The Economics of Next Generation Access Networks and Regulatory Governance: Towards Geographic Patterns of Regulation

Amendola, Giovanni Battista and Pupillo, Lorenzo Maria (2008): The Economics of Next Generation Access Networks and Regulatory Governance: Towards Geographic Patterns of Regulation. Published in: Communications & Strategies No. 69 (March 2008): pp. 85-105.

Abstract

This paper examines the mix of technical, regulatory, and business strategy issues that arise in implementing next generation broadband platforms in Europe. Our review of some European studies on NGAN in Europe and our specific focus on the Italian situation, in particular on the competitive situation in Milano, shows the relevant flaw of continuing to advocate national patterns of regulation. In fact, the deployment of NGAN calls for a radical shift of regulation on a geographic level. The recognition that a NGAN business case does exist for OLO in a number of local areas, mainly metropolitan ones, has relevant regulatory implications.In the first place, since the conditions of competition differ significantly among local areas, regulation should promote both incumbents' and OLO's investments in NGAN by limiting ex ante interventions to those enduring economic bottlenecks found at a specific geographic markets level. In the second place, market definition is the most important step in the market analysis procedure to help decide whether to regulate a given service provided over a NGAN or not. We have proposed a taxonomy of local areas that may be adopted in a country like Italy for a correct geographic definition of markets 4 and 5 and, as a consequence, for the imposition of appropriate remedies.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Next Generation Networks, geographic markets, geographic remedies, infrastructure sharing, market definition
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L10 - General

References

AGCM (2001): Provvedimento 9142 (C4158B) Seat Pagine Gialle/Cecchi Gori Communications.

AGCOM (2007): Annual Report. Analysys (2006): "The business case for sub-loop unbundling in the Netherlands".

ARCEP: - (2006): FTTH Case study for the City of Clermont-Ferrand - (2007): http://www.arcep.fr/uploads/tx_gspublication/consult-ftth-fourreaux-juillet07.pdf.

BANERJEE A. & SIRBU M (2006): "Fiber to the Premise (FTTP) Industry Structure: Implications of a Wholesale-Retail Split".

CAVE M., STUMPF U. & VALLETTI T. (2006): A Review of certain markets included in the Commission's Recommendation on Relevant Markets subject to ex ante Regulation, Report for the European Commission.

DASGUPTA K. & WAVERMAN L. (2007): "Investment in Telecommunications Network: A 21st Century Perspective", London Business School, Working Papers.

European Commission: - (1997): "Commission notice on the definition of relevant market for the purposes of Community competition law", Official Journal C 372. - (2002): "Commission guidelines on market analysis and the assessment of significant market power under the Community regulatory framework for electronic communications networks and services", 2002/C, 165/03. - (2003): "Commission Recommendation on relevant product and service markets ", C(2003) 497. - (2007): "Commission Recommendation on relevant product and service markets", C(2007) 5406 rev 1. European Communities (2002): Directive 2002/21/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council – Framework Directive.

ERG: - (2006): "Revised ERG Common Position on the approach to appropriate remedies in the ECNS regulatory framework". - (2007): "ERG Consultation Document on Regulatory Principles of NGA". Fastweb (2007): "Fastweb's Business model in the Peculiar case of the Italian Market", ERG Meeting, Torino, April. ITU-T Rec. Y. 2001 (2004): General overview of NGN. JPMorgan (2006): "The Fibre Battle".

MAXWELL W., SIERADZKI D. & WOOD M (2007): "Regulating Duct Access for NGA in Europe: Lessons from the U.S. Regulatory Framework", COMMUNICATIONS & STRATEGIES, no. 68, 4th quarter.

Ofcom: - (2006): "Review of the wholesale broadband access markets 2006/07", Consultation, November. - (2007): "Review of the wholesale broadband access markets 2006/2007", November.

PUPILLO L. & A. CONTE (1998): "The economics of local loop architecture for multimedia services", Information Economics and Policy,10, pp. 107-126.

Telecom Italia (2007): "Future Access Network", C5 World Forum, Milano, March.

WIK Consult (2007): "Possibilities and Prerequisites of a FTTx Strategy in Germany", June 6.