Arbitrage Opportunities, Efficiency, and the Role of Risk Preferences in the Hong Kong Property Market

Tsang, Chun-Kei and Wong, Wing-Keung and Horowitz, Ira (2016): Arbitrage Opportunities, Efficiency, and the Role of Risk Preferences in the Hong Kong Property Market. Forthcoming in: Studies in Economics and Finance , Vol. 33, (2016)

Abstract

This paper aims at investigating how a prospective buyer’s optimal home-size purchase can be determined by means of a stochastic-dominance (SD) analysis of historical data of Hong Kong. By means of SD analysis, the paper employs monthly property yields in Hong Kong over a 15-year period to illustrate how buyers of different risk preference may optimize their home-size purchase. Regardless of whether the buyer eschews risk, embraces risk, or indifference to it, in any adjacent pairing of five well-defined housing classes, the smaller class provides the optimal purchase. In addition, risk averters focusing on total yield would prefer to invest in the smallest and second- smallest classes than in the largest class. As the smaller class provides the optimal purchase, the smallest class affords the buyer the optimal purchase over all classes in this important housing market – at least where rental yields are of primary concern. The findings suggest that in the Hong Kong housing market, long-term investors may be better off purchasing smaller homes. For other type of investors, it depends on their risk preference. There is a very small body of empirical literature on housing investment, especially if focuses on the optimal home-size purchase.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: urban studies; stochastic dominance; risk averters, risk seekers, investors with S-shaped and reverse S-shaped utilities, housing investment
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C14 - Semiparametric and Nonparametric Methods: General; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G14 - Information and Market Efficiency ; Event Studies ; Insider Trading; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R3 - Real Estate Markets, Spatial Production Analysis, and Firm Location > R31 - Housing Supply and Markets

References

Addae-Dapaah K, Webb JR, Ho KH and Tan YF (2010). Industrial real estate investment: Does the contrarian strategy work? Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 41(2):193-227.

Anderson G (1996). Nonparametric tests of stochastic dominance in income distributions. Econometrica 64(5): 1183-1193.

Archer WR, Gatzlaff DH and Ling DC (1996). Measuring the importance of location in house price appreciation. Journal of Urban Economics 40(3):334-353.

Ayuso J and Restoy F (2006). House prices and rents: An equilibrium asset pricing approach. Journal of Empirical Finance 13(3): 371-388.

Bai ZD, Li H, Liu HX and Wong WK (2011). Test statistics for prospect and Markowitz stochastic dominances with applications. Econometrics Journal 14(2): 278-303.

Bai ZD, Li H, McAleer M and Wong WK (2015). Stochastic dominance statistics for risk averters and risk seekers: An analysis of stock preferences for USA and China. Quantitative Finance 15(5): 889-900.

Barrett G and Donald S (2003). Consistent tests for stochastic dominance. Econometrica, 71(1): 71-104.

Bishop JA, Formly JP and Thistle PD (1992). Convergence of the south and non-South income distributions. 1969-1979. American Economic Review 82(1): 262-272.

Campbell JY and Shiller RJ (1988). Stock prices, earnings, and expected dividends. Journal of Finance 43(3): 661-676.

Cannon S, Miller NG and Pandher GS (2006). Risk and return in the U.S. housing market: A cross-sectional asset-pricing approach. Real Estate Economics 34(4): 519-552.

Chen M, Chang C, Yang C and Hsieh B (2012). Investment demand and housing prices in an emerging economy. Journal of Real Estate Research 34(3), 345-373.

Ciarlone A (2015) House price cycles in emerging economies. Studies in Economics and Finance 32(1): 17 – 52.

Clayton J (1996). Rational expectations, market fundamentals and housing price volatility. Real Estate Economics 24(4): 441-470.

Davidson R and Duclos JY (2000). Statistical inference for stochastic dominance and or the measurement of poverty and inequality. Econometrica 68(6): 1435-1464.

Dreman D. (1982). The New Contrarian Investment Strategy. Random House: New York.

Dusansky R and Koç C (2007). The capital gains effect in the demand for housing. Journal of Urban Economics 61(2): 287-298.

Falk H and Levy H (1989). Market reaction to quarterly earnings’ announcements: A stochastic-dominance based test of market efficiency. Management Science 35(4): 425-446. Flavin M and Nakagawa S (2008). A model of housing in the presence of adjustment costs: A structural interpretation of habit persistence. American Economic Review 98(1): 474-495.

Flavin M and Yamashita T (2002). Owner-occupied housing and the composition of the household portfolio over the life cycle. American Economic Review 92(1): 345-362.

Fong WM, Lean HH, Wong, WK (2008). Stochastic Dominance and Behavior towards Risk: The Market for Internet Stocks”, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 68(1): 194-208.

Fong WM, Wong WK and Lean HH (2005). International momentum strategies: a stochastic dominance approach. Journal of Financial Markets 8(1): 89-109.

Fuerst F, McAllister P and Sivitanides P (2015) Flight to quality?: An investigation of changing price spreads in commercial real estate markets. Studies in Economics and Finance 32(1): 2-16.

Gallin J. (2008).The long-run relationship between house prices and rents. Real Estate Economics 36(4): 635-658.

Ghent AC and Owyang MT (2010). Is housing the business cycle? Evidence from US cities. Journal of Urban Economics 67(3): 336-351.

Graff RA and Young MS (1996). Real estate correlations: Real-world limitations on relationships inferred from NCREIF data. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 13(2): 121-142.

Guo X, Post T, Wong WK and Zhu LX (2014). Moment conditions for almost stochastic dominance. Economics Letters 124(2): 163–167.

Hadar J and Russell WR (1969). Rules for ordering uncertain prospects. American Economic Review 59(1): 25-34.

Hanoch G and Levy H (1969). The efficiency analysis of choices involving risk. Review of Economic Studies 36(3): 335-346.

Harter-Dreiman M (2004). Drawing inferences about housing supply elasticity from house price responses to income shocks. Journal of Urban Economics 55(2): 316-337.

Henderson JV and Ioannides Y (1987). Owner occupancy: Consumption vs. investment demand. Journal of Urban Economics 21(2): 228-241.

Hiebert P and Sydow M (2011). What drives returns to Euro area housing? Evidence from a dynamic dividend–discount model. Journal of Urban Economics 70(2): 88-98.

Hoang THV, Wong WK and Zhu ZZ (2015). Is gold different for risk-averse and risk-seeking investors? An empirical analysis of the Shanghai Gold Exchange. Economic Modelling 50(C): 200–211.

Ihlanfeldt K and Mayock T (2012). Information, search, and house prices: revisited. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 44(1-2): 90-115.

Jarrow R (1986).The relationship between arbitrage and first order stochastic dominance. Journal of Finance 41(4): 915-921.

Joy OM and Porter RB (1974). Stochastic dominance and mutual fund performance. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 9(1): 24-31.

Kallberg JG, Liu CH and Greig DW (1996). The role of real estate in the portfolio allocation process. Real Estate Economics 24(3): 359-359.

Krainer J (2001). A theory of liquidity in residential real estate markets. Journal of Urban Economics 49(1): 32-53. Leamer EE (2002). Bubble trouble? Your home has a P/E ratio too. UCLA Anderson Forecast June.

Leshno M and Levy H (2002). Preferred by “all”' and preferred by “most” decision makers: Almost stochastic dominance. Management Science 48(8): 1074-1085.

Levy H (1992). Stochastic dominance and expected utility: Survey and analysis. Management Science 38(4): 555–593.

Levy H and Levy M (2004). Prospect Theory and Mean-Variance Analysis, Review of Financial Studies 17(4), 1015-1041.

Levy H and Wiener Z (1998). Stochastic Dominance and Prospect Dominance with Subjective Weighting Functions. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 16(2), 147-163.

Levy M and Levy H (2002). Prospect Theory: Much ado about nothing? Management Science 48(10): 1334-1349.

Levy H and Sarnat M (1970). Alternative efficiency criteria: An empirical analysis. Journal of Finance 25(5): 1153-1158.

Li CK and Wong WK (1999). Extension of Stochastic Dominance Theory to Random Variables. RAIRO Operations Research 33, 509-524.

Lin Z and Liu Y (2008). Real estate returns and risk with heterogeneous investors. Real Estate Economics 36(4): 753-776.

Linton O, Maasoumi E and Whang Y-J (2005). Consistent testing for stochastic dominance under general sampling schemes. Review of Economic Studies 72(3): 735-765.

Markowitz HM (1952). The Utility of Wealth. Journal of Political Economy 60, 151-156.

McMillen DP (2008). Changes in the distribution of house prices over time: structural characteristics, neighborhood, or coefficients? Journal of Urban Economics 64(3): 573-589.

Paciorek A and Sinai T (2012). Does home owning smooth the variability of future housing consumption? Journal of Urban Economics 71(2): 244-257.

Porter RB (1973). An empirical comparison of stochastic dominance and mean-variance portfolio choice criteria. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 8(4): 587-608.

Qiao Z, Clark E and Wong, WK (2014). Investors’ preference towards risk: evidence from the Taiwan stock and stock index futures markets. Accounting & Finance 54(1): 251-274.

Qiao Z and Wong, WK (2015). Which is a better investment choice in the Hong Kong residential property market: a big or small property? Applied Economics 47(16), 1670-1685.

Sriboonchitta, S., Wong, W.K., Dhompongsa, S., and Nguyen, H.T., 2009. Stochastic Dominance and Applications to Finance, Risk and Economics. Chapman and Hall/CRC, Taylor and Francis Group.

Topel R and Rosen S (1988). Housing investment in the United States. Journal of Political Economy 96(4): 718-740.

Tsang,CK, Gao, JJ, Li, XL and Wong, WK (2012). Big house or small house, which one should we buy? Evidence from Hong Kong, Social Science Research Network Working Paper Series 2182403.

Turnbull GK, Dornbrow JD and Simans CF (2008). Big house, little house: Relative size and value. Real Estate Economics 34(3): 439-456.

Wong, WK (2007). Stochastic dominance and mean-variance measures of profit and loss for business planning and investment. European Journal of Operational Research 182(2), 829-843.

Wong WK and Chan R (2008). Markowitz and Prospect Stochastic Dominances. Annals of Finance 4(1): 105-129.

Wong WK, Phoon KF and Lean HH (2008). Stochastic dominance analysis of Asian hedge funds. Pacific-Basin Finance Journal 16(3): 204-223.

Xiao, Q and Liu, Y (2010). The residential market of Hong Kong: rational or irrational? Applied Economics 42: 923–33.

Ziering B and McIntosh W (2000). Property size and risk: Why bigger is not always better. Journal of Property Management 5(2): 62-70.

Zimmer DM (2012). The role of copulas in the housing crisis. The Review of Economics and Statistics 94(2): 607-620.