable consumption over time and across regions in China” China Agricultural Economic Review 3 276-296 Ljungvall A, Zimmerman F J, 2012, “Bigger bodies: long-term trends and disparities in obesity and body-mass0index among US adults 1960-2008” Social Science and Medicine 75 109-119 Morgan, K, 2015, “Nourishing the city: The rise of the urban food question in the Global North”, Urban Studies 52 (8) 1379-1394. Murakami K, Sasaki S, Takahashi Y, Uenishi K, 2010, “No meaningful association of neighbourhood store availability with dietary intake body mass index or waist circumference in young Japanese women” Nutrition Research 30 565-573 O’Brien M C, McConnen A, Hollywood L E, Cuskelly G J, Barnett J, Raats M, Dean M, 2014, “Lets talk about health: shopper’s discourse about health while food shopping” Public Health Nutrition (in press) Pearson A L, Winter P R, McBreen B, Stewart G, Roets R, Nutsford D, Bowie C, Donnellan N, Wilson N, 2014, “Obtaining fruit and vegetables for the lowest prices: pricing survey of different outlets and geographical analysis of competition effects” Plos ONE 9(3) 1-8 Powell L M, Slater S, Mirtcheva D, Bao Y, Chaloupka F J, 2007, “Food store availability and neighbourhood characteristics in the United States” Preventative Medicine 44(3) 189-195 Rudkin S, 2015, “Supermarket interventions and diet in areas of limited retail access: Policy suggestions from the Seacroft intervention study”, MRPA Working Paper Series number 62434, available online at http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/62434/1/MPRA_paper_62434.pdf. Schwanen T, 2015, “Geographies of transport I: reinventing a field?” Progress in Human Geography (In Press) Shaw H, 2012, “Access to healthy food in Nantes, France” British Food Journal 11 224-238 Sohi I, Bell B A, Liu J, Battersby S E, Liese A D, 2014, “Differences in food environment perceptions and spatial attributes of food shopping between residents of low and high food access areas” Journal of Nutrition Education and Behaviour 46(4), 241-249. Tesco plc, 2011, “Tesco plc opens its 40th intervention store” available online via http://www.tescoplc.com/index.asp?pageid=17&newsid=387 (Accessed: 30/01/2015) United States Department of Treasury, 2014, “Frequently asked questions on the healthy food financing initiative” available online via http://www.cdfifund.gov/what_we_do/programs_id.asp?programID=7 (Accessed: 07/02/2015) Volpe R, Okrent A, Leibtag, E, 2013, “The effect of supercentre-format stores on the healthfulness of consumers’ grocery purchases” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 95(3) 568-589 Wetherspoon D, Oehmke J, Dembélé A, Coleman M, Satimanon T, Wetherspoon L, 2013, “Price and expenditure elasticities for fresh fruits in an urban food desert” Urban Studies 50 88-106 Wingert K, Zachary D A, Fox M, Gittelsohn J, Surkan P J, 2014, “Child as change agent. The potential of children to increase healthy food purchasing” Appetite 81 330-336 Wrigley N, Warm D, Margetts B, Whelan A, 2002a, “Assessing the impact of improved retail access on diet in a ‘food desert’: A preliminary report” Urban Studies 39 (11) 2061-2082. Wrigley N, Guy C, Lowe M, 2002, “Urban regeneration, social inclusion and large store development: The Seacroft development in context” Urban Studies 39 (11), 2101-2114. Wrigley N, Warm D, Margetts B, 2003, “Deprivation diet and food-retail access: findings from the Leeds ‘food deserts’ study” Environment and Planning A 35 151-188 Wrigley N, Warm D, Margetts B, Lowe M, 2004a, “The Leeds ‘food deserts’ intervention study: what the focus groups reveal” International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management 32 123-136 Data Sources: Ordnance Survey ITN layer Crown Copyright/database right 2007. An Ordnance Survey (Datacentre) supplied service Map of Leeds ©Crown Copyright Ordnance Survey. An EDINA Digimap/JISC supplied service Wrigley N et al, 2004b, “Food deserts in British cities 2000-2001” [Computer file], Colchester Essex: UK Data Archive [Distributor] November 2004 SN: 5056 Computer Packages: ArcGIS ESRI Inc. R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing R Development Core Team Vienna Austria, http://www.R-project.org Koenker R, 2007, “quantreg: Quantile Regression” R package version 4.10, http://www.R-project.org