Employment Effects of Unemployment Insurance Generosity During the Pandemic

Scott, Dana and Finamor, Lucas (2020): Employment Effects of Unemployment Insurance Generosity During the Pandemic.

Abstract

In response to the Covid-19 pandemic, the United States enacted the CARES Act, which expanded unemployment insurance (UI) benefits by providing a $600 weekly payment in addition to state unemployment benefits. We test whether changes in UI benefit generosity are associated with decreased employment, both at the onset of the benefits expansion and as businesses began to reopen. We use data from Homebase, a private firm that provides scheduling and time clock software to small businesses, which allows us to exploit high-frequency observations to understand how firms and workers respond to policy changes in real time. While our results show that relative declines in employment and hours occurred in mid-March, we find that the workers with higher post-CARES replacement rates did not experience larger declines in employment or hours of work when the benefits expansion went into effect. They have also returned to their previous jobs over time at similar rates as others.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Unemployment Insurance, Employment, COVID-19, CARES Act
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J64 - Unemployment: Models, Duration, Incidence, and Job Search; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J68 - Public Policy

References

ABADIE, A., ATHEY, S., IMBENS, G. W. and WOOLDRIDGE, J. (2017).When should you adjust standarderrors for clustering?Tech. rep., National Bureau of Economic Research.

ALTONJI, J., CONTRACTOR, Z., FINAMOR, L., HAYGOOD, R., LINDENLAUB, I., MEGHIR, C., O’DEA,C., SCOTT, D., WANG, L. and WASHINGTON, E. (2020). The Effects of the Coronavirus on Hours ofWork in Small Businesses, Yale Tobin Center for Economic Policy, June 11.

BARRERO, J. M., BLOOM, N. and DAVIS, S. J. (2020). COVID-19 Is Also a Reallocation Shock, WorkingPaper, June 5.

BARTIK, A. W., BERTRAND, M., LIN, F., ROTHSTEIN, J. and UNRATH, M. (2020a). Measuring the labormarket at the onset of the COVID-19 crisis, NBER Working Paper No. 27613, July.

BARTIK, A. W., CULLEN, Z. B., GLAESER, E. L., LUCA, M., STANTON, C. T. and SUNDARAM, A. (2020b). TheTargeting and Impact of Paycheck Protection Program Loans to Small Businesses, NBER Working PaperNo. 27623, July.

BERTRAND, M., DUFLO, E. and MULLAINATHAN, S. (2004). How much should we trust differences-in-differences estimates?The Quarterly journal of economics,119(1), 249–275.

CAJNER, T., CRANE, L. D., DECKER, R. A., GRIGSBY, J., HAMINS-PUERTOLAS, A., HURST, E., KURZ,C. and YILDIRMAZ, A. (2020). The U.S. labor market during the beginning of the pandemic recession,Working paper, June 14.

CHENG, W., CARLIN, P., CARROLL, J., GUPTA, S., LOZANOROJAS, F., MONTENOVO, L., NGUYEN,T. D., SCHMUTTE, I. M., SCRIVNER, O., SIMON, K. I., WING, C. and WEINBERG, B. (2020). Backto Business and (Re)employing Workers? Labor Market Activity During State COVID-19 Reopenings,NBER Working Paper No. 27419, July.

CHETTY, R., FRIEDMAN, J. N., HENDREN, N., STEPNER, M. andTHEOPPORTUNITYINSIGHTSTEAM(2020). How did COVID-19 and stabilization policies affect spending and employment? A new real-timeeconomic tracker based on private sector data, Working paper, June 17.

COCHRANE, E. and FANDOS, N. (23 March 2020). Top Senate Democrat and Treasury Secretary Say TheyAre Near a Stimulus Deal.The New York Times.— and — (24 March 2020). Democrats Near Deal With White House on Stimulus Package.The New YorkTimes.

COCHRANE, E., TANKERSLEY, J. and SMIALEK, J. (22 March 2020). Emergency Economic Rescue Plan in Limbo asDemocrats Block Action.The New York Times.

FAIRLIE, R. W., COUCH, K. and XU, H. (2020). The Impacts of COVID-19 on Minority Unemployment:First Evidence from April 2020 CPS Microdata, NBER Working Paper No. 27246, May.

GANONG, P., NOEL, P. and VAVRA, J. (2020). US Unemployment Insurance Replacement Rates Duringthe Pandemic, Becker Friedman Institute Working Paper 2020-62, May.

GOOLSBEE, A. and SYVERSON, C. (2020). Fear, Lockdown, and Diversion: Comparing Drivers of Pan-demic Economic Decline 2020, NBER Working Paper No. 27432, June.

GUPTA, S., LOZANOROJAS, F., MONTENOVO, L., NGUYEN, T. D., SCHMUTTE, I. M., SIMON, K. I.,WING, C. and WEINBERG, B. (2020). Effects of Social Distancing Policy on Labor Market Outcomes,NBER Working Paper No. 27280, May.

HAGEDORN, M., KARAHAN, F., MANOVSKII, I. and MITMAN, K. (2019).Unemployment benefits and unemployment in the great recession: the role of macro effects. Tech. rep., Working paper.

HAGEDORN, M., MANOVSKII, I. and MITMAN, K. (2016).The impact of unemployment benefit extensions on employment: the 2014 employment miracle?Tech. rep., Working paper.HULSE, C. (21 March 2020). Push for Cash in Rescue Package Came From Unlikely Source: Conservatives.The New York Times.

JOHNS HOPKINS UNIVERSITY CENTER FOR SYSTEMS SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING(CSSE) (2020).2019 Novel Coronavirus Visual Dashboard.https://github.com/CSSEGISandData/.

KURMANN, A., LAL ́E, E. and TA, L. (2020). The impact of COVID-19 on U.S. employment and hours:Real-time estimates with Homebase data, Working paper, May.

LANDAIS, C., MICHAILLAT, P. and SAEZ, E. (2018). A macroeconomic approach to optimal unemployment insurance: Theory.American Economic Journal: Economic Policy,10(2), 152–81.

MARINESCU, I. E., SKANDALIS, D. and ZHAO, D. (2020). Job search, job posting and unemployment insurance during the COVID-19 crisis, Working paper, July.

MITMAN, K. and RABINOVICH, S. (2015). Optimal unemployment insurance in an equilibrium business-cycle model.Journal of Monetary Economics,71, 99–118.

MONTENOVO, L., JIANG, X., LOZANOROJAS, F., SCHMUTTE, I. M., SIMON, K. I., WEINBERG, B. A.and WING, C. (2020). Determinants of Disparities in Covid-19 Job Losses, NBER Working Paper No.27132, May.

RAIFMAN, J., NOCKA, K., JONES, D., BOR, J., LIPSON, S., JAY, J. and CHAN, P. (2020). COVID-19 USstate policy database.www.tinyurl.com/statepolicies.

SCHMIEDER, J. F. andVONWACHTER, T. (2016). The Effects of Unemployment Insurance Benefits: NewEvidence and Interpretation.Annual Review of Economics,8(1), 547–581.

SULLIVAN, E. (19 March 2020). 5 Takeaways From the Coronavirus Economic Relief Package.The NewYork Times.

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR(2020). Unemployment Insurance Relief During COVID-19 Outbreak.https://www.dol.gov/coronavirus/unemployment-insurance.