The Keiretsu Fable - Where does the Truth Lie?

Anderson, Evelyn (2004): The Keiretsu Fable - Where does the Truth Lie? Published in: ASAA Biennial Conference Paper Proceedings : pp. 1-32.

Abstract

The success of the Japanese automobile industry has mystified Western scholars for many decades. In the early post-war years, the industry did not receive any blessings from the Bank of Japan. Even MITI was a little pessimistic about the industry’s future. The inclusion of the automobile components industry as part of MITI’s “pick-the-winner” industrial policy appeared almost as an afterthought. Yet against all odds the industry flourished to become one of Japan’s best known success stories. Western scholars and business strategists alike are naturally keen to deconstruct this mystery, while Japanese scholars were no less enthusiastic in documenting and offering an explanation. Many explored the keiretsu structure (networking or supplier relationship) as a possible source of the industry’s competitive advantage. Something has gone amiss however, in this parallel effort, and gaps and misperceptions developed. This paper explores some of the myths surrounding this industry. In the process, it revaluates MITI’s policy and raised another research question of whether some of Toyota’s domestic competitors might have misinterpreted the nature of Toyota’s keiretsu.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: keiretsu; industrial policy; exclusiveness; MITI
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D21 - Firm Behavior: Theory; N - Economic History > N1 - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics ; Industrial Structure ; Growth ; Fluctuations > N15 - Asia including Middle East; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior > L22 - Firm Organization and Market Structure

References

Amagai, S. (1982) Jidousha Kougyou no Shiteki Tenkai [Historical Development of the Automobile Industry], Tokyo: Aki Shobou.

Anderson, E. (2003) ‘The Enigma of Toyota’s Competitive Advantage – Is Denso the Missing Link in the Academic Literature? ’, Pacific Economic Papers, No. 339, 1 – 38.

Asanuma, B. (1984a) ‘Nihon ni okeru buhin torihiki no kouzou [The structure of parts transactions in Japan]’, Keizai rongyousou [Economic Theories], Kyoto University, March 133 (3): 137 – 158).

___ (1984b) ‘Jidousha sangyou ni okeru buhin trihiki no kouzou [The structure of automobile parts transactions]’, Kikan gendai keizai [Modern Economics Quarterly], 58 (Summer): 38 – 48.

___ (1985) ‘Nihon ni okeru buhin torihiki no jittai – jidousha sangyou to denkii kiki sanyou o chuushin ni [A report of the Japanese parts transactions – focusing on the automobile and electrical appliances industries]’, Kousei Torihiki [Fair Trade], 416 (June): 32 – 37.

___ (1989a) ‘Nihon ni okeru meikaa to sapuraiyaa no kankei [Assembler – supplier relationship in Japan],’ in M. Tsuchiya (ed.), Nihon no chuushou kigyou [Small-Medium Companies in Japan], Tokyo: Tokyo University Press.

___ (1989b) ‘Manufacturer – supplier relationships in Japan and the concept of relation – specific skill’, Journal of the Japanese and International Economics, 3 (1): 1 – 30.

___ (1992) ‘Japanese manufacturer-supplier relationships in international perspective: The automobile case’ in P. Sheard, (ed.), International Adjustment and the Japanese Firm, St. Leonards, NSW: Allen and Unwin in association with the Australian National University, Australia – Japan Research Centre, p. 99 – 124.

Daiyamondo Sha (1959) Jidousha [Automobile], Tokyo: Daiyamondo Sha.

Dyer, J.H. (1994) ‘Dedicated assets: Japan’s manufacturing edge’, Harvard Business Review, 72(6): 174 – 178.

Edwards, C. and R. Samimi (1997) ‘Japanese interfirm networks: Exploring the seminal sources of their success’, Journal of management Studies 34(4): 489-510.

Flath, D. (2000) The Japanese Economy, New York: Oxford University Press.

Fruin, W.M. (1992) The Japanese Enterprise System, Competitive Strategies and Cooperative Structures, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Fujiki, K. (2002) Keiretsu Kaitai – Kawaru Jiodousha Buhin Torihiki [The Breakdown of Keiretsu – The Changing Automobile Parts Transactions], Tokyo: Ekonomisto Sha.

Jidousha Buhin Kougyoukai, Ooto Toreedo Jaanaru ed. (1971) Nihon no Jidousha Buhin Kougyou [Japan’s Automobile Components Industry], Tokyo: Jidousha Kougyou Shinkoukai (1979)

Nihon Jidousha Kougyoushi Gyousei Kirokushuu – Jidousha Shiryou Shiriizu (3) [History of the Japanese Automobile Industry Administration Records Collection – Automobile Information Series (3)], Tokyo: Jidousha Kougyou Shinkoukai.

Kay, J. (1993) Foundations of Corporate Success: How Business Strategies Add Value, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Kikai Shinkou Kyoukai Keizai Kenkyuujo (1968) Gijutsu Suijun Kakusa no Kenkyuu [The Technology Gap Research].

Kousei Torihiki Kyoukai [Fair Trade Association] (1959) Jidousha Kougyou no Keizairyoku Shuuchuu no jittai [Concentration and Market Power of the Automobile Industry], Tokyo: Kousei Torihiki Kyoukai.

MacMillan, J. (1992) Games, Strategies, and Managers, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Magee, D. (2003) How Carlos Ghosn Rescued Nissan, New York: HarperCollins.

Matsui, T. (1973) ‘Jidousha Kougyou ni okeru Shiatuke・Keiretsu ka no jittai (2) – Motokata Fukusuuka Dankai no Kigyou Keiretsu ni tsuite – [Subcontracting and Keiretsu in the Automobile Inustry (1)(2) – Customer Diversification - ]’, Ritsumeikan Keieigaku [Ritsumeikan Management Studies], December 12(2): 21-70 (4): 39-74.

___ (1981) ‘Hidokusen kigyou to kigyou ruikei – Jidousha kougyou ni okeru shitauke・keiretsuka no hatten to shakaiteki bungyou – [Classification of non-monopolies – Developments and division of labour in the subcontracting keiretsu industry - ]’, Ritsumeikan Keieigaku [Ritsumeikan Management Studies], November 20(3) (4): 357-384.

___ (1982) ‘Chuushou kigyou jiritsukaron no saikentou – Jidousha kogyou ni okeru shitauke・keiretsuka no hatten to shakaiteki bungyou – [Revaluating SME independence – Developments and division of labour in the subcontracting keiretsu industry - ]’, Ritsumeikan Keieigaku [Ritsumeikan Management Studies], May 21(1): 41-60.

___ (1985) ‘Jidousha kougyou ni okeru gaichuu kanri seisaku ・heichuu seisaku no shinten to kaisouteki kigyou kouzou [Outsourcing management policy and multiple sourcing policy in the automobile industry: developments and hierarchical structure]’, Ritsumeikan Keieigaku [Ritsumeikan Management Studies], July・September 24(2): 1-26 (3): 19-52.

___ (1986) ‘Shitaukesei no henka to motokata fukusuu dankai no kigyou keiretsu saikou – jidousha buhin kougyou・hidokusen kigyou no kyousou kouzou [Keiretsu revaluation in view of changes in the subcontracting system and customer diversification – competitive structure of the automobile parts industry and non-monopolies]’, Ritsumeikan Keieigaku [Ritsumeikan Management Studies], July・September・November 25 (1,2): 101-130 (3): 23-73 (4): 53-75.

___ (1987 – 88) ‘Shitaukesei no henka to shitaukesei riron no kentou – keiretsu kigyou no kyousou kouzou – [Changes in the subcontracting system and evaluation of subcontracting theories – competitive structure of keiretsu companies]’, Ritsumeikan Keieigaku [Ritsumeikan Management Studies], March November January 25(6): 63-90 26(4): 59-85 27(1): 29-57.

___ (1989) ‘Motokata fukusuuka dankai no shitukesei to shitauke riron no tayouka – kouzouteki shiten kara no shitauke riron no saikouchiku – [The subcontracting system of customer diversification and the development of diversified subcontracting theories – rebuilding subcontracting theories from a structural perspective -]’, Kikan Keizai Kenkyuu [Economic Research Quarterly], March 11(4): 18-35.

Monteverde K. and D. Teece (1982) ‘Supplier switching costs and vertical integration in the automobile industry’, Bell Journal of Economics, 13(2): 206-213.

Miwa, Y. (1989) ‘Shitauke kankei: jidousha sangyou [Subcontracting relationship: automobile industry]’, in Imai K. & R. Komiya (eds.) Nihon no Kigyou [Japanese Corporations], Tokyo: Tokyo University Press, 163-186.

Miwa, Y. and J.M. Ramseyer, (2002) ‘The Fable of the keiretsu’, Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 11 (2): 169-224.

Nemoto, M. (1997) ‘Riin Seisan Houshiki ・Toyota Seisan Houshiki ・ Toyota no TQC no Kanren – Toyota ni Okeru Taiken Kara – [The Lean Production System ・ The Toyota Production System ・ In Relation to Toyota’s TQC – Based on the Toyota Experience - ]’ Dai 186 kai Chuubu Bukai Shiryou [Working Paper for the 186th Central Division Seminar], Nihon Keiei Gakkai [Japanese Management Society], December 20th, 1 – 5.

Nippon Densou Kabushiki Kaisha Shashi Henshuu Iinkai (ed.) (1984) Nippon Densou 35 nen shashi [Nippon Densou Thirty Five Year Company History], Nagoya: Nippon Densou.

Nihon Jidousha Buhin Kougyou Kai ・ Nihon Kougyou Rengou Kyoukai (1957) Jidousha Buhin Kougyou no Jittai [The Current State of the Automobile Parts Industry], Volume 2.

Nihon Jidousha Kaigisho (ed.) (1968 – 69) Jidousha Nenkan [Automotive Yearbook], Tokyo: Nikkan Jidousha Shimbunsha.

Nissan Jidousha Kabushiki Kaisha Soumubu Chousaka [Research Department, General Affairs Division, Nissan Automobile Company Ltd.] ed. (1965) Nissan Jidousha 30 nenshi Shouwa 8-nen – Shouwa 38-nen [Nissan Thirty Year Company History 1933 - 1963], Tokyo: Nissan Automobile Company Ltd.

Nissan Jidousha Kabushiki Kaisha Shashi Hensan Iinkai [Editorial Committee of Company History, Nissan Automobile Company Ltd.] ed. (1975) Nissan Jidousha Shashi 1964 – 1973 [Nissan Automobile Company History 1964 – 1973], Tokyo: Nissan Automobile Company Ltd.

Odaka, K. Ono, K. & Adachi, F. (1988) The Automobile Industry in Japan, A Study of Ancillary Firm Development, Tokyo: Kinokuniya / Oxford University Press.

Odaka, K. (1996) ‘Kishinhou to Jidousha Buhin – Koudo Seichouki Chokuzen ni okeru Sangyou Seisaku no Keizai teki Kouka nitsuite’ – [The Machinery Promotion Act and Automobile Parts – Economic Effects of Industrial Policy Immediately Preceding the High Growth Era-, Keizai Kenkyuu [Economic Research], 47(4), October, 340 – 356.

Ohkurasho (2000) Yuuka Shouken Houkokusho [Stock and Shares Report], Tokyo: Ohkurasho [Ministry of Finance].

Ooba, Y. (2001) Nihon Jidousha Sangyou no Seiritsu to Jidousha Seizou Gyouhou no Kenkyuu [A Study on the Japanese Automobile Industry, its establishment and Legislature affecting the manufacturing of Automobiles], Tokyo: Shinsan Publisher.

Ouchi, W. (1981) Theory Z: How American Business Can Meet the Japanese Challenge, Reading, Mass: Addison-Wesley.

Sangyou Gakkai ed. (1995) Sengo Nihon Sangyoushi [Post-war History of Japanese Industries], Tokyo: Touyou Keizai Shimbunsha [Touyou Economic News Company].

Smitka, M. (1991) Competitive Ties: Subcontracting in the Japanese Automotive Industry, New York: Columbia University Press.

Tsuushousangyoushou Juukougyouka [MITI Heavy Industry Division] (1956) Kikai Kougyou Shinkou Houto [How to Promote the Machinery Industry], Tokyo: Tsuushousangyou Chousakai [MITI Investigatory Committee].

Tsuushousangyou Juukougyouka 「MITI Heavy Industry Division」 (1965) Nihon no Jidousha Kougyou [The Japanese Automobile Industry], Tokyo: Tsuushou Sangyou Kenkyuusha.

Williamson, O. (1985) The Economic Institutions of Capitalism: Firms, Markets, Relational Contracting, New York: The Free Press.

Womack, J., D. Jones and D. Roos, (1990) The Machine That Changed The World, New York: Macmillan Publishing Company.

Yamaguchi, A. (1979) ‘Jidousha Sangyou Seisaku [The Automobile Industrial Policy]’ in Kitada Y. and T. Aida (eds.) Gendai Nihon no Keizai Seisaku (2) [Japan’s Modern Economic Policy – Volume 2], Tokyo: Ootsuki Shoten.

Yamazaki, S. (2003) Sengo Nihon no Jidousha Sangyou Seisaku [The Automobile Industrial Policy in Post-war Japan], Kyoto: Houritsu Bunkasha.