A Cost Benefit Analysis of introducing Electric Vehicles in Bhutan

Norbu, Nyingtob (2015): A Cost Benefit Analysis of introducing Electric Vehicles in Bhutan.

Abstract

Bhutan is reputed for its pristine environment and its unparalleled commitment towards environmental conservation. However, recent studies have found that carbon emissions are on the rise with rapidly increasing fossil fuel consumption, which now constitutes the most significant item in Bhutan’s import basket. While Bhutan is a net exporter of hydroelectric energy the import of fossil fuel offsets nearly 70% of the exports of electricity to India. In the aftermath of the recent balance of payments challenges with India, the country is compelled to consider alternative mobility options to reduce its dependence on fossil fuel imports and harness its abundant hydro-power, but more importantly, to serve as a model for conservation efforts. With the vision to become the first full-fledged electric-vehicle city in the world, Bhutan must mobilize significant institutional and financial resources. As a stepping stone towards this initiative the government is considering the replacing of a fleet of taxis with electric vehicle equivalents. The relative upfront costs of adopting an electric platform are considered a major deterrent notwithstanding the future stream of savings on account of lower energy and maintenance costs and the intangible benefits to society as a whole. Hence, this paper conducts a Cost Benefit Analysis of the initiative. While most studies focus only on the end-user, this study takes a more comprehensive approach by studying the costs and benefits to both users as well as society taking into consideration various assumptions and scenarios. The macroeconomic and microeconomic implications of this initiative are assessed, and policy recommendations are also offered. Under all scenarios the EV option emerges as the most preferred model. Even the baseline scenario in which no incentives are offered reveals a favourable outcome for the EV. However, these outcomes are assessed over a relatively long time span of 8 and 10 years which gives rise to a time inconsistency problem, which is why some intervention may be necessary to nudge individuals in favour of the EV option.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Cost benefit analysis, sustainable transport, environment
• Subjects: Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q42 - Alternative Energy Sources; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R4 - Transportation Economics > R42 - Government and Private Investment Analysis ; Road Maintenance ; Transportation Planning; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R4 - Transportation Economics > R48 - Government Pricing and Policy

References

Agarwal, Pradeep. 2012. “India’s Petroleum Demand: Empirical Estimations and Projections for the Future.” IEG Working Paper, No. 319

Al-Alawi, Baha and Bradley, Thomas. 2013. “Total Cost of Ownership and Consumer Preference Modelling of Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles.” Colorado State University.

Asian Development Bank. 2008. “Strategy 2020: The long term strategic framework of the Asian Development Bank.” Manila: ADB.

Bhutan Electricity Authority. 2013. “Bhutan Power Corporation Limited Tariff Review Report.” Royal Government of Bhutan.

Bullis, Kevin. 2012. How Improved Batteries Will Make Electric Vehicles Competitive, accessed 21st February, 2014, http://www.technologyreview.com/news/506881/how-improved-batteries-will-make-electric-vehicles-competitive/

Coase, R.H. 1960. “The Problem of Social Cost.” Journal of Law and Economics, Volume 3 (October., 1960), pp. 1-44.

Die Bundesregierung. 2009. “German Federal Government’s National Electromobility Development Plan.” Germany.

Department of Finance and Administration. 2006. “Introduction to Cost-Benefit Analysis for Program Managers.” 1995 (second edition) Commonwealth of Australia.

Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 2011. “Greenhouse Gas Emissions from a Typical Passenger Vehicle.” Michigan, US.

Gayer, Ted and Parker, Emily. 2013. “The Car Allowance Rebate System: Evaluation and Lessons for the Future.” Brookings Institute.

Hoch, Stephen J. 1991. “Time-inconsistent Preferences and Consumer Self-Control.” Journal of Consumer Research, Volume 17 (March, 1991), pp. 492-507.

“Improving Taxi Availability 2013,” accessed 24th February, 2014, http://app.lta.gov.sg/data/apps/news/press/2012/27072012_Factsheet_ImprovingTaxiAavailability.pdf

Ingram, Antony. 2012. Electric Car Maintenance A Third Cheaper than Combustion Vehicles? accessed 25th February, 2014, http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1080925_electric-car-maintenance-a-third-cheaper-than-combustion-vehicles

Kubiszewski Ida, Costanza Robert, Dorji Lham, Thoennes Philip and Tshering Kuenga. 2012. “An Initial Estimate of the Value of Ecosystem Services in Bhutan.” Bhutan.

Litterman, Bob. 2013. “What is the Right Price for Carbon Emissions?” Energy & Environment, (Summer 2013), pp. 38-43.

Mahindra REVA. 2014. “Proposal for Introduction of Electric Mobility in Bhutan.” Bangalore: Mahindra

Mal, Siddhartha, Arunabh Chattopadhyay, Albert Yang, and Rajit Gadh. 2012. “Electric vehicle smart charging and vehicle-to-grid operation.”

International Journal of Parallel, Emergent and Distributed Systems, Volume 27, No. 3 (March 2012).

National Environment Commission. 2013. “Brief Report on Air Quality Status Over 2011-2012.” Royal Government of Bhutan.

National Environment Commission. 2011. “Capacity Building of National Environment Commission in Climate Change: Transport Sector Final Report.” Royal Government of Bhutan.

National Statistical Bureau. 2013. “Annual Statistical Yearbook.” Royal Government of Bhutan.

Nina, Manuel Branco N. 2010. “Introduction of Electric Vehicles in Portugal: A Cost-Benefit Analysis.” Instituto Superior Tecnico.

Perkins, Frances C. 1994. “Practical Cost Benefit Analysis: Basic Concepts and Applications.” Melbourne: Macmillan Education Australia Pty. Ltd.

Road Safety and Transport Authority. 2013. “Annual Report.” Royal Government of Bhutan.

Rosen, Harvey S. and Gayer, Tod. 2010. Public Finance, 9th edition. New York, NY: The McGraw Hill Companies Inc.

Royal Monetary Authority. 2014. “Annual Report.” Royal Government of Bhutan.

Schill, Wolf-Peter. 2010. “Electric vehicles: Charging into the Future.” German Institute for Economic Research, Weekly Report, Volume 6 (September 8, 2010).

TIAX LLC. 2007. “Full Fuel Cycle Assessment: Well to Tank Energy Inputs, Emissions, and Water Impacts.” California Energy Commission.

U.S. Energy Information Administration. 2013. “International Energy Outlook 2013.” Washington, US