The 1719-20 stock euphoria: a pan-European perspective

Condorelli, Stefano (2014): The 1719-20 stock euphoria: a pan-European perspective.

Abstract

The French Mississippi Bubble, British South Sea Bubble and Dutch Windhandel were part of a 1719-20 pan-European equity boom that involved many more countries than hitherto thought. Drawing on extensive archival research, the paper establishes that speculation and stock euphoria spanned from Portugal to Russia, and from Sicily to Sweden. As such, it demonstrates that 1720 European financial markets were largely driven by common forces. Comparing all the projects (successful or unsuccessful) for joint-stock companies promoted around 1720, the paper underlines three aspects that shed new light on this first transnational financial bubble. First, these projects bring to the fore a two-speed Europe: while the most advanced economies focused on innovative business sectors (in particular marine insurance), the least developed were catching up with a model that was more than one century old, namely the privileged company for long-distance trade and colonization. Second, French and British experiments with public debt engineering (that fuelled the Mississippi and South Sea Bubbles) were emulated throughout Europe; in almost every country there were schemes geared to improving public finances. Third, the timing of the global equity boom was more diachronic than previously thought, suggesting that contemporaries did not expect that a stock market crash somewhere should necessarily generate a contagion effect.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Financial history, early modern history, European economic integration, South Sea Bubble, Mississippi Bubble, financial crisis synchronicity, joint-stock companies, public debt-for-equity swap, marine insurance, long-distance trade, financial innovation.
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F31 - Foreign Exchange; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F36 - Financial Aspects of Economic Integration; G - Financial Economics > G0 - General > G01 - Financial Crises; G - Financial Economics > G1 - General Financial Markets > G15 - International Financial Markets; H - Public Economics > H6 - National Budget, Deficit, and Debt > H63 - Debt ; Debt Management ; Sovereign Debt; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M1 - Business Administration > M13 - New Firms ; Startups; N - Economic History > N2 - Financial Markets and Institutions > N23 - Europe: Pre-1913; N - Economic History > N4 - Government, War, Law, International Relations, and Regulation > N43 - Europe: Pre-1913

References

Anderson, A., An historical and chronological deduction of the origin of commerce (London, 1801) [1st ed. 1762].

Barrington, J. S., The Lord Viscount Barrington’s case in relation to the Harburgh Company and the Harburgh lottery (London, 1722).

Bell, J., Travels from St. Petersburgh in Russia to various parts of Asia (Edinburgh, 1788).

Defoe, D. [attributed to], The French Chimera, or the French way of paying National Debts laid open (London, 1720).

Durival, N. L., Introduction à la description de la Lorraine et du Barrois (Nancy, 1774).

Harris, J., Navigantium atque itinerantium bibliotheca. Or, a complete collection of voyages and travels (London, 1744).

Hartsinck, J. J., Beschryving van Guiana, of de wilde kust in Zuid-America (Amsterdam, 1770).

Het groote Tafereel der Dwaasheid (Amsterdam, 1720).

Journal of the House of Commons, from October the 9th 1722 to May the 15th 1727, vol. 20 (London, 1803).

Ker, J., The Memoirs of John Ker of Kersland (London, 1726).

Lécuyer de la Jonchère, E., Système d'un nouveau gouvernement en France (Amsterdam, 1720).

Lettre d’un prélat au marquis de… au sujet du cardinal Alberoni (pub. in Gazette d’Amsterdam, 10 February-17 March 1722).

Marmont du Hautchamp, B., Histoire du système des finances, sous la minorité de Louis XV, pendant les années 1719 & 1720 (The Hague, 1739).

Records of the Convention of the Royal Burghs of Scotland, 1711-1738 (Edinburgh, 1885).

Recueil des edits, ordonnances, declarations […] du règne de Léopold I (Nancy, 1733).

Ronzio, G., Progetto per rimettere il mercimonio decaduto ed il commercio in Milano (Milan, 1720).

Savary des Brûlons, J., Dictionnaire universel de commerce (Copenhagen, 1759-1765).

The Case of great numbers of His Majesty's injured subjects, drawn in by the artifice of Stephen Ram, of London, goldsmith, and agents to become proprietors of lottery tickets, pretended to be Brunswick, s.n., (s.l., 1720).

Ward, E., ‘A South Sea ballad’, [The Delights of the Bottle] (London, 1720).

Amsinck, C., ‘Die ersten hamburgischen Assecuranz-Compagnien und der Aktien-handel im Jahre 1720’, Zeitschrift des Vereins für hamburgerische Geschichte, 9 (1894).

Androsov, S., ‘Le relazioni commerciali e culturali tra la Russia e Genova all'inizio del XVIII secolo’, in Grande pittura Genovese dall'Ermitage da Luca Cambiaso a Magnasco (Milano, 2002).

Ashton, T. S., Economic fluctuations in England in the Eighteenth Century (Oxford, 1959).

Association des historiens modernistes des universités, L’information à l’époque moderne (Paris, 2001).

Baasch, E., ‘Hamburg und die Compagnie von Ostende’, Zeitschrift für Social- und Wirthschaftsgeschichte, 5 (1897).

Banner S., Anglo-American securities regulation: cultural and political roots, 1690-1860 (Cambridge, 1998).

Bartolomei, A., ‘Les réseaux négociants de trois maisons huguenotes de Cadix à la fin du XVIIIe siècle : des réseaux languedociens, protestants ou français ?’, Liame, 25 (2012).

Baer, E., Zur Vorgeschichte der deutschen Kreditgenossenschaften (Heidelberg, 1907).

Béguin, K., Financer la guerre au XVIIe siècle : la dette publique et les rentiers de l'absolutisme (Seyssel, 2012).

Bergasse, L. and G. Rambert, Histoire du commerce de Marseille (Paris, 1954).

Bersani, S., Storia del cardinale Giulio Alberoni (Piacenza, 1861).

Bignami, G., Elogio del cardinale Giulio Alberoni (Piacenza, 1833).

Boiteux, L.-A., L’assurance maritime à Paris sous le règne de Louis XIV (Paris, 1945). – La fortune de mer : le besoin de sécurité et les débuts de l'assurance maritime (Paris, 1968).

Bonnassieux, L. J. P., Les grandes compagnies de commerce; étude pour servir à l’histoire de la colonisation (Paris, 1892).

Boxer, C. R., ‘Padre António Vierira, S.J., and the Institution of the Brazil Company in 1649’, The Hispanic American Historical Review, Vol. 29, No. 4 (November 1949).

Caizzi, B., Industria e commercio nella republica veneta del XVIII secolo (Milano, 1965). – Industria, commercio e banca in Lombardia nel XVIII secolo (Milano, 1968).

Casado Alonso, H., ‘La circulation de l’information dans les réseaux de commerce espagnols aux XVe et XVIe siècles’, Les Cahiers du Centre de Recherches Historiques, 42 (2008).

Carlos, A. and L. Neal, ‘The micro-foundations of the early London capital market: Bank of England shareholders during and after the South Sea Bubble, 1720–25’, Economic History Review, 59, 3 (2006).

Carswell, J., The South Sea Bubble (Stroud 1993, 1st ed. London, 1960).

Clark, C. E., The Public Prints: The Newspaper in Anglo-American Culture, 1665-1740 (Oxford, 1993).

Clark, J. G., ‘Marine Insurance in Eighteenth-Century La Rochelle’, French Historical Studies, 10, 4 (1978).

Clayton, G., British insurance (London, 1971).

Conant, C. A., A history of modern banks of issue (New York, 1915) [1st ed. 1896].

Condorelli, S., ‘La presse étrangère et le Système de Law (1716-20)’, in F. Magnot-Ogilvy (ed.), Gagnons sans savoir comment. Représentations du Système de Law du XVIIIe siècle à nos jours (Rennes, forthcoming).

Costa, L. F., ‘Merchant groups in the 17th-century Brazilian sugar trade: Reappraising old topics with new research insights’, Journal of Portuguese History, 2, 1 (Summer 2004).

Costantini, M., ‘Commercio e marina’, in P. Del Negro and P. Preto (eds), Storia di Venezia. L’ultima fase della serenissima (Roma, 1998).

Cummings, A. J. G., ‘The Harburgh Company and its lottery 1716-1723’, Business History, vol. 28, 3 (1986).

De Jong, A., J. Jonker and A. Röell, ‘Dutch Corporate Finance, 1602-1850’, ERIM Report Series (June 2013).

Delgado Barrado, J. M., Fomento portuario y compañías privilegiadas: los ‘diálogos familiares’ de Marcelo Dantini (1741-1748) (Madrid, 1998).

Dickson, P. G. M., The financial revolution in England: a study in the development of public credit 1688–1756 (London, 1967).

Dickson, P. G. M., and J. Sperling, ‘War Finance, 1689-171’ in J. S. Bromley (ed.), The New Cambridge Modern History, volume 6, The Rise of Great Britain and Russia, 1688-1715/25 (Cambridge, 1970).

Disney, A. R., ‘The First Portuguese India Company, 1628-33’, The Economic History Review, vol. 30, No. 2 (May 1977).

Di Vittorio, A., ‘Porti e porto franco, un aspetto della politica commerciale austriaca nel Mezzoggiorno continentale d’Italia 1707-1734’, Mitteilungen des osterreichischen staatsarchivs, 25 band (1972). – Gli Austriaci e il regno di Napoli. Ideologia e politica di sviluppo (Napoli, 1969). – ‘Un capitolo di storia bancaria europea: i banchi pubblici e il finanziamento dello stato asburgico agli inizi del ‘700’, Rassegna economica del Banco di Napoli, n 4 (July-August 1974).

Drew, B., The London Assurance: a second chronicle (London, 1928).

DuBois, A. B., The English business company after the Bubble act, 1720-1800 (New York, 1938).

Elie, H., ‘La spéculation sous la Régence : l’affaire du canal d’Avignon à la mer’, Provence historique, 12, 3 (1953).

Faure, E., La banqueroute de Law : 17 juillet 1720 (Paris, 1977).

Forbes, K. J. and R. Rigobon ‘Contagion in Latin America: Definitions, Measurement, and Policy Implications’, Economía 1.2 (2001).

Frehen, R. G .P., W. N. Goetzmann and K. G. Rouwenhorst, ‘New evidence on the first financial bubble’, working paper (2011). – ‘New evidence on the first financial bubble’, Journal of Financial Economics, 108 (2013). – ‘Finance in the Great Mirror of Folly’ in C. Labio, W. N. Goetzmann, K. G. Rouwenhorst and T. Young (eds), The ‘Great Mirror of Folly’: Finance, Culture, and the Crash of 1720 (New Haven, 2013).

Fusaro, M., ‘Cooperating Mercantile Networks in the Early Modern Mediterranean’, The Economic History Review, 65, 2 (May 2012).

Gallo, F, ‘La relazione Sul commercio in Sicilia di Ignazio Perlongo (1720)’, Archivio Storico per la Sicilia Orientale (1995).

Gelderblom, O. and J. Jonker, ‘Mirroring different follies. The character of the 1720 Bubble in the Dutch Republic’, working paper (2010). – ‘Mirroring different follies. The character of the 1720 Bubble in the Dutch Republic’, in C. Labio, W. N. Goetzmann, K. G. Rouwenhorst and T. Young (eds), The ‘Great Mirror of Folly’: Finance, Culture, and the Crash of 1720 (New Haven, 2013).

Giarrizzo, G., ‘La Sicilia dal Cinquecento all’unità d’Italia’, in Id. and V. D’Alessandro, La Sicilia dal Vespro all’unità d’Italia (Turin, 1989).

Giraud, M., Histoire de la Louisiane française. L’époque de John Law (1717-1720) (Paris 1966).

Gosling, A., Slingelandt’s Efforts Towards European Peace (The Hague, 1915).

Groeneveld, F. P., De economische crisis van het jaar 1720 (Groningen, 1940).

Hall, F. G., The Bank of Ireland, 1783-1946 (Dublin, 1949).

Hamilton, E. J. ‘Prices and Wages at Paris under John Law’s System’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 51, 1 (November 1936).

Handlin, O. and M. F. Handlin, ‘Origins of the American Business Corporation’, The Journal of Economic History, vol. 5, 1 (May, 1945).

Harris, B., ‘Scotland’s Herring Fisheries and the Prosperity of the Nation, c. 1660-1760’, The Scottish Historical Review, vol. 79, n. 1 (April 2000).

Harris M., London newspapers in the age of Walpole: a study of the origins of the modern English press (London, 1987).

Harris, R., ‘The Bubble Act: Its Passage and Its Effects on Business Organization’, The Journal of Economic History, vol. 54, 3 (1994). – Industrializing English law: entrepreneurship and business organization, 1720-1844 (Cambridge, 2000).

Haussonville, J., Histoire de la réunion de la Lorraine à la France, IV (Paris, 1860).

Hoffman, F. T., G. Postel-Vinay and J.-L. Rosenthal, Des marchés sans prix. Une économie politique du crédit à Paris, 1660-1870 (Paris, 2001).

Hoppit, J., ‘The Myths of the South Sea Bubble’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, VI (2002).

Huisman, M., La Belgique commerciale sous l’empereur Charles VI. La Compagnie d’Ostende (Bruxelles, 1902).

Infelise, M., Prima dei giornali. Alle origini della pubblica informazione (secoli XVII-XVIII) (Roma-Bari, 2002).

Ingrao, C. W., The Habsburg monarchy, 1618-1815, 2d ed. (Cambridge, 2000).

Khandaker, S. and R. Heaney, ‘Do Emerging Markets Have Higher Stock Synchronicity? The International Evidence’, Journal of Business and Policy Research, 4, 1 (2009).

Khandaker, S. and S. Z. Islam, ‘Volatility and co-movement: an analysis of stock markets behaviour of selected emerging and developed countries’, Proceedings of the Australasian Conference on Business and Social Sciences (Sydney, 2015).

Kindleberger, C. P., Manias, panics and crashes: a history of financial crises (London, 1978).

Kleer, R. A., ‘Riding a wave: the Company's role in the South Sea Bubble’, The Economic History Review, 68, 1 (2015).

Kuran, T., ‘The Absence of the Corporation in Islamic Law: Origins and Persistence’, American Journal of Comparative Law, 53, 2005.

Kuznets, S., Population, Capital and Economic Growth: Selected Essays (London, 1974).

Legay, M.-L., La banqueroute de l’État royal. La gestion des finances publiques de Colbert à la Révolution française (Paris, 2011).

Levasseur, E., Recherches historiques sur le système de Law (Paris, 1854).

Levy-Brühl, H., Histoire juridique des sociétés de commerce en France aux XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles (Paris, 1938).

Lüsebrink, H.-J., J.- Y. Mollier and S. Greilich (eds), Presse et événement: journaux, gazettes, almanachs (XVIIIe-XIXe siècles) (Bern, 2000).

Lüthy, H., La banque protestante en France : de la Révocation de l’Edit de Nantes à la Révolution (Paris, 1959).

Marquardt, O., ‘Change and Continuity in Denmark’s Greenland Policy’, in E. Heinzelmann (ed.), The Oldenburg Monarchy: An Underestimated Empire? (Kiel, 2006).

McCagg, W. O., A history of Habsburg Jews, 1670-1918 (Bloomington, 1988). Moore, S., ‘Satiric norms, Swift's financial satires and the Bank of Ireland controversy of 1720-1’, Eighteenth Century Ireland, XVII (2002).

Morineaux, M., Ces Incroyables Gazettes et Fabuleux Metaux (Cambridge, 1985).

Murphy, A. E., Richard Cantillon: Entrepreneur and Economist (Oxford, 1986).

Murphy, A. L., The origins of English financial markets: investment and speculation before the South Sea Bubble (Cambridge, 2009).

Muzzi, S., Annali della città di Bologna (Bologna 1846).

Neal, L., The rise of financial capitalism: international capital markets in the age of reason (Cambridge, 1990). – ‘“For God’s Sake, Remitt Me”. The Adventures of John Law’s Goldsmith-Banker in London, 1712-1729’, Business and Economic History, 23, 2 (1994). – “I am not master of events”: the speculations of John Law and Lord Londonderry in the Mississippi and South Sea Bubbles (New Haven, 2012).

Neal, L. and S. Quinn, ‘Networks of information, markets, and institutions in the rise of London as a financial centre, 1660–1720’, Financial History Review, vol. 8 (2001).

Oswalt, W. H., Eskimos and Explorers (Novato, 1999 [2 ed.]).

Perrott, D., ‘Changes in Attitude to Limited Liability – the European Experience’, in T. Orhnial, (ed.), Limited Liability and the Corporation (London, 1982).

Pons Pons, J., ‘Compañías de seguro marítimo en España (1650-1800)’, Hispania. Revista española de historia, vol. LXVII (2007).

Raynes, H. E., A history of British insurance (London, 1948).

Roider, K. A., ‘Reform and diplomacy in the Eighteen century Habsburg monarchy’, in Ingrao C. W. (ed.), State and Society in Early Modern Austria (West Lafayette, Ind., 1994).

Rosenhaft, E., ‘ “Tout ce qui brille n’est pas d’or” : la couverture du système de Law dans la culture écrite germanophone’, in F. Magnot-Ogilvy (ed.), Gagnons sans savoir comment. Représentations du Système de Law du XVIIIe siècle à nos jours (Rennes, forthcoming).

Roth, P., Kurhessisches privatrecht (Marburg, 1858).

Ryder, M., ‘The Bank of Ireland, 1721: Land, Credit and Dependency’, Historical Journal, 25 (1982).

Saraiva, A. J., The Marrano Factory: The Portuguese Inquisition and Its New Christians, 1536-1765 (Leiden, 2011).

Šarkova, I. S., Rossija i Italija: Torgovye otnošenija, 15 - pervoj četverti 18 (Leningrad, 1982).

Saville, R., Bank of Scotland: A History, 1695-1995 (Edinburgh, 1996).

Sayous, A.-E., ‘L’affaire de Law et les Genevois’, Revue d’Histoire Suisse (1937). – ‘Les répercussions de l’affaire de Law et du South Sea Bubble dans les Provinces Unies’, Bijdragen tot de vaderlandsche geschiedenis en oudheidkunde (1940).

Shiller, R. J., Finance and the Good Society (Princeton, 2012).

Schubert, E., The Ties That Bound: Eighteenth Century Market Behavior in Foreign Exchange, International Goods, and Financial Assets, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation (Urbana-Champaign, 1986). – ‘Innovations, debts, and bubbles: international integration of financial markets in Western Europe, 1688-1720’, Journal of Economic History, 48 (1988).

Scott, W. R., The constitution and finance of English, Scottish, and Irish joint-stock companies to 1720, 3 vols. (Cambridge, 1910-12).

Sladkovskii, M. I., History of Economic Relations Between Russia and China (New Brunswick, 1966).

Slauter, W., ‘Forward-Looking Statements: News and Speculation in the Age of the American Revolution?’, The Journal of Modern History, vol. 81, no. 4 (December 2009).

Slechte, C., ‘De Maatschappij van Assurantie, Disonteering en Beleening der stad Rotterdam van 1720, bekeken naar haar produktiefactoren over de periode 1720-1874’, Rotterdams Jaarboekje, 7, vol. 8 (1970). – Een noodlottig jaar voor veel zotte en wijze: De Rotterdamse Windhandel van 1720 (‘s-Gravenhage, 1982).

Smith, P. H., Business of alchemy: science and culture in the Holy Roman Empire (Princeton, 1994).

Spooner, C., Risks at sea, Amsterdam insurance and maritime Europe, 1766-1780 (Cambridge, 1983).

Stefani, G., L’assicurazione a Venezia: dalle origini alla fine della Serenissima (Trieste, 1956).

Straus, R., Lloyd’s: A Historical Sketch (London, 1937).

Supple, B., The Royal Exchange Assurance: a history of British insurance, 1720-1970 (London, 1970).

Sutherland, J., The Restoration Newspaper and its Development (Cambridge, 2004).

Temin, P. and H. J. Voth ‘Riding the South Sea bubble’, The American Economic Review, 94 (2004).

Torres Sánchez, R., Constructing a Fiscal Military State in Eighteenth Century Spain (Basingstoke, 2015).

Trintzius, R., John Law et la naissance du dirigisme (Paris, 1950).

Trivellato, F., The Familiarity of Strangers: The Sephardic Diaspora, Livorno, and Cross-Cultural Trade in the Early Modern Period (New Haven, 2009).

Troickij, S. M., ‘Le système de John Law et ses continuateurs russes’, in École pratique des hautes études-Sorbonne, Institut d’histoire universelle de l’Académie des sciences de l’U.R.S.S, La Russie et l’Europe, XVIe-XXe siècles (Paris 1970).

Van Langendonck, C.,‘Le mouvement colonial en Belgique au XVIIe siècle’ Revue belge de philologie et d’histoire, 2 (1923).

Van Rijn, G., ‘De Aktiehandel in 1720 te Rotterdam en de Maatschappij van Assurantie, Discontering en Beleening dezer Stad’, Rotterdamsch Jaarboekje (1899).

Velde, F., ‘Government Equity and Money: John Law’s System in 1720 France’, working paper, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago (2003 and 2004). – ‘Was John Law’s System a bubble? The Mississippi Bubble revisited’, in J. Atack and L. Neal (eds), The origins and development of financial markets and institutions: from the seventeenth century to the present (Cambridge, 2009).

Voth, ‘Blowing early bubbles. Rational exuberance in the South Sea and Mississippi and Bubbles’, in C. Labio, W. N. Goetzmann, K. G. Rouwenhorst and T. Young (eds), The ‘Great Mirror of Folly’: Finance, Culture, and the Crash of 1720 (New Haven, 2013).

Walsh, P., The South Sea Bubble and Ireland: Money, Banking and Investment, 1690-1721 (Woodbridge 2014).

Wennerlind, C., Casualties of credit. The English Financial Revolution, 1620-1720 (Cambridge Mass., 2011).

White, E. N., ‘France and the Failure to Modernize Macroeconomic Institutions’, in M. Bordo and R. Cortés-Conde (eds), Transferring Wealth and Power from the Old to the New World. Monetary and Fiscal Institutions in the 17th through the 19th Centuries (Cambridge, 2001). – ‘The long Shadow of John Law on French Public Finance: The Mississippi Bubble’, in C. Labio, W. N. Goetzmann, K. G. Rouwenhorst and T. Young (eds), The ‘Great Mirror of Folly’: Finance, Culture, and the Crash of 1720 (New Haven, 2013).

Wilson, C., Anglo-Dutch Commerce and Finance in the Eighteenth Century (Cambridge, 1941).

Yamamoto, K., ‘The speculation that dared not speak its name: The investment strategies of James Brydges the first Duke of Chandos during the South Sea Bubble’, paper presented at the WEHC 2015.