The Elasticity of Substitution between Skilled and Unskilled Labor: A Meta-Analysis

Havranek, Tomas and Irsova, Zuzana and Laslopova, Lubica and Zeynalova, Olesia (2020): The Elasticity of Substitution between Skilled and Unskilled Labor: A Meta-Analysis.

Abstract

A key parameter in the analysis of wage inequality is the elasticity of substitution between skilled and unskilled labor. We question the common view that the elasticity exceeds 1. Two biases, publication and attenuation, conspire to pull the mean elasticity reported in the literature to 1.9. After correcting for the biases, the literature is consistent with the elasticity in the US of 0.6--0.9. Our analysis relies on 729 estimates of the elasticity collected from 76 studies as well as 37 controls that reflect the context in which the estimates were obtained. We use recently developed nonlinear techniques to correct for publication bias and employ Bayesian and frequentist model averaging to address model uncertainty. Our results suggest that, first, insignificant estimates of the elasticity are underreported. Second, because researchers typically estimate the elasticity's inverse, measurement error exaggerates the elasticity, and we show the exaggeration is substantial. Third, elasticities are systematically larger for developed countries, translog estimation, and methods that ignore endogeneity.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Elasticity of substitution; skill premium; meta-analysis; model uncertainty; publication bias
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor

References

1. Acemoglu, D. (2002): “Technical change, inequality, and the labor market.” Journal of Economic Litera- ture 40(1): pp. 7–72.

2. Allen, G. D. & J. R. Hicks (1934): “A Reconsidera- tion of the Theory of Value, Part II.” Economica 1: pp. 196–219.

3. Amini, S. M. & C. F. Parmeter (2012): “Compari- son of model averaging techniques: Assessing growth determinants.” Journal of Applied Econometrics 27(5): pp. 870–876.

4. Andrews, I. & M. Kasy (2019): “Identification of and correction for publication bias.” American Economic Review 109(8): pp. 2766–2794.

5. Angrist, J. D. (1995): “The economic returns to schooling in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.” The American Economic Review 85(5): pp. 1065–1087.

6. Askilden, J. E. & O. A. Nilsen (2005): “Apprentices and young workers: A study of the Norwegian youth labour market.” Scottish Journal of Political Econ- omy 52(1): pp. 1–17.

7. Autor, D. H. (2014): “Skills, education, and the rise of earnings inequality among the ‘other 99 percent’.” Science 344(6186): pp. 843–851.

8. Autor, D. H., L. F. Katz, & M. S. Kearney (2008): “Trends in US wage inequality: Revising the revi- sionists.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 90(2): pp. 300–323.

9. Avalos, A. & A. Savvides (2006): “The manufactur- ing wage inequality in Latin America and East Asia: Openness, technology transfer, and labor supply.” Review of Development Economics 10(4): pp. 553– 576.

10. Behar, A. (2010): “The elasticity of substitution be- tween skilled and unskilled labor in developing coun- tries is about 2.” Technical report, Department of Economics, University of Oxford.

11. Bergstrom, V. & E. E. Panas (1992): “How robust is the capital-skill complementarity hypothesis?” The Review of Economics and Statistics 74(3): pp. 540– 546.

12. Berman, E., J. Bound, & Z. Griliches (1994): “Changes in the Demand for Skilled Labor within U.

13. S. Manufacturing: Evidence from the Annual Survey of Manufactures.” The Quarterly Journal of Eco- nomics 109(2): pp. 367–397.

14. Berndt, E. R. & L. R. Christensen (1973): “The translog function and the substitution of equipment, structures, and labor in US manufacturing 1929-68.” Journal of Econometrics 1(1): pp. 81–113.

16. Berndt, E. R. & L. R. Christensen (1974): “Test- ing for the existence of a consistent aggregate index of labor inputs.” The American Economic Review 64(3): pp. 391–404.

17. Berndt, E. R. & C. J. Morrisson (1979): “Income re- distribution and employment effects of rising energy prices.” Resources and Energy 2(2-3): pp. 131–150.

18. Binelli, C. (2015): “How the wage-education profile got more convex: Evidence from Mexico.” The B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics 15(2): pp. 509–560.

19. Blanco-Perez, C. & A. Brodeur (2020): “Publica- tion Bias and Editorial Statement on Negative Find- ings.” Economic Journal 130(629): pp. 1226–1247.

20. Blankenau, W. F. & S. P. Cassou (2011): “Indus- try estimates of the elasticity of substitution and the rate of biased technological change between skilled and unskilled labour.” Applied Economics 43(23): pp. 3129–3142.

21. Blundell, R., D. Green, & W. Jin (2016): “The UK wage premium puzzle: How did a large increase in university graduates leave the education premium unchanged?” IFS Working Papers 1/2016, The In- stitute for Fiscal Studies, London.

22. Borghans, L. & B. ter Weel (2008): “Understand- ing the technology of computer technology diffusion: Explaining computer adoption patterns and impli- cations for the wage structure.” Journal of Income Distribution 17(3-4): pp. 37–70.

23. Borjas, G. J. (2003): “The labor demand curve is downward sloping: Reexamining the impact of immi- gration on the labor market.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 118(4): pp. 1335–1374.

24. Borjas, G. J. & L. F. Katz (2007): “The evolution of the Mexican-born workforce in the United States.” In G. J. Borjas (editor), “Mexican immigration to the United States,” pp. 13–56. National Bureau of Economic Research Conference Report, University of Chicago Press.

25. Bound, J., J. Groen, G. Kezdi, & S. Turner (2004): “Trade in university training: Cross-state variation in the production and stock of college-educated la- bor.” Journal of Econometrics 121(1): pp. 143–173.

26. Bowles, S. (1970): “Aggregation of labor inputs in

27. the economics of growth and planning: Experiments with a two-level CES function.” Journal of Political Economy 78(1): pp. 68–81.

28. Broadstock, D., L. Hunt, & S. Sorrell (2007): “UKERC Review of Evidence for the Rebound Ef- fect - Technical report 3: Elasticity of substitution studies.” UKERC Working Paper Series 11/2007, UK Energy Research Centre, London.

29. Brodeur, A., N. Cook, & A. Heyes (2020): “Meth- ods Matter: P-Hacking and Causal Inference in Eco- nomics.” American Economic Review (forthcom- ing).

30. Brodeur, A., M. Le, M. Sangnier, & Y. Zylber- berg (2016): “Star Wars: The Empirics Strike Back.” American Economic Journal: Applied Eco- nomics 8(1): pp. 1–32.

31. Bruns, S. B. & J. P. A. Ioannidis (2016): “p-Curve and p-Hacking in Observational Research.” PloS ONE 11(2): p. e0149144.

32. Camerer, C., A. Dreber, F. Holzmeister, T. H. 33. Ho, J. Huber, M. Johannesson, M. Kirchler, 34. G. Nave, B. A. Nosek, & T. Pfeiffer (2018): “Evaluating the replicability of social science ex- periments in Nature and Science between 2010 and 2015.” Nature Human Behaviour 2: pp. 637–644.

35. Cantore, C., F. Ferroni, & M. A. Leo´n-Ledesma (2017): “The dynamics of hours worked and tech- nology.” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 82(C): pp. 67–82.

36. Card, D. (2009): “Immigration and inequality.” Amer- ican Economic Review 99(2): pp. 1–21.

37. Card, D., J. Kluve, & A. Weber (2018): “What Works? A Meta Analysis of Recent Active Labor Market Program Evaluations.” Journal of the Euro- pean Economic Association 16(3): pp. 894–931.

38. Card, D. & A. B. Krueger (1995): “Time-series minimum-wage studies: A meta-analysis.” Ameri- can Economic Review 85(2): pp. 238–243.

39. Card, D. & T. Lemieux (2001): “Can falling supply explain the rising return to college for younger men? A cohort-based analysis.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 116(2): pp. 705–746.

40. Caselli, F. (2005): “Accounting for Cross-Country In- come Differences.” In P. Aghion & S. Durlauf (ed- itors), “Handbook of Economic Growth,” volume 1, Part A, chapter 9, pp. 679–741. Elsevier, 1 edition.

41. Chirinko, R. S. & D. Mallick (2017): “The Sub- stitution Elasticity, Factor Shares, and the Low- Frequency Panel Model.” American Economic Jour- nal: Macroeconomics 9(4): pp. 225–253.

42. Choi, K.-S., J.-H. Jeong, & J. Hwa Jung (2005): “The rising supply of college graduates and declining returns for young cohort: The case of Korea.” Global Economic Review 34(2): pp. 167–180.

43. Christensen, G. & E. Miguel (2018): “Transparency,

44. Reproducibility, and the Credibility of Economics Research.” Journal of Economic Literature 56(3): pp. 920–980.

45. Ciccone, A. & G. Peri (2005): “Long-run substi- tutability between more and less educated workers: Evidence from US states, 1950–1990.” Review of Economics and Statistics 87(4): pp. 652–663.

46. Corker, R. & T. Bayoumi (1991): “Apartheid, growth and income distribution in South Africa: Past history and future prospects.” IMF Working Papers 116/1991, European Department, Interna- tional Monetary Fund.

47. Cruz, M., E. Milet, & M. Olarreaga (2017): “Online exports and the wage gap.” Policy Re- search Working Paper Series 8160/2017, Trade and Competitiveness Global Practice Group, The World Bank.

48. Das, G. G. (1999): “What is assumed in the GTAP database’s disaggregation of labor by skill level?” Monash Economic Working Papers IP-75, Centre of Policy Studies and Department of Economics, Monash University.

49. DellaVigna, S., D. Pope, & E. Vivalt (2019): “Pre- dict science to improve science.” Science 366(6464): pp. 428–429.

50. Denny, M. & M. Fuss (1977): “The use of approxima- tion analysis to test for separability and the existence of consistent aggregates.” The American Economic Review 67(3): pp. 404–418.

51. Doucouliagos, C. & T. D. Stanley (2013): “Are all economic facts greatly exaggerated? Theory compe- tition and selectivity.” Journal of Economic Surveys 27(2): pp. 316–339.

52. Dougherty, C. R. (1972): “Estimates of labor ag- gregation functions.” Journal of Political Economy 80(6): pp. 1101–1119.

53. Dupuy, A. (2007): “Will the skill-premium in the Netherlands rise in the next decades?” Applied Eco- nomics 39(21): pp. 2723–2731.

54. Dupuy, A. & P. Marey (2008): “Shifts and twists in the relative productivity of skilled labor.” Journal of Macroeconomics 30(2): pp. 718–735.

55. Egger, M., G. D. Smith, M. Schneider, & C. Minder (1997): “Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test.” BMJ 315(7109): pp. 629–634.

56. Eicher, T. S., C. Papageorgiou, & A. E. Raftery (2011): “Default priors and predictive performance in Bayesian model averaging, with application to growth determinants.” Journal of Applied Econo- metrics 26(1): pp. 30–55.

57. Fallon, P. R. & P. R. G. Layard (1975): “Capital-skill complementarity, income distribution, and output accounting.” Journal of Political Economy 83(2): pp. 279–302.

58. Feldkircher, M. & S. Zeugner (2012): “The im-

59. pact of data revisions on the robustness of growth determinants—a note on determinants of economic growth: Will data tell?” Journal of Applied Econo- metrics 27(4): pp. 686–694.

60. Fernandez, C., E. Ley, & M. F. J. Steel (2001): “Benchmark priors for Bayesian Model Averaging.” Journal of Econometrics 100(2): pp. 381–427.

61. Fernandez, M. & J. Messina (2017): “Skill pre- mium, labor supply and changes in the structure of wages in Latin America.” IDB Working Paper Series 786/2017, Inter-American Development Bank.

62. FitzGerald, J. D. & I. Kearney (2000): “Conver- gence in living standards in Ireland: The role of the new economy.” ESRI Working Paper Series 134/2000, Economic and Social Research Institute.

63. Foldvari, P. & B. van Leeuwen (2006): “Is there an optimal allocation of skills? A two-level CES ap- proach.” Technical report, Department of Economics, University of Warwick.

64. Freeman, R. B. (1975): “Overinvestment in college training?” Journal of Human Resources 10(3): pp. 287–311. 65. Freeman, R. B. (1986): “Demand for education.” In 66. O. Ashenfelter & R. Layard (editors), “Hand- book of Labor Economics,” volume 1, chapter 6, pp. 357–386. Elsevier Science Publishers BV.

67. Freeman, R. B. & J. L. Medoff (1982): “Substi- tution between production labor and other Inputs in unionzed and nonunionized manufacturing.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 64(2): pp. 220– 233.

68. Furukawa, C. (2020): “Publication bias under aggre- gation frictions: Theory, evidence, and a new correc- tion method.” Working paper, MIT.

69. Gallego, F. A. (2012): “Skill premium in Chile: Studying skill upgrading in the South.” World De- velopment 40(3): pp. 594–609.

70. Gancia, G. A., A. Muller, & F. Zilibotti (2013): “Structural development accounting.” In D. Ace- moglu, M. Arellano, & E. Dekel (editors), “Ad- vances in Economics and Econometrics: Tenth World Congress,” volume 2 of Econometric Society Mono- graphs, chapter 9, pp. 373–418. Cambridge: Cam- bridge University Press.

71. George, E. I. (2010): “Dilution priors: Compensating for model space redundancy.” In “IMS Collections Borrowing Strength: Theory Powering Applications

144. Stanley, T. D. (2001): “Wheat from Chaff: Meta- analysis as Quantitative Literature Review.” Journal of Economic Perspectives 15(3): pp. 131–150.

145. Stanley, T. D. (2005): “Beyond Publication Bias.” 146. Journal of Economic Surveys 19(3): pp. 309–345.

147. Stanley, T. D., S. B. Jarrell, & H. Doucouliagos (2010): “Could It Be Better to Discard 90% of the Data? A Statistical Paradox.” The American Statis- tician 64(1): pp. 70–77.

148. Steel, M. F. J. (2020): “Model Averaging and its Use in Economics.” Journal of Economic Literature (forthcoming).

149. Tinbergen, J. (1974): “Substitution of g raduate by other labour.” Kyklos 27(2): pp. 217–226.

150. Uzawa, H. (1962): “Production functions with Con- stant Elasticities of Substitution.” Review of Eco- nomic Studies 29: pp. 291–299.

151. te Velde, D. W. & O. Morrissey (2004): “Foreign direct investment, skills and wage inequality in East Asia.” Journal of the Asia Pacific Economy 9(3): pp. 348–369.

152. Verdugo, G. (2014): “The great compression of the French wage structure, 1969–2008.” Labour Eco- nomics 28: pp. 131–144.

153. Wei, X., Z. Guan, G. Onel, & F. Roka (2016): “Im- perfect substitution between immigrant and native farm workers in the United States.” Paper pre- pared for presentation at the 2016 Agricultural & Ap- plied Economics Association Annual Meeting (during July 31-August 2 in Boston, Massachusetts) 235958, Agricultural and Applied Economics Association.

154. Welch, F. (1970): “Education in production.” Journal of Political Economy 78(1): pp. 35–59.

155. Yang, D. (2012): “The responsiveness of firms to labor market changes in China: Evidence from micro level data.” Paper prepared for presentation at the 2012 4th CIER/IZA Annual Workshop on Research in La- bor Economics, (during July 19-21 at IZA, Bonn) 6239, China Institute for Employment Research and IZA Institute of Labor Economics.

156. Zeugner, S. & M. Feldkircher (2015): “Bayesian model averaging employing fixed and flexible priors: The BMS package for R.” Journal of Statistical Soft- ware 68(4): pp. 1–37.