An axiomatic approach to sustainable development

Chichilnisky, Graciela (1995): An axiomatic approach to sustainable development. Published in: Social Choice and Welfare , Vol. 13, (1996): pp. 231-257.

Abstract

The paper proposes two axioms that capture the idea of sustainable development and derives the welfare criterion that they imply. The axioms require that neither the present nor the future should play a dictatorial role. Theorem 1 shows there exist sustainable preferences, which satisfy these axioms. They exhibit sensitivity to the present and to the long-run future, and specify trade-offs between them. It examines other welfare criteria which are generally utilized: discounted utility, lim inf. long run averages, overtaking and catching-up criteria, Ramsey's criterion, Rawlsian rules, and the criterion of satisfaction of basic needs, and finds that none satisfies the axioms for sustainability. Theorem 2 gives a characterization of all continuous independent sustainable preferences. Theorem 3 shows that in general sustainable growth paths cannot be approximated by paths which approximate discounted optima. Proposition 1 shows that paths which maximize the present value under a standard price system may fail to reach optimal sustainable welfare levels, and Example 4 that the two criteria can give rise to different value systems.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: sustainable development; economic development; welfare
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C0 - General; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q0 - General > Q01 - Sustainable Development

References

Arrow KJ (1953) Social Choice and Individual Values. Cowles Foundation Monographs, Wiley, New York

Arrow KJ, Kurz M (1970) Public Investment, the Rate of Return and Optimal Fiscal Policy. Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore and London

Arrow KJ (1964) Aspects of the Theory of Risk-Bearing. Yrjo Jahnsson Lectures, Yrjo Jahonssonin Saatio, Helsinki

Asheim G (1988) Rawlsian intergenerationaljustice as a Markov-perfect equilibrium in a resource economy. Rev Econ Studies LV: 469-484

Asheim G (1991) Unjust Intergenerational Allocations. J Econ Theory 54(2): 350-371

Herrera A, Scolnik H, Chichilnisky G et al. (1976) Catastrophe or New Society: A Latin American World Model. (The Bariloche Model). International Development Research Center, Ottawa, Canada

Beltratti A, Chichilnisky G, Heal GM (1993) The Green Golden Rule: valuing the long run. Working Paper, Columbia University, Economic Letters, 49 (1995) 175-179

Broome J (1992) Counting the Cost of Global Warming. White Horse Press, London

Brundtland GH (1987) The U.N. World Commission on Environment and Development: Our Common Future. Oxford University Press, Oxford

Chichilnisky G (1977) Development patterns and the international order. J Int Affairs 31(2): 275-304

Chichilnisky G (1977) Economic development and efficiency criteria in the satisfaction of basic needs. Appl Math Modeling 1(6): 290-297

Chichilnisky G, Kalman PJ (1980) Application of functional analysis to models of efficient allocation of economic resources. 1 Optimization Theory App 30: 19-32

Chichilnisky G (1982) Social aggregation rules and continuity. Q J Econ 97: 337-352

Chichilnisky G (1993) On strategic control. Q J Econ 108: 285-290

Chichlinisky G (1993) The cone condition, properness and extremely desirable commodities. Econ Theory (3): 177-182

Chichilnisky G, Heal G (1993) Competitive equilibrium in Sobolev spaces without bounds on short sales. J Econ Theory (59): 364-384

Chichilnisky G (1993) North-South Trade and the Dynamics of Renewable Resources. Keynote address to the conference The Environment after Rio. Courmayeur, Italy, 10-12 February 1993. In: Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, vol 4 No. 2, pp 219-248

Chichilnisky G (1991) North-south trade and the global environment. Technical Report No. 31, Stanford Institute of Theoretical Economics, 1992. Am Econ Rev September 1994, vol 84, No 4, pp 851-874

Chichilnisky G (1993) The abatement of carbon emissions in industrial and developing countries: Comment. Paper presented at The International Conference on the Economics of Climate Change, DECD/IEA, Paris, 1993 June 14-16; in OECD: The Economics of Climate Change (ed. T. Jones) pp 159-169

Chichilnisky G (1994) Social diversity, arbitrage and gains from trade: a unified perspective on resource allocation. Am Econ Rev pp 427-434

Cline WR (1992) The Economics of Global Warming. Institute for International Economics, Washington D.C.

Coppel J (1993) Implementing a global environmental policy: some selectd issues. Economic Division, OECD. Paper presented at The International Conference on the Economics of Climate Change, OECD/IEA, Paris, 14-16 June 1993; in OECD: The Economics of Climate Change led. T. Jones), pp 141-159

Debreu G (1954) Valuation equilibrium and Pareto optimum. Pro Nat Acad Sciences 40:588-592

Dasgupta P, Heal G (1979) Economic Theory and Exhaustible Resources. University Press, Cambridge

Dutta P (1991) What do discounted optima converge to? J Econ Theory 55: 64-94

Gale D (1967) On optimal development in a multisector economy. Rev Econ Studies pp 1-18, vol XXXIV (1) No. 97, January 1967

Hammond PJ (1993) Is there anything new in the concept of sustainable development. Paper presented to the conference The Environment after Rio, Courmayeur, Italy, 10-12 February 1993

Heal G (1985) Depletion and discounting: a classical issue in the economics of exhaustible resources. Am Math Society, Pro Symposia App Math 32: 33-43

Heal GM (1993) Valuing the very long run: discounting and the environment. Payne Webber Working Paper Series, Columbia Business School, New York

Hicks J (1946) Value and Capital. The Clarendon Press. Oxford University Press, 2nd edn.

Koopmans T (1963) On the concept of optimal economic growth. Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper No. 163 and 163A

Lauwers L (1993) Infinite Chichilnisky rules. Discussion Paper, Katholik Universitaet Leuven; to appear in Econ Letters

Lauwers L, van Liederkierke L Monotonic Chichilnisky rules with infinite populations. Discussion Paper, Katholik Universitaet: Leuven, to appear in Soc Choice Welfare, 1996

McFadden D (1967) The evaluation of development programmes. Rev Econ Studies pp 25-50, vol XXXIV (1) No 97, January 1967

Mirrleess J, Stern N (1973) Theory of Economic Growth. McMillan for the International Economic Association

Ramsey F (1928) A mathematical theory of saving. Econ J 38: 543-559

Rawls J (1971) A Theory of Justice. Bellknap Press, Cambridge, MA

Solow R (1974) Intergenerational equity and exhaustible resources. Rev Econ Studies, Symposium on the Economics of Exhaustible Resources pp 29-45

Solow R (1992) An almost practical step toward sustainability. Lecture on the Occasion of the Fortieth Anniversary of Resources for the Future. Resources for the Future, Washington D.C.

Yosida K (1974) Functional Analysis. Springer Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York 4th edn.

Yosida K, Hewitt E (1952) Finitely level independent measures. Trans Am Math Society 72: 46-66

von Weizacker (1967) Lemmas for a theory of approximate optimal growth. Rev Econ Studies pp 143-151, vol XXXIV (1) No 97, January 1967

World Resources Institute, United Nations Environment Program and United Nations Development Program (1995) World Resources: People and the Environment (1994-5) A Guide to the Global Environment, Oxford University Press