Cutthroats or comrades: Information sharing among competing fund managers

Ganglmair, Bernhard and Holcomb, Alex and Myung, Noah (2016): Cutthroats or comrades: Information sharing among competing fund managers.

Abstract

Recent evidence of correlated trading among networked fund managers provides an indication that professional investors exchange investment ideas. To examine the motivations underlying this type of collaboration, we design a laboratory experiment in which competing fund managers share ideas until either chance or one of the fund managers (by choice to obtain a competitive advantage) terminates the exchange. We find that managers are more willing, and likely, to share when their rival's ability and intention to share in return are high. For a manager's decision to share, subjective expectations about rivals' intentions matter more than common expectations about their ability.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: conversation, correlated trading, experimental finance, fund managers, hedge funds, information sharing, word-of-mouth communication
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C7 - Game Theory and Bargaining Theory > C72 - Noncooperative Games; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C91 - Laboratory, Individual Behavior; D - Microeconomics > D8 - Information, Knowledge, and Uncertainty; G - Financial Economics > G0 - General > G02 - Behavioral Finance: Underlying Principles; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G14 - Information and Market Efficiency ; Event Studies ; Insider Trading; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G23 - Non-bank Financial Institutions ; Financial Instruments ; Institutional Investors

References

Abbink, Klaus, and Bettina Rockenbach, 2006, Option Pricing by Students and Professional Traders: A Behavioral Investigation, Managerial and Decision Economics 27, 497-510.

Agarwal, Vikas, and Narayan Y. Naik, 2000, Multi-Period Performance Persistence Analysis of Hedge Funds, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 35, 327-342.

Aghion, Philippe, Stefan Bechtold, Lea Cassar, and Holger Herz, 2014, Causal Effects of Competition on Innovation: Experimental Evidence, Working Paper 19987 National Bureau of Economic Research Cambridge, Mass.

Ahuja, Maneet, 2012, The Alpha Masters: Unlocking the Genius of the World's Top Hedge Funds. (John Wiley & Sons Hoboken, N.J.).

Alevy, Jonathan E., Michael S. Haigh, and John A. List, 2007, Information Cascades: Evidence from a Field Experiment with Financial Market Professionals, Journal of Finance 62, 151-180.

Andrei, Daniel, and Julien Cujean, 2015, Information Percolation, Momentum, and Reversal, unpublished manuscript.

Augenblick, Ned, and Aaron Bodoh-Creed, 2014, To Reveal or Not to Reveal: Privacy Preferences and Economic Frictions, unpublished manuscript. Available: http://faculty.haas.berkeley.edu/ned/ToRevealOrNotToReveal.pdf.

Ben-David, Itzhak, Francesco Franzoni, and Rabih Moussawi, 2012, Hedge Fund Stock Trading in the Financial Crisis of 2007-2009, Review of Financial Studies 25, 1-54.

Berg, Joyce, John Dickhaut, and Kevin McCabe, 1995, Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History, Games and Economic Behavior 10, 122-142.

Bolton, Gary E., and Axel Ockenfels, 2000, A Theory of Equity, Reciprocity, and Competition, American Economic Review 90, 166-193.

Brown, Jeffrey R., Zoran Ivkovi'c, Paul A. Smith, and Scott Weisbenner, 2008, Neighbors Matter: Causal Community Effects and Stock Market Participation, Journal of Finance 63, 1509-1531.

Camerer, Colin F., 2015, The Promise and Success of Lab-Field Generalizability in Experimental Economics: A Critical Reply to Levitt and List, in Guillaume R. Fr'echette, small and Andrew Schotter, eds.: Handbook of Experimental Economic Methodology (Oxford University Press, New York, N.Y.).

Cohen, Lauren, Andrea Frazzini, and Christopher Malloy, 2008, The Small World of Investing: Board Connections and Mutual Fund Returns, Journal of Political Economy 116, 951-979.

Cohn, Alain, Jan Engelmann, Ernst Fehr, and Michel Andr'e Mar'echal, 2015, Evidence for Countercyclical Risk Aversion: An Experiment with Financial Professionals, American Economic Review 105, 860-885.

Colla, Paolo, and Antonio Mele, 2010, Information Linkages and Correlated Trading, Review of Financial Studies 23, 203-246.

Cooper, David, 2006, Are Experienced Managers Experts at Overcoming Coordination Failure?, Advances in Economic Analysis and Policy 6, 1-30.

Cooper, David J, John H Kagel, Wei Lo, and Qing Liang Kagel, John H., 1999, Gaming against Managers in Incentive Systems: Experimental Results with Chinese Students and Chinese Managers, The American Economic Review 89, 781-804.

Crawford, Steven S., Wesley R. Gray, and Andrew E. Kern, forthcoming, Why Do Fund Managers Identify and Share Profitable Ideas?, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis.

Dal B'o, Pedro, and Guillaume R. Fr'echette, 2011, The Evolution of Cooperation in Infinitely Repeated Games: Experimental Evidence, American Economic Review 101, 411-429.

Dow, James, and Gary Gorton, 1994, Arbitrage Chains, Journal of Finance 49, 819-849.

Duffie, Darrell, and Gustavo Manso, 2007, Information Percolation in Large Markets, American Economic Review 97, 203-209.

Dziuda, Wioletta, and Ronen Gradwohl, 2015, Achieving Coordination under Privacy Concerns, American Economic Journal: Microeconomics 7, 142-173.

Engle-Warnick, Jim, and Robert L. Slonim, 2006, Learning to Trust in Indefinitely Repeated Games, Games and Economic Behavior 54, 95-114.

Fehr, Ernst, Georg Kirchsteiger, and Arno Riedl, 1993, Does Fairness Prevent Market Clearing? An Experimental Investigation, Quarterly Journal of Economics 108, 437-459.

Fehr, Ernst, and Klaus M. Schmidt, 1999, A Theory of Fairness, Competition, and Cooperation, Quarterly Journal of Economics 114, 817-868.

Fehr, Ernst, and Klaus M. Schmidt, 2006, The Economics of Fairness, Reciprocity and Altruism: Experimental Evidence and New Theories, in Serge-Christophe Kolm, small and Jean Mercier Ythier, eds.: Handbook of the Economics of Giving, Altruism and Reciprocity (North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands).

Feng, Lei, and Mark S. Seasholes, 2004, Correlated Trading and Location, Journal of Finance 59, 2117-2144.

Fischbacher, Urs, 2007, z-Tree: Zurich Toolbox for Ready-Made Economic Experiments, Experimental Economics 10, 171-178.

Fr'echette, Guillaume R., 2015, Laboratory Experiments: Professionals Versus Students, in Guillaume R. Fr'echette, small and Andrew Schotter, eds.: Handbook of Experimental Economic Methodology (Oxford University Press, New York, N.Y.).

Fr'echette, Guillaume R., and Sevgi Yuksel, 2013, Infinitely Repeated Games in the Laboratory: Four Perspectives on Discounting and Random Termination, unpublished manuscript, available at http://ssrn.com/abstract=2225331.

G"achter, Simon, Georg von Krogh, and Stefan Haeflinger, 2010, Initiating Private-Collective Innovation: The Fragility of Knowledge Sharing, Research Policy 39, 893-906.

Ganglmair, Bernhard, and Emanuele Tarantino, 2014, Conversation with Secrets, RAND Journal of Economics 45, 273-302.

Gerritzen, Marc, Jens Carsten Jackwerth, and Alberto Plazzi, 2016, Birds of a Feather - Do Hedge Fund Managers Flock Together?, Swiss Finance Institute Research Paper Series.

Goetzmann, William N., Jonathan E. Ingersoll, and Stephen A. Ross, 2003, High-Water Marks and Hedge Fund Management Contracts, Journal of Finance 58, 1685-1717.

Grinblatt, Mark, and Matti Keloharju, 2001, How Distance, Language, and Culture Influence Stockholdings and Trades, Journal of Finance 56, 1053-1073.

Guttman, Ilan, Ilan Kremer, and Andrzej Skrzypacz, 2014, Not Only What but Also When: A Theory of Dynamic Voluntary Disclosure, American Economic Review 104, 2400-2420.

Hamilton, Mary Beth, and Mark Sangster, 2012, Minimizing Security Risks, The Hedgefund Journal, 15 October 2012. Available: http://www.thehedgefundjournal.com/node/8088 [Last accessed: 26 April 2016].

Hau, Harald, 2001, Location Matters: An Examination of Trading Profits, Journal of Finance 56, 1959-1983.

H"aussler, Carolin, 2011, Information-Sharing in Academia and the Industry: A Comparative Study, Research Policy 40, 105-122.

H"aussler, Carolin, Lin Jiang, Jerry Thursby, and Marie C. Thursby, 2013, Specific and General Information Sharing Among Academic Scientists, Research Policy 43, 465-475.

Hellmann, Thomas F., and Enrico C. Perotti, 2011, The Circulation of Ideas in Firms and Markets, Management Science 57, 1813-1826.

Holt, Chales A., and Susan K. Laury, 2002, Risk Aversion and Incentive Effects, American Economic Review 92, 1644-1655.

Hong, Harrison, Jeffrey D. Kubik, and Jeremy C. Stein, 2004, Social Interaction and Stock-Market Participation, Journal of Finance 59, 137-163.

Ivkovi'c, Zoran, and Scott Weisbenner, 2005, Local Does as Local Is: Information Content of the Geography of Individual Investors' Common Stock Investments, Journal of Finance 60, 267-306.

Kessler, Judd B., and Lise Vesterlund, 2015, The External Validity of Laboratory Experiments: The Misleading Emphasis on Quantitative Effects, in Guillaume R. Fr'echette, small and Andrew Schotter, eds.: Handbook of Experimental Economic Methodology (Oxford University Press, New York, N.Y. ).

Leopold, Les, 2013, Are We Killing Ourselves for Cut-throat Capitalism?, The Huffington Post, 7 May 2013. Available: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/les-leopold/are-we-killing-ourselves_b_3291985.html [Last accessed: 26 April 2016].

Levitt, Steven D., and John A. List, 2007a, Viewpoint: On the Generalizability of Lab Behaviour to the Field, Canadian Journal of Economics 40, 347-370.

Levitt, Steven D., and John A. List, 2007b, What Do Laboratory Experiments Measuring Social Preferences Reveal About the Real World?, Journal of Economic Perspectives 21, 153-174.

Levitt, Steven D., and John A. List, 2008, Homo Economicus Evolves, Science 319, 909-910.

L'evy-Garboua, Louis, Claude Meidinger, and Beno^it Rapoport, 2006, The Formation of Social Preferences: Some Lessons from Psychology and Biology, in Serge-Christophe Kolm, small and Jean Mercier Ythier, eds.: Handbook of the Economics of Giving, Altruism and Reciprocity (North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands ).

MacDonald, Marianne, 2007, She's worth $100m, runs a $400m hedge fund, has two sets of twins and four nannies ldots, The Guardian, 9 September 2007. Available: http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2007/sep/09/features.woman5. [Last accessed: 26 April 2016].

Manela, Asaf, 2014, The Value of Diffusing Information, Journal of Financial Economics 111, 181-199.

McCrary, Stuart A., 2002, How to Create and Manage a Hedge Fund: A Professional's Guide. (John Wiley & Sons Hoboken, N.J.).

Mukherjee, Arijit, and Scott Stern, 2009, Disclosure or Secrecy? The Dynamics of Open Science, International Journal of Industrial Organization 27, 449-462.

Ortmann, Andreas, John Fitzgerald, and Carl Boeing, 2000, Trust, Reciprocity, and Social History: A Re-examination, Experimental Economics 3, 81-100.

Palfrey, Thomas R., and Stephanie W. Wang, 2009, On Eliciting Beliefs in Strategic Games, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 71, 98-109.

Pontiff, Jeffrey, 2006, Costly Arbitrage and the Myth of Idiosyncratic Risk, Journal of Accounting and Economics 42, 35-52.

Pool, Veronika K., Noah Stoffman, and Scott E. Yonker, 2015, The People in Your Neighborhood: Social Interactions and Mutual Fund Portfolios, Journal of Finance 70, 2679-2732.

Roth, Alvin E., and J. Keith Murnighan, 1978, Equilibrium Behavior and Repeated Play of the Prisoner's Dilemma, Journal of Mathematical Psychology 17, 189-198.

Schmerken, Ivy, 2014, Hedge Funds Raise the Urgency Level on Cyber Security, Information Week, 28 August 2014. Available: http://www.wallstreetandtech.com/security/hedge-funds-raise-the-urgency-level-on-cyber-security/d/d-id/1306836 [Last accessed: 26 April 2016].

Shiller, Robert J., 2000, Irrational Exuberance. (Princeton University Press Princeton, N.J.).

Shiller, Robert J., and John Pound, 1989, Survey Evidence on Diffusion of Interest and Information Among Investors, Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 12, 47-66.

Shive, Sophie, 2010, An Epidemic Model of Investor Behavior, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 45, 169-198.

Sorkin, Andrew Ross, 2008, Running a Hedge Fund Is Harder Than It Looks on TV, The New York Times, 18 August 2008. Available: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/19/business/19sorkin.html [Last accessed: 26 April 2016].

Stein, Jeremy C., 2008, Conversations among Competitors, American Economic Review 98, 2150-2162.

Trautmann, Stefan T., and Gijs van de Kuilen, 2015, Belief Elicitation: A Horse Race among Truth Serums, Economic Journal 125, 2116-2135.

Vardi, Nathan, 2013, Former Israeli Intelligence Operatives Now Working For Hedge Funds, Forbes Business, 18 April 2013. Available: http://www.forbes.com/sites/nathanvardi/2013/04/18/former-israeli-intelligence-operatives-now-working-for-hedge-funds [Last accessed: 26 April 2016].

von Hippel, Eric, 1987, Cooperation Between Rivals: Informal Know-How Trading, Research Policy 16, 291-302.