The role of non-tariff measures in the agri-food sector: positive or negative instruments for trade?

Santeramo, Fabio Gaetano and Lamonaca, Emilia (2019): The role of non-tariff measures in the agri-food sector: positive or negative instruments for trade? Forthcoming in:

Abstract

The contribution shows the state of the art of “trade and non-tariff measures” debate in the agri-food sector. It provides an overview on trends in trade and in the level of policy interventions over the last decades, in order to shed lights on potential cause-effect relations. Comparing the evolution of trade and of non-tariff measures (NTMs) in agri-food sector, it appears that the pervasiveness of NTMs is likely to be strictly related to changes in trade patterns. Although the main scope of NTMs is to correct market inefficiencies, they may have a two-fold role: trade catalysts or trade barriers. The potential relationships between trade and NTMs, however, differ across involved countries, products under regulation, and types of measure. Indeed, evidence from the empirical literature support either the “standards as catalysts” and the “standards as barriers” points of view. Our contribution aims at outlining how NTMs and trade influence each other.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Trade; Agri-food sector; Non-tariff measure; Standard as catalyst; Standard as barrier
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations; F - International Economics > F5 - International Relations, National Security, and International Political Economy > F53 - International Agreements and Observance ; International Organizations; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q17 - Agriculture in International Trade; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q18 - Agricultural Policy ; Food Policy

References

Anders S, Caswell JA (2009) Standards-as-barriers versus standards-as-catalysts: Assessing the impact of HACCP implementation on U.S. seafood imports. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 91(2):310–321

Anderson K, Martin W (2005) Agricultural trade reform and the Doha Development Agenda. The World Economy 28(9):1301-1327

Anderson K, Nelgen S (2012) Trade barrier volatility and agricultural price stabilization. World Development 40(1):36-48

Arita S, Beckman J, Mitchell L (2017) Reducing transatlantic barriers on US-EU agri-food trade: What are the possible gains?. Food Policy 68:233-247

Athukorala PC, Jayasuriya S (2003) Food safety issues, trade and WTO rules: a developing country perspective. The World Economy 26(9):1395-1416

Bagwell K, Staiger R (2011) What Do Trade Negotiators Negotiate About? Empirical Evidence from the World Trade Organization. American Economic Review 101(4):1238-73

Beckman J, Arita S (2016) Modeling the Interplay between Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures and Tariff-rate Quotas under Partial Trade Liberalization. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 99(4):1078–1095

Cardamone P (2011) The effect of preferential trade agreements on monthly fruit exports to the European Union. European Review of Agricultural Economics 38(4):553-586

Chen C, Yang J, Findlay C (2008) Measuring the effect of food safety standards on China’s agricultural exports. Review of World Economics 144(1):83–106

Chevassus-Lozza E, Latouche K, Majkovic D, Unguru M (2008) The importance of EU-15 borders for CEECs agri-food exports: The role of tariffs and non-tariff measures in the pre-accession period. Food Policy 33(6):595–606

Cioffi ., Santeramo FG, Vitale CD (2011) The price stabilization effects of the EU entry price scheme for fruit and vegetables. Agricultural Economics 42(3):405-418

Crivelli P, Gröschl J (2016) The impact of sanitary and phytosanitary measures on market entry and trade flows. The World Economy 39(3):444-473

Dal Bianco A, Boatto VL, Caracciolo F, Santeramo FG (2016) Tariffs and non-tariff frictions in the world wine trade. European Review of Agricultural Economics 43(1):31-57

de Frahan BH, Vancauteren M (2006) Harmonisation of food regulations and trade in the Single Market: evidence from disaggregated data. European Review of Agricultural Economics 33(3):337-360

Disdier AC, Fontagné L, Cadot O (2015) North-South standards harmonization and international trade. The World Bank Economic Review 29(2):327-352

Disdier AC, Marette S (2010) The combination of gravity and welfare approaches for evaluating non-tariff measures. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 92(3):713–726

Drogué S, DeMaria F (2012) Pesticide residues and trade, the apple of discord?. Food Policy 37(6):641-649

Essaji A (2008) Technical regulations and specialization in international trade. Journal of International Economics 76(2):166-176

Fernandes AM, Ferro E, Wilson JS (2017) Product Standards and Firms’ Export Decisions. The World Bank Economic Review [in press]

Ferro E, Otsuki T, Wilson JS (2015) The effect of product standards on agricultural exports. Food Policy 50:68-79

Fontagné L, Mayer T, Zignago S (2005) Trade in the triad: How easy is the access to large markets? Canadian Journal of Economics 38(4):1401–1430

Grant JH, Arita S (2017) Sanitary and Phyto-Sanitary Measures: Assessment, Measurement, and Impact. IATRC Commissioned Paper, 21:1-53

Grant JH, Lambert DM (2008) Do regional trade agreements increase members’ agricultural trade?. American journal of agricultural economics 90(3):765-782

Greenville J (2015) Issues in agricultural trade policy: An overview. In Issues in Agricultural Trade Policy: Proceedings of the 2014 OECD Global Forum on Agriculture, May

Harrigan J (1993) OECD imports and trade barriers in 1983. Journal of International Economics 34(1–2):91–111

Henson S, Brouder AM, Mitullah W (2000) Food safety requirements and food exports from developing countries: the case of fish exports from Kenya to the European Union. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 82(5):1159-1169

Henson S, Loader R (2001) Barriers to agricultural exports from developing countries: the role of sanitary and phytosanitary requirements. World development 29(1):85-102

Ivanic M, Martin W (2014) Implications of domestic price insulation for global food price behavior. Journal of International Money and Finance 42:272-288

Jayasinghe S, Beghin JC, Moschini GC (2010) Determinants of world demand for U.S. corn seeds: The role of trade costs. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 92(4):999–1010

Jongwanich J (2009) The impact of food safety standards on processed food exports from developing countries. Food Policy 34(5):447-457

Koo WW, Kennedy PL, Skripnitchenko A (2006) Regional preferential trade agreements: Trade creation and diversion effects. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy 28(3):408-415

Lambert D, McKoy S (2009) Trade creation and diversion effects of preferential trade associations on agricultural and food trade. Journal of Agricultural Economics 60(1):17-39

Martin W (2018) A Research Agenda for International Agricultural Trade. Applied Economic Perspectives and Policy 40(1):155-173

Mehta R, George J (2003). Processed food products exports from India: an exploration with SPS regime. Country report prepared under the ACIAR Project, International Food Safety Regulation and Processed Food Export from Developing Countries, Delhi: Research Information Systems and the Australian National University

Melo O, Engler A, Nahuehual L, Cofre G, Barrena J (2014) Do sanitary, phytosanitary, and quality-related standards affect international trade? Evidence from Chilean fruit exports. World Development 54:350-359

OECD (2015) Regional trade agreements and agriculture. OECD Food, Agriculture and Fisheries Papers, No. 79, OECD Publishing, Paris

Olper A, Raimondi V (2008) Explaining national border effects in the QUAD food trade. Journal of Agricultural Economics 59(3):436–462

Otsuki T, Wilson JS, Sewadeh M (2001a) What price precaution? European harmonization of aflatoxin regulations and African groundnut exports. European Review of Agricultural Economics 28(2):263–283

Otsuki T, Wilson JS, Sewadeh M (2001b) Saving two in a billion: quantifying the trade effect of European food safety standards on African exports. Food policy 26(5):495-514

Peterson E, Grant JH, Roberts D, Karov V (2013) Evaluating the trade restrictiveness of phytosanitary measures on US fresh fruit and vegetable imports. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 95(4):842-858

Santeramo FG (2019) On Non-Tariff Measures and Changes in Trade Routes: From North-North to South-South Trade?. IATRC Commissioned Paper, No. 938-2019-1580

Santeramo FG, Cioffi A (2012) The entry price threshold in EU agriculture: Deterrent or barrier?. Journal of Policy Modeling 34(5):691-704

Santeramo FG, Guerrieri V, Lamonaca E (2019a) On the evolution of trade and sanitary and phytosanitary standards: The role of trade agreements. Agriculture 9(1): 2.

Santeramo FG, Lamonaca E (2019a) On the Drivers of Global Grain Price Volatility: an empirical investigation. Agricultural Economics (AGRIECON) 65(1):31-42

Santeramo FG, Lamonaca E (2019b) The Effects of Non‐tariff Measures on Agri‐food Trade: A Review and Meta‐analysis of Empirical Evidence. Journal of Agricultural Economics 71(1) [in press]

Santeramo FG, Lamonaca E (2019c) On the impact of non-tariff measures on export performances of African agri-food sector. Agrekon 1-18

Santeramo FG, Lamonaca E, Contò F, Nardone G, Stasi A (2018) Drivers of grain price volatility: a cursory critical review. Agricultural Economics (AGRIECON) 64:347-356

Santeramo FG, Lamonaca E, Nardone G, Seccia A (2019b) The benefits of country-specific non-tariff measures in world wine trade. Wine Economics and Policy [in press]

Scheepers S, Jooste A, Alemu ZG (2007) Quantifying the impact of phytosanitary standards with specific reference to MRLs on the trade flow of South African avocados to the EU. Agrekon 46(2):260–273

Schuster M, Maertens M (2013) Do private standards create exclusive supply chains? New evidence from the Peruvian asparagus export sector. Food Policy 43:291-305

Sheldon I (2012) North–South trade and standards: what can general equilibrium analysis tell us?. World Trade Review 11(3):376-389

Shepherd B, Wilson NL (2013) Product standards and developing country agricultural exports: The case of the European Union. Food Policy 42:1-10

Shepotylo O (2016) Effect of non-tariff measures on extensive and intensive margins of exports in seafood trade. Marine Policy 68:47-54

Sun D, Huang J, Yang J (2014) Do China’s food safety standards affect agricultural trade? The case of dairy products. China Agricultural Economic Review 6(1):21-37

Sun L, Reed MR (2010) Impacts of free trade agreements on agricultural trade creation and trade diversion. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 92(5):1351-1363

Swinnen J (2016) Economics and politics of food standards, trade, and development. Agricultural Economics 47(1) 7-19

Swinnen J (2017) Some dynamic aspects of food standards. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 99(2):321-338

Trebilcock M, Pue K (2015) The Puzzle of Agricultural Exceptionalism in International Trade Policy. Journal of International Economic Law 18:233-60

UNCTAD (2012) International Classification of Non-Tariff measures, February 2012 version (UNCTAD/DITC/TAB/2012/2). New York, Geneva: United Nations.

United Nations (2017) World Economic Situation and Prospects. United Nations New York.

Wacziarg R (2001) Measuring the dynamic gains from trade. The World Bank Economic Review 15(3):393-429

Wei G, Huang J, Yang J (2012) The impacts of food safety standards on China’s tea exports. China Economic Review 23(2):253-264

Wilson JS, Otsuki T (2004) To spray or not to spray: Pesticides, banana exports, and food safety. Food Policy 29(2):131–146

Wilson JS, Otsuki T, Majumdsar B (2003) Balancing food safety and risk: do drug residue limits affect international trade in beef?. Journal of International Trade & Economic Development 12(4):377-402

Xiong B, Beghin JC (2011) Does European aflatoxin regulation hurt groundnut exporters from Africa?. European Review of Agricultural Economics 39(4):589-609

Xiong B, Beghin JC (2014) Disentangling Demand‐Enhancing and Trade‐Cost Effects of Maximum Residue Regulations. Economic Inquiry 52(3):1190-1203

Yue C, Beghin, JC (2009) Tariff equivalent and forgone trade effects of prohibitive technical barriers to trade. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 91(4):930-941