Quantitative Analysis of a Wealth Tax in the United States: Exclusions, Evasion, and Expenditures

Moore, Rachel and Pecoraro, Brandon (2021): Quantitative Analysis of a Wealth Tax in the United States: Exclusions, Evasion, and Expenditures.

Abstract

Macroeconomic analyses of wealth taxes typically treat all household wealth as taxable, despite noted administrative difficulties with including owner-occupied housing and noncorporate equity in the tax base. In this paper, we quantify the macroeconomic and budgetary impact of avoidance due to these exclusions from a stylized, broad-based, top-wealth tax in the United States. We use a two-sector, large-scale overlapping generations model where, in the presence of exclusions, avoidance behavior arises endogenously through households’ reallocation of wealth and firms’ reallocation of economic activity. We find that while the macroeconomic and budgetary effects of the housing exclusion are insignificant, the noncorporate equity exclusion introduces a production-level distortion that results in a significant reallocation of economic activity from the corporate to noncorporate sector. We show that the federal revenue loss due to legal avoidance in the latter case can be similar to the amount lost due to illegal evasion via under-reporting wealth, but nonetheless have a quantitatively distinct path of macroeconomic aggregates. Finally, because interest in a wealth tax is linked to its potential for financing federal outlays, we show how variation in macroeconomic and budgetary effects across alternative expenditures affects the amount of new outlays availed by the tax itself. We find that while dedicating new revenue to public infrastructure investment leads to the largest increase in aggregate output, dedicating new revenue to federal debt reduction leads to the largest increase in outlays.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: dynamic scoring; wealth tax; avoidance; evasion
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H26 - Tax Evasion and Avoidance; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H27 - Other Sources of Revenue

References

Advani, A., E. Chamberlain, and A. Summers (2020). A wealth tax for the uk. Wealth Tax Commission Final Report.

Alpert, A. and D. Powell (2020). Estimating intensive and extensive tax responsiveness. Economic Inquiry 58 (4), 1855–1874.

Alvaredo, F. and E. Saez (2010). Income and wealth concentration in spain in a historical and fiscal perspective. In A. Atkinson and T. Piketty (Eds.), Top Incomes: A Global Perspective, pp. 482–559. Oxford University Press.

Andreoni, J. (1989). Giving with impure altruism: Applications to charity and ricardian equivalance. The Journal of Political Economy 97 (6), 1447–1458.

Batchelder, L. and D. Kamin (2019). Taxing the rich: Issues and options. Working Paper.

Bom, P. R. and J. E. Ligthart (2014). What have we learned from three decades of research on the productivity of public capital? Journal of Economic Surveys 28 (5), 889–916.

Borri, N. and P. Reichlin (2021). Optimal taxation with homeownership and wealth inequality. Review of Economic Dynamics 40, 64–84.

Bridgman, B. (2016, February). Accounting for household production in the national accounts: An update, 1965-2014. Survey of Current Business 95 (5), 1–9.

Brülhart, M., J. Gruber, M. Krapf, and K. Schmidheiny (2019). Behavioral responses to wealth taxes. CESifo Working Paper.

Cagetti, M. and M. D. Nardi (2006). Entrepreneurship, frictions, and wealth. Journal of Political Economy 114 (5), 835–870.

Carroll, C. D. (2002). Why do the rich save so much? In J. B. Slemrod (Ed.), Does Atlas Shrug? The Economic Consequences of Taxing the Rich, pp. 446–484. Harvard University Press.

Castañeda, A., J. Díaz-Giménez, and J.-V. Ríos-Rull (2003). Accounting for the u.s. earnings and wealth inequality. Journal of Political Economy 111 (4), 818–857.

CBO (2016). The macroeconomic and budgetary effects of federal investment.

CBO (2021). Effects of physical infrastructure spending on the economy and the budget under two illustrative scenarios.

Chang, Y. and S.-B. Kim (2006). From individual to aggregate labor supply: A quantitative analysis based on a heterogeneous agent macroeconomy. International Economic Review 47 (1), 1–27.

Chang, Y., S.-B. Kim, K. Kown, and R. Rogerson (2011). Interpreting labor supply regressions in a model of full- and part-time work. American Economic Review 101 (3), 476–481.

Chari, V., P. Kehoe, E. Pastorino, and S. Salgado (2021). Taxing the rich. Working Paper.

Cho, S.-W. and J. L. Francis (2011). Tax treatment of owner occupied housing and wealth inequality. Journal of Macroeconomics 33, 42–60.

Cochrane, J. H. (2020). Wealth and taxes. Tax & Budget Bulletin: Cato Institute (86).

Cooley, T. F. and E. Prescott (1995). Economic growth and business cycles. In T. F. Cooley (Ed.), Frontiers of Business Cycle Research, Chapter 1. Princeton University Press.

De Nardi, M. (2004). Wealth inequality and intergenerational links. Review of Economic Studies 71, 743–768.

De Nardi, M. and G. Fella (2017). Saving and wealth inequality. Review of Economic Dynamics 26, 280–300.

DeBacker, J., R. W. Evans, E. Magnusson, K. L. Phillips, S. P. Ramnath, and I. Swift (2018). The distributional effects of redistributional tax policy. Working Paper.

Diamond, J. W. and G. R. Zodrow (2020). The economic effects of wealth taxes. Working Paper.

Durán-Cabré, J. M., A. Esterller-Moré, and M. Mas-Montserrat (2019). Behavioural responses to the (re)introduction of wealth taxes. evidence from spain. IEB Working Paper 2019/04 .

Fernánez-Villaverde, J. and D. Krueger (2010). Consumption and saving over the life cycle: How important are consumer durables? Macroeconomic Dynamics 15.

Francis, J. L. (2009). Wealth and the capitalist spirit. Journal of Macroeconomics 31 (3), 394– 408.

Gamber, E. and J. Seliski (2019). The effect of government debt on interest rates. Congressional Budget Office Working Paper.

Gervais, M. (2002). Housing taxation and capital accumulation. Journal of Monetary Economics 49, 1461–1489.

Gruber, J. W. and R. F. Martin (2003). Does housing wealth make us less equal? the role of durable goods in the distribution of wealth. Federal Reserve Board Working Paper.

Guner, N., R. Kaygusuz, and G. Ventura (2011). Taxation and household labour supply. The Review of Economic Studies 79 (3), 1113–1149.

Guvenen, F., G. Kambourov, B. Kuruscu, S. Ocampo, and D. Chen (2019). Use it or lose it. Working Paper.

Hotz, V. J. and R. A. Miller (1988). An empirical analysis of life cycle fertility and female labor supply. Econometrica 56 (1), 91–118.

Hubmer, J., P. Krusell, and A. A. S. Jr. (2020). Sources of us wealth inequality: Past, present, and future. NBER Macroeconomics Annual 35.

Jakobsen, K., K. Jakobsen, H. Kleven, and G. Zucman (2020). Wealth taxation and wealth accumulation: Theory and evidence from denmark. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 135 (1), 329–388.

JCT (2011). Joint committee on taxation: Summary of economic models and estimating practices of the staff of the joint committee on taxation. JCX-46-11 .

JCT (2015). Joint committee on taxation: Estimating changes in the federal individual income tax: Description of the individual tax model. JCX-75-15 .

Kaymak, B. and M. Poschke (2019). The macroeconomic and distributional effects of progressive wealth taxes. Working Paper.

Keane, M. and R. Rogerson (2012). Micro and macro labor supply elasticities: A reassessment of conventional wisdom. Journal of Economic Literature 50 (2), 464–476.

Kopczuk, W. (Fall 2019). Comment on “progressive wealth taxation". In J. Eberly and J. Stock (Eds.), Brookings Papers on Economic Activity.

Kuhn, P. and F. Lozano (2008, April). The Expanding Workweek? Understanding Trends in Long Work Hours among U.S. Men, 1979-2006. Journal of Labor Economics 26 (2), 311–343.

Leeper, E. M., T. B. Walker, and S.-C. S. Yang (2010). Government investment and fiscal stimulus. Journal of Monetary Economics (57), 1000–1012.

Leiserson, G. (2019). Wealth taxation. Washington Center For Equitable Growth.

Leiserson, G., W. McGrew, and R. Kopparam (2019). Net worth taxes: What they are and how they work. Washington Center For Equitable Growth.

Li, W., H. Liu, F. Yang, and R. Yao (2016). Housing over time and over the life cycle: A structural estimation. International Economic Review 57 (4), 1237–1260.

Michaillat, P. and E. Saez (2021, May). Resolving new keynesian anomalies with wealth in the utility function. Review of Economics and Statistics 103, 197–215.

Moore, R. and B. Pecoraro (2020a). Dynamic scoring: An assessment of fiscal closing assumptions. Public Finance Review 87, 72–91.

Moore, R. and B. Pecoraro (2020b). Macroeconomic implications of modeling the internal revenue code in a heterogeneous-agent framework. Economic Modelling 48 (3), 340–353.

Moore, R. and B. Pecoraro (2021). A tale of two bases: Progressive taxation of capital and labor income. Public Finance Review 49, 335–391.

OECD (2018). The role and design of net wealth taxes in the oecd. OECD Tax Policy Studies (86).

PWBM (2016). Setting behavioral responses in pwbm’s dynamic simulations.

https://budgetmodel.wharton.upenn.edu/issues/2016/9/13/ setting-behavioral-responses-in-pwbms-dynamic-simulations.

PWBM (2019). Senator elizabeth warren’s wealth tax: Budgetary and economic effects.

PWBM (2020). Senator bernie sanders’ wealth tax: Budgetary and economic effects.

Ramey, V. A. (2020). Economic consequences of infrastructure investment. NBER Working Paper 27625 .

Rogerson, R. and J. Wallenius (2009). Micro and macro elasticities in a life cycle model with taxes. Journal of Economic Theory 144, 2277–2292.

Rotberg, S. (2021). The implications of housing for the design of wealth taxes. Forthcoming: International Economic Review.

Rotberg, S. and J. B. Steinberg (2021). Tax evasion and capital taxation. Working Paper. Rupert, P. and G. Zanella (2015). Revisiting wage, earnings, and hours profiles. Journal of Monetary Economics 72, 114–130.

Saez, E. and S. Stancheva (2018). A simpler theory of optimal capital taxation. Journal of Public Economics 162, 120–142.

Saez, E. and G. Zucman (2016). Wealth inequality in the united states since 1913: Evidence from capitalized income tax data. The Quarterly Journal of Economics 131 (2).

Saez, E. and G. Zucman (2019b). Tax justice now. https://taxjusticenow.org.

Saez, E. and G. Zucman (2020a). The rise of income and wealth inequality in america: Evidence from distributional macroeconomic accounts. Journal of Economic Perspectives 34 (4), 3–26.

Saez, E. and G. Zucman (2020b). Trends in us income and wealth inequality. NBER Working Paper 27921 .

Saez, E. and G. Zucman (Fall 2019a). Progressive wealth taxation. In J. Eberly and J. Stock (Eds.), Brookings Papers on Economic Activity.

Scheuer, F. and J. Slemrod (2021). Taxing our wealth. Journal of Economic Perspectives 35 (1), 207–230.

Seim, D. (2017). Behavioral responses to wealth taxes: Evidence from sweden. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 9 (4), 395–421.

Smith, M., O. Zidar, and E. Zwick (2020). Top wealth in america: New estimates and implications for taxing the rich. Working Paper.

Viard, A. D. (2019). Wealth taxation: An overview of the issues. In M. S. Kearney and A. Ganz (Eds.), Maintaining the Strength of American Capitalism. The Aspen Institute.

Wetzler, J. W. (2020). A guide to the wealth tax debate. Tax Notes.

Wolff, E. N. (2019). Wealth taxation in the united states. NBER Working Paper No. 26544 .

Zodrow, G. and J. W. Diamond (2013). Dynamic overlapping generations computable general equilibrium models and the analysis of tax policy: The diamond–zodrow model. Volume 1, Chapter 11, pp. 743–813. Elsevier.