Serial correlation in National Football League play calling and its effects on outcomes

Emara, Noha and Owens, David and Smith, John and Wilmer, Lisa (2014): Serial correlation in National Football League play calling and its effects on outcomes.

Abstract

We investigate the strategic behavior of highly informed agents playing zero-sum games under highly incentivized conditions. We examine data from 3455 National Football League (NFL) games from the 2000 season through the 2012 season, and categorize each play as "rush" or a "pass." We find that the pass-rush mix exhibits negative serial correlation: play types alternate more frequently than an independent stochastic process. This is an exploitable strategy, and we find that this serial correlation negatively affects play efficacy. Our analysis suggests that teams could profit from more clustered play selections, which switch play type less frequently. Our results are consistent with the explanation that teams excessively switch play types in an effort to be perceived as unpredictable.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: serial correlation, game theory, mixed strategies, matching pennies
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C72 - Noncooperative Games; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C93 - Field Experiments; D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D03 - Behavioral Microeconomics: Underlying Principles

References

Alamar, Benjamin C., 2006. "The passing premium puzzle." Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports 2(4), Article 5, 1-8.

Alamar, Benjamin C., 2010. "Measuring risk in NFL playcalling." Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports 6(2), Article 11, 1--7.

Azar, Ofer H. and Michael Bar-Eli, 2011. "Do soccer players play the mixed-strategy Nash equilibrium?" Applied Economics 43(25), 3591--3601.

Bailey, Brett James and Joseph P. McGarrity, 2012. "The Effect of Pressure on Mixed-Strategy Play in Tennis: The Effect of Court Surface on Service Decisions." International Journal of Business and Social Science 3(20), 11--18.

Bar-Eli, Michael, Ofer H. Azar, Ilana Ritov, Yael Keidar-Levin, and Galit Schein, 2007. "Action bias among elite soccer goalkeepers: The case of penalty kicks." Journal of Economic Psychology 28(5), 606--621.

Bar-Hillel, Maya, and Willem A. Wagenaar, 1991. "The perception of randomness." Advances in Applied Mathematics 12(4), 428--454.

Batzilis, Dimitris, Sonia Jaffe, Steven Levitt, John A. List, and Jeffrey Picel, 2014. "How Facebook Can Deepen our Understanding of Behavior in Strategic Settings: Evidence from a Million Rock-Paper-Scissors Games." working paper, Harvard University.

Binmore, Ken, Joe Swierzbinski, and Chris Proulx, 2001. "Does minimax work? An experimental study." Economic Journal 111(473), 445--464.

Brown, James N. and Robert W. Rosenthal, 1990. "Testing the minimax hypothesis: a re-examination of O'Neill's game experiment." Econometrica 58(5), 1065--1081.

Budescu, David V. and Amnon Rapoport, 1994. "Subjective randomization in one-and two-person games." Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 7(4), 261--278.

Bundrick, Jacob and Joseph P. McGarrity, 2014. "Strategic Play in the NFL's Offensive Play Calling." International Advances in Economic Research 20(3), 339--340.

Buzzacchi, Luigi and Stefano Pedrini, 2014. "Does player specialization predict player actions? Evidence from penalty kicks at FIFA World Cup and UEFA Euro Cup." Applied Economics 46(10), 1067--1080.

Chiappori, P-A., Steven Levitt, and Timothy Groseclose, 2002. "Testing mixed-strategy equilibria when players are heterogeneous: the case of penalty kicks in soccer." American Economic Review 92(4), 1138--1151.

Coloma, Germán, 2007. "Penalty Kicks in Soccer An Alternative Methodology for Testing Mixed-Strategy Equilibria." Journal of Sports Economics 8(5), 530--545.

Duffy, Sean, David Owens, and John Smith, 2015. "Cognitive load and mixed strategies." working paper, Rutgers University-Camden.

Geng, Sen, Yujia Peng, Jason Shachat, and Huizhen Zhong, 2015. "Adolescents, cognitive ability, and minimax play." Economics Letters 128, 54--58.

Goldman, Matt and Justin M. Rao, 2013. "Tick Tock Shot Clock: Optimal Stopping in NBA Basketball." working paper, UCSD.

Halpern, Joseph Y. and Rafael Pass, 2015. "Algorithmic rationality: Game theory with costly computation." Journal of Economic Theory 156, 246--268.

Hsu, Shih-Hsun, Chen-Ying Huang, and Cheng-Tao Tang, 2007. "Minimax play at wimbledon: comment." American Economic Review 97(1), 517--523.

Kovash, Kenneth and Steven D. Levitt, 2009. "Professionals do not play minimax: evidence from major League Baseball and the National Football League." working paper, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Levitt, Steven D., John A. List, and David H. Reiley, 2010. "What happens in the field stays in the field: Exploring whether professionals play minimax in laboratory experiments." Econometrica 78(4), 1413--1434.

McGarrity, Joseph P. and Brian Linnen, 2010. "Pass or Run: An Empirical Test of the Matching Pennies Game Using Data from the National Football League." Southern Economic Journal 3, 791--810.

Mookherjee, Dilip and Barry Sopher, 1997. "Learning and decision costs in experimental constant sum games." Games and Economic Behavior 19(1), 97--132.

Mookherjee, Dilip and Barry Sopher, 1994. "Learning Behavior in an Experimental Matching Pennies Game." Games and Economic Behavior 7(1), 62--91.

Ochs, Jack, 1995. "Games with unique, mixed strategy equilibria: An experimental study." Games and Economic Behavior 10(1), 202--217.

Okano, Yoshitaka, 2013. "Minimax play by teams." Games and Economic Behavior 77(1), 168--180.

O'Neill, Barry, 1987. "Nonmetric test of the minimax theory of two-person zerosum games." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 84(7), 2106--2109.

O'Neill, Barry, 1991. "Comments on Brown and Rosenthal's reexamination." Econometrica 59(2), 503--507.

Oskarsson, An T., Leaf Van Boven, Gary H. McClelland, and Reid Hastie, 2009. "What's next? Judging sequences of binary events." Psychological Bulletin 135(2), 262--285.

Palacios-Huerta, Ignacio, 2003. "Professionals play minimax." Review of Economic Studies 70(2), 395--415.

Palacios-Huerta, Ignacio and Oscar Volij, 2008. "Experientia docet: Professionals play minimax in laboratory experiments." Econometrica 76(1), 71--115.

Rabin, Matthew, 2002. "Inference by Believers in the Law of Small Numbers." Quarterly Journal of Economics 117(3), 775--816.

Rapoport, Amnon and Wilfred Amaldoss, 2000. "Mixed strategies and iterative elimination of strongly dominated strategies: an experimental investigation of states of knowledge." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 42(4), 483--521.

Rapoport, Amnon and Wilfred Amaldoss, 2004. "Mixed-strategy play in single-stage first-price all-pay auctions with symmetric players." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 54(4), 585--607.

Rapoport, Amnon and Richard B. Boebel, 1992. "Mixed strategies in strictly competitive games: a further test of the minimax hypothesis." Games and Economic Behavior 4(2), 261--283.

Rapoport, Amnon and David V. Budescu, 1992. "Generation of random series in two-person strictly competitive games." Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 121(3), 352--363.

Reed, Derek D., Thomas S. Critchfield, and Brian K. Martens, 2006. "The generalized matching law in elite sport competition: Football play calling as operant choice." Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis 39(3), 281--297.

Rockerbie, Duane W., 2008. "The passing premium puzzle revisited." Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports 4(2), Article 9, 1--11

Romer, David, 2006. "Do firms maximize? Evidence from professional football." Journal of Political Economy 114(2), 340--365.

Rosenthal, Robert W., Jason Shachat, and Mark Walker, 2003. "Hide and seek in Arizona." International Journal of Game Theory 32(2), 273--293.

Shachat, Jason M., 2002. "Mixed strategy play and the minimax hypothesis." Journal of Economic Theory 104(1), 189--226.

Shachat, Jason and J. Todd Swarthout, 2004. "Do we detect and exploit mixed strategy play by opponents?" Mathematical Methods of Operations Research 59(3), 359--373.

Spiliopoulos, Leonidas, 2012. "Pattern recognition and subjective belief learning in a repeated constant-sum game." Games and Economic Behavior 75(2), 921--935.

Stilling, Stephanie T. and Thomas S. Critchfield, 2010. "The Matching Relation and Situation-Specific Bias Modulation in Professional Football Play Selection." Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior 93(3), 435--454.

Van Essen, Matt, and John Wooders, 2015. "Blind stealing: Experience and expertise in a mixed-strategy poker experiment." Games and Economic Behavior 91, 186--206.

Wagenaar, Willem A., 1972. "Generation of random sequences by human subjects: A critical survey of literature." Psychological Bulletin 77(1), 65--72.

Walker, Mark, John Wooders, and Rabah Amir, 2011. "Equilibrium play in matches: Binary Markov games." Games and Economic Behavior 71(2), 487--502.

Walker, Mark and John Wooders, 2001. "Minimax play at Wimbledon." American Economic Review 91(5), 1521--1538.

Wooders, John, 2010. "Does experience teach? Professionals and minimax play in the lab." Econometrica 78(3), 1143--1154.