Munich Personal RePEc Archive

You go First! Coordination Problems and the Standard of Proof in Inquisitorial Prosecution

Christmann, Robin and Kirstein, Roland (2020): You go First! Coordination Problems and the Standard of Proof in Inquisitorial Prosecution.

[img]
Preview
PDF
MPRA_paper_99686.pdf

Download (640kB) | Preview

Abstract

The prosecution of criminals is costly, and subject to errors. In contrast to adversarial court procedures, the prosecutor is regarded as an impartial investigator and aide to the judge in inquisitorial justice systems. We show in a sequential prosecution game of a Bayesian court that a strategic interaction between these two benevolent enforcement agents exists where each player hopes to freeride on the other one´s investigative effort. This gives rise to inefficient equilibria with excessive operating and error costs. Moreover, we will demonstrate that our results are sensitive to the applied standard of proof and that, more disturbingly, the inefficient outcome becomes more probable when the conviction threshold is raised. Applying the concept of ‘beyond reasonable doubt’, we analyze the impact of the standard of proof and other legal policy instruments on type I and type II errors and operating costs.

Logo of the University Library LMU Munich
MPRA is a RePEc service hosted by
the University Library LMU Munich in Germany.