Separating the Wheat from the Chaff: Icelandic and Irish Policy Responses to the Banking Crisis

Howden, David (2013): Separating the Wheat from the Chaff: Icelandic and Irish Policy Responses to the Banking Crisis. Published in: Economic Affairs , Vol. 3, No. 33 (2013): pp. 348-360.

Abstract

When the tales of the Icelandic and Irish crises are told, they are framed as if one country did everything right to exit recession. In this paper I assess their recovery policies and find that the truth lies somewhere in the middle. By allowing its banking system to suffer substantial losses, Iceland shielded its citizens from the costly debt overhand apparent in Ireland. Ireland’s commitment to open capital markets and price deflation has allowed trade flows to remain robust, and relative prices to realign to signal sustainable production plans to entrepreneurs. These lessons provide a roadmap for other countries entering similar crises in the future.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: subprime crisis, Iceland, Ireland, 2008 crisis, capital controls
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles

References

Árnason, Árni Páll. 2011. “Iceland’s Recovery,” opening remarks at the IMF conference Iceland’s Recovery—Lessons and Challenges. Reykjavik, Oct. 27.

Arnason, Ragnar, and Jon Danielsson. 2011. Capital controls are exactly wrong for Iceland. VoxEU.com, Nov. 14.

Bagus, Philipp, and David Howden. 2011a. Deep Freeze: Iceland’s Economic Collapse. Auburn, AL: Ludwig von Mises Institute.

Bagus, Philipp, and David Howden. 2011b. Monetary Equilibrium and Price Stickiness: Causes, Consequences, and Remedies. Review of Austrian Economics 24(4): 383-402

Baldursson, Friðrik Már. 2011. Iceland’s programme with the IMF 2008–11. VoxEU, Nov. 8. http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/7235

Buiter, Willem H., and Anne Sibert. 2008. The Iceland banking crisis and what to do about it: The lender of last resort theory of optimal currency areas. CEPR Policy Insight, 26.

Connor, Gregory, Thomas Flavin, and Brian O’Kelly. 2010. The U.S. and Irish Credit Crises: Their Distinctive Differences and Common Features. Working paper.

Danielsson, Jon. 2011a. How Not to resolve a banking crisis: Learning from Iceland’s mistakes. VoxEU, Oct. 26. http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/7157

Danielsson, Jon. 2011b. Was the IMF programme in Iceland successful? VoxEU, Oct. 27. http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/7162

Du Caju, Philip, Theodora Kosma, Martina Lawless, Julián Messina and Tairi Rõõm. 2013. Why Firms Avoid Cutting Wages: Survey Evidence from European Firms. Central Bank of Ireland, Research Technical Paper 3/RT/13.

Financial Supervisory Authority. 2008a. New Glitnir Bank Takes Over Domestic Operations of Glitnir banki hf. Oct. 15. [Available] http://en.fme.is/published-material/news--announcements/news/nr/1399.

Financial Supervisory Authority. 2008b. New Kaupthing Bank Takes Over Domestic Operations of Kaupthing banki hf. Oct. 22. [Available] http://en.fme.is/published-material/news--announcements/news/nr/1398.

Financial Supervisory Authority. 2008c. New Landsbanki Takes Over Domestic Operations of Landsbanki Islands hf. Oct. 9. [Available] http://en.fme.is/published-material/news--announcements/news/nr/1400.

Gylfason, Thorvaldur. 2011. Houston, we have a problem: Iceland’s capital controls. VoxEU, Jun. 1. http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/6597

Honohan, Patrick. 2010. The Irish Banking Crisis—Regulatory and Financial Stability Policy 2003–2008.

Howden, David. forthcoming. The Icelandic and Irish Banking Crises: Alternative Paths to a Credit-Induced Collapse. The Independent Review.

Howden, David. 2012. The Iceland and Ireland Banking Crisis: Lessons for the Future. Mercatus Center working paper no. 12-22.

Huerta de Soto, Jesús. 2012. An Austrian Defense of the Euro. Ludwig von Mises Institute Daily Ariticle, June 22. [Available] http://mises.org/daily/6069/An-Austrian-Defense-of-the-Euro

Hutt, William H. 1977. The Theory of Idle Resources, 2nd ed. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund.

International Monetary Fund. 2010. Capital Inflows: The role of controls. IMF Staff Position Note SPN/10/04.

Kalinova, Blanka, Angel Palerm, and Stephen Thomsen. 2010. OECD’s FDI Restrictiveness Index: 2010 Update. OECD Working Papers on International Investment, no. 2010/3.

Kinsella, Stephen. 2012. Is Ireland really the role model for austerity? Cambridge Journal of Economics 36(1): 223–35.

Kinsella, Stephen, and R. Lyons. 2011. “A return to managing the Irish Economy” in (eds.) Burke and Lyons, Next Generation Ireland, pp. 65–90. Dublin: Blackhall Press.

Lane, Philip R. 2011. The Irish Crisis. Centre for Economic Policy Research, Discussion paper no. 8287.

O’Callaghan, Gary. 2011. Did the ECB Cause a Run on Irish Banks? Evidence from Disaggregated Data. Irish Economy Note no. 13.

Ólafsson, Stefán. 2011. Iceland’s Financial Crisis and level of Living Consequences. Þjóðmálastofnun Social Research Centre, University of Iceland, working paper no. 3.

Sharkah, Francis, and Oliver Pawela. 2010. Was the Euro Interest Rate Too Low for Ireland? A Time Series Analysis of the pre-EMU Period in Light of the Taylor Rule. University of Stockholm, working paper.

Sigfusson, Thor, and Ragnar Arnason. 2011. The Importance of the Ocean Cluster to the Icelandic Economy. Islandsbanki. http://www.islandsbanki.is/english/products-and-services/seafood-industry/publications/

Valdimarsson, Omar R. 2012. Iceland property bubble grows with currency controls: Mortgages. Bloomberg, May 30.

Yeyati, Eduardo Levy. 2011. Are capital controls effective? VoxEU, Jan. 20. http://www.voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/6031