When measure matters: coresident sample selection bias in estimating intergenerational mobility in developing countries

Emran, M. Shahe and Greene, William H and Shilpi, Forhad (2015): When measure matters: coresident sample selection bias in estimating intergenerational mobility in developing countries.

Abstract

Potential biases from coresident sample selection have been a major stumbling block for research on intergenerational mobility in developing countries. We use two rich data sets from Bangladesh and India to provide evidence on the extent of coresidency bias in standard measures of intergenerational mobility: intergenerational regression coefficient (IGRC) and intergenerational correlation (IGC). Estimates for all children, father-son, and mother-daughter persistence in schooling show that the IGRC estimates are severely biased downward (average 30 percent). In contrast, the bias in IGC estimates is much lower (average less than 10 percent, in many cases less than 5 percent). Truncation due to coresidency criterion in a survey biases the IGRC estimate downward, but it also biases upward the estimate of the ratio of the standard deviations of parental to children's schooling. The IGC estimate suffers from lower bias because the upward bias in the estimate of the ratio of standard deviations partly cancels out the downward bias in the IGRC estimate. The evidence suggests that the available household surveys in developing countries can be fruitfully used to understand intergenerational mobility if one focuses on IGC. The findings have important implications for cross-country comparison of intergenerational economic mobility.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Coresidency, Sample Selection Bias, Intergenerational Mobility, Intergenerational Regression Coefficient (IGRC), Intergenerational Correlation (IGC), Bangladesh, India
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development

References

Arrow, K, S. Bowles, S. Durlauf (2000). Meritocracy and Economic Inequality, Princeton University Press.

Asadullah, M Niaz, 2012. Intergenerational Wealth Mobility in Rural Bangladesh, Journal of Development Studies, Taylor and Francis Journals, vol. 48(9), pages 1193-1208, September.

Asadullah, M. Niaz, and Y. Gaston, 2012. Inequality of Educational Opportunity in India: Changes Over Time and Across States, World Development, Elsevier, vol. 40(6), pages 1151-1163.

Assaad R. and Saleh M. (2013), Does Improved Local Supply of Schooling Enhance Intergenerational Mobility in Education? Evidence from Jordan, Working Paper 788, The Economic Research Forum, Egypt.

Bardhan, P (2010). Awakening Giants, Feet of Clay: Assessing the Economic Rise of China and India}, Princeton University Press.

Bardhan, P (2013), The State of Indian Economic Statistics: Data Quantity and Quality Issues, Mimeo, Berkeley, CA.

Becket, Gary S. and Nigel Tomes (1979), An equilibrium theory of the distribution of income and intergenerational mobility, Journal of Political Economy 87:1153-1189.

Binder, Melissa and Christopher Woodruff. 2002. Inequality and Intergenerational Mobility in Schooling: The Case of Mexico. Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 50, Iss. 2, pp. 249-267.

Bossuroy, T and Denis Cogneau, 2013. Social Mobility in Five African Countries, Review of Income and Wealth, vol. 59, pages S84-S110, October.

Behrman, J., A. Gaviria and M. Szekely (2001), Intergenerational Mobility in Latin America, Economia, Vol. 2 (1): 1 44.

Benjamin, D., L. Brandt, and J. Giles. 2005. The Evolution of Income Inequality in Rural China. Economic Development and Cultural Change 53 (4): 769824.

Benjamin, Dwayne, Loren Brant, John Giles, and Sangui Wang. 2008. Income inequality during China’s Economic Transition, in Brandt, Loren; Rawski, G. Thomas, China’s Great Transformation, Cambridge: Cambridge university press

Bjorklund A and K. Salvanes. (2011). “Education and Family Background: Mechanisms and Policies,” Handbook in the Economics of Education vol 3, E A Hanushek, S Machin and L Woessmann (es.), The Netherlands: North Holland, 2011, pp. 201-247.

Black, S. E. and P. Devereux (2011). ``Recent Developments in Intergenerational Mobility”, Handbook of Labor Economics, Amsterdam, North-Holland.

Black, Sandra E., Paul J. Devereux and Kjell G. Salvanes (2005), Why the apple does not fall far: Understanding intergenerational transmission of human capital, American Economic Review 95: 437-449.

Blanden, J, P. Gregg, S. Machin (2005). Intergenrational Mobility in Europe and North America, Center For Economic Performance Report, April, 2005.

Bowles, Samuel (1972), ``Schooling and inequality from generation to generation'', Journal of Political Economy 80: 219-251.

Cohen, A (1991), Truncated and Censored Samples: Theory and Applications, CRC Press.

Corak, M and A. Heisz (1999), ``The Intergenerational Earnings and Income Mobility of Canadian Men: Evidence from Longitudinal Income Tax Data”, Journal of Human Resources. Volume 34, Number 3 (Summer), pages 504-533.

Deaton, A (1997), The analysis of household surveys: A microeconometric approach to development policy. Oxford University Press.

Dreze, J and A. Sen (2011), ``Putting Growth In Its Place: It has to be but a means to development, not an end in itself”, Outlook India.com, Nov 14, 2011.

Dreze, J and A. Sen (2013), An Uncertain Glory: India and Its Contradictions, Princeton University Press.

Emran, M. Shahe and F. Shilpi (2011). ``Intergenerational Occupational Mobility in Rural Economy: Evidence from Nepal and Vietnam'', Journal of Human Resources, issue 2, 2011.

Emran, M. Shahe and F. Shilpi (2015). ``Gender, geography and generations: intergenerational educational mobility in post-reform India'', World Development, Vol. 72, 362-380.

Greene, W (2012), Limited Dependent Variables - Truncation, Censoring, and Sample Selection, Chapter 19, Econometric Analysis, Pearson.

Hausman, J and D. Wise (1977), ``Social Experimentation, Truncated Distribution, and Efficient Estimation'', Econometrica, May 1977.

Heckman, J. (1979). ``Sample selection bias as a specification error''. Econometrica 47 (1): 153–61.

Hertz Tom, Tamara Jayasundera, Patrizio Piraino, Sibel Selcuk, Nicole Smith and Alina Veraschagina (2007). ``The Inheritance of Educational Inequality: International Comparisons and Fifty-Year Trends”. The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy (Advances), 7(2), Article 10.

Jalan, J. and R. Murgai, (2008). ``Intergenerational Mobility in Education in India”, Manuscript, World Bank, Delhi.

Jushong, Z and R. Kanbur (2012), ``Confronting Rising Inequality in Asia”, Chapter in Asian Development Outlook 2012, ADB.

Kingdon, G (2007). ``The progress of school education in India,'' Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Oxford University Press, vol. 23(2), pages 168-195, Summer.

Knight, John and Lina Song (1999). The Rural-Urban Divide. Economic Disparities and Interactions in China, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lam, David, and Robert F. Schoeni. 1993. Effects of Family Background on Earnings and Returns to Schooling: Evidence from Brazil. Journal of Political Economy 101(4):710 40.

Lillard, Lee and Robert Willis. 1995. ``Intergenerational Educational Mobility, Effects of Family and state in Malaysia''. The Journal of Human resources, Vol. (29), pp 1126-1166.

Lillard, Lee A., and Rebecca. M. Kilburn. 1995. ``Intergenerational Earnings Links: Sons and Daughters.” RAND Working Paper Series 95–17.

Maitra, P and A. Sharma (2010), ``Parents and Children: Education Across Generations in India”, Working paper, Monash University.

Mazmuder, B (2012), ``Is intergenerational economic mobility lower now than in the past?”, Chicago Fed Letter, April 2012.

Mazumder, Bhashkar (2005): Fortunate Sons: New Estimates of Intergenerational Mobility in U.S. Using Social Security Earnings Data, Review of Economics and Statistics, May, 2005.

Pal, S (2006). ``Elderly Health, Wealth and Coresidence with Adult Children in Rural India,'' Economics and Finance Discussion Papers 06-17, Economics and Finance Section, School of Social Sciences, Brunel University.

Rajan, R (2010), Fault Lines, Princeton University Press.

Solon, Gary, 1992. “Intergenerational Income Mobility in the United States, American Economic Review, American Economic Association, vol. 82(3), pages 393-408, June.

Solon, Gary (1999). ``Intergenerational Mobility in the Labor Market,” in O. Ashenfelter and D. Card (eds.), Handbook of Labor Economics 3A, Elsevier, Amsterdam, North Holland.

Stiglitz, Joseph. 2012. The Price of Inequality: How Today’s Divided Society Endangers Our Future. W. W. Norton & Company.

Thomas, D (1996). ``Education across Generations in South Africa'', American Economic Review, American Economic Association, vol. 86(2), pages 330-34, May.