Gains from Free Trade Agreements: A Theoretical Analysis

Huria, Sugandha (2020): Gains from Free Trade Agreements: A Theoretical Analysis.

Abstract

Empirical estimates from various studies on impact assessment of free trade agreements show that there are limited economic gains from concluding such arrangements. It has been argued by trade negotiators of many countries that while some partners gain more from an agreement, others gain less or, even suffer from a rise in their current account deficits and overall economic losses. Even the Indian scenario is not an outlier in such a case. This question about unequal gains from an FTA has raised various policy concerns. We attempt to provide an answer to this debate by incorporating the role of the type of commodities that countries trade with each other. In an imperfectly competitive setup with three countries and two types of commodities viz. a final good and an intermediate input, our findings reveal that bilateral free trade in final goods is more welfare-enhancing for the member countries vis-à-vis bilateral free trade in intermediates. However, the former possibility is feasible only for a very small range of parametric values given the pre-requisites for ensuring the formation of an effective FTA. More specifically, we find that a horizontal FTA covering final goods becomes feasible only when the degree of market size asymmetry between the two partners is very less. On the contrary, when we emphasise on the role of vertical trade, i.e., where one of the FTA members exports intermediate inputs to the other, and imports the final good in return, we find that FTA is feasible only when the larger partner is an exporter of final goods and an importer of intermediate inputs, vis-à-vis the smaller partner. In such a case, the larger partner accrues higher gains from such a bilateral engagement. While capturing the role of tradable intermediates, we also show that in the presence of well-connected GVCs, RTAs actually become a less attractive option for enhancing trade and welfare of an economy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Free Trade Agreements, Global Value Chains, Vertical Industry Structure
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F12 - Models of Trade with Imperfect Competition and Scale Economies ; Fragmentation; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration

References

Anson, J., Cadot, O., Estevadeordal, A., Melo, J. D., Suwa‐Eisenmann, A., & Tumurchudur, B. (2005). Rules of origin in North–South preferential trading arrangements with an application to NAFTA. Review of International Economics, 13(3), 501-517. Baccini, L. (2019). The economics and politics of preferential trade agreements. Annual Review of Political Science, 22, 75-92. Baier, S. L., Yotov, Y. V., & Zylkin, T. (2019). On the widely differing effects of free trade agreements: Lessons from twenty years of trade integration. Journal of International Economics, 116, 206-226. Baldwin, R. (1993). A domino theory of regionalism (No. w4465). National bureau of economic research. Baldwin, R., & Jaimovich, D. (2012). Are free trade agreements contagious?. Journal of international Economics, 88(1), 1-16. Basco, S., & Mestieri, M. (2019). The world income distribution: the effects of international unbundling of production. Journal of Economic Growth, 24(2), 189-221. Batra, R. N. (1973). Studies in the pure theory of international trade. Springer. Berlingieri, G. (2013) Outsourcing and the rise in services. CEP Discussion Papers (CEPDP1199). Centre for Economic Performance, London School of Economics and Political Science, London, UK. Accessed on September 30, 2020. Berlingieri, G., Breinlich, H., & Dhingra, S. (2018). The impact of trade agreements on consumer welfare—evidence from the eu common external trade policy. Journal of the European Economic Association, 16(6), 1881-1928. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvx053 Bhagwati, J. (1971). Trade-diverting customs unions and welfare-improvement: A clarification. The Economic Journal, 81(323), 580-587. Bhagwati, J. N. (1991). The world trading system at risk. Princeton University Press. Bhagwati, J. N., Panagariya, A., & Srinivasan, T. N. (1998). Lectures on international trade. MIT press. Blanchard, E. J., Bown, C. P., & Johnson, R. C. (2017). Global value chains and trade policy. Dartmouth College and Peterson Institute for International Economics, 2. Retrieved from <http://faculty.tuck.dartmouth.edu/images/uploads/faculty/emily-blanchard/BBJ-August2017.pdf> Brander, J. A. (1981). Intra-industry trade in identical commodities. Journal of international Economics, 11(1), 1-14. Brander, J. A., & Spencer, B. J. (1984). Trade warfare: tariffs and cartels. Journal of international Economics, 16(3-4), 227-242. Bruhn, D. (2014). Global value chains and deep preferential trade agreements: promoting trade at the cost of domestic policy autonomy?. Available at SSRN 2464136. Cadot, O., Graziano, A., Harris, J., & Volpe, C. (2014). Do Rules of Origin Constrain Export Growth?. IDB Integration and Trade Sector No. IDB-DP-350. Carrère, C (2006), “Revisiting the effects of regional trade agreements on trade flows with proper specification of the gravity model”, European Economic Review 50(2): 223–247. Chains, G. V. (2014). Challenges, Opportunities, and Implications for Policy. In Report prepared for submission to the G20 Trade Ministers Meeting Sydney, Australia (Vol. 19). Chandrashekhar, G. (2019, December 30). Inverted duty structure hurts soaps industry. The Hindu Business Line. Retrieved from <https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/markets/commodities/inverted-duty-structure-hurts-soaps-industry/article30431722.ece> Chang, Y. M., & Xiao, R. (2015). Preferential trade agreements between asymmetric countries: Free trade areas (with rules of origin) vs. customs unions. Japan and the World Economy, 33, 28-43. Chen, M. X., & Joshi, S. (2010). Third-country effects on the formation of free trade agreements. Journal of International Economics, 82(2), 238-248. Bagwell, K., & Staiger, R. W. (1999). Regionalism and multilateral tariff co-operation. In International trade policy and the pacific rim (pp. 157-190). Palgrave Macmillan, London. Copeland, B., & Mattoo, A. (2008). The basic economics of services trade. A handbook of international trade in services, 84-129. Corden, W. M. (1971). The effects of trade on the rate of growth. Trade, Balance of payment And Growth. Amsterdam: North Holland, 117-43. Dhar, B., (2014, October 10). Are free trade agreements a dead end for India? East Asia Forum, New Delhi. Retrieved from <https://www.eastasiaforum.org/2014/10/10/are-free-trade-agreements-a-dead-end-for-india/> Dhir, G. (2020, September 19). COVID-19 and Opportunities for India in World Trade. Medium. Retrieved from <https://medium.com/@garimadhir2/covid-19-and-opportunities-for-india-in-world-trade-1a0caa3ba46f> FE Bureau. (2019, September 11). India, Asean to set up joint panel to review free trade agreement. Financial Express. Retrieved from <https://www.financialexpress.com/economy/joint-panel-to-be-formed-india-asean-to-review-free-trade-agreement/1702529/> Freund, C. (2000). Different paths to free trade: The gains from regionalism. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 115(4), 1317-1341. Furusawa, T., Higashida, K., & Ishikawa, J. (2004). Tariffs versus quotas in the presence of imperfect competition and cross‐border externalities. Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d'économique, 37(2), 445-458. Garrett, G. (2017, February 1). Do Trade Agreements Lead to Income Inequality? Knowledge @ Wharton. Wharton University of Pennsylvania. Retrieved from < https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/do-trade-agreements-lead-to-income-inequality/> Government of India. (2020). Economic Survey 2019-20 (Volume 1). Economics Division, Department of Economic Affairs, Ministry of Finance. Retrieved from <https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/economicsurvey/doc/echapter.pdf> Grossman, G., & Helpman, E. (1994). Protection for Sale. The American Economic Review, 84(4), 833-850. <http://www.jstor.org/stable/2118033> Ignatenko, A., Raei, F., & Mircheva, B. (2019). Global Value Chains: What are the Benefits and Why Do Countries Participate?. IMF Working Papers, WP/19/18. Hartwell, C. & Movchan, V. (2018). Finding the right balance across EU FTAs: benefits and risks for EU economic sectors. European Parliament Think Tank Heckscher, E. F. (1919). The effect of foreign trade on the distribution of income. [in Swedish]. Ekonomisk Tidskrift, 21(2), pp. 1-32; reprinted in Readings in the theory of international trade. Homewood, IL: Irwin, 1950, pp. 272-300. Hoffman, C., Osnago, A., & Ruta, M. (2017). Horizontal Depth A New Database on the Content of Preferential Trade Agreements. Policy Research Working Paper, 7981, accessed on November 9th, 2017 Hummels, D. L., Rapoport, D., & Yi, K. M. (1998). Vertical specialization and the changing nature of world trade. Economic Policy Review, 4(2). Impullitti, G. and Licandro, O. (2018). “Quantifying the gains from trade”, VoxEU.org, 29 April. Retrieved from <https://voxeu.org/article/quantifying-gains-trade> Ishikawa, J. (2000). Foreign monopoly and trade policy under segmented and integrated markets. Economic Review, 51(4), 321-336. Ishikawa, J., & Spencer, B. J. (1999). Rent-shifting export subsidies with an imported intermediate product. Journal of International Economics, 48(2), 199-232. Ishikawa, J., Mukunoki, H., & Mizoguchi, Y. (2007). Economic integration and rules of origin under international oligopoly. International Economic Review, 48(1), 185-210. Jha, D. K. (2019, June 20). Secondary metals producers fear inverted duty structure could hurt. Business Standard. Retrieved from < https://www.business-standard.com/article/companies/secondary-metals-producers-fear-inverted-duty-structure-could-hurt-119061900301_1.html> Jha, D. K. (2015, September 17). FTA with EU to increase cotton textile exports. Business Standard. Retrieved from < https://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/fta-with-eu-to-increase-cotton-textile-exports-115091700433_1.html> Ju, J., & Krishna, K. (2005). Firm behaviour and market access in a free trade area with rules of origin. Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d'économique, 38(1), 290-308. Kawabata, Y. (2014). The effects of cross-regional free trade agreements under a vertical industry structure. The Journal of International Trade & Economic Development, 23(6), 906-922. Kawabata, Y. (2015). Endogenous formation of free trade agreements in vertically related markets. Research in Economics, 69(2), 214-223. Kawabata, Y. (2016). Cost Asymmetries and Import Tariff Policy in a Vertically Related Industry. In Regional Free Trade Areas and Strategic Trade Policies (pp. 151-163). Springer, Tokyo. Kawabata, Y., Yanase, A., & Kurata, H. (2010). Vertical trade and free trade agreements. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 24(4), 569-585. Keck, A., & Lendle, A. (2012). New evidence on preference utilization. World Trade Organization Staff Working Paper No. ERSD-2012-12. Kirman, A. P. (1973). Trade diverting customs unions and welfare improvement: a comment. The Economic Journal, 83(331), 890-894. Kohl, T. (2014). Do we really know that trade agreements increase trade?. Review of World Economics, 150(3), 443-469. Krishna, K. (2005). Understanding rules of origin (No. w11150). National Bureau of Economic Research. Krishna, P. (1998). Regionalism and multilateralism: A political economy approach. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 113(1), 227-251. Krugman, P. (1991). Increasing returns and economic geography. Journal of political economy, 99(3), 483-499. Krugman, P. R. (1979). Increasing returns, monopolistic competition, and international trade. Journal of international Economics, 9(4), 469-479. Kwatra, N., & Kundu, T. (2018, August 14). Can regional trade agreements boost India’s exports?. Mint. Retrieved from <https://www.livemint.com/Industry/srfvvWL76rtMLaeQzOtbJM/Can-regional-trade-agreements-boost-Indias-exports.html> Lipsey, R. G. (1957). The theory of customs unions: trade diversion and welfare. Economica, 24(93), 40-46. Lipsey, R. G., & Lancaster, K. (1956). The general theory of second best. The review of economic studies, 24(1), 11-32. Marjit, S., Basu, A, & Veeramani, C. (2019). Growth Gains from Trade. CESifo Working Paper No. 7905, Available at SSRN: <https://ssrn.com/abstract=3477718>. Accessed on April 13, 2020. Mathew, J.C. (2019, September 27). Are free trade agreements beneficial for India? Business Today. Retrieved from <https://www.businesstoday.in/current/economy-politics/are-free-trade-agreements-beneficial-for-india/story/381624.html> Meng, B., Ye, M., & Wei, S. J. (2020). Measuring Smile Curves in global value chains. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 82(5), 988-1016. Doi: <https://doi.org/10.1111/obes.12364> Mon, Y. Y., & Kakinaka, M. (2020). Regional trade agreements and income inequality: Are there any differences between bilateral and plurilateral agreements?. Economic Analysis and Policy, 67, 136-153. Mukunoki, H. (2004). On the optimal external tariff of a free trade area with internal market integration. Japan and the World Economy, 16(4), 431-448. Nguyen, D. B. (2019). A new examination of the impacts of regional trade agreements on international trade patterns. Journal of Economic Integration, 34(2), 236-279. OECD, WTO, & World Bank Group. (2014). Global Value Chains: Challenges, Opportunities, and Implications for Policy. In Report prepared for the G20 Trade Ministers Meeting Sydney. Australia. (Vol. 19). <http://www.oecd.org/tad/gvc_report_g20_july_2014.pdf > Ohlin, B. (1933). International and interregional trade. Harvard Economic Studies, Cambridge, MA. Panagariya, A., & Krishna, P. (2002). On necessarily welfare-enhancing free trade areas. Journal of International Economics, 57(2), 353-367. Pant, M., & Paul, A. (2018). The role of regional trade agreements: In the case of India. Journal of Economic Integration, 33(3), 538-571. Pant, M., & Sadhukhan, A. (2009). Does Regionalism Hinder Multilateralism: a Case Study of India. Journal of Economic Integration, 222-247. Pathania, K., & Bhattacharjea, A. (2020). Inverted Duty Structures and the Paradox of Negative Effective Protection in India, 2000–2014. Foreign Trade Review, 55(2), 139-167. PTI (2015, April 13). Auto sector inclusion in India-EU FTA against 'Make in India'. Economic Times. Retrieved from <https://auto.economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/industry/auto-sector-inclusion-in-india-eu-fta-against-make-in-india/46906251> PTI (2017, July 30). India, South Korea reviewing FTA to boost trade. Economic Times. Retrieved from <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/foreign-trade/india-south-korea-reviewing-fta-to-boost-trade/articleshow/59830991.cms> PTI (2019, June 21). FTAs are against Make in India, need to approach EU pact with caution: SIAM. The Economic Times. Retrieved from <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/policy/ftas-are-against-make-in-india-need-to-approach-eu-pact-with-caution-siam/articleshow/69890551.cms?from=mdr> Rathee, K. (2019, July 23). FTAs with Asean nations hurt domestic TV production. Financial Express. Retrieved from <https://www.financialexpress.com/industry/ftas-with-asean-nations-hurt-domestic-tv-production/1653061/> Ricardo, D. (1921). The first six chapters of the principles of political economy and taxation of David Ricardo, 1817. Macmillan. Robinson, S., & Thierfelder, K. (2002). Trade liberalisation and regional integration: the search for large numbers. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 46(4), 585-604. Ruta, M. (2017). Preferential trade agreements and global value chains: Theory, evidence, and open questions. The World Bank. https://doi.org/10.1596/1813-9450-8190 (Accessed on September 7th, 2020). Saggi, K., & Yildiz, H. M. (2006). On the international linkages between trade and merger policies. Review of International Economics, 14(2), 212-225. Schiff, M. (1996). Small is beautiful: Preferential trade agreements and the impact of country size, market share, efficiency, and trade policy. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper, (1668). Accessed on August 15, 2020. Sen, A. (2019a, June 12). Commerce Minister reviews free trade pacts. The Hindu Business Line. Retrieved from <https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/commerce-minister-reviews-free-trade-pacts/article27891028.ece?homepage=true> Sen, A. (2019b, December 15). EU FTA talks: India looking at ways to end stalemate, re-start negotiations. The Hindu Business Line. Retrieved from <https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/eu-fta-talks-india-looking-at-ways-to-end-stalemate-re-start-negotiations/article30313313.ece> Smith, A. (1776). An inquiry into the wealth of nations. Strahan and Cadell, London, 1-11. Smith, A., & Venables, A. J. (1988). Completing the internal market in the European Community: Some industry simulations. European economic review, 32(7), 1501-1525. Srivastav, A. (2019, January 4). How to enter into an FTA that delivers. The Hindu Business Line. Retrieved from <https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/opinion/columns/ajay-srivastav/how-to-enter-into-an-fta-that-delivers/article25912371.ece> Subramaniam, V. (2016, November 26). Here's why Trump hates the Trans-Pacific Partnership so much. Business Insider. Retrieved from <https://www.businessinsider.com/heres-why-trump-hates-the-trans-pacific-partnership-so-much-2016-11?IR=T> Summers, L. (1991). Regionalism and the world trading system. Policy implications of trade and currency zones, 295-301. Takarada, Y., Kawabata, Y., Yanase, A., & Kurata, H. (2020). Standards policy and international trade: Multilateralism versus regionalism. Journal of Public Economic Theory. TNN. (2020, February 29). Textile industry demands level playing field with Asean. Times of India. Retrieved from <https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ludhiana/textile-industry-demands-level-playing-field-with-asean/articleshow/74409390.cms> Venables, A. J. (1985). Trade and trade policy with imperfect competition: The case of identical products and free entry. Journal of International Economics, 19(1-2), 1-19. Viner, J. (1950). The Customs Union Issue. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. New York. Soo, K. T. (2011). The gains from specialisation and comparative advantage. Lancaster University. Retrieved from < https://www.etsg.org/ETSG2011/Papers/Soo.pdf> Wonnacott, P., & Lutz, M. (1989). Is there a case for free trade areas? Free trade areas and US trade policy, 59, 84. World Bank (2020). World Development Report 2020: Trading for Development in the Age of Global Value Chains. World Bank, Washington, DC. World Trade Organisation (2019). World trade statistical review 2019. WTO, Geneva. [Data] WTO RTA Database: https://rtais.wto.org/UI/charts.aspx#