Pioneers of Financial Economics: Das Adam Smith Irrelevanzproblem?

Poitras, Geoffrey and Jovanovic, Franck (2010): Pioneers of Financial Economics: Das Adam Smith Irrelevanzproblem? Published in: History of Economics Review , Vol. 51, No. 1 (2010): pp. 43-64.

Abstract

This paper is a contribution to the debate surrounding the steady decline in importance of the history of economic thought within the economics curriculum. The relevance of the history of financial economics to this debate is examined and a ‘histories of economic thought’ strategy is suggested to improve the future prospects of the subject. In the process, Das Adam Smith Irrelevanzproblem is identified and discussed. Das Irrelevanzproblem is concerned with the question: why do Adam Smith and other classical political economists continue to play such a central role in traditional thought when the relevance of these thinkers to modern economics, particularly new additions such as financial economics, is so limited? This paper demonstrates that the history of financial economics commences at least a century prior to The Wealth of Nations and is largely independent of the traditional thought which commences with the role of Adam Smith as the leading Enlightenment thinker on issues relevant to political economy.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Adam Smith; Financial Economics
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B0 - General; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals; G - Financial Economics > G0 - General

References

Bachelier, L. 1900. ‘Théorie de la Spéculation’, Annales Scientifiques de l’Ecole Normale Superieure, III-17, pp. 21-86. English translation in Cootner (ed.), 1964, pp. 17-78.

Backhouse, R. 2002. ‘The future of the history of economic thought in Britain’, History of Political Economy 34 (Supplement), pp. 79-97.

Barber, W. 1997. ‘Reconfigurations in America’s academic economics: a general practitioner’s perspective’, Daedalus 126, pp. 87-103.

Bernstein, P. 1992. Capital Ideas: The Improbable Origins of Modern Wall Street. New York: Free Press.

Bernstein, P. 1996. Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk. New York: John Wiley.Black, F. and M. Scholes. 1973. ‘The pricing of options and corporate liabilities’, Journal of Political Economy 81, pp. 637-59.

Blaug, M. 2001. ‘No history of ideas, please, we’re economists’, Journal of Economic Perspectives 15, pp. 145-64.

Burns, A. (ed.) 1952. Wesley Clair Mitchell: The Economic Scientist. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Cardoso, J. 1995. ‘Teaching the history of economic thought’, European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 2, pp. 197-214.

Cardoso, J. 2002. ‘Confusion de confusiones: ethics and options in seventeenth century stock exchange markets’, Financial History Review 9, pp. 109-23.

Cardoso, J. 2006. ‘Joseph de la Vega and the Confusion de confusiones’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 3, pp. 64-75.

Cootner, P. 1964. The Random Character of Stock Market Prices. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Davidson, P. 2007. ‘Understanding Financial Market Prices: Reality vs. Rigor’, in Poitras and Jovanovic 2007, chapter 13.

de Roover, R. 1974. ‘Gerard de Malynes as an Economic Writer: From Scholasticism to Mercantilism’, in J. Kirshner (1974), chapter 11.

Dimand, R. 2007a. ‘Irving Fisher and financial economics: the equity premium puzzle, the predictability of stock prices, and intertemporal allocation under risk’, Journal of the History of Economic Thought (June) 29, pp. 153-66.

Dimand, R. 2007b. ‘Irving Fisher and His Students as Financial Economists’, in Poitras and Jovanovic 2007, chapter 2, pp. 45-59.

Dimand, R. and H. Ben-El-Mechaiekh. 2006. ‘Louis Bachelier’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 10, pp. 225-37.

Durand, D. 1957. ‘Growth stocks and the Petersburg paradox”, Journal of Finance 12, pp. 348-63.

Durand, D. 1959. ‘The cost of capital, corporation finance and the theory of investment: comment’, American Economic Review 49, pp. 639-55

Ekelund, R. and R. Hebert. 1999. Secret Origins of Modern Microeconomics; Dupuit and the Engineers. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Epstein, R. 1987. A History of Econometrics. Amsterdam: North-Holland.

Fabricant, S. 1984. ‘Toward a Firmer Basis of Economic Policy: The Founding of the National Bureau of Economic Research’, National Bureau of Economic Research, http://www.nber.org.proxy.lib.sfu.ca/nberhistory/sfabricantrev.pdf.

Fama, E. 1965. ‘The behavior of stock market prices’, Journal of Business 38, pp. 34-105.

Fama, E. 1970. ‘Efficient capital markets: a review of theory and empirical work’, Journal of Finance 25, pp. 383-417.

Fama, E., L. Fisher, M. Jensen and R. Roll. 1969. ‘The adjustment of stock prices to new information’, International Economic Review 10, pp. 1-21.

Frankfurter, G. and E. McGoun. 1996. Toward Finance with Meaning, The Methodology of Finance: What It Is and What It Can Be. Greenwich, CN: JAI Press.

Frickel, S. and N. Gross. 2005. ‘A general theory of scientific/intellectual movements’, American Sociological Review 70, pp. 204-32.

Fridson, M. (ed.) 1996. Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds; and, Confusion de Confusiones (reprints of classic texts). New York: Wiley.

Groenewegen, P. 2001. ‘The early history of financial economics’, History of Economics Review (Winter) 33, pp. 116-19.

Hafner, W. and H. Zimmermann. 2009. Vincenz Bronzin’s Option Pricing Models: Exposition and Appraisal. New York: Springer-Verlag.

Hald, A. 1990. A History of Probability and Statistics and their Applications before 1750. New York: John Wiley.

Hamilton, W. 1919. ‘The institutional approach to economic theory’, American Economic Review 9, pp. 309-18.

Hands, D. W. 2001. Reflection without Rules: Economic Methodology and Contemporary Science Theory. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Hands, D. W. 1997. ‘Conjectures and reputations: the sociology of scientific knowledge and the history of economic thought’, History of Political Economy (Winter) 29, pp. 695-739.

Haugen, R. 1999. The New Finance: The Case Against Efficient Markets (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Hausman, D. 1992. The Inexact and Separate Science of Economics. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Jarrow, R. 1999. ‘In honor of the Nobel laureates Robert C. Merton and Myron S. Scholes’, Journal of Economic Perspectives 13, pp. 229-48.

Jensen, M. (ed.) 1972. Studies in the Theory of Capital Markets. New York: Praeger.

Jovanovic, F. 2006a. ‘Economic Instruments and Theory in the Construction of Henri Lefevre’s “Science of the Stock Market”’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 8, pp. 169-90.

Jovanovic, F. 2006b. ‘A Nineteenth-Century Random Walk: Jules Regnault and the Origins of Scientific Financial Economics’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 9, pp. 191-222.

Jovanovic, F. 2007. ‘The Role of the CAPM, the Modigliani-Miller Theorems and the Efficient Markets Hypothesis in the Rise of a Scientific Discipline’, in Poitras and Jovanovic 2007, chapter 10, pp. 157-69.

Jovanovic, F. 2008. ‘The construction of the canonical history of financial economics’, History of Political Economy (Summer) 40, pp. 213-42.

Jovanovic, F. and P. Le Gall. 2001. ‘Does God practice a random walk? The “Financial Physics” of a nineteenth-century forerunner, Jules Regnault’, European Journal of the History of Economic Thought (Autumn) 8, pp. 332-62.

Kellenbenz, H. 1957. ‘Introduction’ to de la Vega Confusion de Confusiones; reprinted in Fridson 1996.

Kirshner, J. (ed.) 1974. Business, Banking and Economic Thought, Selected Studies of Raymond de Roover. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Klein, P. 1983. ‘The neglected institutionalism of Wesley Clair Mitchell: the theoretical basis for business cycle indicators’, Journal of Economic Issues 4, pp. 867-93.

Koopmans, T. 1947. ‘Measurement without theory’, Review of Economics and Statistics 29, pp. 161-72.

Le Gall, P. 2007. A History of Econometrics in France: From Nature to Models. London and New York: Routledge.

Lewin, C. 2003. Pensions and Insurance before 1800: A Social History. East Lothian, UK: Tuckwell Press.

Lintner, J. 1965a. ‘The valuation of risk assets and the selection of risky investments in stock portfolios and capital budgets’, Review of Economics and Statistics 47, pp. 13-37.

Lintner, J. 1965b. ‘Security prices, risk and maximal gains from diversification’, Journal of Finance 20, pp. 587-615.

Lucas, R. 1996. ‘Nobel Lecture: Money Neutrality’, Journal of Political Economy 104, pp. 661-82.

Macaulay, F. 1938. The Movements of Interest Rates. Bond Yields and Stock Prices in the United States since 1856. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.

Macaulay, F. and D. Durand. 1951. Short selling on the New York Stock Exchange. New York: Twentieth Century Fund.

Mackenzie, D. 2003. ‘An equation and its worlds: bricolage, exemplars, disunity and performativity in financial economics’, Social Studies of Science 33, pp. 831-68.

Mackenzie, D. 2007. ‘The Emergence of Option Pricing Theory’, in Poitras and Jovanovic 2007, chapter 11, pp. 170-91.

Markowitz, H. 1952. ‘Portfolio selection’, Journal of Finance 7, pp. 77-91.

Markowitz, H. 1959. Portfolio Selection: Efficient Diversification of Investments. New York: John Wiley.

Markowitz, H. 1999. ‘The early history of portfolio theory, 1600–1960’, Financial Analysts Journal 55, pp. 5-16.

McGoun, E. 2007. ‘The History of Quantitative Risk Measurement’, in Poitras and Jovanovic 2007, chapter 12.

Merton, R. C. 1987. ‘In honor of Nobel laureate, Franco Modigliani’, Journal of Economic Perspectives 1, pp. 145-55.

Merton, R. C. 1973. ‘Theory of rational option pricing’, Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 4, pp. 141-83.

Miller, M. and F. Modigliani. 1961. ‘Dividend policy, growth and the valuation of shares’, Journal of Business 34, pp. 411-33.

MIT News. 1996. Obituary for David Durand. (Online at http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/1996/durand-0306.html).

Modigliani, F. and M. Miller. 1958. ‘The cost of capital, corporate finance and the theory of investment’, American Economic Review 48, pp. 261-77.

Modigliani, F. and M. Miller. 1963. ‘Corporation income taxes and the cost of capital: a correction’, American Economic Review 53, pp. 433-43.

Montes, L. 2003. ‘Das Adam Smith Problem: its origins, the stages of the current debate and one implication for our understanding of sympathy’, Journal of the History of Economic Thought 25, pp. 63-90.

Morgan, M. 1990. The History of Econometric Ideas. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Morgan, W. 1815. Memoirs of the Life of Rev. Richard Price. London: R. Hunter.

Ogborn, M. 1962. Equitable Assurances. London: Allen and Unwin. Pearson, E. S. (ed.) 1978. The History of Statistics in the 17th and 18th Centuries: Lectures by Karl Pearson, London: Charles Griffen.

Poitras, G. 1998. ‘Robert Torrens and the evolution of the Real Bills Doctrine’, Journal of the History of Economic Thought 20, pp. 479-98.

Poitras, G. 2000. The Early History of Financial Economics, 1478–1776. Aldershot, UK: Edward Elgar.

Poitras, G. 2005. Security Analysis and Investment Strategy. Oxford, UK: Blackwell Publishing.

Poitras, G. (ed.) 2006. Pioneers of Financial Economics: Contributions Prior to Irving Fisher (volume 1). Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Poitras, G. 2006a. ‘Life Annuity Valuation: From de Witt and Halley to de Moivre and Simpson’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 4, pp. 79-99.

Poitras, G. 2007. ‘Frederick R. Macaulay, Frank M. Redington and the Emergence of Modern Fixed Income Analysis’, in Poitras and Jovanovic 2007, chapter 4.

Poitras, G. 2010. Valuation of Equity Securities: History, Theory and Application. Singapore: World Scientific (forthcoming).

Poitras, G. and F. Jovanovic (eds). 2007. Pioneers of Financial Economics: Twentieth Century Contributions (volume 2). Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Preda, A. 2005. ‘The Rise of the Popular Investor: Financial Knowledge and Investing in England and France, 1840–1880’, in The Psychology of World Equity Markets 1, pp. 387-414.

Preda, A. 2006. ‘Rational Investors, Informative Prices: The Emergence of the “Science of Financial Investments” and the Random Walk Hypothesis’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 7, pp. 149-68.

Rubinstein, M. 2002. ‘Markowitz portfolio selection: a fifty year retrospective’, Journal of Finance 57, pp. 1041-6.

Rubinstein, M. 2003. ‘Great moments in financial economics: I. Present value’, Journal of Investment Management 1 (First quarter).

Rubinstein, M. 2006. ‘Bruno de Finetti and mean-variance portfolio selection’, Journal of Investment Management 4 (Third quarter).

Rutherford, M. 1994. Institutions in Economics: The Old and the New Institutionalism. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

Rutherford, M. 2001. ‘Institutional economics: then and now’, Journal of Economic Perspectives 15, pp. 173-94.

Rutherford, M. and M. Morgan (eds). 1998. ‘From interwar pluralism to postwar neoclassicism’, History of Political Economy 30 (Supplement).

Samuelson, P. 1965. ‘Proof the properly anticipated prices fluctuate randomly’, Industrial Management Review 6, pp. 41-9.

Samuelson, P. 1967. ‘Rational theory of warrant pricing’, Industrial Management Review 8, 13-31.

Sauvain, H. 1967. ‘The state of the finance field: comment’, Journal of Finance 22, pp. 541-2.

Schabas, M. 1992. ‘Breaking away – history of economics as history of science’, History of Political Economy 24, pp. 187-213.

Schabas, M. 2003. ‘Adam Smith’s debts to nature’, History of Political Economy 35 (Supplement), pp. 262-81.

Sharpe, W. 1963. ‘A simplified model for portfolio analysis’, Management Science 9, pp. 277-93.

Sharpe, W. 1964. ‘Capital asset prices: a theory of market equilibrium under conditions of risk’, Journal of Finance 19, pp. 425-42.

Sprenkle, C. 1961. ‘Warrant Prices as Indicators of Expectations and Preferences, Yale Economic Essays 1, pp. 172-231.

Sprenkle, C. 1964. ‘Some Evidence on the Profitability of Trading in Put and Call Options’, in Cootner 1964, Part IV.

Stigler, G. 1965. Essays in the History of Economics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Sullivan, E. and T. Wethers. 1991. ‘Louis Bachelier: The Father of Modern Option Pricing Theory’, Journal of Economic Education 22, pp. 165-71.

Swetz, F. 1987. Capitalism and Arithmetic: The New Math of the 15th C. Including the full text of the Treviso Arithmetic (Translated by D. E. Smith), LaSalle, Ill.: Open Court.

Sylla, E. 2003. ‘Business ethics, commercial mathematics, and the origins of mathematical probability’, History of Political Economy 35 (Supplement), pp. 309-37.

Sylla, E. 2006. ‘Commercial Arithmetic, Theology and the Intellectual Foundations of Jacob Bernoulli’s “Art of Conjecturing”’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 1, pp. 11-44.

Thomas, D. 1977. The Honest Mind: The Thought and Work of Richard Price. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Varian, H. 1993. ‘A Portfolio of Nobel Laureates: Markowitz, Miller and Sharpe’, Journal of Economic Perspectives 7, pp. 159-69.

Weintraub, E. R. 2002. How Economics Became a Mathematical Science. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

Weston, F. 1967. ‘The state of the finance field’, Journal of Finance 22, pp. 539-40.

Wright, J. 2002. ‘The Rise of Adam Smith: Articles and Citations, 1970–1997’, History of Political Economy 34, pp. 55-82.

Yonay, Y. 1994. ‘When black boxes clash: competing ideas of what science is in economics, 1924–39’, Social Studies of Science 24, pp. 39-80.

Yonay, Y. 1998. The Struggle over the Soul of Economics: Institutionalist and Neoclassical Economists in America between the Wars. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.

Zimmermann, H. and W. Hafner. 2006. ‘Professor Bronzin’s Option Pricing Models’, in Poitras 2006, chapter 11.

Zimmermann, H. and W. Hafner. 2007. ‘Amazing discovery: Vincenz Bronzin’s option pricing models’, Journal of Banking & Finance 31, pp. 531-46.