Extreme High Temperatures, Firm Dynamics and Heterogeneity, and Aggregate Productivity: The Case of Chinese Manufacturing

Shi, Xiangyu and Zhang, Xin (2024): Extreme High Temperatures, Firm Dynamics and Heterogeneity, and Aggregate Productivity: The Case of Chinese Manufacturing.

Abstract

We study how extreme (high) temperatures affect firm dynamics---entry, exit, and aggregate productivity---in Chinese manufacturing sectors. Existing studies focus on the effects on incumbent firms (intensive margin), while we examine the effects on entry and exit (extensive margin), and their relationship with the aggregate productivity. Extreme temperatures lower the productivity of incumbent firms (productivity effects), while selecting firms with higher productivity to survive (selection effect). Exploiting a unique data set on the registration information of the universe of firms allows us to document this novel general equilibrium mechanism, whereby resources released by eliminated low-productivity firms are reallocated to firms with higher productivity. Thus, the combined effects on aggregate productivity are muted, a finding that differs from the consensus in the literature that extreme (high) temperatures worsen productivity and economic outcomes. We quantify these effects using a heterogeneous firm framework a la Melitz (2003). The results shed light on the importance of firm dynamics in stipulating climate policies.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: C15, D21, D22, E23, Q56
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy; L - Industrial Organization > L2 - Firm Objectives, Organization, and Behavior; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics

References

@article{zhang2018temperature, title={Temperature effects on productivity and factor reallocation: Evidence from a half million Chinese manufacturing plants}, author={Zhang, Peng and Deschenes, Olivier and Meng, Kyle and Zhang, Junjie}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={88}, pages={1--17}, year={2018}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{melitz2015dynamic, title={Dynamic Olley-Pakes productivity decomposition with entry and exit}, author={Melitz, Marc J and Polanec, Sa{\v{s}}o}, journal={The Rand journal of economics}, volume={46}, number={2}, pages={362--375}, year={2015}, publisher={Wiley Online Library} }

@article{chen2019temperature, title={Temperature and industrial output: Firm-level evidence from China}, author={Chen, Xiaoguang and Yang, Lu}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={95}, pages={257--274}, year={2019}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{dell2012temperature, title={Temperature shocks and economic growth: Evidence from the last half century}, author={Dell, Melissa and Jones, Benjamin F and Olken, Benjamin A}, journal={American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics}, volume={4}, number={3}, pages={66--95}, year={2012} }

@article{seppanen2006room, title={Room temperature and productivity in office work}, author={Seppanen, Olli and Fisk, William J and Lei, QH}, year={2006} }

@article{somanathan2021impact, title={The impact of temperature on productivity and labor supply: Evidence from Indian manufacturing}, author={Somanathan, Eswaran and Somanathan, Rohini and Sudarshan, Anant and Tewari, Meenu}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={129}, number={6}, pages={1797--1827}, year={2021}, publisher={The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{syverson2011determines, title={What determines productivity?}, author={Syverson, Chad}, journal={Journal of Economic literature}, volume={49}, number={2}, pages={326--65}, year={2011} }

@article{topalova2011trade, title={Trade liberalization and firm productivity: The case of India}, author={Topalova, Petia and Khandelwal, Amit}, journal={Review of economics and statistics}, volume={93}, number={3}, pages={995--1009}, year={2011}, publisher={The MIT Press} }

@article{aw2008r, title={R\&D investments, exporting, and the evolution of firm productivity}, author={Aw, Bee Yan and Roberts, Mark J and Xu, Daniel Yi}, journal={American economic review}, volume={98}, number={2}, pages={451--56}, year={2008} }

@article{foster2008reallocation, title={Reallocation, firm turnover, and efficiency: Selection on productivity or profitability?}, author={Foster, Lucia and Haltiwanger, John and Syverson, Chad}, journal={American Economic Review}, volume={98}, number={1}, pages={394--425}, year={2008} }

@article{acemoglu2018innovation, title={Innovation, reallocation, and growth}, author={Acemoglu, Daron and Akcigit, Ufuk and Alp, Harun and Bloom, Nicholas and Kerr, William}, journal={American Economic Review}, volume={108}, number={11}, pages={3450--91}, year={2018} }

@article{song2011growing, title={Growing like china}, author={Song, Zheng and Storesletten, Kjetil and Zilibotti, Fabrizio}, journal={American economic review}, volume={101}, number={1}, pages={196--233}, year={2011} }

@article{broda2006globalization, title={Globalization and the Gains from Variety}, author={Broda, Christian and Weinstein, David E}, journal={The Quarterly journal of economics}, volume={121}, number={2}, pages={541--585}, year={2006}, publisher={MIT Press} }

@article{atkeson2010innovation, title={Innovation, firm dynamics, and international trade}, author={Atkeson, Andrew and Burstein, Ariel Tomas}, journal={Journal of political economy}, volume={118}, number={3}, pages={433--484}, year={2010}, publisher={The University of Chicago Press} }

@article{he2020watering, title={Watering down environmental regulation in China}, author={He, Guojun and Wang, Shaoda and Zhang, Bing}, journal={The Quarterly Journal of Economics}, volume={135}, number={4}, pages={2135--2185}, year={2020}, publisher={Oxford University Press} }

@techreport{fan2019going, title={Going green in China: Firms’ responses to stricter environmental regulations}, author={Fan, Haichao and Zivin, Joshua S Graff and Kou, Zonglai and Liu, Xueyue and Wang, Huanhuan}, year={2019}, institution={National Bureau of Economic Research} }

@article{ryan2012costs, title={The costs of environmental regulation in a concentrated industry}, author={Ryan, Stephen P}, journal={Econometrica}, volume={80}, number={3}, pages={1019--1061}, year={2012}, publisher={Wiley Online Library} }

@techreport{greenstone2012effects, title={The effects of environmental regulation on the competitiveness of US manufacturing}, author={Greenstone, Michael and List, John A and Syverson, Chad}, year={2012}, institution={National Bureau of Economic Research} }

@article{melitz2003impact, title={The impact of trade on intra-industry reallocations and aggregate industry productivity}, author={Melitz, Marc J}, journal={econometrica}, volume={71}, number={6}, pages={1695--1725}, year={2003}, publisher={Wiley Online Library} }

@article{akcigit2021lack, title={Lack of selection and limits to delegation: firm dynamics in developing countries}, author={Akcigit, Ufuk and Alp, Harun and Peters, Michael}, journal={American Economic Review}, volume={111}, number={1}, pages={231--75}, year={2021} }

@article{cui2020firm, title={Firm internal network, environmental regulation, and plant death}, author={Cui, Jingbo and Moschini, GianCarlo}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={101}, pages={102319}, year={2020}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{fowlie2016market, title={Market-based emissions regulation and industry dynamics}, author={Fowlie, Meredith and Reguant, Mar and Ryan, Stephen P}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={124}, number={1}, pages={249--302}, year={2016}, publisher={University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{wang2018environmental, title={Environmental regulation, emissions and productivity: Evidence from Chinese COD-emitting manufacturers}, author={Wang, Chunhua and Wu, JunJie and Zhang, Bing}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={92}, pages={54--73}, year={2018}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{list2003effects, title={Effects of environmental regulations on manufacturing plant births: evidence from a propensity score matching estimator}, author={List, John A and Millimet, Daniel L and Fredriksson, Per G and McHone, W Warren}, journal={Review of Economics and Statistics}, volume={85}, number={4}, pages={944--952}, year={2003}, publisher={MIT Press 238 Main St., Suite 500, Cambridge, MA 02142-1046, USA journals~…} }

@article{nasospatial, title={Spatial Development, Environmental Regulation and Productivity: The Porter Hypothesis Goes to China}, author={Naso, Pedro and Huang, Yi and Swanson, Tim}, year={2018} }

@article{chen2018consequences, title={The consequences of spatially differentiated water pollution regulation in China}, author={Chen, Zhao and Kahn, Matthew E and Liu, Yu and Wang, Zhi}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={88}, pages={468--485}, year={2018}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{jovanovic1982selection, title={Selection and the Evolution of Industry}, author={Jovanovic, Boyan}, journal={Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society}, pages={649--670}, year={1982}, publisher={JSTOR} }

@article{hopenhayn1992entry, title={Entry, exit, and firm dynamics in long run equilibrium}, author={Hopenhayn, Hugo A}, journal={Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society}, pages={1127--1150}, year={1992}, publisher={JSTOR} }

@article{pavcnik2002trade, title={Trade liberalization, exit, and productivity improvements: Evidence from Chilean plants}, author={Pavcnik, Nina}, journal={The Review of economic studies}, volume={69}, number={1}, pages={245--276}, year={2002}, publisher={Wiley-Blackwell} }

@article{deschenes2011climate, title={Climate change, mortality, and adaptation: Evidence from annual fluctuations in weather in the US}, author={Desch{\^e}nes, Olivier and Greenstone, Michael}, journal={American Economic Journal: Applied Economics}, volume={3}, number={4}, pages={152--85}, year={2011} }

@article{agarwal2021impact, title={Impact of Temperature on Morbidity: New Evidence from China}, author={Agarwal, Sumit and Qin, Yu and Shi, Luwen and Wei, Guoxu and Zhu, Hongjia}, journal={Available at SSRN 3807776}, year={2021} }

@article{barreca2016adapting, title={Adapting to climate change: The remarkable decline in the US temperature-mortality relationship over the twentieth century}, author={Barreca, Alan and Clay, Karen and Deschenes, Olivier and Greenstone, Michael and Shapiro, Joseph S}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={124}, number={1}, pages={105--159}, year={2016}, publisher={University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{burke2018higher, title={Higher temperatures increase suicide rates in the United States and Mexico}, author={Burke, Marshall and Gonz{\'a}lez, Felipe and Baylis, Patrick and Heft-Neal, Sam and Baysan, Ceren and Basu, Sanjay and Hsiang, Solomon}, journal={Nature climate change}, volume={8}, number={8}, pages={723--729}, year={2018}, publisher={Nature Publishing Group} }

@article{deschenes2014temperature, title={Temperature, human health, and adaptation: A review of the empirical literature}, author={Deschenes, Olivier}, journal={Energy Economics}, volume={46}, pages={606--619}, year={2014}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{deschenes2007economic, title={The economic impacts of climate change: evidence from agricultural output and random fluctuations in weather}, author={Desch{\^e}nes, Olivier and Greenstone, Michael}, journal={American economic review}, volume={97}, number={1}, pages={354--385}, year={2007} }

@article{deschenes2009extreme, title={Extreme weather events, mortality, and migration}, author={Deschenes, Olivier and Moretti, Enrico}, journal={The Review of Economics and Statistics}, volume={91}, number={4}, pages={659--681}, year={2009}, publisher={The MIT Press} }

@article{garg2020temperature, title={Temperature and human capital in India}, author={Garg, Teevrat and Jagnani, Maulik and Taraz, Vis}, journal={Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists}, volume={7}, number={6}, pages={1113--1150}, year={2020}, publisher={The University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{graff2018temperature, title={Temperature and human capital in the short and long run}, author={Graff Zivin, Joshua and Hsiang, Solomon M and Neidell, Matthew}, journal={Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists}, volume={5}, number={1}, pages={77--105}, year={2018}, publisher={University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{graff2014temperature, title={Temperature and the allocation of time: Implications for climate change}, author={Graff Zivin, Joshua and Neidell, Matthew}, journal={Journal of Labor Economics}, volume={32}, number={1}, pages={1--26}, year={2014}, publisher={University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{zivin2020temperature, title={Temperature and high-stakes cognitive performance: Evidence from the national college entrance examination in China}, author={Zivin, Joshua Graff and Song, Yingquan and Tang, Qu and Zhang, Peng}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={104}, pages={102365}, year={2020}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{karlsson2018population, title={Population health effects and health-related costs of extreme temperatures: Comprehensive evidence from Germany}, author={Karlsson, Martin and Ziebarth, Nicolas R}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={91}, pages={93--117}, year={2018}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{mullins2019temperature, title={Temperature and mental health: Evidence from the spectrum of mental health outcomes}, author={Mullins, Jamie T and White, Corey}, journal={Journal of health economics}, volume={68}, pages={102240}, year={2019}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{obradovich2018empirical, title={Empirical evidence of mental health risks posed by climate change}, author={Obradovich, Nick and Migliorini, Robyn and Paulus, Martin P and Rahwan, Iyad}, journal={Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences}, volume={115}, number={43}, pages={10953--10958}, year={2018}, publisher={National Acad Sciences} }

@article{park2020heat, title={Heat and learning}, author={Park, R Jisung and Goodman, Joshua and Hurwitz, Michael and Smith, Jonathan}, journal={American Economic Journal: Economic Policy}, volume={12}, number={2}, pages={306--39}, year={2020} }

@article{park2020hot, title={Hot temperature and high stakes performance}, author={Park, R Jisung}, journal={Journal of Human Resources}, year={2020}, publisher={University of Wisconsin Press} }

@article{park2021learning, title={Learning is inhibited by heat exposure, both internationally and within the United States}, author={Park, R Jisung and Behrer, A Patrick and Goodman, Joshua}, journal={Nature human behaviour}, volume={5}, number={1}, pages={19--27}, year={2021}, publisher={Nature Publishing Group} }

@article{shah2017drought, title={Drought of opportunities: Contemporaneous and long-term impacts of rainfall shocks on human capital}, author={Shah, Manisha and Steinberg, Bryce Millett}, journal={Journal of Political Economy}, volume={125}, number={2}, pages={527--561}, year={2017}, publisher={University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{white2017dynamic, title={The dynamic relationship between temperature and morbidity}, author={White, Corey}, journal={Journal of the Association of Environmental and Resource Economists}, volume={4}, number={4}, pages={1155--1198}, year={2017}, publisher={University of Chicago Press Chicago, IL} }

@article{yu2019temperature, title={Temperature effects on mortality and household adaptation: Evidence from China}, author={Yu, Xiumei and Lei, Xiaoyan and Wang, Min}, journal={Journal of Environmental Economics and Management}, volume={96}, pages={195--212}, year={2019}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{ackerberg2015identification, title={Identification properties of recent production function estimators}, author={Ackerberg, Daniel A and Caves, Kevin and Frazer, Garth}, journal={Econometrica}, volume={83}, number={6}, pages={2411--2451}, year={2015}, publisher={Wiley Online Library} }

@article{levinsohn2003estimating, title={Estimating production functions using inputs to control for unobservables}, author={Levinsohn, James and Petrin, Amil}, journal={The review of economic studies}, volume={70}, number={2}, pages={317--341}, year={2003}, publisher={Wiley-Blackwell} }

@article{olley1996dynamics, title={The Dynamics of Productivity in the Telecommunications Equipment}, author={Olley, G Steven and Pakes, Ariel}, journal={Econometrica}, volume={64}, number={6}, pages={1263--1297}, year={1996} }

@article{yu2015processing, title={Processing trade, tariff reductions and firm productivity: Evidence from Chinese firms}, author={Yu, Miaojie}, journal={The Economic Journal}, volume={125}, number={585}, pages={943--988}, year={2015}, publisher={Wiley Online Library} }

@article{deschenes2020effect, title={The effect of air pollution on body weight and obesity: evidence from China}, author={Deschenes, Olivier and Wang, Huixia and Wang, Si and Zhang, Peng}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={145}, pages={102461}, year={2020}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{fu2021air, title={Air pollution and manufacturing firm productivity: Nationwide estimates for China}, author={Fu, Shihe and Viard, V Brian and Zhang, Peng}, journal={The Economic Journal}, volume={131}, number={640}, pages={3241--3273}, year={2021}, publisher={Oxford University Press} }

@article{chen2022effect, title={The effect of air pollution on migration: evidence from China}, author={Chen, Shuai and Oliva, Paulina and Zhang, Peng}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={156}, pages={102833}, year={2022}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{haltiwanger1997measuring, title={Measuring and analyzing aggregate fluctuations: the importance of building from microeconomic evidence}, author={Haltiwanger, John}, journal={Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review}, number={May}, pages={55--78}, year={1997} }

@article{griliches1995firm, title={Firm productivity in Israeli industry 1979--1988}, author={Griliches, Zvi and Regev, Haim}, journal={Journal of econometrics}, volume={65}, number={1}, pages={175--203}, year={1995}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{xie2018heterogeneous, title={Heterogeneous firms under regional temperature shocks: exit and reallocation, with evidence from Indonesia}, author={Xie, Victoria Wenxin}, year={2018} }

@article{shapiro2018pollution, title={Why is pollution from US manufacturing declining? The roles of environmental regulation, productivity, and trade}, author={Shapiro, Joseph S and Walker, Reed}, journal={American Economic Review}, volume={108}, number={12}, pages={3814--3854}, year={2018}, publisher={American Economic Association 2014 Broadway, Suite 305, Nashville, TN 37203} }

@article{shapiro2021environmental, title={The environmental bias of trade policy}, author={Shapiro, Joseph S}, journal={The Quarterly Journal of Economics}, volume={136}, number={2}, pages={831--886}, year={2021}, publisher={Oxford University Press} }

@article{brandt2012creative, title={Creative accounting or creative destruction? Firm-level productivity growth in Chinese manufacturing}, author={Brandt, Loren and Van Biesebroeck, Johannes and Zhang, Yifan}, journal={Journal of development economics}, volume={97}, number={2}, pages={339--351}, year={2012}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{duarte2010role, title={The role of the structural transformation in aggregate productivity}, author={Duarte, Margarida and Restuccia, Diego}, journal={The quarterly journal of economics}, volume={125}, number={1}, pages={129--173}, year={2010}, publisher={MIT Press} }

@article{chambers1996aggregate, title={Aggregate productivity measures}, author={Chambers, Robert G and Pope, Rulon D}, journal={American Journal of Agricultural Economics}, volume={78}, number={5}, pages={1360--1365}, year={1996}, publisher={JSTOR} }

@article{basu2002aggregate, title={Aggregate productivity and aggregate technology}, author={Basu, Susanto and Fernald, John G}, journal={European Economic Review}, volume={46}, number={6}, pages={963--991}, year={2002}, publisher={Elsevier} }

@article{li2023temperature, title={Temperature Effects on Firm Entry and Exit}, author={Li, Shuo and Wang, Min and Yu, Xiumei}, journal={Available at SSRN 4441897}, year={2023} }

@article{adhvaryu2020light, title={The light and the heat: Productivity co-benefits of energy-saving technology}, author={Adhvaryu, Achyuta and Kala, Namrata and Nyshadham, Anant}, journal={Review of Economics and Statistics}, volume={102}, number={4}, pages={779--792}, year={2020}, publisher={MIT Press One Rogers Street, Cambridge, MA 02142-1209, USA journals-info~…} }

@article{cascarano2022entry, title={Entry, exit, and market structure in a changing climate}, author={Cascarano, Michele and Natoli, Filippo and Petrella, Andrea}, journal={Available at SSRN 4724004}, year={2022} }

@article{colmer2021temperature, title={Temperature, labor reallocation, and industrial production: Evidence from India}, author={Colmer, Jonathan}, journal={American Economic Journal: Applied Economics}, volume={13}, number={4}, pages={101--124}, year={2021}, publisher={American Economic Association 2014 Broadway, Suite 305, Nashville, TN 37203-2425} }

@article{cruz2024economic, title={The economic geography of global warming}, author={Cruz, Jos{\'e}-Luis and Rossi-Hansberg, Esteban}, journal={Review of Economic Studies}, volume={91}, number={2}, pages={899--939}, year={2024}, publisher={Oxford University Press US} }

@article{rudik2022economic, title={The economic effects of climate change in dynamic spatial equilibrium}, author={Rudik, Ivan and Lyn, Gary and Tan, Weiliang and Ortiz-Bobea, Ariel}, year={2022} }

@article{shi2022local, title={Local content requirements, regional production networks, and spatial distribution of firms in China}, author={Shi, Xiangyu}, journal={Available at SSRN 4091096}, year={2022} }

@article{shi2021hometown, title={Hometown favoritism and intercity investment networks in china}, author={Shi, Xiangyu}, journal={Available at SSRN}, volume={3745064}, year={2021}, publisher={Technical Report 2022.,“Hometown Favoritism and Intercity Investment~…} }

@article{liu2023connect, title={Connect to Invest: Hometown Ties, Intranational Capital Flows, and Allocative Efficiency in China}, author={Liu, Yu and Shi, Xiangyu}, journal={Intranational Capital Flows, and Allocative Efficiency in China}, year={2023} }

@article{shi2021moving, title={“Moving Umbrella”: Bureaucratic transfers and the comovement of interregional investments in China}, author={Shi, Xiangyu and Xi, Tianyang and Zhang, Xiaobo and Zhang, Yifan}, journal={Journal of Development Economics}, volume={153}, pages={102717}, year={2021}, publisher={Elsevier} }