Evolving patterns of payment methods in Turkish foreign trade

Turkcan, Kemal (2015): Evolving patterns of payment methods in Turkish foreign trade.

Abstract

Serving the global marketplace brings many risks to the firm that they may not have on the domestic side. Apart from financing, trade finance mechanisms assist exporters and importers to mitigate or reduce their risks associated with doing business internationally. The present paper sheds lights on the structure and evaluation of payment methods in international trade as well as their changing composition due to 2008-2009 global financial crisis using a unique bilateral trade finance data from Turkey with 206 countries over the period 2002-2012 at the 2-digit level of ISIC Revision 3. Three key results emerge. First, Turkey’s exports are mainly financed via open account method while the majority of its imports were executed via cash-in advance method. Second, the shares of inter-firm trade finance (open account and cash-in advance) in Turkey’s foreign trade dramatically increased over the period 2002-2012, while the shares of the intermediate trade finance (cash against documents and letter of credit) decreased substantially. Finally, the evidence show that both exporters and importers started to use cash-in advance method, the safest method of payment, more intensively than other methods shortly after the global recession in 2008. Overall, the patterns presented in this paper highlight the fact that Turkish traders are not able to set payment terms that are highly favorable to themselves and bear all risks associated with international trade transactions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Method of payments; Trade finance; Trade credit; Financial crisis; Turkey
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F10 - General; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F14 - Empirical Studies of Trade; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F30 - General

References

Acar, O. (2009), “Evaluations for Trade and Trade Finance in Turkey”, TEPAV Policy Note, July.

Ahn, J. (2011), “A Theory of Domestic and International Trade Finance”, International Monetary Fund Working Papers No.11/262.

Ahn, J. (2013), “Estimating the Direct Impact of Bank Liquidity Shocks on the Real Economy: Evidence from Imports by Letters of Credit in Colombia”, International Monetary Fund, mimeo.

Aldan, A. and O. Y. Çulha (2013), “The Role of Extensive Margin in Exports of Turkey: A Comparative Analysis”, Central Bank of Turkey Working Paper No.13/32.

Amiti, M. and D. E. Weinstein (2011), “Exports and Financial Shocks”, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(4), 1841-1877.

Antras, P. and C. F. Foley (2013), “Poultry in Motion: A Study of International Trade Finance Practices”, Harward University, mimeo.

Asmundson, I., Dorsey, T., Khachatryan, A., Niculcea, I. and M. Saito (2011), “Trade and Trade Finance in the 2008-2009 Financial Crisis”, International Monetary Fund, Washington, D.C., IMF Working Paper No.11/16.

Auboin, M. (2007), “Boosting Trade Finance in Developing Countries: What Link with the WTO?”, WTO Staff Working Paper ERSD No. 2007-04.

Auboin, M. and M. Engemann (2013), “Trade Finance in Periods of Crisis: What Have We Learned in Recent Years?, WTO Staff Working Paper ERSD No.2013-01.

Auboin, M. and M. Engemann (2014), “Testing the Trade Credit and Trade Link: Evidence from Data on Export Credit Insurance”, Review of World Economics, 150(4), 715-743.

Badinger, H. and T. Url (2013), “Export Credit Guarantees and Export Performance: Evidence from Austrian Firm-Level Data”, The World Economy, 36, 1115–1130.

Baldwin, R. (2009), “The Great Trade Collapse: What Caused It and What Does It Mean?”, In: Richard Baldwin (Ed.), The Great Trade Collapse: Causes, Consequences and Prospects. London: Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR), p. 1-14.

Bastos, R. and J. Pindado (2013), “Trade Credit during a Financial Crisis: A Panel Data Analysis”, Journal of Business Research, 66, 614-620.

Behrens, K., Corcos, G., and G. Mion (2013), “Trade Crisis? What Trade Crisis?”, The Review of Economics and Statistics, 95(2), 702-709.

Biais, B., and C. Gollier (1997), “Trade Credit and Credit Rationing”, Review of Financial Studies, 10 (4), 903–937.

BIS (Bank for International Settlements) (2014), “Trade Finance: Developments and Issues”, Committee on the Global Financial System Papers No.50, Basel, Switzerland.

Bricongne, J-C., Fontagne, L., Gaulier, G., Taglioni, D., and V. Vicard (2012), “Firms and the Global Crisis: French Exports in Turmoil”, Journal of International Economics, 87 (1), 134-146.

Burkart, M., and T. Ellingsen (2004), “In-Kind Finance: A Theory of Trade Credit”, American Economic Review, 94 (3), 569–590.

Chauffour, J.-P. and T. Farole (2009), “Trade Finance in Crisis: Market Adjustment or Market Failure?”, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series No.5003.

Chor, D. and K. Manova (2012), “Off the Cliff and Back? Credit Conditions and International Trade during the Global Financial Crisis”, Journal of International Economics, 87(1), 117-133.

Contessi,S. and F. Nicola (2012), “What Do We Know about the Relationship between Access to Finance and International Trade?”, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Working Papers No. 2012-054.

Cunat, V. (2007), “Suppliers as Debt Collectors and Insurance Providers”, Review of Financial Studies, 20, 491–527.

Demir, B. (2014), “Trade Financing: Challenges for Developing-country Exporters”, CESifo Forum 15 (3), 2014, 34-38.

Demir, B. and B. Javorcik (2014), “Grin and Bear It: Producer-financed Exports from an Emerging Market”, CEPR Discussion Paper No. DP10142.

Eck, K. (2012), “The Effect of Cash-In-Advance Financing on Exporting during the Recent Financial Crisis-Firm Level Evidence from Europe and Central Asia”, Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics, mimeo.

Eck, K., Engemann, M. and M. Schnitzer (2012), “How Trade Credits Foster International Trade”, Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics (BGPE) Discussion Paper No.116.

Egger, P. and T. Url (2006), “Public Export Guarantees and Foreign Trade Structure: Evidence from Austria”, The World Economy, 29(4), 399-418.

Ellingsen, T. and J. Vlachos (2009), “Trade Finance in a Liquidity Crisis”, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series No.5136.

Engemann, M., Eck, K and M. Schnitzer (2011), “Trade Credits and Bank Credits in International Trade: Substitutes or Complements?”, Bavarian Graduate Program in Economics (BGPE) Discussion Paper No.118.

Felbermayr, G. and E. Yalcin (2013), “Export Credit Guarantees and Export Performance: An Empirical Analysis for Germany”, The World Economy, 36(8), 967–999.

Giannetti, M., Burkart, M., and T. Ellingsen (2011), “What You Sell is What You Lend? Explaining Trade Credit Contracts”, Review of Financial Studies, 24 (4), p. 1261–1298.

Glady, N. and J. Potin (2011), “Bank Intermediation and Default Risk in International Trade-Theory and Evidence”, ESSEC Business School Working Paper.

Gros, D. and C. Selçuki (2013), “The Changing Structure of Turkey's Trade and Industrial Competitiveness: Implications for the EU”, Centre for European Policy Studies (CEPS) Working Paper Series No.03.

Hoefele, A., Schmidt-Eisenlohr, T. and Z. Yu (2013), “Payment Choice in International Trade: Theory and Evidence from Cross-Country Firm Level Data”, CESifo Working Paper No. 4350.

Iacovone, L. and Z. Zavacka (2009), “Banking Crises and Exports: Lessons from the Past?”, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No.5016.

ICC (International Chamber of Commerce) (2009), “Rethinking Trade Finance 2009: An ICC Global Survey”, Banking Commission Market Intelligence Report, ICC, Paris.

ICC (International Chamber of Commerce) (2010), “Rethinking Trade Finance 2010: An ICC Global Survey”, Banking Commission Market Intelligence Report, ICC, Paris.

IMF-BAFT (International Monetary Fund-Bankers’ Association for Finance and Trade). (2009), “IMF-BAFT Trade Finance Survey: A Survey among Banks Assessing the Current Trade Finance Environment”, Report by FImetrix for IMF and BAFT, Washington, DC.

ITA (International Trade Administration) (2012), “Trade Finance Guide: A Quick Reference for U.S. Exporters”, U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, DC.

ITC (International Trade Centre) (2009), “How to Access to Trade Finance: A Guide for Exporting SMEs”, Geneva, Switzerland.

Kaminski, B. and F. Ng (2006), “Turkey's Evolving Trade Integration into Pan-European Markets”, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series No.3908.

Kalkan, S. and H.E. Cünedioğlu (2010), “Did Turkey’s Economy Recover from the Crisis? Did We Out-Compete Rivals?”, TEPAV Policy Note No. N201029.

Klapper, L., Laeven, L. and R. Rajan (2012), “Trade Credit Contracts”, Review of Financial Studies, 25(3), 838-867.

Levchenko, A. A., Lewis, L. T. and L. L. Tesar (2010), “The Collapse of International Trade during the 2008-2009 Crisis: In Search of the Smoking Gun”, NBER Working Papers No.16006.

Long, M., Malitz, I., and A. Ravid (1993), “Trade Credit, Quality Guarantees, and Product Marketability”, Financial Management, 22, 117–127.

Love, I. (2013), “Role of Trade Finance”, In: Gerard Caprio (Ed.), The Evidence and Impact of Financial Globalization, Oxford: Elsevier Inc., 199-212.

Malouche, M. (2009a), “Trade and Trade Finance Developments in 14 Developing Countries Post September 2008”, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No.5138.

Malouche, M. (2009b), “World Bank Firm and Bank Surveys in 14 Developing Countries, 2009 and 2010”, In: Jean-Pierre Chauffour and Mariem Malaouche (Ed.), Trade Finance during the Great Trade Collapse. World Bank, Washington, DC, 173-199.

Manova, K. (2013), “Credit Constraints, Heterogeneous Firms and International Trade”, National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper No. 14531.

Mateut, S. (2012), “Reverse Trade Credit or Default Risk? Explaining the Use of Prepayments by Firms”, Nottingham University Business School Research Paper No.2012-05.

Mateut, S. and P. Zanchettin (2013), “Credit Sales and Advance Payments: Substitutes or Complements?”, Economics Letters, 118(1), 173-176.

Menichini, A. M. (2009), “Inter-Firm Trade Finance in Times of Crisis”, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper Series No.5112.

Mora, J., and W. Powers (2011), “Global Perspectives in the Decline of Trade Finance”, In: Jean-Pierre Chauffour and Mariem Malaouche (Ed.), Trade Finance during the Great Trade Collapse. World Bank, Washington, DC, 117-133.

Moser, C., Nestmann, T. and M. Wedo (2008), “Political Risk and Export Promotion: Evidence from Germany”, The World Economy, 31(6), 781-803.

Ng, C.K., Smith, J.K. and R. Smith (1999), “Evidence on the Determinants of Credit Terms Used in Interfirm Trade”, Journal of Finance, 54 (3), p.1109–1129.

Niepmann, F. and T. Schmidt-Eisenlohr (2013), “International Trade, Risk and Role of Banks”, Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staff Reports No.633.

Olsen, M. (2013), “How Firms Overcome Weak International Contract Enforcement: Repeated Interaction, Collective Punishment and Trade Finance”, University of Navarra, IESE Business School, mimeo.

Paravisini, D., Rappoport, V., Schnabl, P. and D. Wolfenzon (2011), “Dissecting the Effect of Credit Supply on Trade: Evidence from Matched Credit-Export Data”, NBER Working Papers No.16975.

Saygılı, H. and M. Saygılı (2011), “Structural Changes in Exports of an Emerging Economy: Case of Turkey”, Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 22, 342–360.

Schmidt-Eisenlohr, T. (2013), “Towards a Theory of Trade Finance”, Journal of International Economics, 91(1), 96-112.

Türkcan, K. (2014), “Investigating The Role of Extensive Margin, Intensive Margin, Price and Quantity Components on Turkey’s Export Growth during 1998-2011”, Turkish Economic Association Discussion Paper No.2014/2.

Van der Veer, K. J. M. (2014), “The Private Export Credit Insurance Effect On Trade”, The Journal of Risk and Insurance, doi: 10.1111/jori.12034.