Inhibited privatization: a hurdle race over vested interests

Senderski, Marcin (2015): Inhibited privatization: a hurdle race over vested interests. Published in: European Journal of Government and Economics , Vol. 4, No. 1 (2015): pp. 46-66.

Abstract

This paper recognizes vested interests as one of the primary premises that reduce the effectiveness of privatization policy, stall its momentum and produce structural problems in the long-run. Both exogenous and endogenous drawbacks are cited, but the main focus is put on the dynamism of vested interests’ character, interconnectedness and evolution. Policy makers have been long aware of the existence of activities rooted in vested interests including empire building behaviors, creation of sinecures or extravagant management style. Hence, the fundamental effort here is put on the identification of emerging vested interests that were typically not considered by scholars. The channels through which conventional vested interests have snowballed over time are emphasized. This includes casting a closer glance at family employment, as well as at sports sponsorship arrangements, which emerge as the favorite domain of marketing activity for Polish state-owned enterprises. The research of available literature is performed, along with its application to the Polish case, and insightful observations concerning the anatomy of privatization-related reluctance. Rough policy recommendations conclude the paper.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Privatization; Poland; vested interests; state-owned enterprises
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D72 - Political Processes: Rent-Seeking, Lobbying, Elections, Legislatures, and Voting Behavior; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D73 - Bureaucracy ; Administrative Processes in Public Organizations ; Corruption; L - Industrial Organization > L3 - Nonprofit Organizations and Public Enterprise > L33 - Comparison of Public and Private Enterprises and Nonprofit Institutions ; Privatization ; Contracting Out

References

Agarwal, Jamuna P., Nunnenkamp, Peter. (1992) ‘Methods and Sequencing of Privatization: What Post-socialist Countries Can Learn from Chile’, Kiel Institute for the World Economy, Kiel Working Paper No. 527.

Alesina, Alberto F., Tabellini, Guido. (2004) ‘Bureaucrats or Politicians?’, Center for Economic Studies & Ifo Institute for Economic Research, Working Paper Series No. 1130.

Andreff, Wladimir. (2006) ‘New Perspectives in Sports Economics: A European View’, AIES/IASE, Working Paper Series No. 06-05.

Andreff, Wladimir. (2008) ‘Globalization of the Sports Economy’, Rivista di Diritto ed Economia dello Sport 4(3):13-32.

Bauer, Johannes M. (2003) ‘The Coexistence of Regulation, State Ownership and Competition in Infrastructure Industries: Quagmire or Institutional Innovation’, Quello Center for Telecommunication Management and Law, Working Paper 003-2003.

Bel, Germà, Fageda, Xavier. (2008) ‘Local Privatization, Intermunicipal Cooperation, Transaction Costs and Political Interests: Evidence from Spain’, Research Institute of Applied Economics, Working Paper No. 2008/04.

Bel, Germà, Fageda, Xavier. (2009) ‘Factors Explaining Local Privatization: A Meta-regression Analysis’, Public Choice 139(1):105-119.

Bjørnskov, Christian, Potrafke, Niklas. (2011) ‘Politics and Privatization in Central and Eastern Europe: A Panel Data Analysis’, Economics of Transition 19(2):201-230.

Bortolotti, Bernardo, Faccio, Mara. (2004) ‘Reluctant Privatization’, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei, Working Paper No. 2004.130.

Bortolotti, Bernardo, Pinotti, Paolo. (2003) ‘The Political Economy of Privatization’, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei, Working Paper No. 2003.45.

Bortolotti, Bernardo, Pinotti, Paolo. (2008) ‘Delayed Privatization’, Bank of Italy, Working Paper No. 663.

Boycko, Maxim, Shleifer, Andrei, Vishny, Robert B. (1996) ‘A Theory of Privatization’, Economic Journal 106(435):309-319.

Campos, Nauro F., Coricelli, Fabrizio. (2002) ‘Growth in Transition: What We Know, What We Don’t, and What We Should’, William Davidson Institute, Working Paper No. 470.

Careja, Romana, Emmenegger, Patrick. (2009) ‘The Politics of Public Spending in Post-communist Countries’, East European Politics and Societies 23(2):165-184.

Castater, Nichole M. (2002) ‘Privatization as a Means to Societal Transformation: An Empirical Study of Privatization in Central and Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union’, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei, Working Paper 2002.76.

Central Statistical Office in Poland [GłównyUrządStatystyczny]. (2009) ‘Prywatyzacjaprzedsiębiorstwpaństwowych w 2008 r.’ [Privatization of state-owned enterprises in 2008], Warsaw.

Centrum BadaniaOpiniiSpołecznej [Public Opinion Research Center]. (2012) ‘Polacy o nepotyzmie w życiupublicznym’ [Opinions About Nepotism in Public Life],Research report no. BS/124/2012.

Checchi, Daniele, Florio, Massimo, Carrera, Jorge. (2006) ‘Privatization Discontent and its Determinants: Evidence from Latin America’, IZA Discussion Paper No. 1587.

Cheng, Xiaonong. (2012) ‘The Self-empowered New Master at the Workplace: Privatization in Russia and China’, Department of Sociology at Princeton University, November, mimeo.

Christiansen, Hans. (2011) ‘The Size and Composition of the SOE Sector in OECD Countries’, OECD Corporate Governance, Working Paper No. 5.

Christiansen, Hans. (2013) ‘Balancing Commercial and Non-commercial Priorities of State-owned Enterprises’, OECD Corporate Governance, Working Paper No. 6.

Denisova, Irina, Eller, Markus, Fryeand, Timothy, Zhuravskaya, Ekaterina. (2010) ‘Everyone Hates Privatization, but why? Survey Evidence from 28 Post-communist Countries’, Centre for Economic and Financial Research at New Economic School, Working Paper No. 143.

Dinç, Serdar, Gupta, Nandini. (2011) ‘The Decision to Privatize: Finance and Politics’, Journal of Finance 66(1):241-269.

Earle, John S., Gehlbach, Scott. (2002) ‘A Spoonful of Sugar: Privatization and Popular Support for Reform in the Czech Republic’, Upjohn Institute Staff, Working Paper No. 02–79.

Estrin, Saul, Hanousek, Jan, Kocenda, Evzen, Svejnar, Jan. (2007) ‘Effects of Privatization and Ownership in Transition Economies’, IPC Working Paper Series No. 30.

Faccio, Mara. (2010) ‘Differences Between Politically Connected and Nonconnected firms: A cross-country Analysis’, Financial Management 39(3):905–928.

Farrelly, Francis J., Quester, Pascale G., Burton, Richard. (1997) ‘Integrating Sports Sponsorship into the Corporate Marketing Function: An International Comparative Study’, International Marketing Review 14(3):170-182.

Fischer, Stanley, Sahay, Ratna. (2000) ‘The Transition Economies After Ten Years’, National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 7664.

Gabris, Gerald T., Simo, Gloria. (1995) ‘Public Sector Motivation as Independent Variable Affecting Career Decisions’, Public Personnel Management 24(1): 33-51.

Galal, Ahmed, Jones, Leory, Tandon, Pankaj, Vogelsang, Ingo. (1994) Welfare Consequences of Selling Public Enterprises. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Godoy, Sergio, Stiglitz, Joseph E. (2006) ‘Growth, Initial Conditions, Law and Speed of Privatization in Transition Countries: 11 Years Later’, National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 11992.

Goldstein, Andrea, Nicoletti, Giuseppe. (2003) ‘Privatization in Italy 1993-2002: Goals, Institutions, Outcomes, and Outstanding Issues’, Prepared for the CESifo conference on privatization experiences in the EU, held in Munich on 10/11 January 2003.

Gupta, Nandini, Ham, John C., Svejnar, Jan. (2008) ‘Priorities and Sequencing in Privatization: Evidence from Czech Firm Panel Data’, European Economic Review 52:183-208.

Gwiazda, Anna. (2008) ‘Party Patronage in Poland: The Democratic Left Alliance and Law and Justice Compared’, East European Politics and Societies 22(4):802-827.

Hertog, Steffen. (2010) ‘Defying the Resource Curse: Explaining the Successful State-owned Enterprises in Rentier States’, World Politics 62(2):261-301.

Hillman, Amy J. (2005) ‘Politicians on the Board of Directors: Do Connections Affect the Bottom Line?’, Journal of Management 31(3):464-481.

Iimi, Atsushi. (2002) ‘An Empirical Note: Privatization Transaction and Macroeconomy in Developing Countries’, JBICI Working Paper No. 10.

Imai, Masami. (2009) ‘Ideologies, Vested Interest Groups, and Postal Saving Privatization in Japan’, Public Choice 138(1/2):137-160.

Jamasb, Tooraj. (2006) ‘Between the State and Market: Electricity Sector Reform in Developing Countries’, Utilities Policy 14(1): 14-30.

Kapstein, Ethan B., Milanovic, Branko. (2000) ‘Dividing the Spoils: Pensions, Privatization, and Reform in Russia’s Transition’, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2292.

Khwaja, AsimIjaz, Mian, Atif. (2005) ‘Do Lenders Favor Politically Connected Firms? Rent Provision in an Emerging Financial Market’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 120(4):1371-1411.

Kowalik, Tadeusz. (1991) ‘Marketization and Privatization: The Polish Case’, in Miliband, Ralph, Panitch, Leo. (eds.) Communist Regimes: The Aftermath, London: Merlin, pp. 259-278.

Kozarzewski, Piotr. (2008) ‘Corporate Governance Formation in Poland, Kyrgyzstan, Russia and Ukraine’, in McGee, Robert W. (eds.) Corporate Governance in Transition Economics, London: Springer, pp. 251-288.

Krusell, Per, Rios-Rull, Jose-Victor. (1996) ‘Vested Interests in a Positive Theory of Stagnation and Growth’, The Review of Economic Studies 63(2):301-329.

Lewis, David E. (2009) ‘Patronage Appointments in the Modern Presidency: Evidence from a Survey of Federal Executives’, Vanderbilt Law and Economics Research Paper No. 09-24, Vanderbilt Public Law Research Paper No. 09-20.

Li, David D., Lui, Francis T. (2004) ‘Why Do Governments Dump State Enterprises: Evidence from China’, in Takatoshi Ito and Anne O. Krueger (eds) Governance, regulation, and privatization in the Asia-Pacific region, NBER East Asia Seminar on Economics 12:211-230.

Lipton, David, Sachs, Jeffrey. (1990) ‘Privatization in Eastern Europe: The Case of Poland’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 2:293-341.

Majcherkiewicz, Tatiana, Gadowska, Kaja. (2005) ‘Political Clientelism in Public Administration: A Case Study of Institutional Changes in the Post-communist State of Poland’, Paper presented at the 13th NISPAcee Annual Conference: “Democratic Governance for the XXI Century: Challenges and Responses in CEE Countries”, 19-21 May 2005, Moscow.

Megginson, William L., Bortolotti, Bernardo. (2011) ‘Privatization Trends and Major Deals in 2010 and 1H2011’,URL (consulted May 2014): http://ssrn.com/abstract=2136780.

Megginson, William L., Nash, Robert C., van Randenborgh, Matthias. (1994) ‘The Financial and Operating Performance of Newly Privatized Firms: An International Empirical Analysis’, The Journal of Finance 49(2):403-452.

Megginson, William L., Netter, Jeffry M. (1998) ‘From State to Market: A Survey of Empirical Studies on Privatization’, NYSE Working Paper 98-05.

Micek, Grzegorz, Neo, Harvey, Górecki, Janusz. (2011) ‘Foreign Direct Investment, Institutional Context and the Changing Polish Pig Industry’, GeografiskaAnnaler: Series B, Human Geography 93(1):41-55.

Ministry of Treasury in Poland. (2005) ‘Raport o przekształceniachwłasnościowych w 2004 roku’ [Report on ownership transformation in 2004], Warsaw: Author.

Money.pl. (2008) ‘Polskaustawakominowajedyna w krajach UE’ [Polish „chimney bill” is the only one in the EU], URL (consulted March 2014): http://prawo.money.pl/

aktualnosci/wiadomosci/artykul/polska;ustawa;kominowa;jedyna;w;krajach;ue,120,0,330360.html.

Moors, Kent F. (1997) ‘The Failure of Russian Privatization 1992-1994: How the Industrial Nomenklatura Prevented Genuine Reform’, Journal of International Legal Studies 3(1):1-52.

Newton, Ashley N., Uysal, Vahap B. (2013) The Impact of Political Connectedness on Firm Value and Corporate Policies: Evidence from Citizens United. Mimeo: University of Oklahoma.

Nowakowski, Krzysztof. (2005) ‘Problems of Clientelism and Corruption in Poland’, Review of Sociology 11(2):75-86.

Olofsgård, Anders. (2003) ‘The Political Economy of Reform: Institutional Change as a Tool for Political Credibility’, Background paper to the World Bank’s 2005 World Development Report.

Open Society Institute. (2002) ‘Corruption and Anti-corruption Policy in Poland’, in Monitoring the EU accession process: Corruption and anti-corruption policy, New York: Author, pp. 393-450.

Opper, Sonja. (2004) ‘The Political Economy of Privatization: Empirical Evidence from Transition Economies’, Kyklos 57(4):559-586.

Radwan, Arkadiusz, Regucki, Tomasz. (2012) ‘The Possibilities For and Barriers to Sustainable Companies in Polish Company Law’, University of Oslo Faculty of Law Research Paper No. 2012-32.

Raszewski, Sławomir. (2012) ‘Security and the Economics of Energy in North East Europe’, in Kuzemko, Caroline, Belyi, Andrei, Goldthau, Andreas, Keating, Michael F. (eds) Dynamics of energy governance in Europe and Russia, London: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 130-148.

Rattsø, Jørn, Sørensen, Rune J. (2012) ‘Political Control of Government Enterprises: Who Controls Whom?’, Norwegian University of Science and Technology and Norwegian Business School.

Roland, Gérard. (2000) Transition and Economics. London and Cambridge: MIT Press.

Roland, Gérard. (2001) ‘Corporate Governance Systems and Restructuring: The Lessons from the Transition Experience’, in Annual Bank Conference on Development Economics 2000. Washington: World Bank, pp. 331–352.

Rondinelli, Dennis A., Yurkiewicz, Jay B. (1996) ‘Privatization and Economic Restructuring in Poland: An Assessment of Transition Policies’, American Journal of Economics and Sociology 55(2):145-160.

Rosa, Jean-Jacques, Pérard, Edouard. (2010) ‘When to Privatize? When to Nationalize? A Competition for Ownership Approach’, Kyklos 63(1):110-132.

RynekInfrastruktury.pl. (2012) ‘Rząd pracuje nad zmianami w ustawie kominowej.Ekspercichcąjejlikwidacji’ [The government plans to update the „chimney bill”. Experts demand their abolition], 19 July, URL (consulted March 2014): http://www.rynekinfrastruktury.pl/artykul/112/1/rzad-pracuje-nad-zmianami-w-ustawie-kominowej-eksperci-chca-jej-likwidacji.html.

Santalainen, Timo J., Baliga, Ram B., Leimann, Jaak. (2003) ‘Straddling for Market Space: Transforming Estonian State-owned Enterprises Toward a Free-market Orientation’, International Business & Economics Research Journal 2(9):75-87.

Schindele, Ibolya. (2003) ‘Theory of Privatization in Eastern Europe: Literature Review’, Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei, Working Paper No. 2003.2.

Schoenman, Roger. (2005) ‘Captains or Pirates? State-business Relations in Post-socialist Poland’, East European Politics and Societies 19(1):40-75.

Shafik, Nemat. (1996) ‘Selling Privatization Politically’, International Journal of the Economics of Business 3(3):367-378.

Shleifer, Andrei, Vishny, Robert W. (1994) ‘Politicians and Firms’, Quarterly Journal of Economics 109(4):995-1025.

Šikulová, Ivana, Frank, Karol. (2013) ‘The Slovak Experience with Transition to Market Economy’, Ekonomický ústav SAV Working Paper No. 49.

Singh, Nirvikar. (2010) ‘The Dynamics and Status of India’s Economic Reforms’, MPRA Paper No. 24479.

Stark, David. (1990) ‘Privatization in Hungary: From Plan to Market or from Plan to Clan’, East European Politics and Societies 4(3):351-392.

Stiglitz, Joseph. (2002) Globalization and its Discontents. London: Penguin Books.

Tache, Ileana. (2008) The Mass Privatization Process in Romania: A Case of Failed Anglo-Saxon Capitalism. Mimeo: Transilvania University of Brasov.

Tirole, Jean. (1991) ‘Privatization in Eastern Europe: Incentives and the Economics of Transition’, in Blanchard, Olivier J., Fisher, Stanley. (eds) NBER Macroeconomics Annual 1991, 6, Cambridge: MIT Press.

Van de Walle, Nicolas. (1989) ‘Privatization in Developing Countries: A Review of the Issues’, World Development 17(5):601-615.

Vickers, John, Yarrow, George. (1989) Privatisation: An Economic Analysis. London: MIT Press.

Vitkus, Gediminas. (2009) ‘Russian Pipeline Diplomacy: A Lithuanian Response’, Acta Slavica Iaponica 26:25-46.

Wallsten, Scott J. (2002) ‘Does Sequencing Matter? Regulation and Privatization in Telecommunications Reforms’, Development Research Group, World Bank.

Warner, Mildredand, Hebdon, Robert. (2001) ‘Local Government Restructuring: Privatization and its Alternatives’, Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 20(2):315-336.

Warsaw Stock Exchange. (2011) ‘Code of best practice for WSE listed companies:Appendix to Resolution No. 20/1287/2011 of the Exchange Supervisory Board’, 19 October 2011, URL (consulted May 2014): http://www.corp-gov.gpw.pl/assets/library/english/

regulacje/bestpractices%2019_10_2011_en.pdf.

Watts, Michael, Walstad, William B., Skiba, Alexander. (2002) ‘Attitudes Toward Markets and Market Reforms in the Former Soviet Union and Eastern Europe’, in Watts, Michael, Walstad, William B. (eds.) Reforming economics and economics teaching in the transition economies: From Marx to markets in the classroom, Cheltenham and Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp. 8-34.

Wu, Jianfeng, Liu Cheng, Menita. (2011) ‘The Impact of Managerial Political Connections and Quality on Government Subsidies: Evidence from Chinese Listed firms’, Chinese Management Studies 5(2):207-226.

Yusuf, Shahid. (2009) Development Economics Through the Decades: A Critical Look at Thirty Years of the World Development Report. Washington, DC: World Bank.

Zinnes, Clifford, Eilat, Yiar, Sachs, Jeffrey. (2001) ‘The Gains from Privatization in Transition Economies: Is “Change of Ownership” Enough?’, IMF Staff Papers 48(Special Issue):146-170.