(Mis)measuring Argentina’s Progress: Industrial Output, 1870s-1913

Francis, Joseph A. (2015): (Mis)measuring Argentina’s Progress: Industrial Output, 1870s-1913.

Abstract

Evidence of dramatic industrialisation has been used to support the optimistic, staple theory-inspired narrative of Argentina’s late nineteenth century. This narrative is challenged here by an analysis of the available evidence of industrial output in Argentina from the 1870s to the eve of the First World War. Issue is taken, in particular, with Roberto Cortés Conde’s widely used industrial output index, which suggests an 8-9 per cent annual industrial growth rate during this period. It is argued that Cortés Conde has overestimated growth by relying upon misleading data taken from Argentina’s inland revenue service. Rather than reflecting increased production, the rapid growth of Cortés Conde’s index is actually due to increased taxation. Alternative indicators show a lower annual growth rate of 5 per cent, although this is necessarily an approximation, given the lack of data. The cases of textiles and beef products illustrate why the lack of data makes it easy to overestimate industrial growth during this period, as there tends to be more data for dynamic activities than for those that stagnated. The paper concludes with a discussion of wider implications for the study of economic history.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Argentina; nineteenth century; industrialisation; economic history.
• Subjects: N - Economic History > N0 - General > N01 - Development of the Discipline: Historiographical; Sources and Methods; N - Economic History > N1 - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics ; Industrial Structure ; Growth ; Fluctuations > N16 - Latin America ; Caribbean; N - Economic History > N6 - Manufacturing and Construction > N66 - Latin America ; Caribbean

References

Assadourian, C.S., El sistema de la economía colonial: mercado interno, regiones y espacio económico, Lima, 1982.

Balán, J., and N. López, ‘Burguesías y gobiernos provinciales en la Argentina: la política impositiva de Tucumán y Mendoza entre 1873 y 1914’, Desarrollo Económico, 17:67, 1977, pp. 391-435.

Barba, F.E., Aproximación al estudio de los precios y salarios en Buenos Aires desde fines del siglo XVIII hasta 1860, La Plata, 1999.

Barbero, M.I., and F. Rocchi, ‘Industry’, in G. della Paolera and A.M. Taylor, eds., A New Economic History of Argentina, Cambridge, 2003, pp. 261-94.

Barrio de Villanueva, P., ‘Controles estatales a la industria del vino en Mendoza, 1890-1914’, H-industri@, 4:7, 2010, available online at http://www.hindustria.com.ar/images/client_gallery/HindustriaNro7Barrio.pdf (accessed 14 May 2013).

Bénétrix, A.S., K.H. O’Rourke, and J.G. Williamson, ‘The Spread of Manufacturing to the Poor Periphery 1870–2007’, Open Economies Review, 26:1, 2015, pp. 1-37.

Comisión Directiva, Segundo censo de la República Argentina, II, Población, Buenos Aires, 1898.

Comisión Directiva, Segundo censo de la República Argentina, III, Censos complementarios, Buenos Aires, 1898.

Comisión Nacional del Censo (CNC), Tercer censo nacional, VII, Censo de las industrias, Buenos Aires, 1917.

Comité Nacional de Geografía (CNG), Anuario geográfico argentino, Buenos Aires, 1941.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘Problemas del crecimiento industrial de la Argentina (1870-1914)’, Desarrollo Económico, 3:1/2, 1963, pp. 143-71.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘El ‘boom’ argentino: ¿una oportunidad desperdiciada?’, in T. di Tella and T. Halperín Donghi, eds., Los fragmentos del poder, Buenos Aires, 1969, pp. 217-42.

Cortés Conde, R., El progreso argentino: 1880-1914, Buenos Aires, 1979.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘The Export Economy of Argentina 1880-1920’, in idem and S.J. Hunt, eds., The Latin American Economies: Growth and the Export Sector 1880-1930, New York, 1985, pp. 319-91.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘The Growth of the Argentine Economy, c. 1870-1914’, in L. Bethall, ed., The Cambridge History of Latin America, V, c. 1870-1930, Cambridge, 1986, pp. 47-78.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘Export-Led Growth in Latin America: 1870-1930’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 24, Quincentenary Supplement, 1992, pp. 163-79.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘Estimaciones del producto bruto interno de Argentina 1875-1935’, Documento de Trabajo 3, Departamento de Economía y Matemática, Universidad de San Andres, 1994.

Cortés Conde, R., La economía argentina en el largo plazo: Ensayos de historia económica de los siglos XIX y XX, Buenos Aires, 1997.

Cortés Conde, R., ‘The Vicissitudes of an Exporting Economy: Argentina (1875-1930)’, in E. Cárdenas, J.A. Ocampo, and R. Thorp, eds., An Economic History of Twentieth-Century Latin America, I, The Export Age, Oxford, 2000, pp. 265-98.

Cortés Conde, R., The Political Economy of Argentina in the Twentieth Century, Cambridge, 2009.

Crafts, N.F.R., ‘Mickey Mouse Numbers in World History: The Short View. By D.C.M. Platt’, Journal of Economic Literature, 30:1, 1992, pp. 223-24.

Crafts, N.F.R. and C.K. Harley, ‘Output Growth and the British Industrial Revolution: A Restatement of the Crafts-Harley View’, Economic History Review, 45:4, 1992, pp. 703-30.

Díaz Alejandro, C.F., Essays on the Economic History of the Argentine Republic, New Haven, 1970.

Dirección General de Economía y Estadística (DGEE), Estadística Agrícola: Año Agrícola 1913-14, Buenos Aires, 1914.

Dirección General de la Estadística de la Nación (DGEN), Extracto estadístico de la República Argentina correspondiente al año 1915, Buenos Aires, 1916.

Dirección General de la Estadística de la Nación (DGEN), Síntesis estadística mensual de la República Argentina, 1:3, 1947.

Dirección General de la Estadística de la Nación (DGEN), Anuario, Buenos Aires, various years.

Ferrer, A., The Argentine Economy, Berkeley, 1967.

Gallo, E., ‘Agrarian Expansion and Industrial Development in Argentina’, in R. Carr, ed., Latin American Affairs, Oxford, 1970, pp. 45-61.

Gallo, E., and R. Cortés Conde, La formación de la Argentina moderna, Buenos Aires, 1967.

Geller, L., ‘El crecimiento industrial argentino hasta 1914 y la teoría del bien primario exportable’, Trimestre Económico, 37:148(4), 1970, pp. 763-811.

Guy, D.J., ‘Carlos Pellegrini and the Politics of Early Argentine Industrialization, 1873–1906’, Journal of Latin American Studies, 11:1, 1979, pp. 123-44.

Guy, D.J., ‘Women, Peonage, and Industrialization: Argentina, 1810-1914’, Latin American Research Review, 16:3, 1981, pp. 65-89.

Hirschman, A.O., ‘A Generalized Linkage Approach to Development, with Special Reference to Staples’, Economic Development and Cultural Change, 25, Supplement, 1977, pp. 67-98.

Innis, H., Essays in Canadian Economic History, Toronto, 1956. Junta Nacional de Carnes, Estadísticas básicas, Buenos Aires, 1966.

Korol, J.C., and H. Sabato, ‘Incomplete Industrialization: An Argentine Obsession’, Latin American Research Review, 25:1, 1990, pp. 7-30. Latzina, F., Estadísti�ca retrospectiva del comercio exterior argentino 1875-1904, Buenos Aires, 1905.

Llorca-Jaña, M., ‘To Be Waterproof or to Be Soaked: Importance of Packing in British Textile Exports to Distant Markets: The Cases of Chile and the River Plate, c.1810-1859’, Revista de Historia Económica, 29:1, 2011, pp. 11-37.

Llorca-Jaña, M., The British Textile Trade in South America in the Nineteenth Century, Cambridge, 2012.

Llorons do Azar, C., ‘Precios unitarios de consumo y servicios, Capital Federal y provincias: 1901-06: parte primera’, mimeo, 1965.

McCaa, R., M.R. Haines, and E.M. Mulhare, ‘Argentina: The First National Historical Census Microdata’, in P.K. Hall, R. McCaa, and G. Thorvaldsen, eds., Handbook of International Historical Microdata for Population Research, Minneapolis, 2000.

Middleton, R., ‘Mickey Mouse Numbers in World History: The Short View by D.C.M. Platt’, English Historical Review, 106:421, 1991, pp. 1079-80.

Míguez, E.J., ‘¿Veinte años no es nada? Balance y perspectivas de la producción reciente sobre la gran expansión agraria, 1850–1914’, in J. Gelman, ed., La historia económica argentina en la encrucijada, Buenos Aires, 2006, pp. 209-29.

O’Brien, P., ‘Myths of Eurocentrism and Material Progress’, Institute of Historical Research Global History Seminar, 17 February 2010, online at: http://www.history.ac.uk/podcasts/global-history-external/myths-eurocentrism-and-material-progress (accessed 15 August 2015).

Owen, N., ‘Textile Displacement and the Status of Women in Southeast Asia’, in D. Ma, ed., The Pacific World: Lands, Peoples and History of the Pacific, 1500-1900, XII, Textiles in the Pacific, 1500-1900, Aldershot, 2005.

Platt, D.C.M., Mickey Mouse Numbers in World History: The Short View, Basingstoke, 1989.

Rocchi, F., Chimneys in the Desert: Industrialization in Argentina During the Export Boom Years, 1870-1930, Stanford, 2006.

Santos Martínez, P., Las industrias durante el Virreinato (1776-1810), Buenos Aires, 1969.

Somoza, J.L., and A.E. Lattes, ‘Muestras de los dos primeros censos nacionales de población, 1869 y 1895’, Documento de Trabajo 46, Centro de Investigaciones Sociales, Instituto Torcuato Di Tella, 1967. Superintendente del Censo, Primer censo de la República Argentina, Buenos Aires, 1872.

Tornquist, E., The Economic Development of the Argentine Republic in the Last Fifty Years, Buenos Aires, 1919.

Vázquez-Presedo, V., El caso argentino: Migración de factores, comercio exterior y desarrollo, 1875-1914, Buenos Aires, 1971.

Watkins, M.H., ‘A Staple Theory of Economic Growth’, Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, 29:2, 1963.

Watkins, M.H., ‘Staples Redux’, Studies in Political Economy, 79, 2007.

Zubizarreta, I., and F. Gómez, Una historia de la lechería argentina: desde la colonia hasta nuestros días, Inforcampo, 2013.