Tariffs, Domestic Import Substitution and Trade Diversion in Input-Output Production Networks: how to deal with Brexit

Giammetti, Raffaele (2019): Tariffs, Domestic Import Substitution and Trade Diversion in Input-Output Production Networks: how to deal with Brexit.

Abstract

This paper challenges and complements existing studies on the economic impact of Brexit providing a discussion of the UK's decision to leave the EU and how it will affect international trade networks and value-added. Using the World Input-Output Database, we develop a multi-sector inter-country model that allows us to identify the channels through which the economic effects of Brexit would propagate. The inclusion of global value chains and indirect Brexit effects in the model leads to estimates that diverge with the results of the main literature. Indeed our findings, suggest that Brexit could be risky and costly not only for the UK but also for many EU countries. Furthermore, building on the Dietzenbacher and Lahr (2013) method of hypothetical expansion, we develop a second model and present the first empirical analysis on the consequences of domestic import substitution and trade diversion policies in Input-Output schemes. We found that allowing sectors and countries to partly substitute foreign products, leads to significantly lower losses for both macro-regions. In the second model, the UK and EU27 would lose, at worst, the 0.05 and 0.5 percent of value-added, respectively.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Brexit, trade barriers, tariffs, input-output analysis, value chains, import substitution, production networks.
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C67 - Input-Output Models; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F14 - Empirical Studies of Trade; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O2 - Development Planning and Policy > O21 - Planning Models ; Planning Policy; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R15 - Econometric and Input-Output Models ; Other Models

References

Acemoglu, D., Carvalho, V., Ozdaglar, A. and Tahbez-Salehi, A., 2012. The Network Origins of Aggregate Fluctuations, Econometrica 80(5).

Aichele, R., Felbermayr, G., 2015. Costs and benefits of a United Kingdom exit from the European Union. GED Study, Bertelsmann Stiftung.

Aiello, F., Bonanno, G., Via, A., 2015. Again on trade elasticities: evidence from a selected sample of countries, Eurasian Bus Rev (2015) 5:259–287.

Alatriste-Contreras, M., G., Fagiolo, G., 2014. Propagation of Economic Shocks in Input-Output Networks: A Cross-Country Analysis, Physical Review E, Vol. 90, 062812.

Balassa, B., 1979. Accounting for Economic Growth: the Case of Norway, Oxford Economic Papers, Volume 31, Issue 3, 1 November 1979, Pages 415–436

Baldwin, R., 2016. Brexit Beckons: thinking ahead by leading economists. Baldwin, Richard E ed. Publication info: London, CEPR Press.

Battiston, S., Delli Gatti, D., Gallegati, M., Greenwald, B. and Stiglitz, J., 2007. Credit chains and bankruptcy propagation in production networks, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 31, issue 6, pp. 2061-2084.

Becker, S., Fetzer, T., & Novy, D., 2017. Who voted for Brexit? A comprehensive district‐level analysis. Economic Policy, 32(92), 601–650.

Berden, K., Francois, J., Tamminem, S., Thelle, M. and Wymenga, P., 2013. Non-Tariff Measures in EU-US Trade and Investment: An Economic Analysis, IIDE Discussion Papers 20090806, Institute for International and Development Economics.

Bigio, S., La’O, J., 2016. Financial frictions in production networks. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper (22212).

Booth, S., Howarth, C., Persson, M., Ruparel, R., Swidlicki, P., 2015. What if …? The consequences, challenges and opportunities facing Britain outside the EU, Open Europe Report, No. 3, London.

Bruton, H., J., 1998. A Reconsideration of Import Substitution, Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 36, No. 2, pp. 903-936.

Busch, B., Matthes, J., 2016. Brexit - the economic impact: A meta-analysis, IW-Reports 10/2016, Institut der deutschen Wirtschaft (IW) / German Economic Institute.

Cambridge Econometrics, 2018. Preparing for Brexit, Report for Greater London Authority, January.

Cappariello, R., Damjanovic, M., Mancini, M., Vergara Caffarelli, F., 2018. EU-UK global value chain trade and the indirect costs of Brexit. Questioni di Economia e Finanza, Occasional Papers, Bank of Italy. Number 468 – November.

Chen, J., Ebeke, E., Lin, L., Qu, H., Schoelermann, H., Siminitz, J., 2018. The Long-Term Impact of Brexit on the European Union. IMF Country Report No. 18/224.

Chen, W., Los, B., McCann, P., Ortega‐Argilés, R., Thissen, M., & van Oort, F., 2018. The continental divide? Economic exposure to Brexit in regions and countries on both sides of The Channel. Papers in Regional Science, 97(1), 25–54.

Colantone, I., Stanig, P., 2018. Global Competition and Brexit. American Political Science Review, 112(2), pp. 201-218. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055417000685

Commendatore, P., Kubin, I., Sushko, I., 2018. The impact of Brexit on trade patterns and industry location: a NEG analysis. Department of Economics Working Papers Series. Vienna: WU Vienna University of Economics and Business.

Costinot, A. and Rodriguez-Clare, A., 2014. Trade theory with numbers: Quantifying the consequences of globalization, Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Coutts, K., Gudgin, G., Buchanan, J., 2018. How the Economics Profession Got It Wrong on Brexit, Working Papers wp493, Centre for Business Research, University of Cambridge.

Coutts, K., Rowthorn, R., 2013. The UK balance of payments: structure and prospects, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, Volume 29, Number 2, 2013, pp. 307–325.

Crafts, N., 2016. The Growth Effects of EU Membership for the UK: A Review of the Evidence, Social market Foundation Global Perspectives Series Paper 7.

Cripps, F., Godley, W.A.H., 1976. A Formal Analysis of the Cambridge Economic Policy Group Model, Economica New Series, Vol. 43, No. 172, pp. 335-348

Delli Gatti, D., Gallegati, M., Greenwald, B., C., Russo, A., Stiglitz, J., E., 2010. The financial accelerator in an evolving credit network. Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control 34 (2010) 1627–1650.

Dietzenbacher, E., & Lahr, M.L., 2013. Expanding extractions. Economic Systems Research, 25, 341–360.

Dietzenbacher, E., Lenzen, M., Los, B., Guan, D., Lahr, M.L., Sancho, F., Suh, S., Yang, C., 2013. Input-output analysis: the next 25 years, Economic Systems Research, 25:4, 369-389, DOI: 10.1080/09535314.2013.846902

Dietzenbacher, E., Los, B., Stehrer, R., Timmer, M. P., & de Vries, G., 2013. The construction of world input‐output tables in the WIOD project. Economic Systems Research, 25, 71–98.

Dietzenbacher, E., van der Linden, J.A., Steenge, A.E., 1993. The Regional Extraction Method: EC Input-Output Comparisons. Economic Systems Research, 5, 185–206.

Dhingra, S., Huang, H., Ottaviano, G., Pessoa, J., Sampson, T. and Van Reenen, J., 2017. The costs and benefits of leaving the EU: Trade effects, CEP Discussion paper 1478.

Gagnon, J. E., 2013. Currency wars. The Milken Institute Review, 15(1), 47–55.

Godley, W.A.H., and May, R., 1977. The Macroeconomic Implications of Devaluation and Import Restrictions. Cambridge Economic Policy Review, 1977,3,32-42.

Greenaway, D., 1983. International Trade Policy: From Tariffs to the New Protectionism. The MACMILLAN Press LTD, London, England-United Kingdom.

Greenaway, D., Milner, C., 2003. Effective Protection, Policy Appraisal and Trade Policy Reform. The World Economy, 26(4): 441-456. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9701.00531

Gualdi, S., Mandel, A., 2018. Endogenous Growth in Production Networks. J Evol Econ (2018). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00191-018-0552-x

Gudgin G, Coutts K, Gibson N, and Buchanan J., 2017a. The Role of Gravity Models in estimating the Economic Impact of Brexit. Centre forBusiness Research, University of Cambridge Working Paper No. 490.

Gudgin G, Coutts K, Gibson N, and Buchanan J., 2017b. Defying Gravity. A Critique of estimates of the Economic Impact of Brexit. Policy Exchange. London.

Head, K., and T. Mayer, 2014. Gravity Equations: Workhorse,Toolkit, and Cookbook, chapter 3 in Gopinath, G, E. Helpman and K. Rogoff (eds), vol. 4 of the Handbook of International Economics, Elsevier: 131–195.

Imbs, J., Mejean, I., 2017. Trade elasticities, Review of International Economics 25(2), 383– 402.

Johnson, R. C., 2014. Five facts about value-added exports and implications for macroeconomics and trade research, The Journal of Economic Perspectives 28(2), 119–142.

Joyce, M., Lasaosa, A., Stevens, I., & Tong, M., 2011. The financial market impact of quantitative easing in the United Kingdom. International Journal of Central Banking, 7, 113–161.

Kaldor N., 1966. Causes of the Slow Rate of Growth of the United Kingdom, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Kaldor N., 1975. Economic Growth and the Verdoorn Law, in «Economic Journal», 85, pp. 891-896.

Kamitake Y., 1990. The Process of De industrialization in Modern Economic History: Lessons from British Historical Experience, in «Hitotsubashi Journal of Economics», 31, pp. 49-59.

Kierzenkowski, R., Pain, N., Rusticelli, E. and Zwart, S., 2016. The Economic Consequences of Brexit: A Taxing Decision, OECD Economic Policy Paper 16.

Koopman, R., Wang, Z., & Wei, S.‐J., 2014. Tracing value‐added and double counting in gross exports. American Economic Review, 104(2), 459–494.

Los, B., McCann, P., Springford, J., & Thissen, M., 2017. The mismatch between local voting and the local economic consequences of Brexit. Regional Studies, 51(5), 786–799.

Los, B., Timmer, M. P., & de Vries, G. J., 2016. Tracing value‐added and double counting in gross exports: Comment. American Economic Review, 106(7), 1958–1966.

Miller, R.E., 1966. Interregional Feedbacks in Input-Output Models: Some Preliminary Results. Papers, Regional Science Association, 17, 105–125.

Miller, R. E., Blair, P. D., 2009. Input‐output analysis; foundations and extensions (2nd ed.). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Miller, R.E., Lahr, M.L., 2001. A Taxonomy of Extractions. In: M.L. Lahr and R.E. Miller (eds.) Regional Science Perspectives in Economic Analysis. Amsterdam: Elsevier Science, 407–44.

Mulabdic, A., Osnago, A., and Ruta, M., 2017. Deep Integration and UK- EU Trade Relations, Policy Research Working Paper Series 7947, The World Bank.

Noguera, G., 2012. Trade costs and gravity for gross and value added trade, Job Market Paper, Columbia University.

Norman, N.R., 1996. A General Post Keynesian Theory of Protection, Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 18:4, 509-531.

Ottaviano, G., Pessoa, J., Sampson, T. and Van Reenen, J., 2014. The Costs and Benefits of Leaving the EU, Centre for Economic Performance Policy Analysis.

Piermartini, R., Teh, R., 2005. Demystifying Modelling Methods for Trade Policy, WTO Discussion Paper, No. 10. Plummer, M. G., Cheong, D., Hamanaka, S., 2010. Methodology for Impact Assessment of Free Trade Agreements, Asian Development Bank, Mandaluyong City, pp. 20−25.

Rojas-Romagosa, H., 2016. Trade effects of Brexit for the Netherlands. CPB Background Document, June 2016.

Rodrik D., 2018a. Populism and the economics of globalization. Journal of International Business Policy. Volume 1, Issue 1–2, pp 12–33.

Rodrik, D., 2018b. How to Avoid a Trade War - Project Syndicate - July 10, 2018. https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/china-europe-reaction-trump-trade-tariffs-by-dani-rodrik-2018-07

Rodrik, D., 2018c. Can Trade Agreements Be a Friend to Labor? - Project Syndicate - September 14, 2018. https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/trade-agreement-labor-provisions-small-practical-effect-by-dani-rodrik-2018-09

Rowthorn, R., Coutts, K., 2004. De-industrialisation and the balance of payments in advanced economies, Cambridge Journal of Economics, Volume 28, Issue 5, Pages 767–790.

Rowthorn, R. E. and J. R. Wells, 1987. De-industrialisation and Foreign Trade, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Singh, A., 1989. Third World competition and de-industrialisation in advanced countries, Cambridge Journal of Economics 13(1), 103-120.

Skidelsky, R., 2016. The Case for UK Import Substitution - Project Syndicate - October 21, 2016. https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/case-for-uk-import-substitution-by-robert-skidelsky-2016-10

Springford, J., McCann, P., Los, B., & Thissen, M., 2016. Brexiting yourself in the foot: Why Britain’s Eurosceptic regions have most to lose from EU withdrawal. London: Centre for European Reform (CER).

Stone, R., 1970. Foreign Trade and Full Employment: An Input-Output Analysis, in Richard Stone (ed.), Mathematical models of the economy and other essays, Chapman & Hall, London.

Thirlwall A.P., 1979. The Balance of Payments Constraint as an Explanation of International Growth Rate Differences, Banca Nazionale del Lavoro Quarterly Review, 32 (1), pp. 45-53.

Thirlwall A.P., 2001. The Euro and Regional Divergence in Europe, chapter 2 in Martin Holmes (eds), The Eurosceptical Reader 2, PALGRAVE, New York.

Timmer, M.P., Dietzenbacher, E., Los, B., Stehrer, R. and de Vries, G. J., 2015. An illustrated user guide to the world input–output database: the case of global automotive production, Review of International Economics 23(3), 575–605.

Treasury, H. M., 2016. HM Treasury analysis: the long-term economic impact of EU membership and the alternatives. Parliament by the Chancellor of the Exchequer by command of Her Majesty, April.

United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), 2013. Global Value Chains and Development: Investment and Value Added Trade in the Global Economy, Advance Unedited Version.

Vandenbussche, H., Connell, W., & Simons, W., 2017. Global value‐chains, trade shocks and jobs: An application to Brexit. In CEPR Discussion Paper DP123030. London, UK: Centre for Economic Policy Research.