Sanctions and Imports of Essential Goods; A Closer Look at the Equipo Anova (2021) Results

Rodriguez, Francisco (2022): Sanctions and Imports of Essential Goods; A Closer Look at the Equipo Anova (2021) Results.

Abstract

We revisit the results of Equipo Anova (2021), who claim to find evidence of an improvement in Venezuelan imports of food and medicines associated with the adoption of U.S. financial sanctions towards Venezuela in 2017. We show that their results are consequence of data coding errors and questionable methodological choices, including the use an unreasonable functional form that implies a counterfactual of negative imports in the absence of sanctions, the omission of data accounting for four-fifths of the country’s food imports at the time of sanctions and incorrect application of regression discontinuity methods. Once these errors are corrected, the evidence of a significant improvement in the level and rate of change in imports of essentials disappears.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Venezuela, Sanctions, Imports, Economic Growth
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F5 - International Relations, National Security, and International Political Economy > F51 - International Conflicts ; Negotiations ; Sanctions; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O5 - Economywide Country Studies > O54 - Latin America ; Caribbean

References

Afesorgbor, S. K., and Mahadevan, R. (2016). The Impact of Economic Sanctions on Income Inequality of Target States. World Development, 83, 1–11. Allen, S. and Lektzian, D. (2012). Economic sanctions: A blunt instrument? Journal of Peace Research, 50(1). Amaya, V. (2021). Maduro, las sanciones y la mutación en la economía venezolana. Tal Cual. February, 10. https://talcualdigital.com/maduro-las-sanciones-y-la-mutacion-en-la-economia-venezolana/ Armando Armas, Twitter post, July 2022, 9:25 am, https://twitter.com/ArmandoArmas/status/1546485743274565633?s=20andt=SBSqM1e6QgqEzG4DuipPMA Bahar, D., Bustos, S., Morales, J. R., and Santos, M. A. (2019) Impact of the 2017 sanctions on Venezuela: Revisiting the evidence. Brookings Institution. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/impact-of-the-2017-sanctions-on-venezuela_final.pdf Baltagi, B. and Moscone, F. (2010). Health care expenditure and income in the OECD reconsidered: Evidence from panel data. Economic Modelling, 27(4): 804-811. Batmanghelidj, E. (2022). The Inflation Weapon: How American Sanctions Harm Iranian Households. Fourth Freedom Forum. Sanctions and Security Research Project. https://sanctionsandsecurity.org/publications/the-inflation-weapon-how-american-sanctions-harm-iranian-households/ Calonico, S., Cattaneo, M., Farrell, H., and Titiunik, R. (2017). rdrobust: Software for regression discontinuity designs. Stata Journal 17, 372–404 Calonico, S., Cattaneo, M., and Farrell, H. (2020). Optimal bandwidth choice for robust bias-corrected inference in regression discontinuity designs. Econometrics Journal, 23: 192–210. Carreras, M., Visconti, G. and Acácio I. (2021). THE TRUMP ELECTION AND ATTITUDES TOWARD THE UNITED STATES IN LATIN AMERICA. Public Opinion Quarterly, 00(0): 1 – 11. Carter Center (2022). Syria: From Punitive Sanctions to an Incentive-Based Approach. Fourth Freedom Forum. Sanctions and Security Research Project. https://sanctionsandsecurity.org/publications/syria-from-punitive-sanctions-to-an-incentive-based-approach/ Choi, S. W., and Luo, S. (2013). Economic Sanctions, Poverty, and International Terrorism: An Empirical Analysis. International Interactions. 39(2): 17–245. Cunningham, S. (2021). Causal Inference: The Mixtape, New Haven: Yale University Press, pp. 252-282. Dai, M., Felbermayr, G., Kirilakha, A., Syropoulos, C., Yalcin, E., and Yotov, Y. (2021) Timing the Impact of Sanctions on Trade. School of Economics Working Paper Series 2021-7, LeBow College of Business, Drexel University. Dubey, J. (2020). Income elasticity of demand for health care and its change over time: Across the income groups and levels of health expenditure in India. Working Papers 20/324, National Institute of Public Finance and Policy. Equipo Anova (2021). Impacto de las Sanciones Financieras Internacionales contra Venezuela: Nueva Evidencia, 3(1): 1 – 3. Fan, V. and Savedoff, W. (2012). The Health Financing Transition: A Conceptual Framework and Empirical Evidence. Results for Development Institute, Working Paper. Farzanegan, M. R., Khabbazan, M. M., and Sadeghi, H. (2016). Effects of Oil Sanctions on Iran’s Economy and Household Welfare: New Evidence from A CGE Model. Economic Welfare and Inequality in Iran. Felbermayr, G.; Syropoulos, S.; Yalcin, E. and Yotov, Y. (2020). On the Heterogeneous Effects of Sanctions on Trade and Welfare: Evidence from the Sanctions on Iran and a New Database, School of Economics Working Paper Series 2020-4, LeBow College of Business, Drexel University. Filmer, D. and Prtichett, L. (1999). Child Mortality and Public Spending on Health: How Much Does Money Matter? Policy Research Working Paper Series 1864, World Bank. Gharehgozlia, O. (2017). An Estimation of the Economic Cost of Recent Sanctions on Iran Using the Synthetic Control Method. Economic Letters, 157. Gerdtham, U. and Jönsson, B. (2000) International Comparisons of Health Expenditure: Theory, Data and Econometric Analysis. In: Culyer, A.J. and Newhouse, J.P., Eds., Handbook of Health Economics, 1A, 11-53. Godard, M. Koning, P. and Lindeboom, M. (2019). Targeting Disability Insurance Applications with Screening. IZA Institute of Labor Economics, Discussion Paper Series, IZA DP No. 12343. Guaidó, J. (2022a). Juán Guaidó presenta informe de gestión. Press release. VPI Tv. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ubh1zyTbXTA Guaidó, J. (2022b). Juan Guaidó: "Nicolás Maduro ha creado una economía clandestina y mafias en Venezuela". El Clarin. June, 11. https://www.clarin.com/mundo/juan-guaido-nicolas-maduro-creado-economia-clandestina-mafias-venezuela-_0_KjKhcccJrL.html Gutmann, J., Neuenkirch, M. and Neumeier, F. (2017) Sanctioned to Death? The Impact of Economic Sanctions on Life Expectancy and its Gender Gap. ILE Working Paper Series, 11. 2 -36. Gutmann, J., Neuenkirch, M., Neumeier, F. and Steinbach, A. (2018). Economic Sanctions and Human Rights: Quantifying the Legal Proportionality Principle. Universitat Trier Research Papers in Economics No. 2/18. Gutmann, J., Neuenkirch, M. & Neumeier, F. (2021). The Economic Effects of International Sanctions: An Event Study. CESifo Working Paper No. 9007. Ha, L. and Nam, P. (2022). An investigation of relationship between global economic sanction and life expectancy: do financial and institutional system matter? Development Studies Research, 9(1):48 – 66. Hahn, J., Todd, P. and Van der Klaauw, W. (2001), Identification and Estimation of Treatment Effects with a Regression-Discontinuity Design. Econometrica, 69: 201-209. Hausman, C. and Rapson, D. (2018). Regression Discontinuity in Time: Considerations for Empirical Applications. Annual Review of Resource Economics, 10: 533 – 552. Hausmann, R. and Rigobón, R. (2002). An Alternative Interpretation of the 'Resource Curse': Theory and Policy Implications. National Bureau of Economic Research Working Papers 9424. Hausmann, R., and Muci, F. (2019). Don’t Blame Washington for Venezuela’s Oil Woes: A Rebuttal. Americas Quarterly. May 1. https://www.americasquarterly.org/article/dont-blame-washington-for-venezuelas-oil-woes-a-rebuttal/ Hejazi, J. and Emamgholipour S. (2022). The Effects of the Re-imposition of US Sanctions on Food Security in Iran. International Journal of Health Policy Management, 11(5): 651 - 657. Hufbauer, G., Schott, J., Elliott, K. and Oegg, B. (2007). Economic Sanctions RECONSIDERED, 3rd edition, Peterson Institute for International Economics, Washington D. C., United States. Imbens, G. and Lemieux, T. (2007). Regression Discontinuity Designs: A Guide to Practice. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Papers 13039. Iturbe, R. (2021). Estados Unidos quiere negociar con Maduro las sanciones a cambio de elecciones libres. ALNavío. February 14. https://alnavio.es/estados-unidos-quiere-negociar-con-maduro-las-sanciones-a-cambio-de-elecciones-libres/ Jeetoo, J. and Jaunky, V. (2022). An Empirical Analysis of Income Elasticity of Out-of-Pocket Healthcare Expenditure in Mauritius. Healthcare, 10(1): 1 – 21. Kholodilin, K. and Netšunajev, A. (2018). Crimea and punishment: the impact of sanctions on Russian economy and economies of the euro area. Baltic Journal of Economics, 19(1): 39-51 Kim, Y. (2019). Economic sanctions and child HIV. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management, 34(2): 693 – 700. Kim, M. (2019). Unintended Consequences of Health Care Reform in South Korea: Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity in Time Design. SSRN Electronic Journal. Lee, D. and Lemieux, T. (2010). Regression Discontinuity Designs in Economics. Journal of Economic Literature, 48(2): 281 – 355. Lee, M. (2016). Matching, Regression Discontinuity, Difference in Differences, and Beyond. Oxford University Press, 1st ed. Lépine, A. (2014). Is Health a Necessity in Sub-Saharan Africa? An Investigation of Income-Elasticity of Health Expenditures in Rural Senegal. Journal of International Development, 27(7): 1153-1177. Lovett, N. and Xue, Y. (2022). Rare homicides, criminal behavior, and the returns to police labor. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization. 194, 172 – 195. Lucena, C. and Apolinário, L. (2016) Targeted Versus Conventional Economic Sanctions: What Is at Stake for Human Rights? International Interactions. 42(4): 565–589. Magsi, H., Memon, M., Sabir, M., Magsi, I. and Anwar, N. (2021). Income Elasticity of Household’s health and Wellness in Rural Pakistan. Journal of Economics and Management Sciences, 2(1): 67-78. Mendez, B. (2021). ANOVA: Sanciones sí tuvieron impacto en la producción de crudo, pero fueron positivas para las importaciones de alimentos y medicinas. Descifrado. January 22. https://www.descifrado.com/2021/01/22/anova-sanciones-si-tuvieron-impacto-en-la-produccion-de-crudo-pero-fueron-positivas-para-las-importaciones-de-alimentos-y-medicinas/ Morteza, G. (2021). Who is afraid of sanctions? Themacroeconomic and distributional effectsof the sanctions against Iran. Wiley Economics and Politics, 34(3): 395 – 428. Neuenkirch, M. and Neumeier, F. (2015). The impact of UN and US economic sanctions on GDP growth. European Journal of Political Economy, 40A, 110–125. Neuenkirch, M., and Neumeier, F. (2016). The impact of US sanctions on poverty. Journal of Development Economics, 121: 110–119. Oliveros, L. (2020). Impacto de las sanciones financieras y petroleras en la economía venezolana. WOLA, Washington, DC. https://www.wola.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Oliveros-Resumen-FINAL.pdf Omar Zambrano, Twitter Post, January 2021a, 8:23 pm. https://twitter.com/Econ_Vzla/status/1352774002436165632?s=20andt=rPvPqzup2T-YV9kPqFKtSw Omar Zambrano, Twitter Post, January 2021b, 8:23 pm. https://twitter.com/Econ_Vzla/status/1352774002436165632?s=20andt=rPvPqzup2T-YV9kPqFKtSw Parker, D., Foltz, J., and Elsea, D. (2017). Unintended Consequences of Sanctions for Human Rights: Conflict Minerals and Infant Mortality. Journal of Law & Economics, 59(4): 731 – 774. Peksen, D. (2011). Economic Sanctions and Human Security: The Public Health Effect of Economic Sanctions. Foreign Policy Analysis, 7(3): 237–251. Peksen, D., and Drury, A. C. (2010). Coercive or Corrosive: The Negative Impact of Economic Sanctions on Democracy. International Interactions, 36(3): 240–264. Peksen, D. (2009). Better or Worse? The Effect of Economic Sanctions on Human Rights. Journal of Peace Research, 46(1), 2009, pp. 59–77. Petrescu, I (2016). The Humanitarian Impact Of Economic Sanctions. Europolity – Continuity and Change in European Governance - New Series, Department of International Relations and European Integration, National University of Political Studies and Public Administration, 10(2): 1-41. Polítika UCAB (2021). ANOVA presenta estudio sobre nueva evidencia del impacto de las sanciones financieras internacionales contra Venezuela. Polítika UCAB. January, 21. https://politikaucab.net/2021/01/21/anova-presenta-estudio-sobre-nueva-evidencia-del-impacto-de-las-sanciones-financieras-internacionales-contra-venezuela/ Pritchett, L. and Summers, L. (1996). Wealthier is Healthier. Journal of Human Resources, 31(4): 841 – 868. Ringel, J., Hosek, S. Vollaard, B. and Mahnovski, S. (2005). The Elasticity of Demand for Health Care A Review of the Literature and Its Application to the Military Health System. California, CA: RAND Corporation. Rodríguez, F. and Hausmann, R. (2012). Venezuela Before Chávez: Anatomy of an Economic Collapse. Pennsylvania, PA: The Pennsylvania State University Press. Rodríguez, F. and Sachs, J. (1999). Why Do Resource-Abundant Economies Grow More Slowly? Journal of Economic Growth, 4(3): 277–303. Rodríguez, F. (2018). Crude Realities: Understanding Venezuela’s Economic Collapse. WOLA. https://www.venezuelablog.org/crude-realities-understanding-venezuelas-economic-collapse/ Rodríguez, F. (2019). Sanctions and the Venezuelan economy: What the data say. Torino Economics. Rodríguez, F. (2021). Scorched Earth: The Political Economy of Venezuela’s Collapse, 2013-2020. Unpublished book manuscript. Rodríguez, F. (2022a). Sanctions, Economic Statecraft, and Venezuela’s Crisis Case Study. Fourth Freedom Forum, Sanctions and Security Research Project. https://sanctionsandsecurity.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/January-2022-Venezuela-Case_Rodriguez.pdf Rodríguez, F. (2022b). The Human Consequences of Economic Sanctions. Working Paper. Rodríguez, F. (2022c). The economic determinants of Venezuela’s hunger crisis. MPRA Paper No. 113669. Rodríguez, F. (2022d). Sanctions and oil production: Evidence from Venezuela’s Orinoco Basin. Latin American Economic Review 31(6): 1-31. Splinter, M. and Klomp, J. (2021). Do Sanctions Cause Economic Growth Collapses? Netherlands Annual Review of Military Studies, 115–132. Tangtipongkul, K. (2016). Income Elasticity for Medical Care Services: An Empirical Study in Thailand. Thammasat. Review of Economic and Social Policy, 2(1): 76–123. UNDP (United Nations Development Programme), (2010). Human Development Report 2010: The Real Wealth of Nations: Pathways to Human Development. New York, NY. Van Bergeijk, P. (2015). Sanctions against Iran - A preliminary economic assessment. European Union Institute for Security Studies. Warburton, C. (2016). The International Law and Economics of Coercive Diplomacy: Macroeconomic effects and empirical findings. Applied Econometrics and International Development, 16(1). Wen, J., Zhao, X., Wang, Q. and Chang, C. (2020). The impact of international sanctions on energy security. Energy & Environment, 0(0): 1 – 23. Wood, R. (2008). "A Hand upon the Throat of the Nation": Economic Sanctions and State Repression, 1976–2001. International Studies Quarterly, 52(3): 489–513. Xu, K., Saksena, P., and Holly, A. (2011). The Determinants of Health Expenditure: A Country-Level Panel Data Analytis. Working Paper, Washington DC.