Regulation and international telecommunications pricing behaviour

Madden, Gary G and Savage, Scott J (2001): Regulation and international telecommunications pricing behaviour. Published in: Industrial and Corporate Change , Vol. 10, No. 1 (2001): pp. 247-265.

Abstract

Recent technology change and market liberalization have substantially reduced the costs of providing international message telephone services (IMTS). However, the full extent of these cost reductions have generally not been reflected in lower prices. This paper reviews the recent literature on international telecommunications markets, and examines regulation and IMTS pricing behaviour. Particular attention is given to the accounting rate system (ARS), uniform settlement policies, and asymmetric competition. Several market behaviour scenarios are described where regulation has resulted in carriers implementing inefficient pricing rules for both accounting and collection rates. Finally, economic and political strategies are put forward that could supplant the current outmoded and uneconomic ARS, and bring about the full benefits of a freely functioning marketplace to telecommunications users.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L96 - Telecommunications

References

Alleman, J. and Sorce, B. (1997), ‘International Settlements: A Time for a Change’, Proceedings of the Global Networking ‘97 Conference, Calgary, Canada, 15-18 June 1997.

Cave, M. (1995), ‘The Economic Consequence of the Introduction and Regulation of International Resale of Telecommunications Services’, in Lamberton, D. (ed.), Beyond Competition: The Future of Communications, Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Cheong, K. and Mullins, M. (1991), ‘International Telephone Service Imbalances: Accounting Rates and Regulatory Policy’, Telecommunications Policy, 15, 107-118.

Einhorn, M. (1997), International Accounting and Settlements: A Review of Literature, United States Department of Justice, Washington.

Ergas, H. (1995), An Economic Analysis of the Implications of a Trading System for International Telecommunications Services Based on Trade of Termination Services, A Report Prepared for the Department of Communications and the Arts and the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Australia.

Ergas, H. and Patterson, P. (1991), ‘International Telecommunications Settlement Arrangements: An Unsustainable Inheritance’, Telecommunications Policy, 15, 29-48.

FCC (1999), International Simple Resale, www.fcc.gov/ib/isr.html.

FCC (1998), Trends in the US International Telecommunications Industry 1998, Common Carrier Bureau, Washington: FCC.

FCC (1997a), Trends in the US International Telecommunications Industry 1997, Common Carrier Bureau, Washington: FCC.

FCC (1997b), Benchmarks Order IB Docket No. 96-261, Washington: FCC.

FCC (1996), Policy Statement on International Accounting Rate Reform, 96-37, January 31, 1996, Washington: FCC. FCC (various issues), Statistics of Communications Common Carriers, Washington: FCC.

Frieden, R. (1996), International Telecommunications Handbook, Artech House: London.

Frieden, R. (1993), ‘International Toll Revenue Division: Tackling the Inequities and Inefficiencies’, Telecommunications Policy, 17, 211-233.

ITU (1997), World Telecommunication Development Report, Geneva: ITU.

ITU (1996), Direction of Traffic: Trends in International Telephone Tariffs, Second Edition, Geneva: ITU/TeleGeography.

Johnson, L. (1991), ‘Dealing with Monopoly in International Telephone Service: A US Perspective’, Information Economics and Policy, 4, 225-247.

Kennedy, C.H. and Pastor, M.V. (1996), An Introduction to International Telecommunications Law, Boston: Artech House.

Kwerel, E. (1994), ‘Reconciling Competition and Monopoly in the Supply of International: A US Perspective’, in Noam, E. and Pogurel, G. (eds.), Asymmetric Deregulation: The Dynamics of Telecommunications Policy, Norwood (NJ): Ablex Publishing Company.

Laffont, J. and Tirole, J. (1995), ‘Creating Competition Through Interconnection: Theory and Practice’, The Access and Interconnection Workshop, 1995, Wellington, New Zealand.

Larson, A.C., Lehman, D.E. and Weisman, D.L. (1990), ‘A General Theory of Point-to-Point Long Distance Demand’, in De Fontenay, A., Shugard, M.H. and Sibley, D.S. (eds.), Telecommunications Demand Modelling, Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Mitchell and Vogelsang (1991), Telecommunications Pricing: Theory and Practice, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press O’Brien, D.P. (1988). The Effects of the Uniform Settlements Policy in International Telecommunications: A Strategic Bargaining Approach, Mimeo, Department of Economics, Northwestern University.

OECD (1999), Communications Outlook 1999, Paris: OECD publications.

OECD (1997), New Technologies and Their Impact on the Accounting Rate System, Paris: OECD publications.

Productivity Commission, (1997), International Telecommunications Reforms in Australia, Staff Information Paper, Canberra: AGPS.

Propp, K.R. (1996), ‘The Eroding Structure of International Telecommunications Regulation: The Challenge of Call-Back Services’, Harvard International Law Journal, 37, 493-520.

Scanlan, M. (1998), “Using Call-back to Demonstrate the Discriminatory Nature of the Proportionate Return Rule”, Telecommunications Policy, 11, 913-930.

Sheele and Woodall (1997), ‘The Market for Refile and Transit Traffic’, in TeleGeography (ed.), TeleGeography 1997/98: Global Telecommunications Traffic Statistics and Commentary, Washington: TeleGeography.

Stanley, K. (1991), ‘Balance of Payments Deficits and Subsidies in International Telecommunications: A New Challenge to Regulation’, Administrative Law Review, 43, 411-438.

Stanley, K. (1988), The Balance of Payments Deficit in International Telecommunications Services, Common Carrier Bureau, Washington: FCC.

TeleGeography (1998), TeleGeography 1999: Global Telecommunications Traffic Statistics and Commentary, Washington: TeleGeography.

TeleGeography (1996), TeleGeography 1996/97: Global Telecommunications Traffic Statistics and Commentary, Washington: TeleGeography.

Telstra (1999), Submission to the Productivity Commission International Telecommunications Market Regulation Inquiry, May 5, Melbourne: Telstra.

WTO (1997), The Agreement on Basic Telecommunications Services, February 15, Geneva: WTO Publications Service.